Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to start to believe in the magical Mumsnet chicken?

183 replies

HootOwl · 30/01/2022 13:58

Maybe it is actually real?! 🐔😆

I roasted an (admittedly huge) chicken and also this was all only to feed me and two small children so not huge portions but from one chicken we had:

Roast dinner
Chicken fricassee
Chicken risotto
Chicken pasta bake
Paprika chicken
Chicken soup
Crispy chicken skin (snack)

Will make the effort to roast a whole one more often! I swear it only had two breasts, two legs and two wings...

OP posts:
HootOwl · 01/02/2022 01:38

@merrymelodies

I consider an adult portion to be around 180g, which would be a chicken breast so it depends on the size of the bird. An average chicken in our house serves two adults and two children one meal.
But even then, with meat meant to be 1/4 to 1/3 max of a meal, that means one adult sized portion of the whole meal would be 540g - 720g. That seems nuts. Even if you exclude breakfast, it can't be a good idea for an adult to be consuming 1.1kg - 1.5kg of food per day?
OP posts:
merrymelodies · 01/02/2022 01:13

I consider an adult portion to be around 180g, which would be a chicken breast so it depends on the size of the bird. An average chicken in our house serves two adults and two children one meal.

HootOwl · 01/02/2022 00:51

@BreadInCaptivity

To be honest this reminds me of having Sunday dinner with my grandparents.

Meat was very much seen as a luxury commodity and whilst dinners were plentiful and delicious (my GM was an amazing cook) I think today the portions of meat she would serve would be perceived as "thrifty" by todays standards.

The leftover meat from a Sunday dinner was absolutely expected to last several days for the whole family and every scrap was used, bones and all for stock, fat/skin saved for frying bubble and squeak the next day etc.

As meat production has become more efficient cruel and thus cheaper I think our expectations of what a meat portion is has increased dramatically.

I serve the same (plentiful) amount of food as my GM but the meat to veg ratio is very different (much higher) and frankly that's something I'm trying to address.

We eat far too much meat than is sustainable and aren't that good at using it wisely.

One (very) large chicken is a much better buy than two smaller ones, both economically and environmentally, especially if used thoughtfully.

I really think many of us need to re-think our attitude to meat and Sunday dinner is a great place to start in the sense that with all the lovely veggie side dishes you can have with lashings of gravy, stuffing and Yorkshire puddings you really don't need the massive quantities of meat some posters seem to think you do to have a great meal.

We've simply got used to meat being the star of the show and main focus of the plate rather than being part of an all star cast.

This makes a lot of sense. I mean, I love a backn sandwich and very occassionally I might order a steak in a restaurant or something, so will have some very meat-heavy meals, sometimes. But in normal meals it's just one ingredient and certainly not the majority of the food on the plate! And that's not a habit I'd be teaching my children for health reasons as well as the sustainability side.

I don't really get the "if there's not meat it's not a meal" crowd (I love meat but also love vegetarian food!) and I guess it is that mentality feeding through into meat also needing to be 50% of what's on the plate? Or even more perhaps?!

The poster who was talking about 700g portions of chicken per person, do they have 700g of vegetables, too? So they eat 1.4kg of food for one meal?  That seems unbelievable. I can't picture what that plate of food would look like. And even then at 50% meat and 50% veg it would be waaaay to heavy on protein to be a "normal" healthy meal. Or do they just not have much veg at all? I am genuinely intrigued how that works.

Not the point of the thread, which was a bit of a joke, a bit of pride about my revelation and some good recipe sharing. But I must admit that now people have described meals like that I'm fascinated. If meat meant to be 1/3 max of a plate of food then a 700g portion of chicken means that ONE portion of dinner is over 2kg of food? 

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 31/01/2022 23:59

@AlternativePerspective

MN chicken threads are a guilty pleasure for me, though. I LOVE the competitive undereating. It's fascinating (and I don't believe a word of it). how is it competitive under eating to not eat 700g of meat at a time?

It’s no wonder that we have so many problems with obesity and obesity related illness in this country when people feel the need to sneer at those who eat normal sized portions because they over-eat.

Basing a diet on protein is far less likely to lead to obesity than having one which features regular meals like pie, risotto and roast dinners overly bulked out with high calorie but low nutrition filler like roast potatoes, stuffing and Yorkshire pudding.
HootOwl · 31/01/2022 23:51

@AlternativePerspective

@ HootOwl maybe they’re all on the Atkins diet, so they don’t have anything with it, just a slab or two of meat. Wink Grin
Seems like it! 🤷🏻‍♀️😆
OP posts:
BreadInCaptivity · 31/01/2022 23:47

To be honest this reminds me of having Sunday dinner with my grandparents.

Meat was very much seen as a luxury commodity and whilst dinners were plentiful and delicious (my GM was an amazing cook) I think today the portions of meat she would serve would be perceived as "thrifty" by todays standards.

The leftover meat from a Sunday dinner was absolutely expected to last several days for the whole family and every scrap was used, bones and all for stock, fat/skin saved for frying bubble and squeak the next day etc.

As meat production has become more efficient cruel and thus cheaper I think our expectations of what a meat portion is has increased dramatically.

I serve the same (plentiful) amount of food as my GM but the meat to veg ratio is very different (much higher) and frankly that's something I'm trying to address.

We eat far too much meat than is sustainable and aren't that good at using it wisely.

One (very) large chicken is a much better buy than two smaller ones, both economically and environmentally, especially if used thoughtfully.

I really think many of us need to re-think our attitude to meat and Sunday dinner is a great place to start in the sense that with all the lovely veggie side dishes you can have with lashings of gravy, stuffing and Yorkshire puddings you really don't need the massive quantities of meat some posters seem to think you do to have a great meal.

We've simply got used to meat being the star of the show and main focus of the plate rather than being part of an all star cast.

AlternativePerspective · 31/01/2022 23:36

MN chicken threads are a guilty pleasure for me, though. I LOVE the competitive undereating. It's fascinating (and I don't believe a word of it). how is it competitive under eating to not eat 700g of meat at a time?

It’s no wonder that we have so many problems with obesity and obesity related illness in this country when people feel the need to sneer at those who eat normal sized portions because they over-eat.

sadpapercourtesan · 31/01/2022 23:25

@ComtesseDeSpair

I could make a chicken last last four dinners pretty easily. I choose not to, because I like chicken, eat a Keri diet, and I’d rather eat half of one in one meal. But it’s great that all the people who couldn’t possibly manage more than 130g of chicken for dinner are effectively balancing out my consumption. It’s this level of cooperation which makes the world go round.
I like the cut of your jib Grin

On the Toby Carvery question: loads of people don't go to carveries because the meat portions are stingy. I like vegetables very much, but I'm not paying to fill up on boiled carrots and overcooked cauliflower cheese when I can roast a chicken at home and serve us all a decent portion - of better food - for a fraction of the cost.

MN chicken threads are a guilty pleasure for me, though. I LOVE the competitive undereating. It's fascinating (and I don't believe a word of it).

EatingGreens · 31/01/2022 23:22

Pork shoulder.

ComtesseDeSpair · 31/01/2022 23:20

I could make a chicken last last four dinners pretty easily. I choose not to, because I like chicken, eat a Keri diet, and I’d rather eat half of one in one meal. But it’s great that all the people who couldn’t possibly manage more than 130g of chicken for dinner are effectively balancing out my consumption. It’s this level of cooperation which makes the world go round.

AlternativePerspective · 31/01/2022 23:20

@ HootOwl maybe they’re all on the Atkins diet, so they don’t have anything with it, just a slab or two of meat. Wink Grin

HootOwl · 31/01/2022 23:09

@daisyjgrey

Oh gif only on MN could people argue about whether it's "greedy" to want to eat a whole chicken breast...🤦🏼‍♀️
This chicken in question weighed 2kg. The breast of it weighed around 200g when cooked. If I had tried to eat that whole thing myself, even with no vegetables etc, I would not have been able to. That is a crazy amount of meat for one meal, I was stuffed with half the breast and roast potatoes, veg etc. I am not small: I am slim but I'm 5'11" and I love food and certainly don't "eat like a sparrow" as was suggested by a PP. 🙄

I find some of the responses here very odd. I did caveat my original post saying that this was for one adult and two small kids so effectively only two adult portions per meal. So clearly in a household that has 4 adults you'd get half as many meals, roughly, from one chicken the same size. But the idea in some posts that ONE adult portion should be 700g of meat makes me feel a bit sick. I'm not sure how anybody could eat that.

OP posts:
HootOwl · 31/01/2022 23:00

[quote TibetanTerrah]@Thethreecs genuine question - what would happen if you took your family to say a Toby Carvery? Because the meat is 'rationed', everyone gets the same and you can eat as much of everything else as you like. Nobody leaves a carvery hungry.

And don't say, 'we wouldn't go because there wouldn't be enough meat' Grin purely hypothetical, what would they do?[/quote]
Or pretty much any restaurant... they don't generally serve half a cow or a whole chicken per person. 🤣🤦🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 31/01/2022 20:43

I didn't say your facts were wrong, I said that there are limits to this madness and sharing an average sized chicken breast between two adults is absurd. I would be laughed out of my own kitchen at the very notion

We do one standard chicken breast between two as I like adding as much veg as is physically possible to meals - but the ones on a whole chicken are even bigger.

I'm certainly not a teeny tiny little eater, either.

We either slow cook a whole chicken and then do lots of meals with the leftover meat (usually one breast, the legs/thighs, oysters, sides are left, which does 4 - 5 meals for two plus a couple of lunches like GF pasta salad) + the obligatory soups with wings, carcass and scraps - or I leave DP looking rather alarmed as I get out the Big Knife and portion it up for the freezer as soon as it's in the house.

The velociraptor chicken we got one Christmas Eve was a whole other ballgame, though. I think the butcher just wanted it gone, as it was absolutely massive and only cost a fiver.

TibetanTerrah · 31/01/2022 20:15

@Thethreecs genuine question - what would happen if you took your family to say a Toby Carvery? Because the meat is 'rationed', everyone gets the same and you can eat as much of everything else as you like. Nobody leaves a carvery hungry.

And don't say, 'we wouldn't go because there wouldn't be enough meat' Grin purely hypothetical, what would they do?

HootOwl · 31/01/2022 16:22

@daisyjgrey

I think we have peaked. Someone has just conflated extreme porn with eating chicken.

Stick a fork in (precisely 100g of) me, I'm done!

Lol!!!!

Not a turn I foresaw the thread taking.

OP posts:
HootOwl · 31/01/2022 16:21

Freezer use? Well, it takes up very little space and my freezer is always full anyway!

Also freezers are actually more energy efficient when full so you save money there also!

OP posts:
Curlygirl06 · 31/01/2022 16:05

If you have any stuffing left as well, put that and some chicken in a jar of pasta sauce (cheap tomato one is fine). Heat up, eat, bloody lovely and quick!

AlternativePerspective · 31/01/2022 15:59

Even the low salt ones contain around 0.5mg of salt.

And the cheaper they are, the more salt they contain. Aldi stock cubes for instance which are only 80p for 8, contain 4.2g of salt, that’s 2 3rds of your recommended salt intake a day.

I scrutinise salt content on packets because I have a heart condition and a fluid restriction and have to keep my salt down as far as possible.

Chicken stock is actually more expensive to make, although technically if you’re making it from an existing carcas it isn’t really. But 20p stock cubes are generally salt and seasoning and very little else.

I grant you vegetable stock is tasteless, but chicken stock really isn’t.

FoamBurst · 31/01/2022 15:57

It would here. Altho I'd love it to last more than one meal.
I get the largest one in tesco. Does 1 roast. 3 adult portions. 2 kids 1 toddler. Were huge meat eaters.
If there is ever may left I meat just make it for sandwiches the next day. But not often

AlternativePerspective · 31/01/2022 15:54

I put maybe a pinch of salt in my stock.

A chicken stock cube, that is one chicken stock cube, contains between 800mg/1.2g of salt.

PattyPan · 31/01/2022 15:33

@BarbaraofSeville a stock cube only makes a pint though, whereas for homemade stock you can make a lot more from one carcass. Stock is a really good use for onion skins!

SamphiretheStickerist · 31/01/2022 15:03

@BarbaraofSeville

And way to salty, weird tasting for me. But not cheaper. Easier yes, but not cheaper

All the recipes for stock include the addition of salt. Plus onions, carrots and celery. A stock cube costs about 20 pence. Surely once you've added an onion, couple of carrots, some celery and bubbled the thing away all day in the slow cooker, it's not costing less than 20 p?

We use old veg and the tops and tails that don't get eaten otherwise. I have a bag in the freezer for them. Very little salt gets added. I don't know whether it's my taste buds but the low salt Kallax etc taste very salty to me.

And a slow cooker uses very, very little energy. According to various newspapers who asked USwitch at the time the new energy prices were being introduced, October ish last year, I think, the average slow cooker uses about 1.3kWh over eight hours of cooking time.

Uswitch said that would cost 14.37p per kWh. So about 18p of fuel for the equivalent of about 20 stock cubes, plus the odds and ends of veg etc.

Freezer use? Well, it takes up very little space and my freezer is always full anyway!

BarbaraofSeville · 31/01/2022 14:53

And way to salty, weird tasting for me. But not cheaper. Easier yes, but not cheaper

All the recipes for stock include the addition of salt. Plus onions, carrots and celery. A stock cube costs about 20 pence. Surely once you've added an onion, couple of carrots, some celery and bubbled the thing away all day in the slow cooker, it's not costing less than 20 p?

daisyjgrey · 31/01/2022 14:48

I think we have peaked. Someone has just conflated extreme porn with eating chicken.

Stick a fork in (precisely 100g of) me, I'm done!

Swipe left for the next trending thread