Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think titanic movie is cringy

236 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 16:28

Came out when I was 12 and I loved it but at 36 caught it on tv last night and it is so cringy. Whilst I think Winslet and Leo are great actors their acting in it is cringe although I don't know if it's their inexperience or just the script. Every 2nd line is 'Jack Rose'. I don't get how both were nominated for Oscars for it when it genuinely wasn't good acting by any means on either part and again I think both are genuinely brilliant in their other films.

Watching it is reminiscent of watching 90s Home and Away or just bad teenage tv acting. Yea the effects are great but the script in itself is just so mediocre and so 12 year old girl stuff. It didn't occur to me how little the film actually go into the subject matter of the Titanic like the creation of it and the aftermath of the sinking etc.

The rich in it like Cal and Rose's mum are so 1 dimensional greedy villains which is kind of hypocritical considering how wealthy Cameron himself is, and the poor Irish on 3rd class are just laughably bad and cliche with accents Irish people never have. And I say that as an Irish person myself so no racism.

A critic said after that the only reason it got oscar noms was because of the money it gained and I sort of agree. Again the effects and cinematography were great but the film itself was just a predictable cringe fest.

OP posts:
veevee04 · 29/01/2022 19:19

I was 7 when I first watched it and Leo was my first crush still my favourite movie got upset when DD started laughing at it AngryGrin

DrSbaitso · 29/01/2022 19:16

People weren't as used to "epic" films as they are now (for want of a better word for all those special effects and so on). It struck a number of chords back then that we are more used to hearing now.

Time is a great tester and I don't think it's generally considered a shit film now, but nobody truly has it up there with Citizen Kane, The Godfather or Casablanca. It was zeitgeisty at the time and it's remembered as such.

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 19:11

To all those saying it wasn't lauded as royalty./ See below and you will see it was and compared to gone with the wind.

With regard to the film's overall design, Roger Ebert stated, "It is flawlessly crafted, intelligently constructed, strongly acted, and spellbinding... Movies like this are not merely difficult to make at all, but almost impossible to make well." He credited the "technical difficulties" with being "so daunting that it's a wonder when the filmmakers are also able to bring the drama and history into proportion" and "found [himself] convinced by both the story and the sad saga".[124] He named it his ninth best film of 1997.[125] On the television program Siskel & Ebert, the film received "two thumbs up" and was praised for its accuracy in recreating the ship's sinking; Ebert described the film as "a glorious Hollywood epic" and "well worth the wait," and Gene Siskel found Leonardo DiCaprio "captivating".[126] James Berardinelli stated, "Meticulous in detail, yet vast in scope and intent, Titanic is the kind of epic motion picture event that has become a rarity. You don't just watch Titanic, you experience it."[127] It was named his second best film of 1997.[128] Joseph McBride of Boxoffice Magazine concluded, "To describe Titanic as the greatest disaster movie ever made is to sell it short. James Cameron's recreation of the 1912 sinking of the 'unsinkable' liner is one of the most magnificent pieces of serious popular entertainment ever to emanate from Hollywood."[129]

The romantic and emotionally charged aspects of the film were equally praised. Andrew L. Urban of Urban Cinefile said, "You will walk out of Titanic not talking about budget or running time, but of its enormous emotive power, big as the engines of the ship itself, determined as its giant propellers to gouge into your heart, and as lasting as the love story that propels it."[130] Owen Gleiberman of Entertainment Weekly described the film as "a lush and terrifying spectacle of romantic doom. Writer-director James Cameron has restaged the defining catastrophe of the early 20th century on a human scale of such purified yearning and dread that he touches the deepest levels of popular moviemaking."[129] Janet Maslin of The New York Times commented that "Cameron's magnificent Titanic is the first spectacle in decades that honestly invites comparison to Gone With the Wind."[129] Adrian Turner of Radio Times awarded it four stars out of five, stating "Cameron's script wouldn't have sustained Clark Gable and Vivien Leigh for 80 minutes, but, somehow, he and his magical cast revive that old-style studio gloss for three riveting hours. Titanic is a sumptuous assault on the emotions, with a final hour that fully captures the horror and the freezing, paralysing fear of the moment. And there are single shots, such as an awesome albatross-like swoop past the steaming ship, when you sense Cameron hugging himself with the fun of it all."[131]

OP posts:
Timeyime · 29/01/2022 18:50

Actually you do have a point about the reviews.

Obviously the script/story is terrible: as you say it's just "JACK!" runs around a bit "ROSE!" runs around a bit "I'll never let you go"

I think what happened is that the studio punted a load of money on it and then were so relieved and thrilled it made even more that they rewarded him with all the Oscars. Plus ofc once it won the Oscars yet more money would come in. You know like betting on good form.

Even at the time no one compared it to citizen Kane.

GirlInACountrySong · 29/01/2022 18:48

it was thought to be a bit ott and 'cringe' when it came out op!!

i'm old now...i remember it well...despite it getting oscars!

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 18:38

Lots of shit films get nominated for Oscars, that doesn't mean they're held in esteem by critics

look at the reviews at time of release, they were generally universally favourable and positive across the board.

OP posts:
ApresGoldRush · 29/01/2022 18:36

I really did not enjoy it much when I saw it at the time, just too many cliches, and of course knowing in advance what happens in the end :)

DamsonJammyBastard · 29/01/2022 18:36

Lots of shit films get nominated for Oscars, that doesn't mean they're held in esteem by critics. The Oscars is a political game where a lot of backscratching and 'persuasion' goes on. And it's America, of course they're going to applaud something that breaks all box office records.

But no one speaks of Titanic and Citizen Kane in the same breath.

skybluee · 29/01/2022 18:34

I didn't like it. When I laughed at one part my friend slapped me in the face in the cinema.

Suzanne999 · 29/01/2022 18:33

I never understood why it won so many awards as I thought it was shite when it came out & it’s not going to improve with age.

Player20868 · 29/01/2022 18:33

I thought the costumes and sets were amazing, and the recreation of the ship itself was impressive, plus the music was enjoyable (though My Heart Will Go On is definitely in the same bracket as Everything I Do from Robin Hood for me, as in it spent WAY too much time being played everywhere).

Other than that, lots of the script was beyond irritating, and it was packed with cliches and lazy storytelling. It also really irritated me that so many genuinely moving stories from the event were ignored in favour of a "pretty people's love story". (Although I do think Kate Winslet in particular is excellent and went on to do some brilliant work after this movie.)

I saw it when I was in my late 20s, I might have found it easier to cope with if I'd been a bit younger and not been quite so harsh; now I'm a lot older, I'd probably just regard it as just another film milestone in terms of costuming and effects.

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 18:31

But I've never heard anyone make the comparison

the film broke records for the amount of Oscars it got nominated for AND win

OP posts:
Butchyrestingface · 29/01/2022 18:29

i know that but my point was exactly that-that the film was an inflated special effects piece of teenage melodrama with no depth and yet it gets classed with the likes of Citizen Kane in its greatness when it's bloody not

I thought Citizen Kane was shite.

But I've never heard anyone make the comparison.

TrashyPanda · 29/01/2022 18:26

Saw it in the cinema when it came out and was bored rigid.
ExH kept muttering “hurry up and die” and I had to agree with him.
Hugely overrated at the time.
Never in any list of great films though. A bit like the film of Les Mis, which was lauded at the time. I hated it (love the stage show). And now it has just quietly disappeared.

Hohofortherobbers · 29/01/2022 18:22

I loved it at the time, and I enjoyed rewatching it recently with my 10 yo dd. YANBU to not like it, I guess I must be one of the masses it was aimed at Grin

inheritancetrack · 29/01/2022 18:21

There was enough of the historic facts and the grandeur and tragedy that I could ignore the boring love story. I don't like love stories at the best of times, but the sheer magnificance of the story was more than enough to make up for it. And the music was just amazing.

TrufflyPig · 29/01/2022 18:20

It is but I still love it!! We are the same age OP.

DrSbaitso · 29/01/2022 18:19

yet it gets classed with the likes of Citizen Kane in its greatness

Does it?

ClaymationHeartsStillBeat · 29/01/2022 18:17

tbh, I've seen a cumulative 10 minutes of this film. Based on that, YANBU.

DamsonJammyBastard · 29/01/2022 18:16

it gets classed with the likes of Citizen Kane in its greatness

Are you high?

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 18:15

It was thought so at the time as well though wasn’t it

no films like that are usually given rassies,this topped oscar season.

OP posts:
Davros · 29/01/2022 18:14

It was shite then and it's shite now. We saw it at the cinema and people laughed out loud in a number of places

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 18:14

It was a commercial exercise - the point of the film was to make as much money as possible. Not to render a scientific examination of events

i know that but my point was exactly that-that the film was an inflated special effects piece of teenage melodrama with no depth and yet it gets classed with the likes of Citizen Kane in its greatness when it's bloody not.

OP posts:
draramallama · 29/01/2022 17:46

It didn't occur to me how little the film actually go into the subject matter of the Titanic like the creation of it and the aftermath of the sinking etc.

It was a commercial exercise - the point of the film was to make as much money as possible. Not to render a scientific examination of events.

Same goes for all the industry awards. It's about money, connections and reputation not an objective rewards process.

eddiemairswife · 29/01/2022 17:42

It was far, far too long and didn't arouse any emotion (apart from boredom) in me whatsoever. Whereas 'A Night to Remember' was genuinely moving.