Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the common idea that Diana was murdered is absurd

438 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 17:01

Heard a journalist on the radio the other day speculating it was not an accident and heard others saying the same. AIBU to think people like this are complete idiots?

OP posts:
IcedPurple · 03/02/2022 22:54

[quote wanttomarryamillionaire]@mahoncash Also no one in that party noticed that the Driver who wasn't even supposed to be on duty that night had had a drink, it wasn't just the bodyguard who didn't notice. In fact if you watch videos of them in the lift or leaving the hotel he doesn't look remotely drunk. As a pp stated if someone is an alcoholic ( Henri Paul was on medication for this) then they can quite often drink a lot before anyone notices they are drunk. [/quote]
Henri Paul wasn't even a professional driver. He was a security officer at The Ritz.

hookiewookie29 · 03/02/2022 22:37

She died because she got in a car with a driver who was off his face on drink and drugs, she wasn't wearing a seatbelt- nor was Dodi- who lost control of a speeding car.

mahoncash · 03/02/2022 22:31

He was ex military and very well trained as was the other body guard assigned to them. The problem was they were employed by the al fayed family, so they had to do whatever they were told

but military doesn't equate to being a bodyguard to a high profile person-they are 2 very different jobs. He didn't make her put her belt on is a major red flag.

wanttomarryamillionaire · 03/02/2022 22:20

@mahoncash Also no one in that party noticed that the Driver who wasn't even supposed to be on duty that night had had a drink, it wasn't just the bodyguard who didn't notice. In fact if you watch videos of them in the lift or leaving the hotel he doesn't look remotely drunk. As a pp stated if someone is an alcoholic ( Henri Paul was on medication for this) then they can quite often drink a lot before anyone notices they are drunk.

wanttomarryamillionaire · 03/02/2022 22:16

@mahoncash That's not true. He was ex military and very well trained as was the other body guard assigned to them. The problem was they were employed by the al fayed family, so they had to do whatever they were told ie. Change routes etc at the drop of a hat. The Royal families police protection is employed by the government not the royals themselves so therefore will only take their orders from their superiors or the government. Both bodyguards had complained to mr al fayed senior that they were struggling to provide proper protection to his son and the princess due to their behaviour and the ever constant changing itineraries but were both ignored. A bodyguard can no more force a VIP to wear their seatbelt than you or i can.

mahoncash · 03/02/2022 21:52

No-one particularly cared about Fergie's money troubles, for instance

yea but Fergie was nowhere near as publicised/high profile as Diana so I don't think they cared.

mahoncash · 03/02/2022 21:47

Anyone who has done any kind of training in this area will know that the bodyguard needs to be able to exit the car quickly in a dangerous situation for example an attempted kidnapping, training at the time would have required him not to wear a belt

I think the problem though was that Trevor Reese Jones wasn't trained nor were the security team adequately experienced or prepped to cover such a high profile person like Diana. Even Diane's former body guard publicly blasted them for their incompetence saying they had her in their care for 8 weeks and she was dead.

Jones was an ex soldier and a bit of muscle, he was completely out of his depth. Jones as a security guard should have checked they had their belts on and the fact that he ''didn't notice'' the driver was pissed is both questionable and again shows the man was out of his depth, and the driver was a bloody moron.
Having said that, Diana herself was as much to blame as she didn't have a belt on herself.

wanttomarryamillionaire · 03/02/2022 21:02

@mahoncash I think the reason that there is a misunderstanding over the bodyguard wearing a seatbelt is because he was the only one who shouldn't have been wearing one. Anyone who has done any kind of training in this area will know that the bodyguard needs to be able to exit the car quickly in a dangerous situation for example an attempted kidnapping, training at the time would have required him not to wear a belt. There was lots of speculation as to why he was actually wearing it, this gave rise to many conspiracy theories. As far as I recall he wasn't wearing it at first but then put it on due to the drivers erratic driving, this is what saved his life.

mahoncash · 03/02/2022 20:13

But how do you think she was going to maintain a life of philanthropy? She was used to a pretty high standard of living and seemed to quite enjoy the red carpet events. How do you think she could have funded a life of 'good deeds' indefinitely

she was paid off 17 million in the settlement I believe but also she was getting 400k a year for life so she easily could have done good deeds with wealth like that. I am not talking millions but 100k a year would have made a big difference and not hit her.

mahoncash · 03/02/2022 20:10

As for pp saying they are unsure if the body guard was wearing a belt, his biography stated he was wearing one

I recall reading forums online in which he people said he contradicted himself in interviews, his book and the enquiries so hard to know. In the pic of him leaving you can't see a belt on him.

ToffeeNotCoffee · 03/02/2022 18:55

If Charles hadn't made such a big deal out of Camilla's July birthday that year, would Diana have felt the need to, 'reply.'

By cavorting on a millionaire's yacht in Summer. (Yes, I know Diana's birthday is also in July.)

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 13:05

@IcedPurple there are far more damning ones than that. But not ones I care to speculate on.

IcedPurple · 03/02/2022 12:26

[quote Monopolyiscrap]@IcedPurple I am not interested in Kate. But you do like to rewrite history. There have been plenty of controversies around Kate in the past.[/quote]
You're not interested in Kate but you've mentioned her in several of your posts?

OK.

And nobody is going to spend their entire adult life in the pubic eye without a few 'incidents', but if the worst 'controversies' are having your skirt blow up or being papped coming out of a nightclub when you're a student, I don't think Kate has much to worry about.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 12:21

@IcedPurple It was reported at the time that she couldn't afford to carry on being Patron to so many charities. And that she thought they would be better having a Royal Patron. Yes they should have been told by her or her staff beforehand. It was announced on the day her divorce came through. It was directly linked. Diana did write to the charities.
Diana had over 100 patronages which is too much really. Kate has 19 patronages by comparison. Now 21 with the new Rugby ones.
Diana had a divorce settlement.

IcedPurple · 03/02/2022 12:10

[quote Monopolyiscrap]@IcedPurple after her divorce she dropped 94 patronages, not over 100. Many of these were the great and good charities that are common Royal patronages. It was directly linked to her divorce and no longer being a member of the Royal Family.
Harry and Meghan did the same. I am not sure why you would expect an ex-member of the Royal Family to pretend they are still one?[/quote]
I'm not going to quibble over the numbers but most of these patronages weren't 'royal', strictly speaking. She could have continued to maintain a relationship with most of them had she wished, and the charities only learned of her decision through the newspapers.

But how do you think she was going to maintain a life of philanthropy? She was used to a pretty high standard of living and seemed to quite enjoy the red carpet events. How do you think she could have funded a life of 'good deeds' indefinitely?

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 03/02/2022 12:08

"She" at the start of my post being Diana, not Kate!

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 12:07

@IcedPurple I am not interested in Kate. But you do like to rewrite history. There have been plenty of controversies around Kate in the past.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 12:05

@IcedPurple after her divorce she dropped 94 patronages, not over 100. Many of these were the great and good charities that are common Royal patronages. It was directly linked to her divorce and no longer being a member of the Royal Family.
Harry and Meghan did the same. I am not sure why you would expect an ex-member of the Royal Family to pretend they are still one?

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 03/02/2022 12:05

She was probably fed guff about Jackie Onassis on a yacht, to get her to go/stay. JO would have been an obvious rôle-model, the difference between them being that Jackie Kennedy was beloved, never in any way betrayed her husband, was a tragic widow, and had good qualifications (she graduated well from Vasser) and had started on a successful career before she married. JO was genuinely hounded by the paperazzi, so I suppose that's a point of similarity.

IcedPurple · 03/02/2022 12:02

@InisnaBro

That's what I mean, *@IcedPurple* -- what interests people that someone else young and pretty married a high-profile royal in line to the throne, and has remained a well-behaved (un-Diana-like) enigma.

And absolutely, KM is behaving in her own best interests to provide no tabloid fodder whatsoever, though the downside is insane micro-expression and body language 'analysis' of her briefest public moments.

Yes, Kate is a model of discretion and inscrutability. I'm sure during her break up with William, she could have sold her story to the papers and lived off the money for the rest of her life, but she has always played a superb long game.
IcedPurple · 03/02/2022 12:00

[quote Monopolyiscrap]@IcedPurple that is not true. After her Divorce, Diana dropped a lot of her Royal patronages.
Just a few weeks before her death she was working on landmines.
Criticise her if you want, but make them truthful.[/quote]
She voluntarily gave up helping over 100 charities of which she had once been patron, which was described as 'devastating' to those charities.

I never said she didn't continue to work for some charities, but it is a fact that she drastically cut down on her 'charity work' after the divorce, and that she left almost nothing to charity. She did do a lot of good and was genuinely compassionate, but I don't see her as ever being either willing or able to make a whole life out of charity work.

InisnaBro · 03/02/2022 11:47

That's what I mean, @IcedPurple -- what interests people that someone else young and pretty married a high-profile royal in line to the throne, and has remained a well-behaved (un-Diana-like) enigma.

And absolutely, KM is behaving in her own best interests to provide no tabloid fodder whatsoever, though the downside is insane micro-expression and body language 'analysis' of her briefest public moments.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 11:46

@IcedPurple that is not true. After her Divorce, Diana dropped a lot of her Royal patronages.
Just a few weeks before her death she was working on landmines.
Criticise her if you want, but make them truthful.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 11:43

She could also as a member of the RF have simply worn a pretty dress to the BAFTAs, sporting events and visited a few hospices. Instead, Diana highlighted controversial causes and did some good in doing so.

ToffeeNotCoffee · 03/02/2022 11:33

If she'd remained a not-very-bright nursery teacher's assistant, unknown to press and public alike and without the money to travel round the world at will, there is not a snowball's chance in hell that anyone would have either known or cared what she thought about landmines, or AIDS, or indeed anything. So really, the person to thank for her doing any good is whoever selected her to marry Prince Charles; without that she couldn't have done it.

This^

She could have married some other chinless wonder and gone quietly to hell holding a gin bottle somewhere in the home counties.