Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found his message unusual and now he seems to have taken offence that I questioned it

189 replies

wasiwrongtoask · 30/01/2022 10:57

I have been seeing someone for almost a year now and last night his last message seemed a bit unusual. I sent a text to say good night and he responded with a number of emojis. He is very articulate and not usually big on these and they included an aubergine 🍆 which I found odd so I asked if he was talking to someone else pointing out that it was unusual. He has now taken offence and was very defensive. Was I BU to ask?

OP posts:
wasiwrongtoask · 30/01/2022 12:30

I sent 'Hmmmm unusual response, are you talking to someone else?'

OP posts:
ballsdeep · 30/01/2022 12:27

@Pushmepullyou

I would read that as he loves you and wants a blow job
Me too.
TurquoiseBaubles · 30/01/2022 12:27

Did the op say "are you cheating on me"?

Chimen · 30/01/2022 12:25

What a massive leap from those messages to are you cheating on me?
You sound a bit paranoid and you’re failing to see it.

I think the BF is ending it because there is no doubt in my
mind this isn’t the first time you’ve acted paranoid.

ChickenStripper · 30/01/2022 12:25

@Anniegetyourgun

It's not out of context is you have been seeing him for a year and having sex with him. It's an unfortunate in your eyes statement of how attracted he is to you .

If the OP has been seeing him for a year, you might assume she knows him slightly better than someone who has never seen or communicated with him at all - and yet you know exactly what he did and why Confused

Just the same as any punter on here - making a suggestion and she obviously asked for that.
TurquoiseBaubles · 30/01/2022 12:23

It's interesting that some posters are saying that you "accused" him of something.

I would like to know exactly what your text said that led to him suggesting that things are over.

If you said "that's a weird message, did you mean to send it to me" and his reply was to accuse you of accusing him of inappropriate behaviour and suggest you break up, then I suspect he was behaving inappropriately.

if your text said "what the hell does that mean, are you texting another woman, wtf", then maybe his reaction is understandable.

So what, exactly, have you sent him in reply?

Anniegetyourgun · 30/01/2022 12:22

It's not out of context is you have been seeing him for a year and having sex with him. It's an unfortunate in your eyes statement of how attracted he is to you .

If the OP has been seeing him for a year, you might assume she knows him slightly better than someone who has never seen or communicated with him at all - and yet you know exactly what he did and why Confused

KurtWilde · 30/01/2022 12:22

Asking why he sent it and asking if he was texting someone else are 2 separate things.

Exactly. One is being direct, the other is being accusatory.

Arbeity · 30/01/2022 12:22

If it is out of the ordinary for him, then why would he text it to someone else? Especially if you haven't been together that long.

If he was out drinking, my first thought would probably be that a mate has gotten hold of his phone. Or perhaps he had the Dutch courage to try to initiate a bit of sexting?

And yes, I think you work will affect the conclusions you jump to. Tbh, I find that if I spend too much time on the relationships board here I do exactly the same. Hearing about men being dicks all the time makes you jump more quickly to that conclusion in the case of a misunderstanding

Branleuse · 30/01/2022 12:21

id wonder if it was meant for someone else too. I wouldnt accuse immediately though, but i definitely would dig a little

ChickenStripper · 30/01/2022 12:19

[quote wasiwrongtoask]@LawnFever but it's the fact it seemed out of context, was it wrong to ask in those circumstances?[/quote]
It's not out of context is you have been seeing him for a year and having sex with him. It's an unfortunate in your eyes statement of how attracted he is to you .

LittleWins · 30/01/2022 12:19

[quote wasiwrongtoask]@LittleWins yes a lot of people do but it's out of the ordinary for him. I think it's the fact that it out of the ordinary and not his usual'pattern' of communication that made me question it [/quote]
I get that but how you ask is so important and you’re talking about his reaction here too. I would be so hurt to be accused of connecting with others.

Do you think he’s cheating? Is there more to this?

Skeumorph · 30/01/2022 12:18

These replies seem purposefully shitty.

So after a year you know what someone's 'style' is and yep, if he does not typically - or ever! - reply to a goodnight with a string of emojis like that then it's absolutely WTF? time.

And so you look at the message with the aubergine after the stars in eyes etc and yep, absolutely that totally indicates that it's supposed to be a response to seeing a sexy pic. It most certainly isn't a response to a goodnight.

Honestly I would think exactly the same as op. Might not have said so though.

But then he's super defensive in response to Qs and jumps to 'it's over' -?

Ok, caught out.

dump and move on OP. I'm with you on this one.

PiesNotGuys · 30/01/2022 12:18

I can understand your point OP. That’s not how you communicate and so it might not have been meant for you.

No man I’ve been seeing has ever sent me a text with an emoji, ever. It would seem strange to me and it’s a very out of context response to ‘goodnight’

I think you are right tbh, and the defensive response points that way too.

AlDanvers · 30/01/2022 12:17

@TheGreatATuin

This is a fascinating thread. Usually if a DP does something out of character, the advice is 'just ask him' usually with an eyeroll. The OP did and he completely freaked out and is now acting like the relationship might be over over a question. If I were OP, I'd also have just asked but I'd be very Hmm 🚩 at his reaction.
Asking why he sent it and asking if he was texting someone else are 2 separate things.

Often people are told not to confront if they are suspicious. But try and find more out first.

wasiwrongtoask · 30/01/2022 12:16

@LittleWins yes a lot of people do but it's out of the ordinary for him. I think it's the fact that it out of the ordinary and not his usual'pattern' of communication that made me question it

OP posts:
User310 · 30/01/2022 12:13

I disagree with every single one of the posts saying there is something wrong in the relationship to making you think cheating. I also disagree that wording it differently would mean something different.

If my DP sent me the same row of Emojis that the op received I would also ask if that was meant for me. I have never been sent anything like that before, he is very articulate and doesn’t faff on texts. I would find it out of character. Op has only been with her partner for a year, yes you would like to see the best in everybody and hope they wouldn’t cheat but statistically you are more likely to be cheated on than not and this was out of character. He has then been incredibly defensive and is basically saying the relationship is over?! That is madness.

If I asked my DP if he sent that to somebody else and he was just messing around he would reply something along the lines of ‘no you idiot’, and that would be the end of it.

LittleWins · 30/01/2022 12:13

I would have felt accused & been defensive too.

Maybe he had nothing else to say. I lazily rely on emojis when sleepy/had too many drinks.

TheGreatATuin · 30/01/2022 12:13

This is a fascinating thread. Usually if a DP does something out of character, the advice is 'just ask him' usually with an eyeroll.
The OP did and he completely freaked out and is now acting like the relationship might be over over a question.
If I were OP, I'd also have just asked but I'd be very Hmm 🚩 at his reaction.

Loopytiles · 30/01/2022 12:07

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood makes good points.

It seems likely your suspicion was correct.

Also agree with PP that for you to have come to the suspicion of cheating - unless you have a history of not trusting boyfriends when there’s been little reason not to - perhaps other things about his behaviour had concerned you.

My sibling maintains that, unless people have a history of being overly suspicious without reason about people they’re dating, friends with, work with, neighbours, that suspicions they have about one person are often useful!

MeSanniesareBrannies · 30/01/2022 12:02

As opposed to asking if he was talking to someone else, you could have just asked why he sent you the emoji?

If you’d done something silly in random and this immediately triggered him asking if you were talking to someone else, wouldn’t you be offended? The zero to 60 nature of that would cause me, personally, to seriously question the relationship.

CheesusWept · 30/01/2022 12:02

You said he’d been drinking - were his messages his usual up until that last one?

I’d have found it odd to receive a message like that in response to a good night text.

AlDanvers · 30/01/2022 12:02

[quote wasiwrongtoask]@AlDanvers no first time ever I have questioned him. I'm not clingy, possessive or jealous either![/quote]
I didn't say you had questioned him. Bit ita really not hard to pick up on someone's behaviour. The change of their mood or body language when something is mentioned for example, or plans are made etc.

You don't have to be jealous, posseive or clingy to also be suspicious.

Its not all as rosey as you make out, if you jump straight to cheating. Something is going on for you for this to be first thought.

OwlIceCrem · 30/01/2022 12:02

@WhyMeLord

Was there any mention of Stonehenge?
😂🤣
wasiwrongtoask · 30/01/2022 11:59

@AlDanvers no first time ever I have questioned him. I'm not clingy, possessive or jealous either!

OP posts: