Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the common idea that Diana was murdered is absurd

438 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 17:01

Heard a journalist on the radio the other day speculating it was not an accident and heard others saying the same. AIBU to think people like this are complete idiots?

OP posts:
TheMarzipanDildo · 02/02/2022 13:09

“The British take the racial purity of their royal family very seriously.“

Count me out of that please!

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 02/02/2022 12:40

Old man Fayed was a bit mono-manic about the whole business, what with one of his employees being directly responsible for the death of his son but dead himself and beyond punishment. He had to blame someone, anyone but the driver who actually did it and was beyond reach of his vengeance, and avenge Dodi somehow. So he did, in all directions and no matter how loony any given accusation. (I slightly wondered whether the royal family had even noticed that Dodi existed; he was a summer fling for three and a half weeks for someone who was no longer really of any great interest to thm; he simply would not have been important enough to them for them to bother to want him dead. And their killing two complete innocents in a very hit-and-miss way in order possibly to quash one nuisance seems somehow unlikely.)

I do like the idea of a Fiat Uno ( between1,567lb and 2,006lb curb weight) having the leverage to deflect into a crash a reinforced Mercedes-Benz W140 (between 4,542lb and 4,938lb curb weight plus extra for armour-plating) in a glancing collision, though. The Fiat would bounce off and the Mercedes would continue on its course pretty-much unknowing. In a head-on, the Fiat would be crushed and the Mercedes would probably have a damaged crumple-zone. If the Mercedes had by some strange ballistic frek been caused to alter course, spin and all the rest of it by collision with a Fiat, there is no way the Fiat would not have been in a worse state, still on the scene in an undriveable condition.

Itsnotover · 02/02/2022 12:37

What a load of rubbish.
The reality is that 25years ago times were different. The future king of England having a half sibling that was Muslim would have put the Queen in a difficult position. She is the Supreme Governor of the Church of England

@Sweetpea2021 so how do you explain that the Queen was fine, supportive even, of Diana dating Hasnat Khan? You're the one talking rubbish. How exactly would it have put the Queen in a difficult position? You've proved my point that it is sentiment such as yours that is racist.

Sweetpea2021 · 02/02/2022 12:27

@MarieIVanArkleStinks

It's laughable.

Look at who stood to gain what by her death (nothing) and then consider who had what to lose if what they'd 'done' was ever
uncovered (everything).

The woman was none-too bright. Charles' PR people had already painted her as a whackadoodle, and she helped them. The Panorama interview did her absolutely no favours. Once the label of 'mad' has been attached to someone - nearly always a woman it's interesting to note - then their voice is effectively removed and nobody takes a word they say seriously. For modern-day examples look no further than Charlene of Monaco and Britney Spears.

Nobody cares who she was dating or the nonsense she was spouting. In time, had she lived, she'd probably have become persona non grata and a laughing stock like Fergie.

Not at all. I remember those days. People didn't view her as a mad woman. They had great sympathy for her after the Panorama interview. She was a really popular figure that was becoming more and more defiant against the royals.
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 02/02/2022 12:23

It's laughable.

Look at who stood to gain what by her death (nothing) and then consider who had what to lose if what they'd 'done' was ever
uncovered (everything).

The woman was none-too bright. Charles' PR people had already painted her as a whackadoodle, and she helped them. The Panorama interview did her absolutely no favours. Once the label of 'mad' has been attached to someone - nearly always a woman it's interesting to note - then their voice is effectively removed and nobody takes a word they say seriously. For modern-day examples look no further than Charlene of Monaco and Britney Spears.

Nobody cares who she was dating or the nonsense she was spouting. In time, had she lived, she'd probably have become persona non grata and a laughing stock like Fergie.

Sweetpea2021 · 02/02/2022 12:20

@MorningStarling

I have a hard time understanding why people think she was murdered. The method was a rather silly and unreliable one, and the peak of her ability to cause embarrassment to the Royal Family had already passed. When you factor in the drunk driver and lack of seat belts, plus speeding through the streets in the early hours, the murder argument makes less and less sense.

Still, I suppose there are people who deny that the Holocaust happened, so it takes all sorts I guess.

But many argue that the driver wasn't actually drunk. He wasn't staggering to the car. There was video of him tying his shoe laces up before got in the car.
Sweetpea2021 · 02/02/2022 12:19

@Itsnotover

The people who say that Diana was murdered because she was going out with a person of colour are the ones who are racist. Because they've dreamed up the idea in the first place and assume others would perceive it to be a problem that would cause someone to be murdered!
What a load of rubbish. The reality is that 25years ago times were different. The future king of England having a half sibling that was Muslim would have put the Queen in a difficult position. She is the Supreme Governor of the Church of England.
Sweetpea2021 · 02/02/2022 12:06

@bubbleblower85

I think the people who overlook the strange things around her death are ridiculous. Why were all the cameras in the tunnel turned off? Why wasn't she taken to the hospital which was very nearby immediatly? Why did they embalm her against the law? Why was the white fiat punto found burnt out and the driver killed? Why the nonsend about Henri Paul being drunk, his level of blood alcohol would have left him paraplegic but he was fine on all the CCTV camera's and his family have said he wasn't a drinker. Why wasn't Charles asked about why his wife said she fears she would be killed in a staged car crash by him, at the inquest? If this was a ordinary Mr Smith/Jones they would have questioned him in an inquest. There are other things that raises eyebrows.

I guess we will never know exaxctly what happened but I think the car accident was just setting the stage for something neferious afterwards (i.e in thhe ambulance/hospital) and then it gives them plausible deniability i.e she died because of a car crash.

Exactly all of this. Also the photographers at the scene all had their houses raided and all their images taken from them.
Itsnotover · 02/02/2022 12:04

The press and the racists are the ones who made a fuss about Fayed being an Arab, and Fayed senior made much of his son going out (for which read, possibly having sex a few times) with a divorced ex-member of the royal family.

Exactly this. People just parrot nonsense. It's depressing.

CSIblonde · 02/02/2022 12:04

An Australian crime journalist talked to crash investigation experts & found the still existing gouges on the tunnel entrance wall match with the car hitting it then ricocheting into the tunnel.The same journalist also interviewed a French woman who saw a white Fiat with Paris plates collide with Diana's car at the tunnel entrance. She rang Police after the crash but was ignored. She described a young, dark haired Fiat driver with a huge black dog in the back seat, wearing a bright orange muzzle. The man has been traced. His own father said he resprayed his Fiat red, just hours after the crash. He's refused to speak to anyone re the crash.

Sweetpea2021 · 02/02/2022 12:03

@maggiecate

If you’re going to assassinate someone you need to know where they’re going to be and when. The trip that evening was a spontaneous one that Dodi suggested and organised at the last minute. The driver was drinking because he thought he was done for the night. It would have been impossible to plan for the accident to happen because the whole event was unplanned. There were other routes that could have been taken, they couldn’t have anticipated that the driver would be speeding, that the passengers wouldn’t be wearing seatbelts. The odds of pulling it off and getting away are astronomical - far too high for any professional setup like the security services to attempt.

And the idea that the royal family would have put the boys through that trauma - after having themselves endured the grief of the Mountbatten assassination - is frankly ridiculous.

Why would it be traumatic for them? It would be more traumatic for them to have her alive with all the secrets she knew (Paul Burrell was aware of these) and the new relationships she was having was causing them problems.
Sweetpea2021 · 02/02/2022 12:00

@Wizzbangfizz

I think that to claim the world was losing interest in her is wholly incorrect - it anything to frenzy was growing - particularly if as heavily speculated she was going to announce an engagement and pregnancy.
Exactly she was the most photographed royal at the time. This was before the days of internet. She was in all the newspapers everyday.
Sweetpea2021 · 02/02/2022 11:58

@TroysMammy

It's a ridiculous theory only believed by idiots. I'm sure other ways would have been used to murder someone as a car crash could go either way. What if she had survived the car crash? Would there have been other attempts to kill her until she was finally dead?
People are not idiots to believe it. Mohammed Al Fayed was not an idiot. He firmly believed it.
MorningStarling · 02/02/2022 11:58

Because the future king of England would have had a half sibling who was potentially Muslim. Massive problem for the Queen.

So what? They wouldn't be part of the Royal Family by blood, they wouldn't be in the line of accession. Even if they were, as a Muslim they wouldn't be able to become king anyway.

Sweetpea2021 · 02/02/2022 11:57

@layladomino

I have never had a conversation about Diana with someone who thought she was murdered. And I think this is on account of:

-Noone benefitted from her dying
-If she'd worn a seatbelt she would't have died - that was her choice
-there is no evidence (and yes I have watched a documentary).

If you get in a car with a driver who's been drinking, don't put on a seat belt and then the driver drives at speed, it's an unfortunate but quite predictable ending I'm afraid.

The conspiracy theories are so outlandish that most people see them for what they are. There are always those who love a conspiracy though.

The royal family benefited from her dying. She was embarrassing them (as the mother of the future King of England) by having lots of different relationships. She also did the Panorama interview and disclosed 'secrets' about the family. She also was privy to a lot more secrets that the Royal Family do not want disclosed.
MorningStarling · 02/02/2022 11:56

I have a hard time understanding why people think she was murdered. The method was a rather silly and unreliable one, and the peak of her ability to cause embarrassment to the Royal Family had already passed. When you factor in the drunk driver and lack of seat belts, plus speeding through the streets in the early hours, the murder argument makes less and less sense.

Still, I suppose there are people who deny that the Holocaust happened, so it takes all sorts I guess.

Sweetpea2021 · 02/02/2022 11:53

@TerribleCustomerCervix

Why on earth would Diana being pregnant with another man’s baby be any threat whatsoever to the RF? Confused

Surely it would be a relief to them that she had “moved on” and totally irrelevant.

Plus they’d recently weathered the total embarrassment of Fergie and the toe sucking and managed not to assassinate her.

Because the future king of England would have had a half sibling who was potentially Muslim. Massive problem for the Queen.
Sweetpea2021 · 02/02/2022 11:50

@makkapacca

Heard a journalist on the radio the other day speculating it was not an accident and heard others saying the same. AIBU to think people like this are complete idiots?
I think it's absurd to think she wasn't.
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 02/02/2022 11:48

Yes, it was an issue for the racists. Saying it was an issue without emphasising that does lay the person saying it was an issue open to the suspicion that they themselves are racist.

And yes indeed, if it was a murder it was a singularly inept one. A bit like Hamlet causing the deaths of eight people including himself just in order to kill a man he could easily have stabbed in private but didn't take the opportunity when it offered.

Porcupineintherough · 02/02/2022 11:41

It might not have been an issue for the rotal family bit it was very much an issue for quite large sections of the British public (and ironically particularly more so in quarters where the royal family are considered important) and yes, whipped up by the media. That in no way means it was murder, although it may have contributed to the eagerness of the press to get a photograph on that night which precipitated the accident.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 02/02/2022 11:25

Porcupineintherough
Noticing racism doesn't make you racist. And you are dreaming if you think this wasnt an issue (albeit not one worth killing over) when Diana was going out with Dodi.

It seems not to have been an issue at all for the royal family who a] appear to have been delighted when she went out for two years with and talked about marrying a Pakistani Muslim and b] know better than to think that a 47-day acquaintance (during more than half of which the two people have not seen each other) is so serious that anyone needs to think about it at all.

The press and the racists are the ones who made a fuss about Fayed being an Arab, and Fayed senior made much of his son going out (for which read, possibly having sex a few times) with a divorced ex-member of the royal family.

Itsnotover · 02/02/2022 11:08

Do so many people really think that the Queen is so sociopathic that she would be glad about close relatives dying? I can't stand the royal family but even I find this quite peculiar.

JustLyra · 02/02/2022 11:05

@makkapacca

i think the queen gave an internal sigh of relief and the royals in general as she was a loose cannon especially after the panorama interview. Her death was therefore convenient but I still think it was an accident. She was under a shoddy security team.
I don't think her death was remotely convenient for them, which is why I find the suggestions that the royals were involved in it so baffling.

Her death and their handling of it brought them to their point of lowest popularity in modern times. She still hangs over Charles and Camilla like the proverbial bad smell that they'll never, ever shift.

Some of the papers were starting to turn on her for her holidays and the likes, people would have got irritated with her interviews and always selling the photos eventually. Especially as more and more came out about her behaviour with things like basically stalking Hasnet Khan and her affair with Will Carling. Being dead she can do no wrong and that's not good for the royals.

Plus her decision to refuse Met police protection is so often cited as the royals "removed" her security so they get the blame for the shoddy security.

I think they know they'd have been far better with her still alive as she'd have fallen in and out of favour with the press and public, just as they do, rather than being held up as some weird saintly example as she is now.

TheMarzipanDildo · 02/02/2022 10:50

It might have been ‘convenient’ (I’m not sure why...) but it would also be an incredibly unreliable way to murder someone.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 02/02/2022 10:23

@VickyEadieofThigh

Can't believe that 50% of voters think that the drunk driver and failure to put on seatbelts was contrived. If she'd worn a seatbelt, she probably would have survived - as the only person in the car wearing one did.
I can't - but then I can't believe a lot of popular things.