Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the common idea that Diana was murdered is absurd

438 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 17:01

Heard a journalist on the radio the other day speculating it was not an accident and heard others saying the same. AIBU to think people like this are complete idiots?

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 02/02/2022 10:17

Can't believe that 50% of voters think that the drunk driver and failure to put on seatbelts was contrived. If she'd worn a seatbelt, she probably would have survived - as the only person in the car wearing one did.

Itsnotover · 02/02/2022 10:13

@Porcupineintherough that is rubbish. The Queen was supportive of Diana's relationship with Hasnat Khan.

Porcupineintherough · 02/02/2022 08:43

@Itsnotover

The people who say that Diana was murdered because she was going out with a person of colour are the ones who are racist. Because they've dreamed up the idea in the first place and assume others would perceive it to be a problem that would cause someone to be murdered!
Noticing racism doesn't make you racist. And you are dreaming if you think this wasnt an issue (albeit not one worth killing over) when Diana was going out with Dodi. Just as it was when Harry married Meghan. The British take the racial purity of their royal family very seriously.
AlDanvers · 02/02/2022 04:50

I think if Markle were to die the Queen would also breathe an inner sigh of relief today

No she wouldn't. Because again, Meghan would be sainted. The mother of 2 young children dying, perceived (by some) as treated poorly by the RF. Harry would be forgiven (by the public) for anything he does, in grief, going forward.

It would cause the RF a far bigger problems than a Oprah interview. As it stands H&M have had their say, it didn't go down as well as they had hoped. They are universally loved and missed.

There's no fountains or statues to Meghan around London.

Diana dying made things infintly worse for the RF, particularly the Queen and Charles and Camellia. Meghan dying would cause them more issues also.

Plus the Queen is a person, a mother, grandmother and Great grand mother she wouldn't be happy her Grandson and his children lost their wife and mother.

So it makes no sense. Even if she is an unfeeling bitch, she wouldn't want it to happened because it would cause more problems. It's likey she is not an unfeeling bitch and would not want that pain felt by her family.

No sense at all

Itsnotover · 02/02/2022 00:42

The people who say that Diana was murdered because she was going out with a person of colour are the ones who are racist. Because they've dreamed up the idea in the first place and assume others would perceive it to be a problem that would cause someone to be murdered!

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 01/02/2022 16:31

The number of people who have got up their noses that the royal family has not bumped off is enormous. The wild rumour that there might be one such person, a rumour started by someone with very good motives for not wanting attention focussed on the fact that his employees were heavily involved and whose son had also died, and kept alive by people with an excellent motive for not wanting to have their own behaviour examined too closely, is just that: a rumour. Not even a very coherent one, certainly not cogent.

I do slightly despair of people who assume that the Queen is a psychopathic monster on no evidence whatever, though. Also those who think that if MI5/Prince Philip's friends/whoever had decided to kill her off before she sank herself without a trace, as she was going the right way about doing, would have made such a shoddy job of offing her: they would have had to be amateurs at a Danger Mouse level to come so close to failure. Oh, and that two French hospitals, the French legal system and all the medics at the scene would have been bought off in advance, and kept their silence for all this time.

HikingforScenery · 01/02/2022 16:26

I don’t think she was murdered but I’m not convinced it’s impossible.

History has shown that there were plots/plans behind some situations that were thought to be coincidences at the time.

Hobbesmanc · 01/02/2022 15:42

Bonkers- there is no credible narrative that doesn't conclude that a drunk driver, a high speed journey, a badly lit tunnel led to the very sad death of a mother and two other men.

If any royal scandal would have resulted in assassination surely they'd have bumped off Wallis. She was much more dangerous.

LovedayCL · 01/02/2022 15:26

@alittleje

Unless you have insider knowledge, which I very much doubt, IMO it’s despicable to suggest that the Queen was ‘relieved’ that two young grandsons were left without their mother

meh in an ideal world yes but people are complex, I think if Markle were to die the Queen would also breathe an inner sigh of relief today.

I thought I couldn’t be surprised by the awful things people say now, but you’ve managed it.
StarbucksSmarterSister · 01/02/2022 12:05

I think if Markle were to die the Queen would also breathe an inner sigh of relief today

Really? Leaving her grandson devastated and 2 very small children without a mother? I know the Royals are odd but I don't think HMQ is that odd.

alittleje · 31/01/2022 22:08

I can't help wondering though what happened to the lone survivor who barely commented before apparently dropping off the face of the earth despite having the story to dine out on until the end of time

he got married after to a teacher and had kids. I saw him in a few interviews and saw him recently popped up in the Sun in a pic of him walking with his family. The reason he didn't say much after the crash is because he remembers nothing of it due to the head injury.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 31/01/2022 21:43

Changed his name, living in Shropshire, working as a security advisor, playing a bit of rugby...

Reconstructing his face took over a hundred bits of titanium to replace the shattered bits of bone, and they kept him in a coma for ten days while they did it.

He did write a book after Fayed started accusing him of everything under the sun that Philip didn't arrange, just to put the record straight as he saw it. All the money from it went to defending himself from Fayed's lawsuits against him (none of which succeeded; makes one think of Trump, somehow).

CathyorClaire · 31/01/2022 21:32

But it increasingly negative coverage, she was being criticised for her lifestyle

Absolutely this. People were pig sick of her cavorting round Europe on a playboy's yacht.

Her death was a combination of unlucky circumstances. I'm not a royalist (!) but even I don't think the royals planned it or could have carried it off without someone flapping their gums before now. I do agree they might well have been relieved to have a tidy ending to what was fast becoming a soap.

I can't help wondering though what happened to the lone survivor who barely commented before apparently dropping off the face of the earth despite having the story to dine out on until the end of time.

alittleje · 31/01/2022 20:28

Unless you have insider knowledge, which I very much doubt, IMO it’s despicable to suggest that the Queen was ‘relieved’ that two young grandsons were left without their mother

meh in an ideal world yes but people are complex, I think if Markle were to die the Queen would also breathe an inner sigh of relief today.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 31/01/2022 20:24

@makkapacca

i think the queen gave an internal sigh of relief and the royals in general as she was a loose cannon especially after the panorama interview. Her death was therefore convenient but I still think it was an accident. She was under a shoddy security team.
Unless you have insider knowledge, which I very much doubt, IMO it’s despicable to suggest that the Queen was ‘relieved’ that two young grandsons were left without their mother.
TurquoiseDragon · 31/01/2022 20:17

@makkapacca

Oh bless you, no, it’s really not. This is why people fall for it. Such naivety

ok so you you suggesting along with your condescending that a few posters make up 1000s of accounts merely to make a point?

Bots are also programmable to "like" posts. I wouldn't know how to do it, but I have a colleague who reckons it''s easy enough.
TurquoiseDragon · 31/01/2022 20:12

@SantaHat

Even though James and Harry look nothing alike and not to mention the fact that she didn’t meet James Hewitt until a couple of years after Harry was born (but as many have said, why let the facts get in the way of a trashy story).
Not to mention that if she had been pregnant with James' baby, there'd have been a quiet abortion, no announcement, etc.
alittleje · 31/01/2022 19:57

I wouldn’t have thought it was common at all

I would say it is very common. Sure look at all the conspiracies with covid and I know plenty of people who hang on its every word. Even think of the deaths of big icons like Grace Kelly and Marilyn Monroe- many people don't think they were accidents or are what we are told, Grace Kelly's death is surrounded by conspiracy. I would also say many people think the husband murdered Natalie Wood although that 1 in fairness is a mysterious case.
I would also say that many, if not the majority, of people think there is alot more to 9 11 than was revealed.

alittleje · 31/01/2022 19:51

Much as I am no royalist I honestly don't think that the family would have 'heaved a sigh of relif ' at her death, Diana was a mother and I think the Queen would never have wanted her grandsons to go through the grief of losing her. Yes Diana was a loose cannon and a pain in the arse for them but wanting her dead? Nah

meh whilst I don't think was murdered I would say her death was bloody convenient to them. Whilst the queen and Charles might have not wanted the boys to go without a mother I think they would have had relief at some level that she was out of the way. God knows what she was going to reveal next or do to go against their traditional values.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 31/01/2022 11:17

I wouldn’t have thought it was common at all.
But some people thrive on conspiracy theories, especially if they involve Dastardly Deeds by the Forces of Evil, i.e MI5/6, politicians, big pharma, anyone very rich, the Royal Family, very senior police, etc. All obviously in fiendish league together.

The sad fact is, if Diana had been wearing a seatbelt, she’d probably be here today.

UniversalAunt · 31/01/2022 11:00

Ooops @SomeOwlsCoo for a moment I thought you were talking about one of Diana’s sons…

UniversalAunt · 31/01/2022 10:54

Understandably, people account for discrepancies in the narrative…

‘ Lots of detail (one of the many snippets were a video of the driver tieing his shoelace before he drove off. The speaker made us get up and stoop down to tie our laces, not easy when sober, apparently the driver was alleged to be drunk, but video showed him tieing his laces perfectly. ‘

My understanding is that the driver had a high blood alcohol level, & as he was an habituated heavy drinker he may not have been or seen to be drunk & still be capable of functioning within the range of normal hand co-ordination. He was not socially eased like the audience or rolling drunk, he was a functioning heavy drinker/alcoholic.Many heavy drinkers or alcoholics manage fine hand motion tasks all the time. Otherwise, badly tied shoelaces or slip on shoes might be a easy give away for alcoholics…

As we know, anything that affects brain function (e.g. alcohol, prescription or recreational drugs, distractions talking on mobile phones) impairs the capacity to drive a car or operate heavy machinery.
It takes a small amount of alcohol to affect driving skill & judgement - this may not correlate to how much is needed to impair finer motor skills or appear to be under the influence.

Driver under influence of recent alcohol intake, driving at high speed into difficult to navigate confined space, passengers not wearing seat belts - makes for an everyday road traffic accident that happens all too often.

Maybe it is too difficult to accept that an iconic figure like Diana could have such a mundane death. That she was flawed in her judgement, imperfect & as mortal as the rest of us?

thebabessavedme · 31/01/2022 10:46

Much as I am no royalist I honestly don't think that the family would have 'heaved a sigh of relif ' at her death, Diana was a mother and I think the Queen would never have wanted her grandsons to go through the grief of losing her. Yes Diana was a loose cannon and a pain in the arse for them but wanting her dead? Nah.

DePfeffoff · 31/01/2022 10:11

@VladmirsPoutine

I think given that the death seems so 'accidental' i.e. the driver was drunk and she wasn't wearing a seatbelt therefore people think any conspiracy is absolutely crazy. So in other words nobody would suspect it of being organised because of the way it looks. Because if there was anything a little bit hidden about it they knew that these rumours would chase them for years.
But then rumours have chased them - which was entirely predictable. So no-one in their right minds would ever use this as a means of assassination when so many foolproof methods are available.
Stookeen · 30/01/2022 21:13

@JudgeJ, are you suggesting we don’t hold the state forces of democratic nations to higher standards than paramilitaries?