Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Hollyoaks should move on from Luke’s rape in 1999?

41 replies

Appleavocado · 30/01/2022 10:01

I dip in and out of this programme but I was obsessed with it in the late 90s/early 2000s.

Luke came back in it a few years ago and every episode I’ve seen since has a storyline about the rape (1999 I think.)

Apart from being a bit boring now AIBU to think it’s probably not entirely responsible to promote the idea that rape will ruin your whole life?

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 30/01/2022 10:24

I find it interesting how male rape is always given much more attention in terms of the effects on the person, than female rape is. That's often reflected in sentencing and how historical cases are handled in RL as well.
My teens used to watch it. It was the only soap that depicted HIV correctly. It depicted abusive relationships well. I stopped watching when Teagan was drinking with Joe etc then when he had his fall, she was the one to decide to switch off his life support a few hours later. All of the hospital situations became ridiculous.

Puffflashpuffflashbang · 30/01/2022 10:20

But luke was about 19 when it happened and this idea that it’s still the most significant defining moment in his life 23 years later seems a bit odd to me.

I was 17. Next time I speak about it in therapy, I'll mention to my therapist that as it was years ago that I really shouldn't think of it as a significant experience that's created lasting trauma.
I'll also mention that @Appleavocado finds it odd that I'm still so upset about it and see what he says.

Appleavocado · 30/01/2022 10:20

I think if they’d wanted to do that, which is a reasonable take - to have Luke come back in the show broken and destroyed by what happened to him - then they’d have been better to do it like that.

What they actually did was have him come back and then have endless storylines where he - and therefore we - had various reminders of what happened to him, every time involving lots of red faces and clenched fists and shouting.

Like a lot of young women, unfortunately, I experienced sexual assault and while it is one thing to show how it impacts someone’s life, this tends to be in subtle ways, not endlessly bumping into your rapists.

I also don’t think you can say that someone’s life is ‘destroyed’ for any one reason, usually - things are more nuanced than that.

OP posts:
Puffflashpuffflashbang · 30/01/2022 10:16

Rape effects everyone in very different ways, some people will try put it behind them,
Some, it will unfortunately be with them in everything they do, no matter how long after.
I think some of what you've said is quite insensitive actually. It's much more realistic to portray that someone's life was destroyed by assault, than just carrying on like all is fine and they're over it.

Appleavocado · 30/01/2022 10:13

Me too @Eslteacher06 and no, come back to the thread, it’s good nostalgia.

I remember they did a ‘good’ (if that’s not too dark a take on it) date rape storyline with Andy and Sam and the twins. Then (since this is ‘Oaks) it got daft with Sam escaping from prison and burning down the Dog in the Pond!

OP posts:
Appleavocado · 30/01/2022 10:12

No one’s said ‘everything hunky dory’ though.

Life just doesn’t work like that. It’s like when Jacqueline Wilson tried to make Tracy beaker an adult - it was just daft because she kept bumping into characters from her childhood, as if nothing significant between the ages of say eleven and about thirty five happened!

OP posts:
Eslteacher06 · 30/01/2022 10:11

It was my way of getting through a hangover on a Sunday morning...infact i have that association with it now haha. Sorry, I don't want to derail the thread Grin...I'll back away now

sometimespeopletakethepiss · 30/01/2022 10:10

Never seen the show either but I agree OP, ultimately it's an entertainment show not a documentary so perhaps they could love on from such a grim storyline

Sirzy · 30/01/2022 10:09

I have never watched the show but it’s much more realistic to suggest that something like rape will have a long term impact than to suggest that everything is hunky dory

Appleavocado · 30/01/2022 10:07

@Eslteacher06

Saying that, I've not watched it since the early 2000s lol
It’s still somewhat less than realistic Grin

I used to love it, would obsessively watch the omnibus on Sunday mornings Blush

OP posts:
Eslteacher06 · 30/01/2022 10:07

Saying that, I've not watched it since the early 2000s lol

Appleavocado · 30/01/2022 10:06

I know, I always think it’s ridiculous when someone has their entire family wiped out with a traumatic event but they are never mentioned again a few weeks later!

I suppose the problem is it isn’t just mentioned in passing, there’s entire storylines based around it with rapists coming back and so on. I think they are trying to rehash what was a very successful storyline but as a result it’s insincere.

I also don’t think I am comfortable with the message that if you are raped it will ruin your life. I do understand there’s a fine line here. You don’t want to give the message that you move on and it won’t impact you at all when of course it will. But luke was about 19 when it happened and this idea that it’s still the most significant defining moment in his life 23 years later seems a bit odd to me.

OP posts:
Shiningpath · 30/01/2022 10:06

I agree with the PP: that’s more realistic than the usual soap rubbish where at the end of the particular storyline the victim seems to move on with no lasting effects and it never gets mentioned again.

If only life really were like that for victims of sexual crimes.

Eslteacher06 · 30/01/2022 10:05

I see what you mean OP in terms of entertainment, but they are depicting real life. I can only imagine the horror the victim goes through and the effect on their whole life. So they're highlighting that fact.

Turquoisa80 · 30/01/2022 10:05

I was an avid viewer in the late 90s too and Lukes rape story was so powerful. I also watched recently and as far as I'm aware he was okay and went on to have relationships and a son, it's his dementia diagnosis that is making him more vulnerable

cheekychaplin · 30/01/2022 10:02

I have never seen it but it's not unrealistic to suggest that it stays with a person. In fact you could argue that it's more realistic than any other soap which features characters bounce right back and almost forget traumatic events.