Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think mn are very intolerant/disrespectful on conservative values?

285 replies

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 09:09

Several threads have appeared on last several months over the sharing of bedrooms for posters adult children and partners. When a poster or her husband acknowledges they don't feel comfortable over this and want separate beds until marriage and mn gets up in arms over it blasting the latter as 'ridiculous' 'absurd' etc.

The poster or her husband will get bullied almost and be seen as an anti Christ. AIBU to think if people want to be conservative or have values different to our own that are not seriously harming anybody then that is fine and something posters should respect especially when it is the rules they set in their own house.

BTW I am not conservative or prudish by any means but aibu to think shaming and heckling people over being conservative and different to ourselves is bully like?

OP posts:
pointythings · 30/01/2022 12:04

It's really very simple, OP. If you won't let your adult children share a bed with someone they are in a relationship with but not married to, they are likely to choose to visit you less often.

You're free to have that rule, but you can't then whinge about 'oh, you never come to see me'. Choices, consequences.

Crikeyalmighty · 30/01/2022 12:03

The only thing I have ‘conservative values ‘ on is that I’m not ok with constant secretive porn use in long term live in relationships— I’m afraid I don’t feel very liberal on that.

ThirdElephant · 30/01/2022 11:59

YABU for saying the posters are treated as an 'antichrist'. I've been on those threads and you're looking at hyperbole in the rest view mirror there.

Anniegetyourgun · 30/01/2022 11:57

I would go to the barricades for my right to make my rules in my own house, or for that matter for anyone else's right to do the same, provided it isn't something harmful or illegal. However, if I post on an open forum asking for views on those rules, people have a total right to disagree with them. They don't have a right to come into my house and start breaking the rules they disagree with; but I don't think anyone claimed they did? "Your house, your rules, but I think it's batshit" is a fair enough response seeing as the OP of the (hypothetical?) thread actually asked what people think. Posters gave them the courtesy of an honest response.

Cheekypeach · 30/01/2022 11:57

YABU because it isn’t ‘intolerant’ to give an opinion when asked. If the poster has come to the website asking for honest opinions & gets them, what do you expect?

godmum56 · 30/01/2022 11:55

@LumosSolem

lets be clear.....my rules are not requests. I require compliance.......and yes i agree that setting rules by the owner of the house will have consequences and one of those consequences will be that certain people won't visit BUT its my house. My rules don't have to be logical or reasonable or make sense to others BECAUSE ITS MY HOUSE.

And do you generally find that you have to dictate and state that you 'require compliance' or do you find that you can make polite and reasonable requests of your friends and family which they are happy to respect?

As you say, it's your house, but people tend to follow things are reasonable without fuss anyway. If not, why would anyone want them to visit? And why indeed would anyone visit with ridiculous rules being imposed?

I think most people now would really question the sense of someone whose unreasonable house rules could cause a wedge between themselves and their children. Just because 'IT'S MY HOUSE!'. But it says a lot about people's priorities I guess.

In practice I have had people visit who were supposed to be in the house to work for me. they felt themselves to be unable to comply with the rules and I required them to leave.

but what I am discussing is the principle involved (as i believe was the OP) and the principle is that its not up to others to decide what is or is not reasonable or ridiculous in my house.

I don't understand why you don't understand this? Do you think that its reasonable for visitors to make judgements over what is reasonable or acceptable to do in other people's houses?

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 30/01/2022 11:52

@makkapacca

Any threads about women feeling pressured into sex are very supportive of the woman, whatever her reasons. Can you show examples of how the MN 'hive' have insulted a woman for not having sex

that's the point i am making, there are no such bashing threads and it's hypocritical to support 1 value but not the other.

No it's not, because they are two completely different scenarios Hmm

One is about a woman's bodily autonomy - if she doesn't want to have sex before marriage, that view should always be respected.

Parents deciding that their adult children can't share a room with their partner are trying to control what other, independent adults do with their bodies. The two aren't comparable in the slightest.

topcat2014 · 30/01/2022 11:52

I am a Conservative party member. I don't have those values. Think you are conflating with religion, OP.

This is why hotels exist.

Cornettoninja · 30/01/2022 11:51

@MrsSkylerWhite

I don’t understand why people even put such questions. If they are confident that their values are right they don’t need validation. If they are going to put such questions to a wide range of people they can expect a wide range of answers.
I was just scanning this thread thinking that.

I would add that attributing a popular view to ‘hive mind’ isn’t particularly helpful either. People agree and disagree on lots of things, when you find yourself with an unpopular view it’s quite likely that you’re just not on the side of the majority. There are some things where that matters and education is important, the examples posed here? Not so much.

Stravaig · 30/01/2022 11:46

I'm guessing there's a large degree of overlap in the Venn diagram of

People who don't like being disagreed with;
People who try to control the behaviour of their adult children;
People who espouse 'conservative values'.

Goldbar · 30/01/2022 11:46

Expressing an opinion is not in itself intolerant and/or disrespectful.

Even if that opinion is in disagreement to your own.

No one is entitled to an echo chamber.

Avaynia · 30/01/2022 11:46

Considering the amount of times I’ve seen woke tossed around as an insult as well as handmaidens, cool girls/wives and various isms defended as being traditional or just an opinion someone is entitled to have (conveniently excluding sexism of course) YABVU

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/01/2022 11:45

I don’t understand why people even put such questions.
If they are confident that their values are right they don’t need validation.
If they are going to put such questions to a wide range of people they can expect a wide range of answers.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 30/01/2022 11:42

@makkapacca

Can you give an example of bullying or treating someone as the Antichrist please
  1. What does making them sleep in separate rooms actually achieve other than making them feel like they’re about 15? They’re an adult couple. Ridiculous.
  1. I do think it’s ridiculous to make two consenting adults sleep in separate rooms when you know they are sharing a bed the rest of the time.

3.I think it would be ridiculous to make them sleep in different rooms.

4.This is one of the most ridiculous things I've seen on here. It was also ridiculous to make your dd's bf sleep in a separate room when she was 21. YABVU

5.They are 23 and 26! Sorry its complete madness! They have obviously share a bed regularly because they are couple, and some pretence of 'waiting till marriage' when they arent is bizarre

  1. They are 23 and 26! Sorry its complete madness! They have obviously share a bed regularly because they are couple, and some pretence of 'waiting till marriage' when they arent is bizarre
None of that is bullying - it's called having an opinion.
LumosSolem · 30/01/2022 11:41

lets be clear.....my rules are not requests. I require compliance.......and yes i agree that setting rules by the owner of the house will have consequences and one of those consequences will be that certain people won't visit BUT its my house. My rules don't have to be logical or reasonable or make sense to others BECAUSE ITS MY HOUSE.

And do you generally find that you have to dictate and state that you 'require compliance' or do you find that you can make polite and reasonable requests of your friends and family which they are happy to respect?

As you say, it's your house, but people tend to follow things are reasonable without fuss anyway. If not, why would anyone want them to visit? And why indeed would anyone visit with ridiculous rules being imposed?

I think most people now would really question the sense of someone whose unreasonable house rules could cause a wedge between themselves and their children. Just because 'IT'S MY HOUSE!'. But it says a lot about people's priorities I guess.

OlympicProcrastinator · 30/01/2022 11:40

Half missing the point here but threads often feel like a 'hive mind' is happening because people pile on when their view has already been espoused by another person - they feel safe to say similar. Most people with an opposite view will not post on those occasions because they're in the minority. I know there are some who'll stick their neck out but not many

Yes this is me. I often start to type a reply with a different view, particularly with regards to dating / sex on a first date, texting, what is / isn’t ok in a relationship in my opinion but then delete it because I can’t be arsed with personal attacks or name calling. It’s a sad fact that people who have a different opinion often resort to name calling and I can’t be arsed with that when I’m just trying to give advice or opinions the OP asked for. Then the threads are basically squeed one way.

PrincessNikla · 30/01/2022 11:37

@makkapacca

If she doesn't want to have sex before marriage, thats fine, HER BODY HER CHOICE

likewise HIS/HER HOUSE , HIS/HER CHOICE

Not the same by any means
blyn72 · 30/01/2022 11:30

I've not come across anyone saying they would not sleep together before marriage, on MN.

HTH1 · 30/01/2022 11:29

The point of Mumsnet is to anonymously seek opinions from the general public. So yes, YABU if you think that all Mumsnetters should hold the same opinions as you or any given OP re conservative values or anything else.

Alexandra2001 · 30/01/2022 11:26

Which comes across as so incredibly petty and controlling that hopefully petty-minded people who want to dictate 'MY HOUSE MY CHOICE' will reap the consequences. I wouldn't visit my parents if they still wanted to treat me like a child

My mum was a committed Christian, she didn't believe in sex before marriage, so when i stayed with my partner we slept in separate rooms - i didn't feel it was controlling, i thought i was being respectful.

Funnily enough after a while she she asked me why was i doing this? i replied that i thought she would object, she said No of course not, they are my beliefs not yours.

Doubleraspberry · 30/01/2022 11:26

I think the last two years have probably led to a lot of live-in partners in family homes just because of the household mixing rules. I can well imagine it’s been a stress for many. I know some of them! But on a practical not a moral basis.

I have to say that I can’t think of anywhere I’m less likely to have sex than my in-laws’ house. It’s like a vow of chastity when I step over the front door mat.

godmum56 · 30/01/2022 11:25

@LumosSolem
"Which comes across as so incredibly petty and controlling that hopefully petty-minded people who want to dictate 'MY HOUSE MY CHOICE' will reap the consequences. I wouldn't visit my parents if they still wanted to treat me like a child.

Decent, sensible adults are respectful of other people's sensible, reasonable requests/house rules. No shoes indoors for example, makes sense, @godmum56 you mentioned rules around your elderly dog- even someone who isn't a dog lover as such like me is fully understanding of why you would make certain requests for your dog's wellbeing and comfort. Any decent, caring person would respect them.

Now where is the benefit of requesting that consenting adults, who may well live together the rest of the time, sleep in separate beds? It smacks of being entirely about control and moral judgements as opposed to any meaningful, sensible reason for the request.

When the argument solely comes down to 'my house, my rules', it indicates there isn't really a reasonable logic to it in the first place"

lets be clear.....my rules are not requests. I require compliance.......and yes i agree that setting rules by the owner of the house will have consequences and one of those consequences will be that certain people won't visit BUT its my house. My rules don't have to be logical or reasonable or make sense to others BECAUSE ITS MY HOUSE.

DirectionToPerfection · 30/01/2022 11:22

@makkapacca

Any threads about women feeling pressured into sex are very supportive of the woman, whatever her reasons. Can you show examples of how the MN 'hive' have insulted a woman for not having sex

that's the point i am making, there are no such bashing threads and it's hypocritical to support 1 value but not the other.

No it's really not. Every person has autonomy over their own body.

The woman in that situation is making her own choices about her own body.

You are trying to impose your views on two grown adults who presumably don't share your values.

MsAgnesDiPesto · 30/01/2022 11:22

@makkapacca

Any threads about women feeling pressured into sex are very supportive of the woman, whatever her reasons. Can you show examples of how the MN 'hive' have insulted a woman for not having sex

that's the point i am making, there are no such bashing threads and it's hypocritical to support 1 value but not the other.

I am unable to understand the point you make here.

Mumsnet posters support women who do not want to be pressured into sex, believing she has the choice to do what she wants with her body.

Mumsnet posters also support women who DO want to have sex, when they post asking for advice, believing she has the choice to do what she wants with her body.

Mumsnet posters, in general, support women’s bodily autonomy. What position do you think that the forum should be ‘bashing’ which they aren’t?

billy1966 · 30/01/2022 11:22

What I have found interesting is how many are open to girlfriends/boyfriends staying over so much and often half living in posters home.

With 4 kids, there is absolutely NO way I will ever be open to that I think.

The odd night perhaps but having it constantly would be too much.

I have an acquaintance that I met out walking during lockdown and she told me she had all 4 partners in her house constantly and she and her husband were absolutely sick of it.
She said they had both become very fit from being out walking the neighbourhood so much!

I am very welcoming to my children's friends but having them syaying over constantly seems like too much to me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread