Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to start to believe in the magical Mumsnet chicken?

183 replies

HootOwl · 30/01/2022 13:58

Maybe it is actually real?! 🐔😆

I roasted an (admittedly huge) chicken and also this was all only to feed me and two small children so not huge portions but from one chicken we had:

Roast dinner
Chicken fricassee
Chicken risotto
Chicken pasta bake
Paprika chicken
Chicken soup
Crispy chicken skin (snack)

Will make the effort to roast a whole one more often! I swear it only had two breasts, two legs and two wings...

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 01/02/2022 11:51

The point was directed at those who were specifically targeting others who said they ate a whole chicken breast for Sunday lunch with responses like “no wonder we have such an obesity crisis, if people are eating an entire chicken breast to themselves”, right after they’ve extolled the virtues of eating the sort of stuff more likely to lead to obesity.

I’m really not particularly invested in what other people eat. I’m slim, money isn’t an issue and I don’t care about being sustainable. I’ll eat the entire chicken in one sitting if I want to. Spreading a chicken across four or five meals if you want to - great! Nothing wrong with that. But what inevitably creeps into these threads is not those perfectly sensible attitudes that it can be done, but the bizarre posts opining that anything else is the cause of the obesity crisis.

00100001 · 01/02/2022 11:47

@gluenotsoup

Where are you buying these chickens?? The last time I bought a supposedly large chicken, from Tesco, it was absolutely tiny. We managed a roast dinner for 5 plus soup with the leftover meat, totally stripped down and stock made with the carcass. That’s it! I need a giant chicken.
It depends on a few things:
  1. The size of the chicken in the first place - some people buy a small chicken and and can't see how people stretch it out, not realising they're talking about an extra large chicken.
  1. Portion sizes: Some people will happily consume a leg and some breast meat each - others think half a breast is plenty
  1. The meal type: For example if we do a roast, we'll eat more meat than if I do a curry. So For example, I might have a whole breast, DS18 and DH might have a whole leg each on a roast day - and they'll have extras of the breast etc for seconds. But if I make a chicken and spinach curry - I'll use possibly 1-2 breasts for all of us. 'padding out' the meat with veggies etc

So combine these 3 factors and you'll have different experiences and anecdotes.

AlternativePerspective · 01/02/2022 11:14

@ComtesseDeSpair you’re making up your own narrative here.

Nowhere on the thread have people suggested that you fill your plate up with unrefined flour and oil, what a load of rubbish.

People have suggested that you could have a Yorkshire pudding, some potatoes, several different vegetables which will bulk out the amount of food you need.

And whole meal pasta most definitely isn’t junk. But hey if you want to live as a carnivore then crack on.

There is a middle ground you know between those who think no-one should eat any meat ever, and those who eat over half a kilo of it in one sitting and kid themselves that it’s somehow healthier than eating vegetables.

HootOwl · 01/02/2022 11:03

@Mammyloveswine fortunately for me my two kids don't really like it! Smile So I eat some with my roast dinner then freeze the rest to have as a very unhealthy snack!

OP posts:
HootOwl · 01/02/2022 11:02

@ComtesseDeSpair I don't think that's a fair reflection of what the majority of posters have said! People were mainly describing meals including a sensible balance of protein, carbs and lots of vegetables.

OP posts:
Mammyloveswine · 01/02/2022 11:01

Chicken skin that should say...

Mammyloveswine · 01/02/2022 11:01

Eh? The chicken gets devoured as soon as i take my chicken out of the oven!

DSGR · 01/02/2022 10:40

Nah, it’s rubbish. The point of a huge chicken is that you eat loads of it fresh on an amazing roast dinner!

PattyPan · 01/02/2022 10:40

Wholemeal pasta is not junk. And eating 500g of meat at each serving is going to give you kidney stones.

sanbeiji · 01/02/2022 10:34

Ah fair enough - I thought you were referring to generic protein.
A roast dinner is one of those things where meat is the centrepiece, fair enough as it’s a treat.

Making meat lasts longer involves extra effort, and s combination of things not just loads of carbs…

ComtesseDeSpair · 01/02/2022 10:28

[quote HootOwl]@ComtesseDeSpair what junk have people said they are eating? [/quote]
“Have just a tiny amount of roast chicken with your Sunday dinner - replace it with things which are basically a mixture of refined white flour, oils and salt.”

“Know how you can make a chicken last ages? Stuff yourself with pasta and sauce instead and you barely need any protein at all!”

Everyone is welcome to do as they please, but those lecturing about obesity and bad diets and suggesting replacing a lean protein with lots of Yorkshire pudding and stuffing really aren’t the beacons of nutritional advice they think they are.

sanbeiji · 01/02/2022 10:27

@ComtesseDeSpair so you consider anything non-meat junk?

Eating the amount of meat you describe is unsustainable and involves animals raised in horrific conditions. Unless you’re rich enough to buy lots of well raised meat. Even then the U.K. won’t be able to produce enough.

HootOwl · 01/02/2022 10:23

@ComtesseDeSpair what junk have people said they are eating?

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 01/02/2022 10:06

@PattyPan

MN chicken threads are a guilty pleasure for me, though. I LOVE the competitive undereating. It's fascinating (and I don't believe a word of it).

It’s not competitive undereating to abide by recommended portion sizes. If anything we’ve had competitive overeating on this thread!

Considering all the other shit the NHS recommends about “healthy eating”, I’m not sure it’s “recommended portion sizes” and types of food best to eat are something I’m going to put much stock in any time soon tbh. And I’m definitely not going to replace my 500g of chicken or meat portion with some of the junk eaten on this thread to replace it.
sanbeiji · 01/02/2022 08:37

I do the same OP! Only two of us and chicken feeds us for a few days.
However you have to make foods with chicken as an ‘ingredient’ rather than the main course. I’ve also mastered the art of butchering my own chicken ;) into 22 pieces

Many people though only buy chicken pieces, or have them as the centrepiece with some sort of carbs and salad. Of course your chicken won’t last as long if you do that.

You can always pad meals out with veggies and lentils (I do it not to save money but it’s healthier and I feel much better with more veggies anyway)

PattyPan · 01/02/2022 08:29

MN chicken threads are a guilty pleasure for me, though. I LOVE the competitive undereating. It's fascinating (and I don't believe a word of it).

It’s not competitive undereating to abide by recommended portion sizes. If anything we’ve had competitive overeating on this thread!

SamphiretheStickerist · 01/02/2022 08:00

@HootOwl

Freezer use? Well, it takes up very little space and my freezer is always full anyway!

Also freezers are actually more energy efficient when full so you save money there also!

Thanks for clarifying that for me. I really did mean to add that Smile
anotherbloodyyearofcovid · 01/02/2022 04:43

@HootOwl

Maybe it is actually real?! 🐔😆

I roasted an (admittedly huge) chicken and also this was all only to feed me and two small children so not huge portions but from one chicken we had:

Roast dinner
Chicken fricassee
Chicken risotto
Chicken pasta bake
Paprika chicken
Chicken soup
Crispy chicken skin (snack)

Will make the effort to roast a whole one more often! I swear it only had two breasts, two legs and two wings...

You didn't make faggots with the offal?? Wasteful!
Thethreecs · 01/02/2022 04:32

[quote TibetanTerrah]@Thethreecs genuine question - what would happen if you took your family to say a Toby Carvery? Because the meat is 'rationed', everyone gets the same and you can eat as much of everything else as you like. Nobody leaves a carvery hungry.

And don't say, 'we wouldn't go because there wouldn't be enough meat' Grin purely hypothetical, what would they do?[/quote]
What's a Toby carvery?

We have pubs here that do carverys, we haven't been in over 2 years due to lock downs here, restrictions on pubs and restaurants, they're only really open recently. Also due to the age of my kids we don't go to pub lunches anymore as they're not interested or working or school, college.

When we did go to carverys here, they didn't eat half a cow. They'd get meat and veg, it's usually about 4 slices of meat, 4 veg stuffing gravy. That's standard for a carvery here. You can get chicken breast at some carverys, they don't serve the leg as most don't buy it, there's other types of foods like curries etc they don't half a chicken breast between customers, you get a whole one to yourself. It's fairly common to be served a whole chicken breast when eating out here.

coodawoodashooda · 01/02/2022 04:04

I'm doing this next week!

TibetanTerrah · 01/02/2022 03:44

@sadpapercourtesan I mean, a carvery isn't exactly great food Grin but my point was it's possible to 'fill up' on a wide variety of other things in a roast that aren't meat.

If you go to a carvery, fill your plate, go back for seconds, and still need a mcdonalds shortly afterwards, you probably have worms rather than the lack of meat being the problem Grin

Meat has become so cheap to the detriment of animal welfare and people have become unimaginative and lazy. They also need far less protein than they pretend think most of the time. I'm an avid meat eater but there's an air of greed and entitlement that portion sizes are 'stingy' if they don't take up half the plate Confused

HootOwl · 01/02/2022 01:56

@AlternativePerspective

@ HootOwl maybe they’re all on the Atkins diet, so they don’t have anything with it, just a slab or two of meat. Wink Grin
🤣🤣
OP posts:
HootOwl · 01/02/2022 01:52

@blyn72

You'd have to have a pretty big chicken to do all that, Hoot. A capon maybe.

I used to buy three free range chickens for £10 at a local supermarket, some years ago. Obviously I'd freeze a couple. They weren't very big but were lovely roasted with all the trimmings and beautiful gravy made from the juices and some wine. There wasn't much left after dinner though. I'd cut up what there was and we'd sometimes have it with mashed potato and pickle plus some other cold meat, eg ham. Sometimes I did a pasta dish and included the leftovers and occasionally a risotto but there really wasn't much chicken meat.

Having written all that and completely forgotten what I was originally going to say, I am now sitting here at stupid o'clock, fancying a roast chicken dinner! I don't cook much since husband died. He used to love my roasts. Ah well, life goes on.

I'm interested to know about the 'Mumsnet chicken' that is so versatile and lasts so long, even though I won't be buying one as I am on my own.

I'm so sorry to hear that @blyn72. SadThanks

I am sure he'd want you to still do that for yourself, even if you then eat it across many days?

It was a very big chicken, yes!

OP posts:
blyn72 · 01/02/2022 01:50

You'd have to have a pretty big chicken to do all that, Hoot. A capon maybe.

I used to buy three free range chickens for £10 at a local supermarket, some years ago. Obviously I'd freeze a couple. They weren't very big but were lovely roasted with all the trimmings and beautiful gravy made from the juices and some wine. There wasn't much left after dinner though. I'd cut up what there was and we'd sometimes have it with mashed potato and pickle plus some other cold meat, eg ham. Sometimes I did a pasta dish and included the leftovers and occasionally a risotto but there really wasn't much chicken meat.

Having written all that and completely forgotten what I was originally going to say, I am now sitting here at stupid o'clock, fancying a roast chicken dinner! I don't cook much since husband died. He used to love my roasts. Ah well, life goes on.

I'm interested to know about the 'Mumsnet chicken' that is so versatile and lasts so long, even though I won't be buying one as I am on my own.

HootOwl · 01/02/2022 01:41

@merrymelodies

I consider an adult portion to be around 180g, which would be a chicken breast so it depends on the size of the bird. An average chicken in our house serves two adults and two children one meal.
And, this was about a 2kg chicken to probably 1.4-1.5kg meat. So 180g per portion would mean 7-8 portions, not 4!
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread