Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the common idea that Diana was murdered is absurd

438 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 17:01

Heard a journalist on the radio the other day speculating it was not an accident and heard others saying the same. AIBU to think people like this are complete idiots?

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 29/01/2022 18:57

@Wizzbangfizz

I think that to claim the world was losing interest in her is wholly incorrect - it anything to frenzy was growing - particularly if as heavily speculated she was going to announce an engagement and pregnancy.
Maybe the world wasn’t losing interest then but I do think they were falling out of love with her a bit
LovedayCL · 29/01/2022 18:57

Yes, YANBU - they’re a combination of completely thick and / or enjoying a vicarious thrill out of someone else’s tragedy.

SantaHat · 29/01/2022 18:55

That is manslaughter, which is murder

No. It. Isn’t.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 29/01/2022 18:55

@peboh

Technically she was murdered. Wether or not you want to believe it was premeditated and planned. She was in a car accident due to paparazzi not leaving her be. Cars chasing her, and not giving them space. That is manslaughter, which is murder.
If it was neither premeditated nor planned, then it was not murder.

Manslaughter is not murder. They are two different crimes.

peboh · 29/01/2022 18:52

Technically she was murdered. Wether or not you want to believe it was premeditated and planned. She was in a car accident due to paparazzi not leaving her be. Cars chasing her, and not giving them space. That is manslaughter, which is murder.

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 18:52

I think that to claim the world was losing interest in her is wholly incorrect - it anything to frenzy was growing - particularly if as heavily speculated she was going to announce an engagement and pregnancy

not losing interest is what people are saying, it's that she was starting to fall out of public/media favour.

OP posts:
makkapacca · 29/01/2022 18:50

Interestin g article below where her ex bodyguard blamed the security team:

It's been nearly 20 years since Princess Diana was killed in a car accident in Paris, a death that shook the world. And ever since that fateful night, conspiracy theories have swirled around what really happened. One man who was close to Diana for years is now blaming her security team for not intervening.

Ken Wharfe, who served as Diana's royal protection officer for six years, resigned from the position in 1993. He now says if he and his team were working with the Princess in 1997, they may have been able to prevent her death. "On behalf of all the professional men and women of the Met's protection squad, let me say that neither [bodyguard Trevor] Rees-Jones nor any of the other bodyguards who attended Diana in the two months preceding her death were from our department," he writes in an excerpt of his updated memoirs, published by the Daily Mail. "I am still angry beyond words that this team of 'bodyguards' let her come to harm."

Rees-Jones was the sole survivor of the crash that killed Diana, Dodi Fayed, and driver Henri Paul. He had been appointed by the Fayed family to protect Diana during their trip to Paris, but Wharfe alleges he was never briefed by police and had a misunderstanding of the paparazzi as an "enemy" he could beat. Plus, because he was hired by the Fayeds, he was prevented from speaking against their wishes. (Diana had declined the Queen's offer to have round-the-clock police protection, which Wharfe says led to the security issues in the first place.)

Wharfe alleges that Rees-Jones should have intervened when Fayed made risky decisions, like ordering Paul to drive although he had allegedly been drinking, and letting Fayed tell Paul to drive too fast to outpace photographers. He also says the security team should have called local Paris police for backup, and Rees-Jones should have insisted everyone in the car wear his or her seatbelt.

"I can say with certainty, drawing on decades of police experience, that Diana's death was not murder but a dreadful accident that should have been avoided," Wharfe wrote. "She was not the victim of shadowy figures who regarded her as an embarrassment to the Establishment, but of her boyfriend's erratic behavior and her bodyguard's mistakes''
Rees-Jones, for his part, has said under oath that he has no concrete memories of the car crash that killed Diana, because he suffered a head injury in the collision. He told a jury during an investigation that he had been unhappy with Fayed's plans that night, but "went along with it." He has also written a memoir about his time working with Diana after Dodi's father, Mohamed, blamed him for the crash, but has not responded to Wharfe's new claims.

According to Sky News, Wharfe's book also reveals the one rumor that truly hurt Princess Diana: that Prince Harry's biological father was not Prince Charles. Wharfe says that Diana did have an affair with James Hewitt, the man some rumors claim is Harry's dad, but they were only an item after Harry was born. "A simple comparison of dates proves it is impossible for Hewitt to be Harry's father. Only once did I ever discuss it with her, and Diana was in tears about it."

Rees-Jones was the sole survivor of the crash that killed Diana, Dodi Fayed, and driver Henri Paul. He had been appointed by the Fayed family to protect Diana during their trip to Paris, but Wharfe alleges he was never briefed by police and had a misunderstanding of the paparazzi as an "enemy" he could beat. Plus, because he was hired by the Fayeds, he was prevented from speaking against their wishes. (Diana had declined the Queen's offer to have round-the-clock police protection, which Wharfe says led to the security issues in the first place.)

Wharfe alleges that Rees-Jones should have intervened when Fayed made risky decisions, like ordering Paul to drive although he had allegedly been drinking, and letting Fayed tell Paul to drive too fast to outpace photographers. He also says the security team should have called local Paris police for backup, and Rees-Jones should have insisted everyone in the car wear his or her seatbelt.

"I can say with certainty, drawing on decades of police experience, that Diana's death was not murder but a dreadful accident that should have been avoided," Wharfe wrote. "She was not the victim of shadowy figures who regarded her as an embarrassment to the Establishment, but of her boyfriend's erratic behavior and her bodyguard's mistakes."

Princess Diana and Prince Harry in 1995.
Princess Diana and Prince Harry in 1995.
GETTY IMAGES
Rees-Jones, for his part, has said under oath that he has no concrete memories of the car crash that killed Diana, because he suffered a head injury in the collision. He told a jury during an investigation that he had been unhappy with Fayed's plans that night, but "went along with it." He has also written a memoir about his time working with Diana after Dodi's father, Mohamed, blamed him for the crash, but has not responded to Wharfe's new claims.

According to Sky News, Wharfe's book also reveals the one rumor that truly hurt Princess Diana: that Prince Harry's biological father was not Prince Charles. Wharfe says that Diana did have an affair with James Hewitt, the man some rumors claim is Harry's dad, but they were only an item after Harry was born. "A simple comparison of dates proves it is impossible for Hewitt to be Harry's father. Only once did I ever discuss it with her, and Diana was in tears about it."

OP posts:
maggiecate · 29/01/2022 18:49

If you’re going to assassinate someone you need to know where they’re going to be and when. The trip that evening was a spontaneous one that Dodi suggested and organised at the last minute. The driver was drinking because he thought he was done for the night. It would have been impossible to plan for the accident to happen because the whole event was unplanned. There were other routes that could have been taken, they couldn’t have anticipated that the driver would be speeding, that the passengers wouldn’t be wearing seatbelts. The odds of pulling it off and getting away are astronomical - far too high for any professional setup like the security services to attempt.

And the idea that the royal family would have put the boys through that trauma - after having themselves endured the grief of the Mountbatten assassination - is frankly ridiculous.

Wizzbangfizz · 29/01/2022 18:47

I think that to claim the world was losing interest in her is wholly incorrect - it anything to frenzy was growing - particularly if as heavily speculated she was going to announce an engagement and pregnancy.

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 18:45

It didn’t though. SHE chose to give up her security

well regardless my point still stands, her ex bodyguard said the same.

OP posts:
1987qwerty · 29/01/2022 18:44

Load of crap. A million better ways they'd have done it.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 29/01/2022 18:41

Private Eye very unkindly got hold of the Sunday papers which had already been delivered in the West Country by the time of her death, and printed extracts from columns by the writers who were being most sob-stuff about her death in those same publications. Yes, the media sainted her once she was dead, but the comments on her (even about her sons being embarrassed by her carryings-on and not liking Dodi) when they didn't know she was dead were damning. They were all ready to do a total hatchet job on her, and then the wretched woman got herself killed and they had to call those papers in and print a complete new run full of overblown tragic-face.

My favourite comment at the time was from the representative of Mercedes, who said rather sadly that they build very good cars, but even their cars are not proof against being driven into a concrete pillar at over eighty mile an hour.

SantaHat · 29/01/2022 18:41

I might say that as the removal of her HRH status led to the withdrawal of her police protection

It didn’t though. SHE chose to give up her security.

Hoppinggreen · 29/01/2022 18:41

@makkapacca

because everybody i know thinks it was a murder.
Get different friends
OmgIThinkILikeYou · 29/01/2022 18:41

There are also a lot of books and documentaries based on the theory. I'm not arguing that it isn't a stupid theory, it obviously is. But that doesn't stop millions of people believing it to be true.

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 18:40

But I thought the main reason for the conspiracy theory was that she herself predicted it - didn’t she write a letter saying something along the lines of ‘[blank] is planning an accident in my car

no that's tabloid shite along with the m15 ''witnesses'' that has no substance.

OP posts:
OmgIThinkILikeYou · 29/01/2022 18:35

That’s not really reliable. You could see 20 accounts from the same person or bots saying something that give an impression there are 20 people who have a particular opinion but it’s not necessarily true

Hmm maybe, I didn't say I thought the idea was true, just that its a common view. There are thousands of videos on tiktok of people saying it, looking into it. Lots on YouTube also, I'm not talking anonymous forums, although I am sure there are millions.

Chasingaftermidnight · 29/01/2022 18:33

I don’t know anyone who genuinely thinks she was assassinated.

But I thought the main reason for the conspiracy theory was that she herself predicted it - didn’t she write a letter saying something along the lines of ‘[blank] is planning an accident in my car’?

SantaHat · 29/01/2022 18:32

Even though James and Harry look nothing alike and not to mention the fact that she didn’t meet James Hewitt until a couple of years after Harry was born (but as many have said, why let the facts get in the way of a trashy story).

HalfCakeHalfBiscuit · 29/01/2022 18:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Allycott · 29/01/2022 18:29

@480Widdio

I don’t know a single person who thinks she was murdered! You would have to be a bit on the thick side to think she was.
I don't think it was a total accident and I can assure you I'm not thick. I'm intelligent enough no to rubbish other opinions - unlike yourself.
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 29/01/2022 18:26

It would be a spectacularly crap way to murder someone, that depended on them not wearing their seat belt, the crash happening at a particular point, hiring a drunk driver who died himself etc. Just not the perfect crime!

If they were going to kill someone it made more sense to kill of Camilla’s husband as there would then be not objection to their marriage. Not that I’m advocating it!

HomeHomeInTheRange · 29/01/2022 18:26

OP; IMO YANBU. People who believe this are complete idiots.

And the sheer number of complete idiots (whether holding individual accounts or represented by troll bots) does not make conspiracy theories any more plausible.

Idiots like to idiot.

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 18:25

It's like saying "Why did the Kennedys have such terrible things happen to them as a family?" Well the answer is because the lives they led as a family: in politics during a volatile period, serving in wars, being high-profile enough to pilot their own private plane made them peculiarly vulnerable to, respectively: assassination, death in action, crashing a plane. Sad, but there you have it.

Diana's lifestyle became such that she ended up relying for her personal safety on some dubious playboy with a driver who turned out to be pissed and a security man who didn't even notice.

I might say that as the removal of her HRH status led to the withdrawal of her police protection, which would have been much more efficient than Fayed's "protection" turned out to be (you wouldn't imagine a Met Police driver being pissed behind the wheel), it could therefore be argued that the removal of Royal privileges contributed directly to her death. But she had a brain of her own, she chose to rely on Fayed's security. She chose not to put her seatbelt on. Shame.

OP posts:
Stookeen · 29/01/2022 18:24

@OmgIThinkILikeYou

I think it's quite a common opinion, I see it online all the time.
Yeah, along with the Queen being a lizard, Finland being imaginary and Elvis and Shergar hanging out together there.