Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think mn are very intolerant/disrespectful on conservative values?

285 replies

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 09:09

Several threads have appeared on last several months over the sharing of bedrooms for posters adult children and partners. When a poster or her husband acknowledges they don't feel comfortable over this and want separate beds until marriage and mn gets up in arms over it blasting the latter as 'ridiculous' 'absurd' etc.

The poster or her husband will get bullied almost and be seen as an anti Christ. AIBU to think if people want to be conservative or have values different to our own that are not seriously harming anybody then that is fine and something posters should respect especially when it is the rules they set in their own house.

BTW I am not conservative or prudish by any means but aibu to think shaming and heckling people over being conservative and different to ourselves is bully like?

OP posts:
youvegottenminuteslynn · 30/01/2022 10:52

OP if people thought the poster who started the thread (about adult children and partners not being allowed to share beds) was being OTT and ridiculous, how would you suggest they did word that in a way you didn't consider to be 'bullying'.

Because your threshold for what you consider bullying seems ever so low and it sounds like you just think if people disagree with an OP they shouldn't post on the thread.

Which would rather defeat the object of a discussion forum.

So how could they have worded their opinion that it was an outdated and ridiculous rule, in a way you would have found acceptable? Genuinely interested.

PonyPatter44 · 30/01/2022 10:50

Its wonderfully British to suggest that calling someone's behaviour ridiculous is like calling them the Antichrist. Can you imagine Satan returning to Earth in Milton Keynes, 100 feet of winged, horned anger rising through the pavement.... and people tutting and saying "how ridiculous, its bad enough that the council are digging up all the grid roads, but now the bloody Antichrist is doing it too".

MOTU · 30/01/2022 10:50

if you ask for peoples opinions and the vast majority of responses go against your position, that's not bullying it's demonstrating what the current "norm" is....being out of step with the modern standard is not a form of oppression

godmum56 · 30/01/2022 10:45

@3scape

I think most people would expect someone's values to be robust enough to stand up to logical challenge.
but if its "my house my rules", then its doesn't have to be logical to others. Currently my house rules take into account my frail elderly dog. To someone who doesn't care about dogs, or has never cared for one with the problems mine has, the rules might seem extreme and unreasonable. Their "logical challenge" frankly doesn't interest or concern me. My choice is to set the rules for my house...their choice is to visit me or not.
Fearnyleaves · 30/01/2022 10:44

A hell of a lot of harm, abuse & oppression has been inflicted on women and gay people under the guise of 'conservative values'.

Lesperance · 30/01/2022 10:42

You are being ridiculous. But would you see me considering your view as ridiculous as me being intolerant? Rather than having a different view to you, and putting it bluntly?
There isn't a "mumsnet view" is there? You prove that yourself with your post.

3scape · 30/01/2022 10:39

I think most people would expect someone's values to be robust enough to stand up to logical challenge.

godmum56 · 30/01/2022 10:36

@Pedalpushers

The 'my house my rules' people are the bullies in this situation. They are the ones who want to enforce control, push their values onto others and shame them for perfectly acceptable behaviour.
no I don't think so....."my house my rules" can cover all kinds of things....no outdoor shoes, no smoking, no animal products, no bringing your dog/lizard/pet spider and so on. Its not bullying to require your rules to be followed in your house....it can be enforced in a bullying and unpleasant way of course but the requirement alone isn't bullying.
ToykotoLosAngeles · 30/01/2022 10:34

If the couple already lives together they're probably not going to have sex in your precious guestroom. Who wants to deal with bed squeaks and cleanup when your parents are in the next room?

LumosSolem · 30/01/2022 10:33

Dp's mum doesn't approve, we know such views exist! his siblings think she's ridiculous (she's relented and let his brothers fiancé stay when they visited because she wanted to see the baby!) we stay at his sisters when we go, but it's a lot less frequent than it otherwise would be.

That, right there, is why people find it ridiculous. They have a baby- does she think the stork dropped it off? 😂

Darkstar4855 · 30/01/2022 10:28

If you post in a forum asking people for their opinions then that’s what you’ll get. If you only want to hear from people who agree with your outdated religious values then you’re in the wrong place.

gogohm · 30/01/2022 10:28

Those posters obviously had questions over their stance otherwise they wouldn't have posted on a public forum! I would always caution those posting that they are out of step with the general consensus now and risk alienating their children, they are free to hold views but others can disapprove too.

Dp's mum doesn't approve, we know such views exist! his siblings think she's ridiculous (she's relented and let his brothers fiancé stay when they visited because she wanted to see the baby!) we stay at his sisters when we go, but it's a lot less frequent than it otherwise would be.

ElftonWednesday · 30/01/2022 10:26

So you are trying to shut down opinions you don't care for, OP? Perhaps you could find a nice mimsy little socially conservative talkboard instead. People here are entitled to say what a pile of wank other people's opinions or beliefs are.

Pedalpushers · 30/01/2022 10:25

The 'my house my rules' people are the bullies in this situation. They are the ones who want to enforce control, push their values onto others and shame them for perfectly acceptable behaviour.

CaptSkippy · 30/01/2022 10:24

OP, I voted YABU because you descibed one thing and posted examples of another. You are drawing a false equivalency.

Consenting adults wanting to wait to have sex untill marriage is their business. I would not personally consider it wise, but it's a decision that two people get to make for themselves.

People trying to prevent two consenting adults from having sex because they are not married is meddling and completely unreasonable, even if these adults are the children of the meddlesome person. Children are not property, especially not once they reach adulthood.

So, yes YABU. One thing has nothing to do with the other and if "conservative values" consist of a bunch of logical fallacies then I won't be very tolerant of them.

longwayoff · 30/01/2022 10:23

Shouldn't you be at Church OP instead of wasting time on here? It is Sunday. As for conservative values, if you can find some that aren't simple bigotry and bias, bring them.

CaptainMerica · 30/01/2022 10:21

Whenever I've seen responses to similar posts, they have largely seemed to be trying to help the OP, not treat them as evil. E.g. "if you do that, it will damage your relationship and your kids won't want to visit you". Not "you are a terrible person".

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 30/01/2022 10:20

I think it’s interesting that the general consensus is that conservative beliefs are wrong, outdated etc… unless your family follows specific religions and then it’s perfectly fine to tell your adult children what to do.

AlexaShutUp · 30/01/2022 10:18

None of the examples that you gave back up y your point at all.

People come onto MN and ask for opinions about their stance on a particular issue. If other posters answer honestly to say that they find that stance ridiculous, how is that bullying? What's the point of asking strangers for their opinions in the first place if you just want them to agree with whatever you say?

JugglingJanuary · 30/01/2022 10:17

@makkapacca

An adult not in the relationship wants to stop 2 people sleeping together is the same as 1 person not wanting to sleep with another person

I am saying people are entitled to have their values that are not harming anybody and have them carried out in their own house if that's what they want. Every mn user will have policies/rules/principles they use to govern their lives/houses and that is their prerogative, they shouldn't be called 'mad' or 'ridiculous' for it.

Yes, they're entitled to have rules in their own home, what they're NOT entitled to, is to expect everyone to agree with them.

If people ask for opinions on their batshit rules, people are entitled to tell them they're being ridiculous.

SunshineOnKeith · 30/01/2022 10:17

@makkapacca

*So? My gay adult DC can share a room in my house with their gay adult partner just the same as my other adult DC could share a room with their adult partner. Why does being gay make any difference?

My DC are not adults yet but one of them is gay and I wouldn't apply different moral judgements to him because of it*

I was saying it because the stance was seen as an attack on women whereas the thread I was referring to had nothing to do with women.

Well I think you'll find that TAAT are against talk guidelines and you're breaking the rules
Hospedia · 30/01/2022 10:14

I was saying it because the stance was seen as an attack on women whereas the thread I was referring to had nothing to do with women.

Your initial descriptions and responses implied it was a man and woman. "But they were gay men" is not the 'gotcha' moment you seem to think it is.

MsAgnesDiPesto · 30/01/2022 10:14

@makkapacca

*So? My gay adult DC can share a room in my house with their gay adult partner just the same as my other adult DC could share a room with their adult partner. Why does being gay make any difference?

My DC are not adults yet but one of them is gay and I wouldn't apply different moral judgements to him because of it*

I was saying it because the stance was seen as an attack on women whereas the thread I was referring to had nothing to do with women.

No, YOU raised the fact that you think Mumsnet sees all views as attacks on women. Not any of us. YOU. And that was so offensive that I was moved to respond.

If you feel there is a valid argument to support the view that adult children who share a bed in their own home shouldn’t be allowed to do so at a relative’s home, then crack on with your discussion. You might persuade others to adopt your own view with your arguments if they are sound, in the same way that someone with the opposing view might persuade you of theirs. But don’t come and try to paint all the people on Mumsnet as somehow hating everything because they think women are oppressed. Supporting the oppression of women anywhere and everywhere is a view which really is indefensible.

SunshineOnKeith · 30/01/2022 10:13

@makkapacca

*Those are not examples of bullying whatsoever confused

They are in disagreement with the OP- they are opinions clearly at odds with the OP- you cannot call disagreement, even if plainly spoken, 'bullying'*

ok so if posters were using the same words to go against a woman saying she believed in no sex before marriage would you say it wasn't bullying or harsh?

So what you're suggesting is that when a poster asks for opinions, we should only respond if we agree with that poster because disagreeing is 'bullying'?  I don't think you understand how discussion boards work @makkapacca I'd suggest that if posters cannot cope with an alternative viewpoint then they shouldn't post.
godmum56 · 30/01/2022 10:11

@makkapacca

*Those are not examples of bullying whatsoever confused

They are in disagreement with the OP- they are opinions clearly at odds with the OP- you cannot call disagreement, even if plainly spoken, 'bullying'*

ok so if posters were using the same words to go against a woman saying she believed in no sex before marriage would you say it wasn't bullying or harsh?

if I have understood you correctly, for me the difference is that one is two people in a partnership and one telling the other that they won't do sex before marriage and the other is two people visiting a third person't home and that third person saying that only married people can sleep in the same bed under their roof...which ok their gaff their rules but is slightly batshit