Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the common idea that Diana was murdered is absurd

438 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 17:01

Heard a journalist on the radio the other day speculating it was not an accident and heard others saying the same. AIBU to think people like this are complete idiots?

OP posts:
DePfeffoff · 04/02/2022 18:15

I do wish people had retained the sense to take the cellophane off the flowers, though. If they had, the stench would have been far less.

This! I thought that it was a real shame that all those beautiful flowers were essentially hidden, and all you could see really was a sea of white. Plus, if they'd taken the cellophane off, at least they could have begun to compost down.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/02/2022 17:13

I don;t think you can have that one both ways: Diana was popular among the small section of the population who pay attention to the royal family as you say here, or as you said in a previous post, "with the general public she was very popular." One or the other; not both.

I wrote of what I know. "Many now have no idea why they felt anything at all about her after the immediate shock, or why they went to put flowers outside the house she'd lived in to rot and smell vile for streets in all directions." had become a fact within a year; it's possible they were unable to say why they had done it because they were ashamed that the general hoohah, and the press frenzy intended to whip up general hysteria and distract everyone from the behaviour of the press with regard to her, had caused them to behave in a way they now perceived as irrational, but more of the ones I asked seemed simply to be a bit bewildered rather than anything else. They certainly were no longer of the opinion that a woman they had never met was of such paramount importance to them that they needed to weep and rend their garments and for all I know put ash in their hair.

I do wish people had retained the sense to take the cellophane off the flowers, though. If they had, the stench would have been far less.

Monopolyiscrap · 04/02/2022 14:19

@AskingQuestionsAllTheTime As I said most people don't care about the Royal Family. The BBC got a record number of complaints about the level of their coverage after Prince Philip died.
It is a small section of the population who pay any attention to the Royal Family. But amongst them Diana was popular.
And her funeral was watched by a record audience. The Elton John song rewritten for her funeral was Number 1 best selling record in the charts. And newspapers and magazines full of stories about her in - remembering her life special editions - sold in large numbers. And books of condolences were in Town Halls around the country with people queuing for hours to sign them.
Lots of people didn't care about Diana dying. Just as they wouldn't care about any member of the Royal Family or ex-member dying. But there seems to be an attempt to rewrite history about those that do care.
Also very patronising to declare without any evidence that those who laid flowers or were upset now dont know why.
It was always popular to sneer at those upset by Diana's death amongst a certain type of person who saw themselves as superior and viewed the public response as unBritish.
Jokes about Diana's death prove nothing except that some people will joke about anything. There were jokes about 9-11 online within hours. While most people were shocked and still watching TV footage about the mass tragedy.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/02/2022 14:12

"not beSt pleased"

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 04/02/2022 14:10

During the week before her funeral, which was going to take place on the last shopping Saturday before most children went back to school, I asked many, many people in the ordinary suburb I was living in what they thought about it all. Not a single one of them was in the least interested in her as a person, none thought she had been deliberately killed, none grieved her much ("It's a shame she died so young" was common, but "her poor boys" was far more a concern) and almost all were exasperated about the timing, which was monstrously inconvenient for them: buying last-minute things for their children's new term had been made extremely difficult because the shops were all going to be shut. And the shopkeepers, most of whom I knew well, didn't feel the slightest respect for her; they planned to close on that day because they were afraid people would think they weren't being respectful after someone had delivered a leaflet about it all along the street. Some of them thought that if they were open they might get a brick though the window from a nutter. All knew that they would lose the money for that day because of her and were not bet pleased by that.

One of the people I talked with described the whole press furore as "they want the whole county to come down with DI-arroeah and dribble about her all over the street".

I did know one person who cancelled a weekend in Paris, but when I asked her why, she didn't really know: it wasn't because she had liked Diana (she was clear on that) but a sort of incoherent fear that They might have it in for Brits in some way and it would all be rather awkward. Or bad luck, or something.

The jokes about her death had begun to circulate on the internet within a very few hours of the news being announced; my favourite was the Australian site which had "Latest news about Diana" on the front page, and when you clicked on it the page you were sent to simply said "Yup, still dead." Most of the others were cruel and taking the piss of both her and Dodi. Not a lot of love there! And I was sent them by people all over the country.

I would say that she was certainly well-known, possibly even notorious, but I am not at all convinced she was popular; more a focus for people's catharsis. Many now have no idea why they felt anything at all about her after the immediate shock, or why they went to put flowers outside the house she'd lived in to rot and smell vile for streets in all directions.

Monopolyiscrap · 04/02/2022 10:49

@DePfeffoff Yes, it is true that many/most? people don't care about celebrities or the Royal Family. Look at the people on MN who had no idea that Prince Philip was the Queen's husband.

DePfeffoff · 04/02/2022 09:04

@Monopolyiscrap, simply repeating that she was popular with "most people" doesn't make it true. She was popular with a section of the public, but the reality is that, as time went on, she simply didn't impinge on most people's lives beyond maybe spending the occasional minute or two looking at the occasional news report about her.

Monopolyiscrap · 04/02/2022 01:09

@DePfeffoff they sold for the prices they did because they had been worn by Diana.
I dont know why you are so determined to deny her popularity.

Vanellopee · 04/02/2022 00:08

I won’t reveal my sources, but I heard from someone who you could describe as ‘very senior’ in the UK government that she was indeed murdered.

By Keir Starmer.

DePfeffoff · 04/02/2022 00:03

Well, yes, They were gorgeous dresses and were famous ones having been plastered over the papers. It says nothing about her being popular with most of the population as suggested.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 23:57

@DePfeffoff My point about the dresses is that people were prepared to pay a lot for one of Diana's dresses.

DePfeffoff · 03/02/2022 23:56

[quote Monopolyiscrap]@IcedPurple after her divorce she dropped 94 patronages, not over 100. Many of these were the great and good charities that are common Royal patronages. It was directly linked to her divorce and no longer being a member of the Royal Family.
Harry and Meghan did the same. I am not sure why you would expect an ex-member of the Royal Family to pretend they are still one?[/quote]
The point is that this is the other side of the coin to all of the stuff about how supportive to good causes she was.

DePfeffoff · 03/02/2022 23:51

@Monopolyiscrap

Kate Middleton does not have the same level of public interest as Diana. She doesn't sell media in the same way. Instead it is notable that lots of articles about Kate that are clearly only about her, shoehorn in Harry and Meghan, as the media know the public are interested in that story.
That's mostly because she doesn't court the press in the way that Diana did. She gets more respect as a result.
DePfeffoff · 03/02/2022 23:50

@Monopolyiscrap

Her face sold lots of newspapers and magazines. Popularity is not the same as thinking someone is a saint. People were interested in her. Most people admired some things she did, but also could see her flaws. Not that long ago before her death, there had been a public auction of some of her dresses for charity, which were sold for huge amounts. The Royal Family did not like how popular she was.
But there again, being interested in someone doesn't mean that person is popular. Unless you took a poll, I just don't see how you can claim "most people" admired her. I remember someone commenting on the dresses sale that they were all paid for by other people in the first place so the entire charity gesture was carried out at no personal cost to Diana whatsoever.
Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 23:45

Philip was said to be incandescent with rage at Fergies antics and banned her from Royal Family events.

mahoncash · 03/02/2022 23:35

Fergie was slated in the press for how she made money

I didn't say she was never in the press, she was. But her star power, popularity and influence wasn't anywhere near that of Diana's is my point so hence the Royals weren't overly bothered about her antics.

Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 23:23

@mahoncash

No-one particularly cared about Fergie's money troubles, for instance

yea but Fergie was nowhere near as publicised/high profile as Diana so I don't think they cared.

Fergie was slated in the press for how she made money.
Monopolyiscrap · 03/02/2022 23:21

The Queen was photographed in a car I think about a month after Diana died, not wearing a seat belt.

wanttomarryamillionaire · 03/02/2022 23:14

The security were highly trained professionals who knew the whole thing was getting out of control, they reported this situation to their employer who did absolutely nothing about it. That is why he encouraged all these rumours about murder by the British establishment. It was a tragic accident caused by a drunk man and an arrogant man unwilling to override his sons wishes. As for it being a major red flag that TRJ didn't " make" Diana or Dodi wear seatbelts, well if you think that's possible you clearly have never worked with VIPs. I would love to see the reaction if a close protection officer/ body guard tried to make the queen or any other member of the royal family do anything. It simply doesn't happen. They can ask a VIP to put a belt on but there's absolutely nothing they can do if they refuse!

mahoncash · 03/02/2022 23:13

In other words, we all have our own selfish desires at the end of the day no matter how much we may put others 1st. If something benefits ourselves even at the expense of others we will still find relief at some level. It's called survival.

mahoncash · 03/02/2022 23:07

I very much doubt The Queen gave a sigh of relief. Her grandsons mother was dead

Meh I have a sister I hate, she's a mother and child to my parents. Would I want her dead? No for that reason.

Would I see some relief in her death at the same time after all the damage she did to my life? By all means yes for my own selfish reasons I would give an inner sigh of relief and I wouldn't grieve an inch of her.

megletthesecond · 03/02/2022 23:04

I very much doubt The Queen gave a sigh of relief. Her grandsons mother was dead.

Didioverstep · 03/02/2022 23:00

My dh thinks it was a murder. He also loves a conspiracy theory though. I just humour it any more because I can't be arsed.

mahoncash · 03/02/2022 22:57

Henri Paul wasn't even a professional driver. He was a security officer at The Ritz

and I think that was why she was killed really-because none of them in that team were professional yet people are too busy blaming the latest conspiracy to see the facts.

Swipe left for the next trending thread