Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for my money back and end this friendship

139 replies

KeeG8181 · 29/01/2022 16:36

Hi everyone.

Last January I lent a "friend" a substantial amount of money that I had saved up. They claimed to be going through financial abuse at the time and needed help getting away. Going through that myself I wanted to help and my head was all over the place. She repaid £100, whilst being "financially abused" she has managed to live off Domino's pizza and afford nice clothes and shoes on a weekly basis. But has never once offered to pay back what she owes me.

This "friend" left in November, she has paid to have her new home professionally decorated, alongside sky TV, endless amounts of clothes and shoes, piercings and tattoos, £1000 laptops and phones. I haven't been offered a penny back.

She messaged me today informing me that once she gets her student loan in September she's buying a car. I haven't replied. I'm so hurt that she couldn't even be bothered to pay back even a fiver a week but I'm worried I've left it too late.

I don't wanna continue a one sided friendship anyway but I haven't got much confidence myself and I'm not very forthcoming so I have no idea how to ask for it back.

OP posts:
EmmaGrundyForPM · 29/01/2022 17:47

She's not a friend.
Ask for the money back.

KeeG8181 · 29/01/2022 17:47

I do actually have a paper trail of this being a loan! It was £1850.

She paid me once in February and that was it.
I kept asking and she said she was doing it. Then started with the "he's took all my money" crap so I felt bad. She offered to pay it once she's "on her feet" but she's never been off them.

OP posts:
BluebellsGreenbells · 29/01/2022 17:46

Funny how these people are always free with others money. Friend owes me £50 - will be payday I’m sure - but she’s brought the kids a lot of stuff, lid for her nails to be done and cut and colour on her hair.

People just don’t think.

billy1966 · 29/01/2022 17:44

How much money OP?

1,000 is substantial to some people?

5,000?

10,000?

How much will inform answers.

ClaymationHeartsStillBeat · 29/01/2022 17:43

I think the small claims court is full of cases of friends lending money to friends (aka grifters).

Do you have proof of bank transfer?
How much was it? Hopefully under the amount dealt with by a small claims court.

It's going to be very hard to not get her back up with a text. I would suggest meeting her for coffee. When she starts talking about her circumstances then bring it up. The chances are she is not an idiot and will be aware that you are meeting her for this reason so be prepared for her to claim poverty. Nevertheless stand your ground. Tell her you need the money. If needs be spin the same lines that she gave you. As suggested above, mention the boiler etc. It is your money. Do not wave goodbye to it.

Yuckypretty · 29/01/2022 17:37

I would keep her sweet until you get your money back. She sounds like the sort that won't give you the money back if you fall out.

I'd just text something like." Hi, how are you? Please let me know when you are going to pay me back the £x you owe me. I could do with it back by £x."

sansucre · 29/01/2022 17:37

To those who are saying to do this face to face, not file a claim etc, it doesn't work. If someone doesn't want to pay back a loan, they won't do it, so there's no point treading softly softly around them. I know this from experience having tried every nice way I could think of to get my (ex) friend to repay me. We had a contract and a deadline for the loan to be repaid. She repeatedly promised me to start making repayments numerous times and no money ever materialised. Sometimes, you have to take definitive action.

MaudieandMe · 29/01/2022 17:37

A substantial amount? You really can’t let this go due to feeling a bit awkward.

Initially, I’d message her using the wording that other posters have suggested and get her to acknowledge the loan amount and that she still intends to replay you. Doesn’t matter if her reply is full of excuses at this stage. You need her to admit that she accepted the money on a loan basis to be repaid when she was no longer living with her ex partner.

Then take her to the small claims court if she doesn’t make good on the repayments. Your friendship is already toast by the sounds of it.

HeartTerriers · 29/01/2022 17:35

I'd text back 'I need the money I lent you back please. I was saving to X'.

NoSquirrels · 29/01/2022 17:35

How much does she owe you?
Did you have an agreement on repayments?
Do you have a paper trail?

And crucially - when did you last ask her to start paying you back?

sansucre · 29/01/2022 17:34

I've been in your position albeit with paperwork and a signed loan agreement. The friend is no longer my friend and I have had to take her to court to recover the debt. As this has been going on for 6 years now, she is having to pay statutory interest on the loan which is almost 50% of the loan's value. Despite the judgement ruling in my favour, I am resigned to never seeing this money again

Do not be like me and allow it to carry on for years. Now is the time to tell her that she needs to start to repay this money either in its entirety, or in regular monthly repayments. If she ignores this, file in the small claims court. Do it ASAP.

As an aside, she clearly is not your friend, so do not even bother to mourn any loss of friendship.

skybluee · 29/01/2022 17:33

TBH I'd actually do it face to face as I think you're more likely to have success that way.

skybluee · 29/01/2022 17:32

Lots of these options are going to end up massively getting her back up resulting in her possibly not paying you. Why threaten someone with court? I'd just keep it casual and text her 'Hey, how are you? Would you be able to pay me back some of the money I lent you? I'm really struggling right now. Hope all's well'. See what happens. If you haven't asked for it back it's pointless going in all guns blazing before simply asking politely. If you start talking about payment plans you may scare her off.

I hope you get your money back.

Sockpile · 29/01/2022 17:32

It really doesn’t sound like she’ll offer it back. I agree with the PPs about suggesting a repayment schedule now she’s financially more secure (able to spend money buying a new car)

treesandweeds · 29/01/2022 17:28

When are you going to text then?!

IncompleteSenten · 29/01/2022 17:20

Agree with pp.
The friendship is not salvageable now.

At least you can try to get your money back.

just a glad to hear things are better. When will you repay me the £X you borrowed?

Good luck.

Chakraleaf · 29/01/2022 17:14

@IwishICouldTurnBackTime

Tell her if she doesn't start to repay you, you'll take her to the small claims court. I did this, they starting repaying me, although I never did get the full amount back, but better than nothing.

Just google small claims court, it takes you to the gov.uk site. The fees are on a sliding scale, but are not excessive.

Sometimes you just have to get tough with people who disrespect you like this, no matter how hard it is. She obviously thinks you're an easy target, who she can then fob off. Show her she can't. Good luck!

Agree get a formal letter drawn up
IwishICouldTurnBackTime · 29/01/2022 17:13

Tell her if she doesn't start to repay you, you'll take her to the small claims court. I did this, they starting repaying me, although I never did get the full amount back, but better than nothing.

Just google small claims court, it takes you to the gov.uk site. The fees are on a sliding scale, but are not excessive.

Sometimes you just have to get tough with people who disrespect you like this, no matter how hard it is. She obviously thinks you're an easy target, who she can then fob off. Show her she can't. Good luck!

earsup · 29/01/2022 17:05

To add...where is she getting the money from for this spending spree...is it all credit and loans or does she actually have money..??

earsup · 29/01/2022 17:03

I once lent a friend only 100...said she didnt have money to buy food etc as working pt etc....her life was always chaos and had 4 vehicles and a spoilt son....she bought him a real Gucci belt a few weeks later...i blocked her etc as that was the last straw in her needy and selfish behaviour..no loss....dreaded seeing her anyway due to the needy rants....hope it wasnt too much money you lent...pop note thro door maybe...keep a copy...

CoraPirbright · 29/01/2022 17:02

Agree with WhiteXmas21. She is being a CF and you really don't have anything to lose. She might respond to a super-nice message rather than go on the offensive so how about something like : “oh that is such wonderful news. I am so so happy for you that you have really come out of the other end of your awful time with . So delighted that I could help you out at the time! Now, how would you like to pay back the £xxx I lent you? If not all in one go (which I totally get) how about £xxx per month? Then it will be all cleared by x time and we can go out and celebrate your wonderful new life”.

Teaforme123 · 29/01/2022 17:02

Say ' Hi. Glad to hear you are getting a car. Please remember that you owe me x amount. Installments of x monthly would be great if easier. Happy to wait for your loan to come in.'

Please keep records/screenshots of all messages and have evidence of her owing /acknowledging she owes you money because you can go to the small claims court if necessary. Don't let her take the piss, been there myself, it's awkward and horrible but don't be taken for a mug.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 29/01/2022 17:02

Why haven’t you asked her?
Why don’t you ask her?

It isn’t too late and you would be mad to end the friendship without even asking… because I’m asking, what do you have to lose but the friendship?

In response to the car message reply “sounds great but before you splash out in the car, don’t forget the £xxx I lent you! I really need it back ASAP so can you let me know when you can return it? Instalments starting now will be ok if that’s easier? “.

runsmidgeOMG · 29/01/2022 16:57

Oh OP, I hate how money often comes between friends (not your fault!) sadly it is an expensive lesson and lending to friends is always underwritten as "could I afford to loose this money?"
I agree with the message PP wrote... I'm glad you're back on your feet, could we discuss a payment plan for the ££ I leant you ? Etc...

If she's anyway nasty, defensive or says no she's not your friend.
I'm sorry ! Thanks

Pleaseuniverseplease · 29/01/2022 16:54

You've got nothing at all to lose by asking her when she plans to pay you back.
At the very least you'll be gaining some self respect, sticking up for yourself showing her you're no doormat.
I wouldn't expect getting all the money but you may get a bit of it back.
If she cuts ties you're not losing a friendship either as a true friend wouldn't treat you as she is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread