Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think titanic movie is cringy

236 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 16:28

Came out when I was 12 and I loved it but at 36 caught it on tv last night and it is so cringy. Whilst I think Winslet and Leo are great actors their acting in it is cringe although I don't know if it's their inexperience or just the script. Every 2nd line is 'Jack Rose'. I don't get how both were nominated for Oscars for it when it genuinely wasn't good acting by any means on either part and again I think both are genuinely brilliant in their other films.

Watching it is reminiscent of watching 90s Home and Away or just bad teenage tv acting. Yea the effects are great but the script in itself is just so mediocre and so 12 year old girl stuff. It didn't occur to me how little the film actually go into the subject matter of the Titanic like the creation of it and the aftermath of the sinking etc.

The rich in it like Cal and Rose's mum are so 1 dimensional greedy villains which is kind of hypocritical considering how wealthy Cameron himself is, and the poor Irish on 3rd class are just laughably bad and cliche with accents Irish people never have. And I say that as an Irish person myself so no racism.

A critic said after that the only reason it got oscar noms was because of the money it gained and I sort of agree. Again the effects and cinematography were great but the film itself was just a predictable cringe fest.

OP posts:
Fenella2000 · 30/01/2022 12:39

@makkapacca

100%, Titanic is no sillier than the Terminator films (which are by the same filmmaker, are equally unsubtle, and also feature a love story between people who’ve known each other a couple of days) but it’s seen as silly and pathetic because teenage girls like it

T1 and 2 are on totally different levels to titanic, the scripts were generally complex and interesting. Titanic's was like Saturday morning teen sop opera on Nickledon, huge difference.

I LOVE the Terminator films, but neither the characters nor the premise are “complex”! James Cameron is a very unsubtle filmmaker and he’s GOOD at being unsubtle, which is a real skill.

T1 is quite similar to Titanic, if you think about it. Woman has noble qualities she doesn’t quite recognise, is living a life that doesn’t utilise them. She meets a man who has an absolute, totalising love for her, sees the very best in her, helps her survive terrifying disasters and then dies at the end - giving his life for hers. The woman is changed forever by the experience and vows to live her life every day to honour her departed love.

TatianaBis · 30/01/2022 12:39

Titanic and Love Actually are two of the most cringe films ever made. Plus Mama Mia.

TatianaBis · 30/01/2022 12:38

Romeo and Juliet - fluff - really?

Bbq1 · 30/01/2022 12:34

I loved Titanic then and I still do today.
There's a lot of people on here giving a lot of time to a film they dislike. Why bother? For example, I think Love Actually is utter tripe but millions of people rave about it. I couldn't be bothered giving an extended rant about how rubbish it is because tbh, everything is down to personal taste and opinion.

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 12:28

100%, Titanic is no sillier than the Terminator films (which are by the same filmmaker, are equally unsubtle, and also feature a love story between people who’ve known each other a couple of days) but it’s seen as silly and pathetic because teenage girls like it

T1 and 2 are on totally different levels to titanic, the scripts were generally complex and interesting. Titanic's was like Saturday morning teen sop opera on Nickledon, huge difference.

OP posts:
makkapacca · 30/01/2022 12:25

I took so much shit for years. It only stopped when Leo fell back into favour, after Inception, and Shutter Island came out, (both 2010,) and Leo became hugely popular again.. (And still is...)

leo never fell out of favour with the masses though,he was always pretty much universally loved. Yes he did fluff like titanic and r and j which were aimed at teenage girl audience yet he had plenty of big universally loved hits like catch me if you can, the departed and gangs of new york many years before inception.

OP posts:
CaptainThe95thRifles · 30/01/2022 12:18

I thought it was shite when I was 12 and I remain of the same conviction now. I wasn't a cool kid though, the cool kids at my school liked it. I have no interest in Di Caprio now either. I quite liked a bit of Home and Away in that era though Grin

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/01/2022 12:17

Never seen it: the song put me right off Grin

HufflepuffPride · 30/01/2022 12:15

See I don’t remember the cool girls not liking it. I was 15 when it came out and all of my peers were obsessed with it, everyone around me was. Even the cool girls (and I definitely wasn’t one of those!).

HelloFrostyMorning · 30/01/2022 11:51

@Fenella2000

Ugh. I saw it at 12 and was deeply, deeply moved but all the Cool Girls in my class insisted it was shit. “I’m a strong woman who’s going to have a career, I’m not going to cry at silly romantic films”.

Now 36 and I still think it’s a wonderful film and still cry my eyes out. You can all shove it 🤣 The podcast You Are Good did a lovely episode on it recently and host Sarah Marshall has written about it before - www.buzzfeednews.com/article/sarahmarshall/20-years-ago-titanic-took-over-the-world-heres-why

Gone With The Wind is similarly a romantic melodrama, I don’t understand why it’s supposed to be more “highbrow”.

@HufflepuffPride

What is it with posters on Mumsnet saying how much they hate popular films and pointing out all that’s wrong with them? Is it an attempt to look cool and edgy? Well I still like Titanic and I still like Home Alone as well.

As for you who watched it and laughed, well you do realise that really happened and nearly 2,000 people died? But never mind you are so cool and edgy aren’t you 🙄

This annoys me too. It's not just 'yeah I'm not a fan' it's the sneery put downs and mocking of anyone who likes them. The deep rooted snobbery and sneering, that is what fucks me off.

I got verbally bashed and beaten ceremoniously in the late 1990s and early noughties by people who thought they were better than me, because I loved Titanic, had a collection of memorabilia on it, and became a huge Leo fan, (and also a fan of Kate.) I have been a fan of both of them ever since.

I was ripped apart by all the 'cool girls' who only liked art house, Avant Garde, indie films, and thought I was thick and stupid and very immature because I liked Titanic. The Leo bashers told me how shit he was, how he couldn't act for toffee, how The Beach was the wankiest film ever, (even worse than Titanic apparently,) and how much he looked like toddler. Hmm

I took so much shit for years. It only stopped when Leo fell back into favour, after Inception, and Shutter Island came out, (both 2010,) and Leo became hugely popular again.. (And still is...)

I have stayed a fan ever since Titanic, and weirdly, those same arseholes think Leo is a fucking God now. A legend, an icon, a brilliant actor, and fucking gorgeous. I do occasionally mention how they hated him, and mocked me some 2 decades ago, for liking him. They don't remember any of this strangely..... Hmm

Fenella2000 · 30/01/2022 11:49

@loveisanopensore

Sentimental Garbage did a great podcast about Titanic.

Highly praised on release, great action sequences but as soon as it took hold in teenage girls minds it began to be seen as silly.

100%, Titanic is no sillier than the Terminator films (which are by the same filmmaker, are equally unsubtle, and also feature a love story between people who’ve known each other a couple of days) but it’s seen as silly and pathetic because teenage girls like it.
ChardonnaysPetDragon · 30/01/2022 11:45

@HufflepuffPride

What is it with posters on Mumsnet saying how much they hate popular films and pointing out all that’s wrong with them? Is it an attempt to look cool and edgy? Well I still like Titanic and I still like Home Alone as well.

As for you who watched it and laughed, well you do realise that really happened and nearly 2,000 people died? But never mind you are so cool and edgy aren’t you 🙄

Well, it was bad film and if you want to get all hot under the collar about this, then why don't you get upset with the people who made it this bad and exploitative and who released it to make tons of money from a disaster that cost 2,000 their lives.

You are barking up the wrong tree here.

illbeinthegarden · 30/01/2022 11:42

I was 19 when it came out, saw it 3 times at the cinema and preordered the vhs when it came out (on two tapes as it was so long) 😂

Watched it a couple of weeks ago and hated it.... I wont watch it again. I think at 19 I really thought relationships were all about a love story etc etc and life soon knocked that outta me!

Timeyime · 30/01/2022 11:40

Of course 36 is middle aged! It's halfway to 72, which is two years past your three score and ten.

HelloFrostyMorning · 30/01/2022 11:40

As @Nietzschethehiker said, you can dislike a film without mocking and bashing those who likes it. It just makes you look incredibly small minded and immature.

I think The Godfather films are an overrated pile of crap, but I don't bash the people who enjoy them, and think they're amazing.

HelloFrostyMorning · 30/01/2022 11:38

@Nietzschethehiker

I genuinely do not understand why people like the OP can't just not like something without trying to insist that it's objectively bad. You don't like it now as an adult , so?

It's not really my thing either but why on earth do you need to spend so much effort denigrating it in order to try to get an objective agreement to validate your personal dislike.

You don't like it now and disagree with the reviews. Other people like it. You in fact do not need other people to validate your dislike.

This. ^ It's pathetic.
HelloFrostyMorning · 30/01/2022 11:36

[quote tackling]**@HelloFrostyMorning GrinGrinGrin

@Winniemarysarah oh dear, could you really not even remotely guess what I meant about a movie I watched a good 25 years ago where one of the main characters dies in the water??

I actually love the Godfather young Al Pacino what's not to like[/quote]
@HelloFrostyMorning

Pedant alert from* @Winniemarysarah *You know she meant JACK. Yeah we all know he froze to death, and Rose snapped his fingers off the big door and pushed his frozen dead carcus deep into the sea.

@PurpleThursdays

I don't know why this is making me laugh... 😂

Grin

@tackling

@HelloFrostyMorning Grin Grin Grin

LOL Grin I did actually read that back this morning!

DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 11:33

@loveisanopensore

Sentimental Garbage did a great podcast about Titanic.

Highly praised on release, great action sequences but as soon as it took hold in teenage girls minds it began to be seen as silly.

Excellent point.
loveisanopensore · 30/01/2022 11:32

Sentimental Garbage did a great podcast about Titanic.

Highly praised on release, great action sequences but as soon as it took hold in teenage girls minds it began to be seen as silly.

Pootlepoodle · 30/01/2022 11:12

Great example @Fenella2000 !

Ditto Sleepless in Seattle. Loved it when it came out, oh how romantic. Now I see that Annie is basically a stalker and if she wasn’t so pretty, he would have had an injunction taken out in her.

Fenella2000 · 30/01/2022 11:05

@Pootlepoodle

It’s a bit like Wuthering Heights. I absolutely LOVED it aged 13, the passion and drama of it all completely blew me away.

As an adult I see it for what it is: a story of 2 hormonal, self obsessed teenagers making a hash of their lives in the name of “love”.

But do I remember how first love felt all consumingly life or death? Absolutely I do and respect it for the rite of passage it is.

Titanic does capture that purity of first love, in part due to the unmistakable chemistry between Winslet and DiCaprio and I think that’s a big reason why it was generally well received by critics and hugely successful with the audience of the time.

Yeah.

I saw Last Tango In Paris at 19 and was incredibly aroused by it “ooh, they have such a complicated and fucked up relationship but part of it is a raw human connection”.

Then watched it with a friend in our 30s (who had never seen it before) and she just found it disturbing/exploitative. So these things can depend on the age at which you watch them and how much you identify with the emotional journey (from the characters’ point of view).

Fenella2000 · 30/01/2022 10:59

@HoppingPavlova

Gone With The Wind is similarly a romantic melodrama, I don’t understand why it’s supposed to be more “highbrow”.

I don’t think GWTW is highbrow but it was watchable. I think manly due to the characters as Scarlet and Rhett had some depth to them plus the supporting cast had their own interesting side stories. Rose and Jack were dull as dishwater. The plot consisted of them bleating each other’s names. Couldn’t wait for the boat to sink. Never watched it again.

Ok I will admit that GWTW has more depth and complexity. Fine.

James Cameron-created characters are pretty one-note in general (if Terminators 1&2 are anything to go by) but boy do they evoke the emotional experience of that note, and pull you along for the ride. If you ask me anyway!

Also Titanic does spend a LOT of time evoking the experience of the sinking ship, and portraying how differently people react to it. I also think it’s unfair to say the villains are entirely one-dimensional; they have humanising moments (Cal putting the coat back on Rose / Rose’s mum revealing her fears of having to work as a seamstress) and seem pretty realistic to me (i.e. there are plenty of people in the world like that).

Pootlepoodle · 30/01/2022 10:56

That all said, Rose could’ve tried a bit harder to share the door with Jack!

DaggerIsle · 30/01/2022 10:55

I saw it age 22 at the cinema.
I remember being utterly bored at the love story (the sex in the car scene was embarrassing) and annoyed that it distracted from the 'real' story.
I was genuinely moved by the little touches (lost family using their dictionary to find their way to safety, old couple in bed, musicians etc)

As far as Rose and Jack? Terribly miscast as a couple and when she was holding on to him on that bloody door I kept wishing she would push him off and put him out of his misery.

Pootlepoodle · 30/01/2022 10:55

It’s a bit like Wuthering Heights. I absolutely LOVED it aged 13, the passion and drama of it all completely blew me away.

As an adult I see it for what it is: a story of 2 hormonal, self obsessed teenagers making a hash of their lives in the name of “love”.

But do I remember how first love felt all consumingly life or death? Absolutely I do and respect it for the rite of passage it is.

Titanic does capture that purity of first love, in part due to the unmistakable chemistry between Winslet and DiCaprio and I think that’s a big reason why it was generally well received by critics and hugely successful with the audience of the time.