Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to consider telling 3 year old some people believe in Heaven even though I don’t?

59 replies

Lancssss · 29/01/2022 20:25

My 3 year old has become terrified of dying. She gets upset about it daily and is often awake for hours in the night and is distressed. It’s been happening for a couple of weeks.
We haven’t lost any family members, no one is ill, so I don’t know where it’s coming from. So far I’ve told her it won’t happen to any of us for a really, really, really long time. I’ve said that we’re going to have so many years of loads of fun with our family and friends. Nothing seems to be helping.
A family member has suggested I tell her that some people believe you go to Heaven when you die and to explain what Heaven is. Then also explain that some people believe we get reincarnated, so she might come back as a cat or something.
I am an Atheist and my older DC knows I am. Would I be unreasonable to tell her about Heaven etc to try to reassure her and comfort her?

OP posts:
Lancssss · 29/01/2022 23:17

@CorneliusBeefington

I’m so sorry for your loss, life can really be cruel sometimes Flowers

I honestly feel quite jealous at times that some people have a comforting religious faith. I hope it does bring you comfort after such a sad loss.

OP posts:
Lancssss · 29/01/2022 23:15

@Barrawarra

I think this is a very normal developmental stage and she is younger than some for it, but it’s not unusual. I think the best you can do to comfort her is to accept and ‘be with’ her feelings. Saying things like ‘it’s scary/sad/upsetting thinking about this isn’t it’, and just letting her feel what she feels, but with your support. At a similar ages my eldest was similar and we talked about most people living until they were old, she wanted all the details and settled on the idea most people live until 100. Then she was very sad as she realised that we would die before she did, and said ‘I wish we could all die together’. I don’t know now at 6 if she’s dwelt on the knowledge that she or others could die younger, but at 3/4 it was that first realisations that people can die. My youngest at 3 will bandy around the words due and killed but I don’t think she really grasps what they mean.

Re the heaven, different beliefs, I think you can tell her what others believe but don’t think you should lie about your beliefs, so I think this could be unhelpful given you are atheist. She’s most likely to want to align with your beliefs at this age.

I did wonder if it would actually comfort her if I was saying some people believe this but I don’t. I definitely won’t be lying to her about what I believe and have always been honest with my eldest but he has never seemed upset about death at all.
OP posts:
CorneliusBeefington · 29/01/2022 22:36

@TheCanyon

I wouldn't entertain a heaven chat with a 3 year old no matter how 'comforting' it is. It's false, insincere and pretty manipulative.
Unless a person actually believes in it, surely?

My DS2 died just after he was born. We told my DS1, then just turned 4 that his brother was very poorly, his heart stopped beating and that he went to heaven to live with God and the angels to be a star in the sky. (We are religious, so it works for us.)

There was then a conversation about cremation (led by him) and your body becoming star dust, this was down to him discovering ds2s ashes.

We told him that when you love someone, even if they die, they are always in your heart, your love goes with them, and their love goes with you.

WiddlinDiddlin · 29/01/2022 22:01

I can still remember my utter terror at realising some day my mother would die. I would have been about four.

It was entirely about being left alone, that those I needed wouldn't be there, that I'd somehow be on my own and I couldn't see how that would be possible and so it was very very scary. Its a big shock to realise that the security of your parents that you have assumed is complete, 100%, rock solid, never going to fail... actually might.

My mother told me she wouldn't die for a very very very long time and if we wanted we could have her stuffed like our stuffed Otter so she'd still be there, which i found pretty amusing but other kids might not.

We didn't get any heaven business as she was fiercely (nay, offensively) atheist but she did explain (probably multiple times over the years as I doubt I took this in straight away first time round)...

Everyone we know and love, who we talk with, spend time with, shares some part of themselves with us. That then shapes who we are, in effect a bit of them becomes part of us. So if they die... the bit of them that is part of us doesn't die, it carries on.

I think she came up with that as the first deaths I experienced were not of blood relatives but of our cat, and then two family friends who had been honorary uncle types, and so that one works better than trying to explain a blood link or umbilical link.

Ultimately I needed comfort and cuddles and time, I don't really think the words matter all that much, but some sort of reassurance does, and it shouldn't be a blatant lie or that will cause problems later on.

FloatyBoaty · 29/01/2022 21:59

@Barrawarra

Is it a book?! LOL I thought I was so original! Looking now!

Lancssss · 29/01/2022 21:27

@NutellaEllaElla

You could tell her that death feels the same as how it felt before she was born.
She’s funny about that as well. She asks where she was when I was a little girl for example and gets really upset when you say she hadn’t been born yet.
OP posts:
Barrawarra · 29/01/2022 21:27

Oh and further to pp comment there is a lovely book called ‘the invisible string’ you may want to look at.

Barrawarra · 29/01/2022 21:26

I think this is a very normal developmental stage and she is younger than some for it, but it’s not unusual. I think the best you can do to comfort her is to accept and ‘be with’ her feelings. Saying things like ‘it’s scary/sad/upsetting thinking about this isn’t it’, and just letting her feel what she feels, but with your support. At a similar ages my eldest was similar and we talked about most people living until they were old, she wanted all the details and settled on the idea most people live until 100. Then she was very sad as she realised that we would die before she did, and said ‘I wish we could all die together’. I don’t know now at 6 if she’s dwelt on the knowledge that she or others could die younger, but at 3/4 it was that first realisations that people can die. My youngest at 3 will bandy around the words due and killed but I don’t think she really grasps what they mean.

Re the heaven, different beliefs, I think you can tell her what others believe but don’t think you should lie about your beliefs, so I think this could be unhelpful given you are atheist. She’s most likely to want to align with your beliefs at this age.

Lancssss · 29/01/2022 21:18

@Mischance

When my OH died 2 years ago, the GC, then aged from 4 to 17 were very much in the loop with what was happening. He did not die suddenly and the children had seen him getting more helpless - and had been suitably intrigued by the catheter pipework!

He then went into a nursing home and they visited him there and watched him slowly fading away - I have a photo of some of them round his bed when he was unconscious - taken at their request. They held his hand and gave him hugs and so on.

I was particularly impressed by my 14 year old autistic GD who responded very caringly to his needs.

When he died it was not a shock to them - they all had been told this was where it was all leading. We talked about his atoms going "back to the stardust". All except the youngest two came to the funeral and burial and took this in their stride - the two littlest were brought to the wake and were there for several conversations about the death.

I do think that it helped that they were involved before and could see that it was just grandpa getting sleepier.

I hope that you can find the right way to reassure your DD. Certainly for ours the concept of the law of conservation of matter helped - expressed age-appropriately as the idea that our atoms never go away, they just go somewhere else and - who knows? - become something else.

Sorry for your loss Flowers

Her older sibling is always talking about atoms etc so she’d probably like this explanation.

OP posts:
NutellaEllaElla · 29/01/2022 21:18

You could tell her that death feels the same as how it felt before she was born.

BeardyButton · 29/01/2022 21:15

Right there with you. My father died recently. My son keeps asking about heaven.... will I go to heaven? Will he see me when he dies? I do the same! “Some people believe....”

What is the alternative? There’s no heaven kid? You ll never see your beloved grandad? I might be nxt and then you ll never see me either??

Lancssss · 29/01/2022 21:15

And I confess because he is a bit concerned about being separated from me, I told him that before he was born, there was a special cord that went between us that gave him food and oxygen. When he was born, that cord was cut, but it was replaced by an invisible cord that goes from my heart to his heart and vice versa- so even better than the umbilical cord because it goes two ways, and carries our love- and that no matter what happens, or where we go, in our bodies or in our spirits, we’ll always have that special heart connection.

This is so lovely!

OP posts:
FunkyPhantom · 29/01/2022 21:13

Wait until you have to chat to them about Santa, The Tooth Fairy and the Easter Bunny.......then you'll be for it 👍

Mischance · 29/01/2022 21:10

When my OH died 2 years ago, the GC, then aged from 4 to 17 were very much in the loop with what was happening. He did not die suddenly and the children had seen him getting more helpless - and had been suitably intrigued by the catheter pipework!

He then went into a nursing home and they visited him there and watched him slowly fading away - I have a photo of some of them round his bed when he was unconscious - taken at their request. They held his hand and gave him hugs and so on.

I was particularly impressed by my 14 year old autistic GD who responded very caringly to his needs.

When he died it was not a shock to them - they all had been told this was where it was all leading. We talked about his atoms going "back to the stardust". All except the youngest two came to the funeral and burial and took this in their stride - the two littlest were brought to the wake and were there for several conversations about the death.

I do think that it helped that they were involved before and could see that it was just grandpa getting sleepier.

I hope that you can find the right way to reassure your DD. Certainly for ours the concept of the law of conservation of matter helped - expressed age-appropriately as the idea that our atoms never go away, they just go somewhere else and - who knows? - become something else.

Lancssss · 29/01/2022 21:05

@TheCanyon

I wouldn't entertain a heaven chat with a 3 year old no matter how 'comforting' it is. It's false, insincere and pretty manipulative.
This was my initial worry when it was suggested, but as has been pointed out on the thread already, my family members argument was that she’ll be told that at school which is only a year off. Her sibling has already been told that. One of my parents has a very religious upbringing and has rejected it completely as an adult, so I’ve been brought up to believe that God definitely doesn’t exist and religion can be quite harmful to peoples lives. It’s absolutely heartbreaking though to listen to her crying in the middle of the night for hours that she doesn’t want to die, and why do we have to die.
OP posts:
FloatyBoaty · 29/01/2022 21:04

My DS (5) is very curious about death and dying and what happens after. I’ve told him (in response to various questions):

  • that yes we will all die one day, that it’s nothing to be afraid of, and that lots of people have lots of different ideas about what happens next
  • that dying is when our bodies get too tired or too poorly or broken to carry on- but nobody knows what happens to the inside bit that some people call the soul- which is made up of all of your dreams and hopes and loves … and that many people believe that that part can carry on without the body
  • that the trick is to enjoy life and not worry about the after - but that as he gets older, he’ll find that he has his own ideas about death and what’s next
  • I’ve told him about different belief systems- reincarnation, heaven, the idea that all of the energy in our bodies goes back out into the universe and we become part of everything, and like a PP, that it’s maybe how it was before he was born
  • I’ve explained that when someone you love dies, you don’t really lose them. They stay in your heart, and you keep a special connection with them through your memories and sometimes your dreams

And I confess because he is a bit concerned about being separated from me, I told him that before he was born, there was a special cord that went between us that gave him food and oxygen. When he was born, that cord was cut, but it was replaced by an invisible cord that goes from my heart to his heart and vice versa- so even better than the umbilical cord because it goes two ways, and carries our love- and that no matter what happens, or where we go, in our bodies or in our spirits, we’ll always have that special heart connection.

It seems to have done the trick. He’s very calm about the idea of death and doesn’t seem at all afraid of people he loves dying- (I was terrified at his age)- which was all I want for him really. To accept it as part of life, and not to worry.

It IS a bit perturbing when I’m trying to have a really beautiful, sensitive moment, and he asks if human bodies are like dinosaur bodies and we turn into fossils when we die “when our meat falls off” Envy (not envy) but hey ho!

BikiniB0tt0m · 29/01/2022 21:00

@TheCanyon

I wouldn't entertain a heaven chat with a 3 year old no matter how 'comforting' it is. It's false, insincere and pretty manipulative.
I would say we all have a mind of our own and sooner or later children learn all sorts of beliefs. Especially if they go to school. We should teach our kids what we believe in all honesty (because well we believe it to be true) why wouldn't we. But it's up to the child to make their own mind up at the end of the day. They may believe what the parent believes but as they get older the complete opposite and parents should respect they are their own person.
MrWhippyBloon · 29/01/2022 20:56

I'm atheist and haven't told my kids about heaven. What helped my son with similar worries at that age was to explain that most people die when they're very very old, so by the time I die he will probably have children and grandchildren of his own, and would be living in his own house. This really seemed to reassure him that he'd probably be a grown up so a) it's a long way off and b) he'd be better equipped to deal with it by then. He has never seemed worried about his own death though, just DH and I (I blame Disney - why do so many kids films feature tragic deaths of parents!)

sohypnotic · 29/01/2022 20:55

DD is 4 now but was 3 when her Great Grandafther died and I took quite a long time to talk to her as didn't want to scare her, and her understanding was very good. She is 4 now, and understands death but still has moments of fear - as others have said, more about not being with us, not having her toys - she's expressed similar fear about growing up.

I definitely wanted to avoid any explanation that likened it to sleep (fear or bed - no thankyou!) but like you we are not religious. I did this book with her just as a story, it's obviously about the concept of heaven but in a very non-religious way. Tell Me About Heaven, Grandpa Rabbit!: https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/0992616794/ref=cmswwrcppapiglttiJ7EEYPAR7HRM6GM7QNFR

She also twigged the granny in Julia Donaldson's 'paper dolls' was in the little girls memory because she had died - so the idea of someone living on in everyones memories is another route.

We also talked about it not happening to any of us for a really long time - we looked up the oldest people who had ever lived on internet to give a bit more context to how long 'really long time' could be.

satci · 29/01/2022 20:52

@TheCanyon

I wouldn't entertain a heaven chat with a 3 year old no matter how 'comforting' it is. It's false, insincere and pretty manipulative.
What? To tell a child that some people believe in heaven?? Absolutely true. Even for non believers heaven is quite an abstract and worldwide concept. She'll have to learn about it soon enough.
AutomaticMoon · 29/01/2022 20:52

@TheCanyon Have a heart. Should she tell her straight that dear GP is rotting away in the ground? I’m very sorry, OP to say it so bluntly but it bothers me when adults parentify children because it’s ‘manipulative’ to protect them from the world.

AutomaticMoon · 29/01/2022 20:49

Nobody told me about heaven but I wish they had cause at around age 6 I got extremely sad and became depressed at the sudden realisation that my grandparents would die (they were raising me for years)

TheCanyon · 29/01/2022 20:48

I wouldn't entertain a heaven chat with a 3 year old no matter how 'comforting' it is. It's false, insincere and pretty manipulative.

AutomaticMoon · 29/01/2022 20:45

Aww I rarely see 100% agreement on here. I was a raging atheist from 7 onwards but at 29 became christian anarchist.

Lancssss · 29/01/2022 20:45

@Redglitter

My niece was a similar age when my Dad died. She had no concept of death and Heaven seemed the easiest and least scary option to explain why Grandpa wasn't coming back.

Though I remember a few months later her asking 'How did my Grandpa get to heaven, did God send a bus down for him' I quite liked that idea 😂

Kids are so funny!
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread