Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the common idea that Diana was murdered is absurd

438 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 17:01

Heard a journalist on the radio the other day speculating it was not an accident and heard others saying the same. AIBU to think people like this are complete idiots?

OP posts:
IcedPurple · 03/02/2022 11:33

[quote Monopolyiscrap]@InisnaBro Kate Middleton gets good popularity ratings. But there isn't that much interest in stories the media publish about her. There isn't even that much talk on the RF board here about her. But start a thread about Harry and Meghan and it will explode.
Diana used to be the same. People were very interested in reading and talking about her.[/quote]
I'm not sure being click bait is such a great thing.

Kate has been famous for pretty much all her adult life, but we really know very little about what she's 'really like'. She's an enigma. Given that she's going to remain a public figure for decades to come, that's a good thing. Inviting drama into your life isn't really a sustainable way to live.

ToffeeNotCoffee · 03/02/2022 11:30

Also, people seem to forget, she’d been dating Dodi for a month ffs. That’s it. It was hardly the romance of the century.

That's right. A put up job by Dodi's Dad. Diana was flown by helicopter and plonked in front of Dodi. That's how they were introduced.

She got the opportunity to pose about on a millionaire's yacht in the summer in a selection of swimwear. Sometimes gushing all over Dodi (on the deck of said yacht) because she knew the paparazzi were watching.

He was just being courteous most of the time. It seems to me they didn't have anything in common and didn't really know what to say to each other.

On their dates, they acted like a couple of clueless 12 year old kids. Dodi was just pretty much going along with it because his Dad told him to and because what his Dad wanted i.e. a foot into the 'British Establishment.'

Dodi had no time for British VIP protocol and whined to his Dad which is why the then off duty and drinking pastis driver ended up driving. Only too pleased for an opportunity to impress his boss.

'You won't catch us tonight' he goaded the waiting paparazzi.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 03/02/2022 11:19

@Monopolyiscrap

Diana was clearly motivated to do good as well. So I doubt your assessment of her if she was born now. Her work with AIDS and Landmines was not glamorous or the usual kind of Royal Family work. It wasn't turning up to the BAFTAs or a sports event wearing a pretty dress and having some photos taken. She was serious about making the world a better place.
If she'd remained a not-very-bright nursery teacher's assistant, unknown to press and public alike and without the money to travel round the world at will, there is not a snowball's chance in hell that anyone would have either known or cared what she thought about landmines, or AIDS, or indeed anything. So really, the person to thank for her doing any good is whoever selected her to marry Prince Charles; without that she couldn't have done it.
wanttomarryamillionaire · 03/02/2022 11:17

Diana actually used to play games with the press/paps. Use them when it suited her and then pretend they wouldn't leave her alone. She regularly called them in advance to let them know she would be in a certain place at a certain time, much like the celebrities of today do. If you play with fire enough times then eventually you will get burned. As for pp saying they are unsure if the body guard was wearing a belt, his biography stated he was wearing one. Thats the only reason he survived. The only other injuries Diana had apart from the one that killed her were a broken arm and a cut on her forehead. She would also be alive had she worn a belt.

IcedPurple · 03/02/2022 11:15

@Monopolyiscrap

Diana was clearly motivated to do good as well. So I doubt your assessment of her if she was born now. Her work with AIDS and Landmines was not glamorous or the usual kind of Royal Family work. It wasn't turning up to the BAFTAs or a sports event wearing a pretty dress and having some photos taken. She was serious about making the world a better place.
And yet she publicly abandoned almost all of 'her' charities just weeks before the accident, and left almost all of her money to her already extremely well provided for sons.

Not saying she didn't have genuine charitable intentions, but she was never going to devote her life to charity. Hard to see how she would be able to finance it and also live in the style to which she was accustomed. In any case, why can't a model or an actress also do good deeds?

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 03/02/2022 11:15

Kate Middleton doesn't as far as we know ring up members of the press and say "I shall be taking the children to x place at y time tomorrow, if anyone wants photos", as Diana has been reported by retired journalists as having done. (Well, we haven't been treated to pictures of her and her children in a McDonalds so I think we can assume she hasn't.) The journalists' complaint was that when they did turn up to her rendezvous with them, Diana then made a fuss to other members of the press about her never having any privacy.

In other words Kate is not a self-absorbed publicity-hound, and Diana was. The press corps knew this very well, and indulged her; it sold papers, and that paid their salaries.

People don't gossip about Kate because there is nothing much to gossip about. Some of the press did their best to stir up rubbish about whether she was too thin, but she neither denied it nor got obviously upset, so it was no fun for them.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 11:02

@InisnaBro Kate Middleton gets good popularity ratings. But there isn't that much interest in stories the media publish about her. There isn't even that much talk on the RF board here about her. But start a thread about Harry and Meghan and it will explode.
Diana used to be the same. People were very interested in reading and talking about her.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 11:00

Diana was clearly motivated to do good as well. So I doubt your assessment of her if she was born now.
Her work with AIDS and Landmines was not glamorous or the usual kind of Royal Family work. It wasn't turning up to the BAFTAs or a sports event wearing a pretty dress and having some photos taken. She was serious about making the world a better place.

InisnaBro · 03/02/2022 10:59

@Monopolyiscrap

Kate Middleton does not have the same level of public interest as Diana. She doesn't sell media in the same way. Instead it is notable that lots of articles about Kate that are clearly only about her, shoehorn in Harry and Meghan, as the media know the public are interested in that story.
No, because her private life isn’t emerging into the public domain likeDiana’s did, partly through intrusive paps, but also partly through her own connivance, planting of stories and photo ops etc. I think that’s the source of such interest as there is in KM — the carefully-presented, calculatedly inoffensive public face concealing - what?
IcedPurple · 03/02/2022 10:54

@Monopolyiscrap

Kate Middleton does not have the same level of public interest as Diana. She doesn't sell media in the same way. Instead it is notable that lots of articles about Kate that are clearly only about her, shoehorn in Harry and Meghan, as the media know the public are interested in that story.
Diana wouldn't sell media in the same way if she was around today. She was very much a product of the media culture of the time, which is long gone.

Diana wouldn't be Diana if she were young now. More likely she'd be having a go at being a model or actress, like Kitty Spencer, Cressida Bonas and so many other tall pretty posh gels.

Sweetpea2021 · 03/02/2022 10:40

@Itsnotover

It's not my sentiment that's racist it's the reality of the times 25 years ago.

No, it's really not.

Mohammed al fayed said also that it was because he was Muslim.

Mohammed Al Fayed said a lot of things.

Yes it really is. How old were you in 1997? Times and viewpoints have changed massively in 25 years.
Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 10:26

Kate Middleton does not have the same level of public interest as Diana. She doesn't sell media in the same way.
Instead it is notable that lots of articles about Kate that are clearly only about her, shoehorn in Harry and Meghan, as the media know the public are interested in that story.

InisnaBro · 03/02/2022 10:23

I think that’s also in part why people are so fascinated by Kate Middleton — another ordinary, privileged past with houseshares and make-uppy non-jobs and terrible clothes decisions, and then after she married in, the perfect royal wife, utterly discreet, perfectly dressed, not an unscripted word even breathed. The un-Diana. It’s impossible to imagine her looking coyly up through her mascara to complain about William’s philandering to the BBC, or being discovered with a man behind a pot plant in KP during a fire alarm.

InisnaBro · 03/02/2022 10:17

@DePfeffoff

I really don't see how anyone can make the claim that she was very popular with the general public. Yes, her face still sold newspapers, but that was more to do with general curiosity and celebrity culture. But so many people found her increasingly irritating and/or slightly laughable. Yes, they were still shocked at her death, and found it sad, but that was more because of her age and her sons.
And because of the soap opera-nature of a messy, if privileged life, lived out very publicly. The fact that it ended so suddenly and prematurely was a bit like people getting outraged because their favourite show was cancelled, or George RR Martin died without finishing the Game of Thrones series — a long running story of a fairytale princess captured and kept in a castle that turned out not to be a fairytale, and who turned out herself to be human, flawed, silly and messy in her own emotional life, was cut off abruptly, and now we were never going to find out what happened next.
Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 10:03

Her face sold lots of newspapers and magazines. Popularity is not the same as thinking someone is a saint. People were interested in her. Most people admired some things she did, but also could see her flaws. Not that long ago before her death, there had been a public auction of some of her dresses for charity, which were sold for huge amounts.
The Royal Family did not like how popular she was.

DePfeffoff · 03/02/2022 08:45

I really don't see how anyone can make the claim that she was very popular with the general public. Yes, her face still sold newspapers, but that was more to do with general curiosity and celebrity culture. But so many people found her increasingly irritating and/or slightly laughable. Yes, they were still shocked at her death, and found it sad, but that was more because of her age and her sons.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 00:48

It is not true that she was losing popularity overall.
The press had periods of saying how wonderful she was, and then periods of being critical. That cycle sells newspapers and magazines. Nearly any famous female celebrity has the same media cycle.
She was being criticised by the media at the time of her death. It would have soon changed back.
But with the general public she was very popular.

DePfeffoff · 03/02/2022 00:41

Have you forgotten Charles' interview and didn't that come first?

No. My post wasn't about him, it was about how people were reacting to Diana's actions and how she was perceived by the time she died.

DePfeffoff · 03/02/2022 00:39

Whatever badly judged things she did, I don't think anyone can deny that Diana changed societal attitudes to people with AIDS in a way that was nothing short of groundbreaking. She should never be forgotten in that regard.

I wouldn't deny that for a moment. I was simply pointing out the facts in response to the poster who claimed that she was still very popular at the time of her death.

DePfeffoff · 03/02/2022 00:37

@shortroundd

If she'd worn a seatbelt, she probably would have survived - as the only person in the car wearing one did

this has being largely disputed and I don't think an answer was ever given.

What is disputed is whether the bodyguard was wearing a seatbelt, not whether Diana would have survived if she had. The point is that he demonstrated that this was a survivable accident - if he wasn't saved by the seatbelt he was probably saved by an airbag - so if she'd been wearing one the chances of her surviving were very high.
AKASammyScrounge · 03/02/2022 00:20

@Hoppinggreen

Very unlikely Also, I don’t think it was necessary. People were staring to lose interest/fall out of love with her and she did far more damage to The Monarchy by dying than she did when alive
The press had turned on her. Negative stories about her abounded. Had it not been such a dreadful event, it would have been hilarious to watch the press backtracking.
shortroundd · 02/02/2022 23:20

So there is absolutely no disputing that she would have survived that accident had she been wearing a seatbelt

I didn't dispute this, I disputed that the bodyguard Trevor was wearing a seatbelt as ,multiple sources contradict this. Also I don't understand when you say ''there is absolutely no disputing that she would have survived that accident had she been wearing a seatbelt''. Who knows what would have happened had she being belted up? Sometimes the belt can do more damage.

Also it is a matter of public record that she refused police protection from the met police, she didn't trust them and thought they were reporting all her comings and going's to her ex husband and his family

Ok can you source this please as I have seen this disputed across mn over the years with no conclusion.

Perime · 02/02/2022 23:18

@AskingQuestionsAllTheTime

Charles's Central TV interview with Jonathan Dimbleby was in June 1994; Diana's with the lying Martin Bashir was in February the following year.
Thank you. So Charles set the precedent of airing the dirty laundry
wanttomarryamillionaire · 02/02/2022 23:15

@shortroundd she died from a ruptured blood vessel ( I think aorta although i could be wrong) she basically bled out into her chest cavity. So there is absolutely no disputing that she would have survived that accident had she been wearing a seatbelt. Also it is a matter of public record that she refused police protection from the met police, she didn't trust them and thought they were reporting all her comings and going's to her ex husband and his family.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 02/02/2022 21:31

Charles's Central TV interview with Jonathan Dimbleby was in June 1994; Diana's with the lying Martin Bashir was in February the following year.