Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the common idea that Diana was murdered is absurd

438 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 17:01

Heard a journalist on the radio the other day speculating it was not an accident and heard others saying the same. AIBU to think people like this are complete idiots?

OP posts:
Perime · 02/02/2022 21:08

@DePfeffoff

Not at all. I remember those days. People didn't view her as a mad woman. They had great sympathy for her after the Panorama interview. She was a really popular figure that was becoming more and more defiant against the royals.

I remember it well. She was popular when they were married and she was having children. By the time of her death that was very obviously slipping. I particularly remember the photographs of her on Fayed's boats accompanied by sneering articles about the number of holidays she was taking, how happy she was to be apart from her children, and how many people she was freeloading off. People were also massively unimpressed by blatant photo opportunities, e.g. standing over some unfortunate heart surgery patient dripping mascara. I well remember it was a standing joke that whenever there was a disaster she couldn't drop everything quickly enough to try to get there first so that she could get photos published of herself bending caringly over the unfortunate victims, who didn't get any say in whether they wanted to be photographed.

The Panorama interview was particularly badly misjudged. All that peeking up at the camera through her eyelashes just didn't work in a woman of her age, and people were only too well aware that when she moaned about three in the marriage she was artistically forgetting about all her own lovers. She was losing popularity by the day.

Have you forgotten Charles' interview and didn't that come first?
shortroundd · 02/02/2022 19:31

Being dead she can do no wrong and that's not good for the royals...I think they know they'd have been far better with her still alive as she'd have fallen in and out of favour with the press and public, just as they do, rather than being held up as some weird saintly example as she is now

I wouldn't agree with this at all, I think many people are aware by now she was far from the saintly figure she was made out to be. Enough came out since 97 about her fallouts with people, her manipulation of the press and her affairs to know she was morally flawed like the rest of us. And I would say the saintly reputation she had is long worn thin.

Plus her decision to refuse Met police protection is so often cited as the royals "removed" her security so they get the blame for the shoddy security

Again this has being much disputed and I don't know whether she shunned it or it was shunned on her.

Itsnotover · 02/02/2022 19:29

@DePfeffoff

Not at all. I remember those days. People didn't view her as a mad woman. They had great sympathy for her after the Panorama interview. She was a really popular figure that was becoming more and more defiant against the royals.

I remember it well. She was popular when they were married and she was having children. By the time of her death that was very obviously slipping. I particularly remember the photographs of her on Fayed's boats accompanied by sneering articles about the number of holidays she was taking, how happy she was to be apart from her children, and how many people she was freeloading off. People were also massively unimpressed by blatant photo opportunities, e.g. standing over some unfortunate heart surgery patient dripping mascara. I well remember it was a standing joke that whenever there was a disaster she couldn't drop everything quickly enough to try to get there first so that she could get photos published of herself bending caringly over the unfortunate victims, who didn't get any say in whether they wanted to be photographed.

The Panorama interview was particularly badly misjudged. All that peeking up at the camera through her eyelashes just didn't work in a woman of her age, and people were only too well aware that when she moaned about three in the marriage she was artistically forgetting about all her own lovers. She was losing popularity by the day.

Whatever badly judged things she did, I don't think anyone can deny that Diana changed societal attitudes to people with AIDS in a way that was nothing short of groundbreaking. She should never be forgotten in that regard.

IcedPurple · 02/02/2022 19:26

It simply wouldn't. The child wouldn't be an heir of the queen's and wouldn't be in the line of succession. In essence it would be no different to the future king having a Muslim cousin.

Exactly. The future queen (whether or not she goes by that title) was married to a Catholic and her children, technically the step brother and sister of a future king, are also Catholics. Nobody cares, despite the fact that the ban on royals marrying Catholics was only lifted a few years ago, and Catholics are still specifically excluded from the line of succession.

The religion or race of any children Diana might have gone on to have would have been just as irrelevant. They simply wouldn't matter.

shortroundd · 02/02/2022 19:24

If she'd worn a seatbelt, she probably would have survived - as the only person in the car wearing one did

this has being largely disputed and I don't think an answer was ever given.

Nontransfer · 02/02/2022 19:23

I've no idea or much what the truth is in this case, but I don't think the idea that the rich and powerful "get rid" of those who are inconvenient is absurd in itself.

shortroundd · 02/02/2022 19:23

As it stands H&M have had their say, it didn't go down as well as they had hoped. They are universally loved and missed

I wouldn't agree with this at all, much of the comments I hear about Markle are very much negative and people both on here and that I know have being harsh towards her.

Meghan dying would cause them more issues also
perhaps but she'd also solve a lot of their issues- another loose cannon like her mother in law. Again this is not to say I think they'd kill her or that they killed Diana. I very much believe that was an accident.

JustLyra · 02/02/2022 19:17

People are not idiots to believe it. Mohammed Al Fayed was not an idiot. He firmly believed it.

He started it…

But coincidentally not for months after it happened. Just like the pregnancy bollocks that he concocted many months after the fact.

He was both grieving and desperately trying to deflect the fact that if anyone was to blame for the accident it was his driver and security chief that he had called in specifically to drive them.

shortroundd · 02/02/2022 19:17

Why would it be traumatic for them? It would be more traumatic for them to have her alive with all the secrets she knew (Paul Burrell was aware of these) and the new relationships she was having was causing them problems

this,whilst I do think they were sad/pained to see the boys lose their mum, they'd still have had some sort of relief she'd gone. It was a thorn out of their side.

DePfeffoff · 02/02/2022 19:01

Not at all. I remember those days. People didn't view her as a mad woman. They had great sympathy for her after the Panorama interview. She was a really popular figure that was becoming more and more defiant against the royals.

I remember it well. She was popular when they were married and she was having children. By the time of her death that was very obviously slipping. I particularly remember the photographs of her on Fayed's boats accompanied by sneering articles about the number of holidays she was taking, how happy she was to be apart from her children, and how many people she was freeloading off. People were also massively unimpressed by blatant photo opportunities, e.g. standing over some unfortunate heart surgery patient dripping mascara. I well remember it was a standing joke that whenever there was a disaster she couldn't drop everything quickly enough to try to get there first so that she could get photos published of herself bending caringly over the unfortunate victims, who didn't get any say in whether they wanted to be photographed.

The Panorama interview was particularly badly misjudged. All that peeking up at the camera through her eyelashes just didn't work in a woman of her age, and people were only too well aware that when she moaned about three in the marriage she was artistically forgetting about all her own lovers. She was losing popularity by the day.

DePfeffoff · 02/02/2022 18:52

The future king of England having a half sibling that was Muslim would have put the Queen in a difficult position. She is the Supreme Governor of the Church of England.

It simply wouldn't. The child wouldn't be an heir of the queen's and wouldn't be in the line of succession. In essence it would be no different to the future king having a Muslim cousin.

But many argue that the driver wasn't actually drunk. He wasn't staggering to the car. There was video of him tying his shoe laces up before got in the car.

It's very well known that habitual drinkers will be able to function ostensibly normally when it comes to day to day activities; indeed, concentrating on small things like tying shoelaces helps to steady them. But that doesn't work when they're in charge of a speeding car at night time.

RonCarlos · 02/02/2022 18:52

Yes, it's absurd. It was an accident. She had ditched her usual security which probably didn't help. The paps were crazy about her that summer, I was in France when she was. I agree they played a part. But her driver was also speeding and she had no seatbelt on.

DePfeffoff · 02/02/2022 18:48

People are not idiots to believe it. Mohammed Al Fayed was not an idiot. He firmly believed it

I'm not sure he did. He kept passionately saying that he did, but he was grieving for his son at the same time as being desperate to try to ensure that no-one blamed him and his employees.

DePfeffoff · 02/02/2022 18:46

The royal family benefited from her dying. She was embarrassing them (as the mother of the future King of England) by having lots of different relationships.

They really wouldn't care about this. Look at the history of the family - even if you only go back to the beginning of the last century, it's littered with scandal. An ex-wife making an idiot of herself would be utterly trivial, if anything it would be welcomed because it would put Charles in a better light. No-one particularly cared about Fergie's money troubles, for instance. If she'd lived, William would simply take care to distance himself from her, and by the time he got to be king, she would, at the very least, have been well into her 60s and relationship scandals would be past history.

IcedPurple · 02/02/2022 18:07

The future king of England having a half sibling that was Muslim would have put the Queen in a difficult position. She is the Supreme Governor of the Church of England.

Why would it have mattered?

As others have said, her 'relationship' was nowhere near the marriage stage. Diana told friends it was just a bit of summer fun.

Besides, if she did remarry, she would no longer be able to call herself Princess of Wales and any resulting child would not be a member of the royal family. Hardly a constitutional crisis.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 02/02/2022 17:45

wanttomarryamillionaire
A car crash is not a guaranteed way to kill somebody, no special forces or spies or whoever all the nut jobs believe killed her would use such a tactic.

I think the thing which really makes it unlikely from my point of view is that it happened in France, where neither the British royal family nor the British government nor any branch of the British security services has the power to control anything in particular. Would I, if I wanted to arrange the death of someone, arrange it in a place where I had no way to do anything about it if something went wrong with my plot? No, I probably wouldn't.

wanttomarryamillionaire · 02/02/2022 17:28

It really is a commonly held belief, absolutely everyone i know thinks she was murdered by the Royals! I personally think you need to be stupid to think that and people find it hard to accept that she died in such a mundane way via the hands of a drunk driver. A car crash is not a guaranteed way to kill somebody, no special forces or spies or whoever all the nut jobs believe killed her would use such a tactic.

Itsnotover · 02/02/2022 17:21

Actually I think it’s highly offensive for anyone to be talking about ‘racial purity’ and saying it’s important to the RF🤮 it’s completely made up.

The RF are, no doubt a bunch of snobs. They prefer people from aristocratic backgrounds or with aristocratic links in their family . Which doesn’t have anything to do with race.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 02/02/2022 15:54

@TheMarzipanDildo

“The British take the racial purity of their royal family very seriously.“

Count me out of that please!

Why would the later child of a woman who had had a divorce from a member of the royal family have anything whatever to do with the racial purity of the royal family? She was not part of it, and the child would not have been part of it.

Even if there were such a thing as "the racial purity of the royal family" in the first place which on the whole there isn't. It would be pretty silly to object to people of another race in the royal family, given the fact that they've been marrying people from all over Europe for centuries. For instance Prince Philip, or Prince Albert. What is really surprising is that none of Elizabeth's children found a spouse outside this country even on the second try, and that William also married someone from England.

I think actually that 25 years ago the British were less afraid of the Other than they are now; Brexit hadn't happened, 9/11 hadn't happened, and the terrorists setting off bombs in this country were Irish, not Muslim; Blair had not yet decided that unlike any other country in Europe, we would allow anyone European at all who wanted to come here to do so. The nastiness of racism was on the wane, not on the increase as it feels at present.

Itsnotover · 02/02/2022 15:14

She wasn't even serious about Dodi - he was a fling as far as she was concerned.

Itsnotover · 02/02/2022 15:14

It's not my sentiment that's racist it's the reality of the times 25 years ago.

No, it's really not.

Mohammed al fayed said also that it was because he was Muslim.

Mohammed Al Fayed said a lot of things.

JustLyra · 02/02/2022 13:48

The future king of England having a half sibling that was Muslim would have put the Queen in a difficult position. She is the Supreme Governor of the Church of England.

She'd been having a fling with Dodi Fayed for a few weeks - it was hardly grand romance of the century.

If the religion thing was going to be an issue then it would have come up during her realtionship with Hasnat Khan, not waiting until then.

The only reason that came up is because Mohammed Al Fayed started coming up with conspiracy theories months, and sometimes years, after the crash to deflect from the fact that his driver and head of security was drunk and caused the crash.
He was also in a massive sulk over losing his royal warrants from Harrods.

InisnaBro · 02/02/2022 13:37

@Sweetpea2021, the press coverage of Diana was turning negative before her death it was no longer quite so possible to view her as the innocent young victim of Charles and Conniving Camilla, or the suffering young ingenue in the hands of the grey men of the Palace. The gutter press is cruel towards women as they age and I think it's likely she would have been viewed as increasingly irrelevant and silly as she hit 40, in part depending on whether she remarried and who, or whether she continued to be viewed in terms of glamorous holidays and vaguely unsuitable men.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 02/02/2022 13:36

Because the future king of England would have had a half sibling who was potentially Muslim. Massive problem for the Queen.
What/who is the King/Queen of England?

Sweetpea2021 · 02/02/2022 13:11

@Itsnotover

*What a load of rubbish. The reality is that 25years ago times were different. The future king of England having a half sibling that was Muslim would have put the Queen in a difficult position. She is the Supreme Governor of the Church of England*

@Sweetpea2021 so how do you explain that the Queen was fine, supportive even, of Diana dating Hasnat Khan? You're the one talking rubbish. How exactly would it have put the Queen in a difficult position? You've proved my point that it is sentiment such as yours that is racist.

It's not my sentiment that's racist it's the reality of the times 25 years ago. Mohammed al fayed said also that it was because he was Muslim.

I guess (on a smaller scale) it's just like say some Muslim families don't like their children marrying Christians etc

Things are different now. Times have changed (which is brilliant).