Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think mn are very intolerant/disrespectful on conservative values?

285 replies

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 09:09

Several threads have appeared on last several months over the sharing of bedrooms for posters adult children and partners. When a poster or her husband acknowledges they don't feel comfortable over this and want separate beds until marriage and mn gets up in arms over it blasting the latter as 'ridiculous' 'absurd' etc.

The poster or her husband will get bullied almost and be seen as an anti Christ. AIBU to think if people want to be conservative or have values different to our own that are not seriously harming anybody then that is fine and something posters should respect especially when it is the rules they set in their own house.

BTW I am not conservative or prudish by any means but aibu to think shaming and heckling people over being conservative and different to ourselves is bully like?

OP posts:
makkapacca · 30/01/2022 14:17

MN isn’t compulsory for anyone. If you find the company unpleasant, you can simply not post. Not that disagreement isn’t healthy and welcome but some of the posters on here seem to find the tone of the site simply awful

again this is side stepping the issue, my point was that many posters here seem so proactive in that people are allowed to have their own beliefs/values/freedom etc yet heckle those who carry different values to their own.

OP posts:
pointythings · 30/01/2022 14:16

Disagreeing is fine as is debate but the examples I posted were not that, they were crude and harsh akin to bullying and even gaslighting.

Sorry, but no. Describing something as 'ridiculous' is not crude or harsh. Describing it as 'bizarre' is not crude or harsh. I think you may be a little too sensitive for the AIBU board.

Gaslighting is a different thing altogether and not remotely anything to do with the responses you have quoted.

In the wider scheme of things, social conservatism is a minority view these days. You're right, most people do not respect those views - but people who hold them will just have to live with that, because they are not entitled to have their views respected. They're entitled to hold those views, but putting them out there online will lead to some opinions being robustly expressed, i.e. by using the word 'ridiculous'.

Any actual bullying on those threads can be reported to MN, but I very much doubt that any of the posts you quoted would be deleted because they are not rude, crude, harsh or offensive.

WabbitsAndWeasels · 30/01/2022 14:14

At what age should adult children be allowed to share with non married partners though? What if they've been in a relationship for the last decade but have zero intention to ever marry? Would they forevermore have to sleep in separate rooms unlike their married siblings?

The responses you posted (I've been following the thread but am at work) were blunt and to the point but not crude, gaslighting or bullying. Now if the same poster came back time and again and angrily talked down the the poster like a child I could see it but they were essentially the same comment phrased differently.

Doubleraspberry · 30/01/2022 14:13

MN isn’t compulsory for anyone. If you find the company unpleasant, you can simply not post. Not that disagreement isn’t healthy and welcome but some of the posters on here seem to find the tone of the site simply awful.

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 14:03

It's also like a prototype for trying to stifle debate and impose self-silencing behaviour. The responses are often akin to bullying. It's not the same as disagreeing. And posters are savvy enough to know the difference no matter how much they pretend they can't tell

this. It irks me when posters saying the 'disagreeing' I posted were reasonable or respectable when it wasn't. Disagreeing is fine as is debate but the examples I posted were not that, they were crude and harsh akin to bullying and even gaslighting.

OP posts:
Stravaig · 30/01/2022 13:54

@HebeMumsnet

Afternoon, everyone. Could we ask that we keep this thread to general discussion? If it becomes too much about one or more other specific threads we might have to take it down.

Thanks! Gin

Sorry, I think that's been me, among others. I was wondering how it worked, where the lines were. Now I know! Thank you x
makkapacca · 30/01/2022 13:53

Son and boyfriend in that thread experience homophobic discrimination in the world, every single day. Their situation is not remotely comparable to the normative heterosexual daughter and boyfriend who were also made to sleep apart on previous visits home. Failing to understand that is a huge problem. Additional to the controlling parental behaviour

again homophobia in the world has nothing to do with a father who has conservative sleeping habits in his own home, if he does it to the daughter it is only equal and the equality the gay son gets it. I say that as a gay man.

OP posts:
HebeMumsnet · 30/01/2022 13:51

Afternoon, everyone. Could we ask that we keep this thread to general discussion? If it becomes too much about one or more other specific threads we might have to take it down.

Thanks! Gin

HashtagSexy · 30/01/2022 13:43

Your beliefs and values shouldn't be forced into anyone else. Have them, sure. Ask that they be followed in your home, but don't be surprised if they're not followed to the letter by people who aren't signed up to the same set

ShinyHappyPoster · 30/01/2022 13:41

I think this thread is quite a good example of the phenomenon actually. You were clear about your meaning. Posters have extrapolated out to other examples so they can pretend you're being 'more' UR. Posters have equated conservatism with the Conservative Party. And posters have accused you of making the posts I did.

There isn't any space for respectful discussion of conservative views on MN and MN has no desire to moderate threads that descend into abuse about beliefs and religion if those beliefs and religion are Christian. It's one of the areas where intolerance and lack of respect for the Equalities Act is encouraged. You'll also see it around any date that is important in the Christian calendar too. Without fail there will be a bigoted thread on those dates.

It's interesting because it creates a skewed view of the general public's views. It's also like a prototype for trying to stifle debate and impose self-silencing behaviour. The responses are often akin to bullying. It's not the same as disagreeing. And posters are savvy enough to know the difference no matter how much they pretend they can't tell.

AgathaAllAlong · 30/01/2022 13:36

YABU. Almost always those types of threads are asking a question. If someone asked me, "Do you think I'm unreasonable to make my daughter and her boyfriend of 17 years sleep in a different room?" or "My son is no longer visiting me, do you think it's becuase him and the boyfriend he lives with can't share a room at ours?" then I will give them an honest answer. In my opinion it is ridiculous. That's not because I "disrespect" conversative values in general (although, I do actually disrespect some values that some people class as conservative). It's because I do find it ridiculius, and I've been asked.

Stravaig · 30/01/2022 13:35

@makkapacca

and how to not add to the homophobic discrimination son and beau already experience

it clearly stated on thread equal treatment was given to the daughter and her boyfriend in their hetro sexual relationship so again go and get your facts right before you come in with your inaccuracies.

Son and boyfriend in that thread experience homophobic discrimination in the world, every single day. Their situation is not remotely comparable to the normative heterosexual daughter and boyfriend who were also made to sleep apart on previous visits home. Failing to understand that is a huge problem. Additional to the controlling parental behaviour.
kittymamma · 30/01/2022 13:33

Your original question was if MN is intolerant/disrespectful of conservative views, conservative views have fallen out of popularity, hence there are less people who agree with them as a general principle.

You are asking people to respect views that they don't feel are respectful. So a thread about a husband who works long hours and expects his wife to child-rear, cook, and clean is conservative in nature, but will not be respected by people who see this as exploitation and a lack of respect for his wife. If the view being shared seems disrespectful of another, why is that view entitled to more respect or tolerance because it is labeled "conservative"?

Going to your unmarried partners in a parents' house. Here we have conflicting views. The parents' show no regard for their adult-child's views and adult-child are expected to disregard their views in favour of their parents' views. Neither are unworthy of "respect", but as a parent, you can't then complain if the adult-child decides they would rather not stay than comply with rules they disagree with. Perfectly reasonable!

By asking in a public forum you are asking people to judge which they think is more unreasonable, you can't then call it bullying or a pile-on when the majority return with the same verdict. You seem to object to the ferociousness of some of the responses with words such as "ridiculous" or "outrageous", well, the internet brings out the Outrage Culture, very few actually feel that it is ridiculous or outrageous, but it sounds better than "I agree they are BU" or "I think your views are a little dated and unfair, YABU". To be fair, many posts are like this though, they just aren't as memorable.

ShallWeTalkAboutBruno · 30/01/2022 13:32

What it boils down to OP is that you are entitled to put into place whatever house rules you wan in your own house. As a consequence, your visitors are entitled to decide that they’d rather not visit based on those rules.
And if people ask for an opinion on their rules on a public forum, people are entitled to give their opinion on those rules.

Pedalpushers · 30/01/2022 13:30

@godmum56 so you believe that you have the right to demand anything of anyone who enters your home no matter what it is? Or do you believe that there are levels of acceptable behaviour, dictated by wider society, that we must adhere to and don't get thrown out as soon as someone happens to cross your threshold? For example, presumable you believe that you shouldn't be allowed to demand someone do something illegal in your home?

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 13:25

and how to not add to the homophobic discrimination son and beau already experience

it clearly stated on thread equal treatment was given to the daughter and her boyfriend in their hetro sexual relationship so again go and get your facts right before you come in with your inaccuracies.

OP posts:
hellcatspangle · 30/01/2022 13:24

@makkapacca

Can you give an example of bullying or treating someone as the Antichrist please
  1. What does making them sleep in separate rooms actually achieve other than making them feel like they’re about 15? They’re an adult couple. Ridiculous.
  1. I do think it’s ridiculous to make two consenting adults sleep in separate rooms when you know they are sharing a bed the rest of the time.

3.I think it would be ridiculous to make them sleep in different rooms.

4.This is one of the most ridiculous things I've seen on here. It was also ridiculous to make your dd's bf sleep in a separate room when she was 21. YABVU

5.They are 23 and 26! Sorry its complete madness! They have obviously share a bed regularly because they are couple, and some pretence of 'waiting till marriage' when they arent is bizarre

  1. They are 23 and 26! Sorry its complete madness! They have obviously share a bed regularly because they are couple, and some pretence of 'waiting till marriage' when they arent is bizarre
None of that is "treating someone like they're the anti christ". It's just having a different opinion.
Mediocrates · 30/01/2022 13:23

@makkapacca None of the examples you give at the beginning of the thread are comparing anyone to an Antichrist. They're giving opinions and, in all honesty, they strike me as pretty reasonable.

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 13:23

I see the goalposts are being moved to teen sex, presumably because OP hasn't had the desired response

and if you try to see harder you will see I wasn't the one who raised teen sex.

OP posts:
Mediocrates · 30/01/2022 13:22

@Waxonwaxoff0

I think telling your adult children what they can and can't do is ridiculous no matter what your values.
This sums it up for me. It's pretty controlling
Stravaig · 30/01/2022 13:21

I see the goalposts are being moved to teen sex, presumably because OP hasn't had the desired response.

One of the threads OP originally quotes from was about a mid-twenties son bringing his long-term boyfriend home for Christmas, and his father insisting on separate rooms for him and his love. Hopefully Mum valued the great advice she received on how to move with the times; how to stand up to her husband; how to put herself in the shoes of boyfriend, a barely welcome guest in a strange family at Christmas; and how to not add to the homophobic discrimination son and beau already experience.

If that was a challenging read for some people with 'conservative values' then perhaps they were long overdue for the challenge?

tigger1001 · 30/01/2022 13:21

@makkapacca

But I think what you're experiencing here is just that you are in a genuine minority

i don't agree with it though, i said that in my op.I said I think people should have the right to have their own views without being piled on.

But you are posting in what is essentially a debate forum.

Of course you are entitled to your views but when you post them online in a discussion forum people will comment. Otherwise what's the point in posting? Because if it's just to get people to agree with you I don't think posting online is the way to go.

ShinyHappyPoster · 30/01/2022 13:17

@ShallWeTalkAboutBruno

Are you new here? There are often threads where posters are concerned about their teens' bfs and/or gfs and they are told they should make it easier for them to have sex at home because they're definitely going to do it anyway

Letting them sleep in the same bed isn’t encouraging them to have sex, though. It may be facilitating, but it’s not encouraging.

I think you have missed the threads then. And since MN doesn't allow TAAT, I'm not going to give you more examples. But if you look, you will find them.
makkapacca · 30/01/2022 13:16

But I think what you're experiencing here is just that you are in a genuine minority

i don't agree with it though, i said that in my op.I said I think people should have the right to have their own views without being piled on.

OP posts:
LittleGwyneth · 30/01/2022 13:15

@RosesAndHellebores what a sensible attitude. I imagine your children probably don't feel the need to keep secrets from you as a result of this. It's amazing to me that more parents can't emulate this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread