Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to consider telling 3 year old some people believe in Heaven even though I don’t?

59 replies

Lancssss · 29/01/2022 20:25

My 3 year old has become terrified of dying. She gets upset about it daily and is often awake for hours in the night and is distressed. It’s been happening for a couple of weeks.
We haven’t lost any family members, no one is ill, so I don’t know where it’s coming from. So far I’ve told her it won’t happen to any of us for a really, really, really long time. I’ve said that we’re going to have so many years of loads of fun with our family and friends. Nothing seems to be helping.
A family member has suggested I tell her that some people believe you go to Heaven when you die and to explain what Heaven is. Then also explain that some people believe we get reincarnated, so she might come back as a cat or something.
I am an Atheist and my older DC knows I am. Would I be unreasonable to tell her about Heaven etc to try to reassure her and comfort her?

OP posts:
Lancssss · 29/01/2022 20:42

@Footnote

I told mine it was the same as before she was born and she was happy with that, She was mostly worried about not being alone and I told her she would never feel alone. I also tell her how many birthdays her grandparents have had and ask her how many she has had and tell her that people mostly have lots of birthdays before they die. This also seemed to help. I really really didn’t want to start with the heaven stuff and so far I have avoided it.
I think this is probably the issue actually, not being alone. It’s definitely helpful to get other peoples views so thanks all.
OP posts:
Redglitter · 29/01/2022 20:42

My niece was a similar age when my Dad died. She had no concept of death and Heaven seemed the easiest and least scary option to explain why Grandpa wasn't coming back.

Though I remember a few months later her asking 'How did my Grandpa get to heaven, did God send a bus down for him' I quite liked that idea 😂

Footnote · 29/01/2022 20:39

I told mine it was the same as before she was born and she was happy with that,
She was mostly worried about not being alone and I told her she would never feel alone.
I also tell her how many birthdays her grandparents have had and ask her how many she has had and tell her that people mostly have lots of birthdays before they die. This also seemed to help.
I really really didn’t want to start with the heaven stuff and so far I have avoided it.

Lancssss · 29/01/2022 20:38

@Rodion

Not a bad suggestion at all, but I do wonder if at 3 it isn't really about dying (because what does that really mean to them at that age, it's a very hard concept to grasp) but about being away from you, in which case heaven might not really change anything.

Have there been any big changes like having to start nursery or something recently?

She is very clingy at the moment, so it may well be about being away from me. She also keeps saying “Granny will be really sad when I’m dead” and that she’ll miss her teddies. Nothing has happened recently, she’s been in nursery for 18 months and is very happy there. She’s nearly 4 and has very good language skills and good understanding compared to her sibling at the same age, but I accept “dead” is a very advanced concept for a pre schooler.
OP posts:
MistyFrequencies · 29/01/2022 20:38

My daughter went through a death obsessed phase about the same age. We are also atheist but her granny is buried in a Catholic cemetery with big crosses with Jesus on them. So she asks. So we tell her. Our explanation is that there is a book called the Bible that some people think is true, but mum&dad think it's a story book. So she knows about Heaven. She still says her granny has "gone to the grave" though if anyone asks. I think it's good for them to understand other people's views on religion etc.

AvocadoParsnip · 29/01/2022 20:37

YANBU. I grew up with (strong) religious beliefs and am now an atheist. The thought of heaven was quite comforting - wish I could believe in it still as death scares the crap out of me tbh.

BlueberryBalloon · 29/01/2022 20:34

It’s a always good to present both sides of an argument to children- they can then make up their own minds.

Rodion · 29/01/2022 20:32

Not a bad suggestion at all, but I do wonder if at 3 it isn't really about dying (because what does that really mean to them at that age, it's a very hard concept to grasp) but about being away from you, in which case heaven might not really change anything.

Have there been any big changes like having to start nursery or something recently?

busyeatingbiscuits · 29/01/2022 20:28

Sure, why not? She'll learn about different beliefs at school anyway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread