Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think mn are very intolerant/disrespectful on conservative values?

285 replies

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 09:09

Several threads have appeared on last several months over the sharing of bedrooms for posters adult children and partners. When a poster or her husband acknowledges they don't feel comfortable over this and want separate beds until marriage and mn gets up in arms over it blasting the latter as 'ridiculous' 'absurd' etc.

The poster or her husband will get bullied almost and be seen as an anti Christ. AIBU to think if people want to be conservative or have values different to our own that are not seriously harming anybody then that is fine and something posters should respect especially when it is the rules they set in their own house.

BTW I am not conservative or prudish by any means but aibu to think shaming and heckling people over being conservative and different to ourselves is bully like?

OP posts:
ShallWeTalkAboutBruno · 30/01/2022 11:22

that's the point i am making, there are no such bashing threads and it's hypocritical to support 1 value but not the other

Why is it? They are 2 completely different values. One is about bodily autonomy, the other isn’t.

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 11:18

Decent, sensible adults are respectful of other people's sensible, reasonable requests/house rules. No shoes indoors for example, makes sense, @godmum56 you mentioned rules around your elderly dog- even someone who isn't a dog lover as such like me is fully understanding of why you would make certain requests for your dog's wellbeing and comfort. Any decent, caring person would respect them

so we must only follow rules that we agree with then?

OP posts:
makkapacca · 30/01/2022 11:17

Any threads about women feeling pressured into sex are very supportive of the woman, whatever her reasons. Can you show examples of how the MN 'hive' have insulted a woman for not having sex

that's the point i am making, there are no such bashing threads and it's hypocritical to support 1 value but not the other.

OP posts:
LumosSolem · 30/01/2022 11:17

@makkapacca

If she doesn't want to have sex before marriage, thats fine, HER BODY HER CHOICE

likewise HIS/HER HOUSE , HIS/HER CHOICE

Which comes across as so incredibly petty and controlling that hopefully petty-minded people who want to dictate 'MY HOUSE MY CHOICE' will reap the consequences. I wouldn't visit my parents if they still wanted to treat me like a child.

Decent, sensible adults are respectful of other people's sensible, reasonable requests/house rules. No shoes indoors for example, makes sense, @godmum56 you mentioned rules around your elderly dog- even someone who isn't a dog lover as such like me is fully understanding of why you would make certain requests for your dog's wellbeing and comfort. Any decent, caring person would respect them.

Now where is the benefit of requesting that consenting adults, who may well live together the rest of the time, sleep in separate beds? It smacks of being entirely about control and moral judgements as opposed to any meaningful, sensible reason for the request.

When the argument solely comes down to 'my house, my rules', it indicates there isn't really a reasonable logic to it in the first place.

Alexandra2001 · 30/01/2022 11:16

@makkapacca why would anyone post a thread on the sleeping arrangements of their adult children?

If they did, then of course they will get opinions on the subject, some strongly held.

However i associate Conservative Values much like i do with the Values of the Carphone Warehouse.

Hospedia · 30/01/2022 11:15

Surely a home is usually a family home.

If the adult child lives there then it's their home too.

Cantleave · 30/01/2022 11:11

@Madamswearsalot

Half missing the point here but threads often feel like a 'hive mind' is happening because people pile on when their view has already been espoused by another person - they feel safe to say similar. Most people with an opposite view will not post on those occasions because they're in the minority. I know there are some who'll stick their neck out but not many.

I've seen various threads where the tone of the first couple of responses sets out how it's going to go for the rest of the thread. For example, if an early responder is picky about a specific detail in the op you'll see a load more responses saying the same.

I think there is lots of very valuable advice to be had on here but there's also a lot of people who don't employ critical thinking and just enjoy the experience of everyone agreeing with them.

Agree with this, although it doesn’t have to be the first couple of responses. Often well into the thread, a poster will make a comment that hasn’t already been made, and lo and behold there then appears more responses saying the same thing! Was it really the case that poster number 90 is the first one to make a certain comment and posters 91, 92 and 95 just so happened to have just had that thought as well? Doubt it! Hmm
slashlover · 30/01/2022 11:08

@makkapacca

If she doesn't want to have sex before marriage, thats fine, HER BODY HER CHOICE

likewise HIS/HER HOUSE , HIS/HER CHOICE

I think you're entitled to say what happens in your house. Just don't complain if your adult DC decide not to visit you, or stay in a hotel instead. (Looking at you, mum and dad(not me, my sister)).
PastMyBestBeforeDate · 30/01/2022 11:08

You've conflated two entirely different things here. The Conservative Party and conservative views are not the same thing. The Conservative Party had conservativeviews about land and property 200 odd years ago.
Presumably you aren't suggesting we take the vote away from working men and all women? And you can be a libertarian Conservative like Boris Johnson (grab what you can, do what you want) or a conservative Socialist.

DirectionToPerfection · 30/01/2022 11:07

Perhaps because we have the privilege of living in a liberal democracy where respect and tolerance for everyone is a fundamental cornerstone of civilised discourse?

Many conservative values are intolerant and disrespectful to others though, causing actual harm, but apparently that's ok.

MsAgnesDiPesto · 30/01/2022 11:07

@makkapacca

If she doesn't want to have sex before marriage, thats fine, HER BODY HER CHOICE

likewise HIS/HER HOUSE , HIS/HER CHOICE

Are you being deliberately obtuse? Every person is allowed to make choices which affect his or her own body. Nobody else is allowed to make their choices for them. Even a parent.

If you wish to impose your views on your adult children, you can try, but be prepared that they will be unlikely to want to expose themselves to your exertion of control over their legal, adult choices, so you are unlikely to maintain a relationship with them.

saddowizca · 30/01/2022 11:05

"Cam77

There used to be such a thing as disagreeing with someone's views in a respectful manner, but the anonymity and angry confrontational nature of much of the internet is making it something of a lost art"

Agreed.

Socialcarenope · 30/01/2022 11:05

I think it's reflective that these opinions are in the minority.

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 11:04

If she doesn't want to have sex before marriage, thats fine, HER BODY HER CHOICE

likewise HIS/HER HOUSE , HIS/HER CHOICE

OP posts:
ShallWeTalkAboutBruno · 30/01/2022 11:03

Or do you think that people who have very different opinions to you don’t qualify for respect?

I respect everyone’s right to have their own opinions. I don’t always respect that opinion, no. There are many opinions that aren’t worthy of respect.

ArchibaldsDaddy · 30/01/2022 11:01

@ShallWeTalkAboutBruno

Why should people automatically be ‘respectful’ of conservative values though, if we think that particular value is batshit?
Perhaps because we have the privilege of living in a liberal democracy where respect and tolerance for everyone is a fundamental cornerstone of civilised discourse?

Or do you think that people who have very different opinions to you don’t qualify for respect??

PrincessNikla · 30/01/2022 11:01

@makkapacca

*Those are not examples of bullying whatsoever confused

They are in disagreement with the OP- they are opinions clearly at odds with the OP- you cannot call disagreement, even if plainly spoken, 'bullying'*

ok so if posters were using the same words to go against a woman saying she believed in no sex before marriage would you say it wasn't bullying or harsh?

If she doesn't want to have sex before marriage, thats fine, HER BODY HER CHOICE!
MsAgnesDiPesto · 30/01/2022 11:00

but if its "my house my rules", then its doesn't have to be logical to others. Currently my house rules take into account my frail elderly dog. To someone who doesn't care about dogs, or has never cared for one with the problems mine has, the rules might seem extreme and unreasonable. Their "logical challenge" frankly doesn't interest or concern me. My choice is to set the rules for my house...their choice is to visit me or not.

There is a distinction, surely, between house rules which avoid harm to someone (or a pet), and those which don’t? I don’t want people wearing shoes in my house because if they do I will need to shampoo my carpet more frequently. So it inconveniences me if they do so, where taking off their shoes doesn’t inconvenience them. People coming in and upsetting your dog is something which causes harm, where staying away from the place the dog is won’t cause them any harm or inconvenience.

Two people sleeping in the same bed doesn’t cause the OP any harm or inconvenience, so there is less defence - s/he is only objecting on ideological grounds. There is a world of difference.

ArchibaldsDaddy · 30/01/2022 10:58

I agree wholeheartedly that there is a lot of shaming on here unless it subscribes to a very particular narrative.

Man-bashing and a propensity to say ‘do whatever YOU like because THEY are being totally unreasonable’ are probably the two least helpful tropes…

But, sadly, the polarisation of online opinion is a growing trend…as is the indignation and self-righteousness that very often accompanies it.

My personal opinion: the posts that give a balanced view are the ones that have value, whereas the one-dimensional ones where you can almost feel the keys getting ploughed into the desk in rage are probably less so.

ShallWeTalkAboutBruno · 30/01/2022 10:58

Why should people automatically be ‘respectful’ of conservative values though, if we think that particular value is batshit?

Cam77 · 30/01/2022 10:57

There used to be such a thing as disagreeing with someone's views in a respectful manner, but the anonymity and angry confrontational nature of much of the internet is making it something of a lost art among younger generations.

saddowizca · 30/01/2022 10:54

I'm not sure why you care tbh, MN is just lots of different people posting anonymously, it doesn't really matter what we think does it?

CeleriacOfTheNight · 30/01/2022 10:53

Treated like the Antichrist- a few robust posts on Mumsnet?

Thank god the makers of The Omen film got their version to our screens first.

Cam77 · 30/01/2022 10:53

I think it depends on how serious the relationship is. A gf/bf who are cohabiting usually and have been together for several years - no problem. But a short term thing, one night stands or multiple relationships in a couple of years. nah. Surely a home is usually a family home. Not a Tinder stopover. Respect is a two way street.

RantyAunty · 30/01/2022 10:52

My parents were like this and I had a baby with with boyfriend.
I wasn't angry at the time but puzzled at their thinking.

That baby is now nearly 40 and I have a good laugh at it.

It's truly not getting upset over.