Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think titanic movie is cringy

236 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 16:28

Came out when I was 12 and I loved it but at 36 caught it on tv last night and it is so cringy. Whilst I think Winslet and Leo are great actors their acting in it is cringe although I don't know if it's their inexperience or just the script. Every 2nd line is 'Jack Rose'. I don't get how both were nominated for Oscars for it when it genuinely wasn't good acting by any means on either part and again I think both are genuinely brilliant in their other films.

Watching it is reminiscent of watching 90s Home and Away or just bad teenage tv acting. Yea the effects are great but the script in itself is just so mediocre and so 12 year old girl stuff. It didn't occur to me how little the film actually go into the subject matter of the Titanic like the creation of it and the aftermath of the sinking etc.

The rich in it like Cal and Rose's mum are so 1 dimensional greedy villains which is kind of hypocritical considering how wealthy Cameron himself is, and the poor Irish on 3rd class are just laughably bad and cliche with accents Irish people never have. And I say that as an Irish person myself so no racism.

A critic said after that the only reason it got oscar noms was because of the money it gained and I sort of agree. Again the effects and cinematography were great but the film itself was just a predictable cringe fest.

OP posts:
HufflepuffPride · 30/01/2022 14:19

@TatianaBis

Titanic and Love Actually are two of the most cringe films ever made. Plus Mama Mia.
Oh I like Mama Mia as well!
DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 14:18

@makkapacca

I am not saying it was crap, i am saying it was a career move which at the time would have being selling the young leo to a teenage girl/younger women fanbase in the same way predator was selling arnie to a younger male demographic.
He had the perfect young romantic hero look, like Cary Elwes in The Princess Bride. I love Harrison Ford but I wouldn't have cast him as Jack. What, Kate Winslet wasn't appealing to the men? I remember the boys being dazzled by her. The casting required good looking young people, so what?
makkapacca · 30/01/2022 14:15

I am not saying it was crap, i am saying it was a career move which at the time would have being selling the young leo to a teenage girl/younger women fanbase in the same way predator was selling arnie to a younger male demographic.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 14:11

@makkapacca

And William Shakespeare wasn't writing teen flicks either. That script is still taught in schools and performed on stages now

it still doesn't make it any less of a chick flick in the same way emma or jane austen novels are. Yes Shakespeare wrote plays for the masses but r and j would have being predominantly aimed at the fairer sex.

Ok, Romeo and Juliet was aimed at women, even in 1597. Why does that mean it has to be crap, or mere "fluff"? And would you say that about it the next time the RSC performs it?
makkapacca · 30/01/2022 14:08

And William Shakespeare wasn't writing teen flicks either. That script is still taught in schools and performed on stages now

it still doesn't make it any less of a chick flick in the same way emma or jane austen novels are. Yes Shakespeare wrote plays for the masses but r and j would have being predominantly aimed at the fairer sex.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 13:51

I bet nobody saw Ian McKellen in the "modern day" (well, 1940s) film adaptation of Richard III and thought it was "fluff" just because they'd done something to make it a bit more relatable to the modern day. Personally I LOVE it when people put Shakespeare in modern settings, showing how the stories are still relevant. Plus ca change, after all.

And I thought Baz Luhrmann's R&J was a brilliant way of telling the story to a new generation. Doing it in a time when teen movies were popular was a great idea. Turning the Queen Mab speech into a drug reference was truly inspired. It really worked.

DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 13:45

@makkapacca

I took so much shit for years. It only stopped when Leo fell back into favour, after Inception, and Shutter Island came out, (both 2010,) and Leo became hugely popular again.. (And still is...)

leo never fell out of favour with the masses though,he was always pretty much universally loved. Yes he did fluff like titanic and r and j which were aimed at teenage girl audience yet he had plenty of big universally loved hits like catch me if you can, the departed and gangs of new york many years before inception.

Titanic wasn't intended for teenage girls. Its original audience was way more diverse than that and still is. It would never have got the reviews you hate so much otherwise. And William Shakespeare wasn't writing teen flicks either. That script is still taught in schools and performed on stages now. And Steven Spielberg has just released a remake of a famous musical based on it, to critical acclaim.

That PP was correct. Once something is enjoyed by teenage girls, people assume that's the only audience and it must be mindless crap for that reason alone.

Also, there was nothing wrong with the acting in Titanic. Di Caprio has always been a brilliant actor. So is Winslet and the rest of the cast...Billy Zane was terrifying.

I'm really starting to get the impression that it's your own 12 year old self you're trying to distance yourself from. Give the kid a break. She was 12.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 30/01/2022 13:29

And there was room on the door, the selfish cow.

There was, wasn't it? Well, not quite enough for waterpolo team for example, but still. She was clearly never taught to share when she was a toddler.

Sloughsabigplace · 30/01/2022 13:24

I used it as a learning tool for my ds when he started dating girls.

Jack was such a dick. Look at all the trouble
he got into and how many times he almost died and DID die for a girl he’d known for five minutes.

They would have got to New York, had a bust up over what colour curtains to buy and split up. He died for that.

And there was room on the door, the selfish cow.

Basically, I told ds don’t be a dick like Jack over a girl, no matter if she’s let you paint her in the nuddy.

PrincessNutella · 30/01/2022 13:19

I don't think you can go back with these things. It was on a big screen and one had not seen the Titanic portrayed the way it was then. Of course it was a ridiculous story. She threw the jewels back into the ocean! But it was also an emotionally hooking story. It worked. The special effects were excellent for the time. But now they definitely look cheesy on the small screen.

HelloFrostyMorning · 30/01/2022 13:19

@DearlyBeloathed

Well, it was bad film

In your opinion.

This exactly. I'm done on here. CBA with 'debating' with people who think that only THEIR opinion is correct. It's so small minded and ignorant, and very typical of some posters on mumsnet.

The ones who liked/loved Titanic are saying they loved it, it made them cry, it was wonderful, they still like it now, they thought it was an epic film etc etc. The ones who disliked/loathed it are making firm statements that is was bad/crap/shit/naff/cheesy/cringe etc etc...... Not in their opinion, but it just IS.

It shows a lack of critical thinking, a small mind, and general ignorance to just put your views as FACT.

As I said, I CBA to converse with people like this, I find them irksome, and tiring, and I don't want them to embarrass themselves any more.

So I'm done. I loved the film, and I thought it was wonderful, and I still do. Fuck what anyone else thinks.

DearlyBeloathed · 30/01/2022 13:09

Well, it was bad film

In your opinion.

HashtagSexy · 30/01/2022 13:04

"When this ship docks, I'm getting off with you."

😂😂😂😂

She'd just done that in the car!

CaveMum · 30/01/2022 13:01

I was 16 when it came out, saw it 4 times at the cinema and sobbed like the hormone-ravaged teen I was Grin

Agree the added storyline wasn’t great, but I guess they needed a “vehicle” to tell the story - it’s far easier to get people to care about the fate of two people than that of hundreds at once.

For me it did spark a lifelong interest in all things Titanic - I have several books on the subject and love to watch documentaries about it. It’s so sad to think that in the not too distant future the ship itself will totally collapse and disappear forever.

HelloFrostyMorning · 30/01/2022 13:00

@makkapacca

Why pick on Titanic

because it has global fame the rest didn't bar gtwt and titanic had great reviews at time of release as a brilliant script with great profound performances when it wasn't.

@makkapacca

because it has global fame the rest didn't bar GWTW, and titanic had great reviews at time of release as a brilliant script with great profound performances when it wasn't - IN MY OPINION.

Fixed that for you too. And YOU are welcome too. Smile

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 12:59

You are funny OP! First we get comparisons between Titanic and Citizen Kane followed by the randomness of Home Alone v Gone with the Wind and now Terminator with Titanic! 😂

I didn't mention home alone though nor did i bring up the terminator comparisons. I mentioned gone with the wind as several critics compared it to that at time of release so it's not random.

OP posts:
makkapacca · 30/01/2022 12:55

Why pick on Titanic

because it has global fame the rest didn't bar gtwt and titanic had great reviews at time of release as a brilliant script with great profound performances when it wasn't.

OP posts:
ChardonnaysPetDragon · 30/01/2022 12:53

Funny how despite being such a professed fan of Leonardo DiCaprio you missed one of his most important films, The Revenant.

As you were.

everythingthelighttouches · 30/01/2022 12:50

I think it does exactly what it says on the tin.
And there’s nothing wrong with that.

Out of interest, as someone mentioned A Night to Remember, has anyone seen this? It is a YouTube video which compares the two films side by side. Fascinating and surprising.

m.youtube.com/watch?v=gsMy3nWWtHc

Titanic is almost a direct copy of A Night to Remember in all the key scenes. Right down to the camera angles! I hadn’t realised at the time it came out it was a remake.

HelloFrostyMorning · 30/01/2022 12:47

@ChardonnaysPetDragon You are COMPLETELY missing my point entirely, (conveniently.) Got no answer that's why.

As you were..

HelloFrostyMorning · 30/01/2022 12:46

@TatianaBis

Titanic and Love Actually are two of the most cringe films ever made. Plus Mama Mia.
@TatianaBis

Titanic and Love Actually are two of the most cringe films ever made. Plus Mama Mia IN MY OPINION.

Fixed that for you. Smile

You're welcome.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 30/01/2022 12:45

[quote HelloFrostyMorning]@ChardonnaysPetDragon

Well, it was bad film and if you want to get all hot under the collar about this, then why don't you get upset with the people who made it this bad and exploitative and who released it to make tons of money from a disaster that cost 2,000 their lives.

Oh yeah, so it exploited the disaster that cost 2000 lives. What about the multiple dozens of WAR films, about Vietnam, WW1, WW2, The American Civil War (Gone with the wind,) 9/11 films, and films about the holocaust, and Hillsborough, and all manner of disasters. Why pick on Titanic? Confused[/quote]
Because it was a bad film. Or am I not allowed to say that? You happen to like it, good for you.

There have been countless bad films about the other events you have mentioned.

No one is picking on anything.

HelloFrostyMorning · 30/01/2022 12:44

@Bbq1

I loved Titanic then and I still do today. There's a lot of people on here giving a lot of time to a film they dislike. Why bother? For example, I think Love Actually is utter tripe but millions of people rave about it. I couldn't be bothered giving an extended rant about how rubbish it is because tbh, everything is down to personal taste and opinion.
Exactly this. Giving soooo much time to a film they allegedly loathe. Bet they watch it at least once a month, with a bar of Cadbury's Dairy Milk, and a bottle of wine.

Seriously though, I HATE film snobs. See also food snobs, cook from scratch snobs, benefit snobs, location snobs, and music snobs. All loathsome.

Pootlepoodle · 30/01/2022 12:41

You are funny OP! First we get comparisons between Titanic and Citizen Kane followed by the randomness of Home Alone v Gone with the Wind and now Terminator with Titanic! 😂

Ok I get that Cameron directed both films but they could not be more worlds apart. One is a sci-fi movie about time travelling robots sent to kill the saviour of mankind before he’s born and the other is a love story about 2 teenagers on a sinking ship. It’s like comparing Star Trek with 50 Shades of Grey. Weird!

HelloFrostyMorning · 30/01/2022 12:41

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

Well, it was bad film and if you want to get all hot under the collar about this, then why don't you get upset with the people who made it this bad and exploitative and who released it to make tons of money from a disaster that cost 2,000 their lives.

Oh yeah, so it exploited the disaster that cost 2000 lives. What about the multiple dozens of WAR films, about Vietnam, WW1, WW2, The American Civil War (Gone with the wind,) 9/11 films, and films about the holocaust, and Hillsborough, and all manner of disasters. Why pick on Titanic? Confused