Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the common idea that Diana was murdered is absurd

438 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 17:01

Heard a journalist on the radio the other day speculating it was not an accident and heard others saying the same. AIBU to think people like this are complete idiots?

OP posts:
DePfeffoff · 29/01/2022 23:17

The speaker made us get up and stoop down to tie our laces, not easy when sober, apparently the driver was alleged to be drunk, but video showed him tieing his laces perfectl

Habitual drinkers get very good at focussing on small tasks like that. Keeping a speeding car under control, not so much.

PermanentTemporary · 29/01/2022 23:16

Ridiculous idea. I don't know who in 'the RF' is supposed to have ordered this and why. The criminal mastermind that is Prince Andrew? Prince Philip who lost so many of his own family would do this to his grandchildren? They are a family that enthusiastically holds grudges for decades but quite obviously don't bump the people they have grudges against off - cf Edward VIII. Tbh the only role they had in her eventually death was promoting the marriage with Charles which was a terrible idea from the start, just to stop him having much too good a time shagging other man's wives across the globe.

LondonQueen · 29/01/2022 23:15

I don't think it was a murder. Just a lesson to wear your seatbelt and never get in the car of a drunk or drugged up driver.

Pyewhacket · 29/01/2022 23:01

@Strictlyfanoftenyears

We were on holiday about 5 years ago, a forensic scientist gave a talk about this subject. Absolutely fascinating but there were certainly parts of what happened that didn't make sense. Lots of detail (one of the many snippets were a video of the driver tieing his shoelace before he drove off. The speaker made us get up and stoop down to tie our laces, not easy when sober, apparently the driver was alleged to be drunk, but video showed him tieing his laces perfectly. Obviously there were lots of other snippets too.
He also drove at nearly 80mph in a 30mph inner city area ( confirmed by the speed cameras ) straight into a known accident black spot and if she had been wearing her seat belt she would have almost certainly have survived.

They tried to recreate the crash ( don't forget the white FIAT ) but none of the stuntmen would continue with it after just one attempt - too dangerous. In the end they set out traffic cones and none of them could control such a heavy car and avoid hitting the cones. Simulations with McDonnell-Douglas software also proved the accident unavoidable.

All he had to do was slow down. She was the most photographed woman on the planet, what was a few more pics ?.

She was offered professional security staff from the Embassy. Even Chirac offered his personal presidential protection people but she was intent on playing games with the paparazzi. Thinking wasn't one of her strengths.

DePfeffoff · 29/01/2022 23:00

If the Royal Family was into killing off people likely to cause scandal, Virginia Giuffre would have died long ago.

DePfeffoff · 29/01/2022 22:59

She was on the front of the sunday red tops every week!

They were noticeably turning against her, though. The headlines and copy were beginning to have that sneery tone that they now use for Meghan Markle, and the right wing press particularly didn't like her attraction to Asian men. Just before her death they were sneering at the number of freebie holidays she was cadging.

THisbackwithavengeance · 29/01/2022 22:50

@AlDanvers

I think Diana dying actually made things harder for Charles and Camellia. And the RF. She has practically become sainted.
Indeed.

I never understood why Joe Public wanted Diana and Charles to stay married. They were so unsuited and unhappy together, it was ridiculous. I couldn't stand Diana personally. She openly shagged married men and broke up their marriages and not a word was said. And Dodi Fayed as a serious boyfriend was scraping the barrel in poor taste.

murasaki · 29/01/2022 22:35

I al not an Al Fayed fan by any means, but I think he said what he's said in grief, and that his son's death was almost overlooked in all this. I have a certain sympathy with him wanting to find a reason that wasn't to do with his family, even if I don't believe it.

Itsnotover · 29/01/2022 22:25

I saw a YouTube video recently where the commentary was talking about Prince Andrew and all his vile and ridiculous behaviour and obvious lies. The commentator made reference to the conspiracy theory about the royal family being reptilian humanoids aliens with a huge amount of power. The commentator pointed out that if Andrew was one of those, he’d never have made this many mistakes. Grin

jcyclops · 29/01/2022 22:17

It makes me think that Virginia Giuffre should watch out for Space Debris re-entering the atmosphere and hitting her on the head. Maybe an unknown volcano could erupt underneath the court in New York. She had also better watch out for the MI6 trained Tiger ready to escape from the NY Zoo, and whatever she does don't let her click a ballpoint pen three times in a row.

Itsnotover · 29/01/2022 22:01

It’s convenient that people now twist it into a love story that they’ve fabricated the ending of (or Dodi’s father did).

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 29/01/2022 21:59

We were on holiday about 5 years ago, a forensic scientist gave a talk about this subject. Absolutely fascinating but there were certainly parts of what happened that didn't make sense. Lots of detail (one of the many snippets were a video of the driver tieing his shoelace before he drove off. The speaker made us get up and stoop down to tie our laces, not easy when sober, apparently the driver was alleged to be drunk, but video showed him tieing his laces perfectly. Obviously there were lots of other snippets too.

Itsnotover · 29/01/2022 21:59

@StarbucksSmarterSister

The suggestion is, this could be secret services due to Diana having a child with Dodi, right?

There are some people who do think that, except she'd only been going out with him for about 6 weeks so even if pregnant might not have known it herself.

Years ago at the beginning of Mumsnet when there were only a small number of people here, one Mner claimed to know a woman that was friends with Diana and had been with her on that holiday with Dodi. This woman had apparently been aware that Diana had her period at this time, making pregnancy unlikely. That always stuck in my mind.

Also, some people have come out and said that she was never that much in love with Dodi and that he was only a fling to her.

SantaHat · 29/01/2022 21:40

^ lol I am quite amused that I managed an auto correct mistake in my previous post.
It should be paparazzi. Not parasite! 🤣🤣

LovedayCL · 29/01/2022 21:36

Her death was convenient, the RF would have hated her marrying an Arab, let alone having a child with him.

I often think this says more about the people suggesting it, than those it’s directed at.

SantaHat · 29/01/2022 21:30

To me, the saddest thing is that nearly every one of these conspiracy theories comes back to Al Fayed running his mouth off with no evidence or basis in reality. Arguably, if you truly want to lay the blame for the deaths of Diana and Dodi on someone (other than the pressures in general from
The parasite), it should probably lie with Mohammed Al-Fayed. I try to think kindly that is rantings come from purely a place of utter grief and internal guilty. In my not so kind moments they seem purely about deflection from his own actions.

StartupRepair · 29/01/2022 21:30

Too many variables for it to be anything other than a terrible accident, brought about by a combination of the paparazzi (and public) intense interest, the slapdash arrangements of the Al Fayeds and perhaps the gung ho attitude of Dodi to outrun the photographers.

AlDanvers · 29/01/2022 21:14

@gunnersgold

I think it's more to do with the fact the fireman who did cpr on her said she was alive and talking when he left her and was very shocked when he heard she died. I don't think it was an assassination because had she had her belt on she might be ok today !
My dad called an ambulance for mum because her breathing was bad. Paramedics came, gave her oxygen. She was talking to them and her oxygen levels were coming back up.

She then had heart attack and never regained consciousness. I am really surprised a fire fighter has never come across someone who seemed ok, then just died. Especially after a massive physical trauma.

Knockoneofftheshelftowin · 29/01/2022 21:13

I also know lots of people who think she was murdered.

I know, crackers.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/01/2022 21:09

Why did they embalm her against the law?

That's the one which has always stayed with me
When you have a case as massive as that, everyone knows that you play it straight down the line, but they broke the law "because it was hot"? In a major hospital in a major western city with ample cooling facilities? Even if disinclined to place her in the mortuary "because security", they could have used ice packs in her private room, but no - they steamed in and embalmed her

None of that makes it murder of course, but I've still never seen a sensible explanation

SilverDoe · 29/01/2022 20:54

@makkapacca

because everybody i know thinks it was a murder.
I haven't RTFT so forgive me if itw been addressed or if I'm just wrong but I wonder if you are misunderstanding people. A lot of people me included believe that the behaviour of the media contributed to her death quite substantially. While it wasn't literally murder, I do understand (because I think it's demonstrable) that there was significant media manipulation in her life which set in motion the events that lead to her death. I don't even mean specifically the actual car crash that killed her. It just seems to me like something like that was bound to happen at some point due to the way she was treated.
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 29/01/2022 20:46

@Suzi888

It’s pretty much a 50-50 split on voting.

Her death was convenient, the RF would have hated her marrying an Arab, let alone having a child with him.

Hang on: she went out for two years with Hasnat Khan and the Windsors seem to have been all for that relationship: Prince Charles gave it his blessing quite openly. Why would they have approved of her being with a Pakistani Muslim long-term, but been driven into a panic by her 47-day relationship with an Arab?
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 29/01/2022 20:43

@bubbleblower85

I think the people who overlook the strange things around her death are ridiculous. Why were all the cameras in the tunnel turned off? Why wasn't she taken to the hospital which was very nearby immediatly? Why did they embalm her against the law? Why was the white fiat punto found burnt out and the driver killed? Why the nonsend about Henri Paul being drunk, his level of blood alcohol would have left him paraplegic but he was fine on all the CCTV camera's and his family have said he wasn't a drinker. Why wasn't Charles asked about why his wife said she fears she would be killed in a staged car crash by him, at the inquest? If this was a ordinary Mr Smith/Jones they would have questioned him in an inquest. There are other things that raises eyebrows.

I guess we will never know exaxctly what happened but I think the car accident was just setting the stage for something neferious afterwards (i.e in thhe ambulance/hospital) and then it gives them plausible deniability i.e she died because of a car crash.

All these "oh how unlikely" notions miss out a few simple facts.

It is not possible from a distance to cause someone to drive a car into a pillar far too fast for the road and kill three people including himself. And it is not possible to cause three people not to put on their seatbelts unless you are in the car with them.

So unless the driver was a criminal mastermind who wanted DiPoW dead, the "it was all a Master Plot" conspiracy theory falls flat on its face. And funnily enough, that Henri Paul was a suicidal master villain who by pure coincidence was also taking anti-depressants and had drunk enough that evening for it to be illegal for him to drive never seems to get suggested.

One thing does need to be answered. "Why were all the cameras in the tunnel turned off?" They were not. At that time there were no CCTV cameras sited in that tunnel. The ten CCTV cameras in the immediate area all were turned on, and none showed any image of the car that night for the simple reason that they were privately-owned security cameras and directed towards the building for which they were security, not the road. The traffic-monitoring camera at the entrance to the underpass was not in use after 11pm because it the traffic department which used it was not on duty at that hour, and it did not make recording because it was not designed to do so.

Oh, and one putative driver of a white Fiat Uno which he no longer owned at the time of the accident did indeed die by suicide th following year -- in a burnt out BMW, not a white Fiat Uno. The other putative driver did indeed own a car of that description, and did get his brother-in-law to help him spray-paint it red on the day after the crash; but he seems still to be alive, and also to have been at work at the time the accident happened.

She was not taken to the nearest hospital immediately because she was still in the car for some time, since moving her with anything less that extreme caution might have killed her on the spot; it was more than an hour before the ambulance carrying her left the scene of the accident. And she was not admitted to the nearest hospital because that one was not equipped to treat what were by then known to be her injuries, so she was redirected to a specialist trauma hospital.

gunnersgold · 29/01/2022 20:32

I think it's more to do with the fact the fireman who did cpr on her said she was alive and talking when he left her and was very shocked when he heard she died. I don't think it was an assassination because had she had her belt on she might be ok today !

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 20:27

The suggestion is, this could be secret services due to Diana having a child with Dodi, right

other 1 was that it was the landsmines people as she was getting too much publicity for it

OP posts: