Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think titanic movie is cringy

236 replies

makkapacca · 29/01/2022 16:28

Came out when I was 12 and I loved it but at 36 caught it on tv last night and it is so cringy. Whilst I think Winslet and Leo are great actors their acting in it is cringe although I don't know if it's their inexperience or just the script. Every 2nd line is 'Jack Rose'. I don't get how both were nominated for Oscars for it when it genuinely wasn't good acting by any means on either part and again I think both are genuinely brilliant in their other films.

Watching it is reminiscent of watching 90s Home and Away or just bad teenage tv acting. Yea the effects are great but the script in itself is just so mediocre and so 12 year old girl stuff. It didn't occur to me how little the film actually go into the subject matter of the Titanic like the creation of it and the aftermath of the sinking etc.

The rich in it like Cal and Rose's mum are so 1 dimensional greedy villains which is kind of hypocritical considering how wealthy Cameron himself is, and the poor Irish on 3rd class are just laughably bad and cliche with accents Irish people never have. And I say that as an Irish person myself so no racism.

A critic said after that the only reason it got oscar noms was because of the money it gained and I sort of agree. Again the effects and cinematography were great but the film itself was just a predictable cringe fest.

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 30/01/2022 15:28

Iirc Cameron originally cast Clare Danes, off the back of R + J. But she pulled out citing exhaustion. Between the lines I think she may have been in love with Leo.

I highly rate Clare Danes as an actress, but Kate is more classically pretty.

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 15:27

The problem in Titantic is that Leo was quite small. She needed a more built male star as she’s quite tall and curvy

he's 6 foot- that's not small for a man by any means, above average if you check and look at all the pics of them then and now, he is a good head bigger than her.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 15:26

@makkapacca

If she wasn't anything special to look at, the film must have had even more good points to compensate the men who most definitely also flocked to see it

Winslet never sold the film though, it was the massive budget and the revolutionary special effects that did that along with the publicity and it been a James Cameron film. The only actor in the cast who'd have sold the film was Leo following the success of R an J, Winslet was very much an unknown then and ,male audiences typically would not come to a film to see an actress.

Ah, so it DID have good points!
TatianaBis · 30/01/2022 15:24

Winslet was stunning. She is still very goodlooking. Her breakthrough role was Marianne in S&S.

The problem in Titantic is that Leo was quite small. She needed a more built male star as she’s quite tall and curvy.

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 15:22

I also agree with you about the cod-Irish accents. There are so many excellent actors and a rake of extras in Ireland, I can never understand why they don't employ them to play Irish characters. It really annoys me so it must piss native Irish people right off

even if they'd used all Irish cast they'd still have been directed to be stereotypically Irish. Any Irish part in Hollywood is always so cringe.I am Irish and the amount of people abroad who think we are all 'very friendly/very nice'....eh no we are just like the rest of youse.

OP posts:
makkapacca · 30/01/2022 15:20

If she wasn't anything special to look at, the film must have had even more good points to compensate the men who most definitely also flocked to see it

Winslet never sold the film though, it was the massive budget and the revolutionary special effects that did that along with the publicity and it been a James Cameron film. The only actor in the cast who'd have sold the film was Leo following the success of R an J, Winslet was very much an unknown then and ,male audiences typically would not come to a film to see an actress.

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 30/01/2022 15:17

Slow clap for @HelloFrostyMorning’s Titanic flounce.

Imagine posting opinions without writing imo every time!

2Gen · 30/01/2022 15:16

YANBU.
I don't think much of it. It's just OK but I wouldn't ever pay to watch it. I do remember being very upset at the end of the old film when I was a child though. Watching the ship break in half and sink into the freezing water had me in bits and haunted me for a long time. I was a bit nervous the next time we went to Ireland on the ferry too!
I also agree with you about the cod-Irish accents. There are so many excellent actors and a rake of extras in Ireland, I can never understand why they don't employ them to play Irish characters. It really annoys me so it must piss native Irish people right off!

Pootlepoodle · 30/01/2022 15:09

Is this really about a dislike for Kate Winslet?

She is absolutely gorgeous in that film by anybody’s standards and to deny that suggests there’s something else going on.

TatianaBis · 30/01/2022 15:06

@makkapacca

And William Shakespeare wasn't writing teen flicks either. That script is still taught in schools and performed on stages now

it still doesn't make it any less of a chick flick in the same way emma or jane austen novels are. Yes Shakespeare wrote plays for the masses but r and j would have being predominantly aimed at the fairer sex.

What complete twaddle.
DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 14:53

@makkapacca

Well, let's just say I've never met a single man who refused to watch the scene because she wasn't worth his sight, and nor have you

she was 22 and young looking, many of us are bangable at that age but still doesn't mean we are beauties.

I truly don't know why this is such a sticking point for you. If she wasn't anything special to look at, the film must have had even more good points to compensate the men who most definitely also flocked to see it.

I'm also getting uncomfortable devoting this much effort to picking apart the looks of a very talented actress.

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 14:50

Well, let's just say I've never met a single man who refused to watch the scene because she wasn't worth his sight, and nor have you

she was 22 and young looking, many of us are bangable at that age but still doesn't mean we are beauties.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 14:47

@makkapacca

What's this got to do with the film apparently having no reason at all to have any appreciative audience

because it was said upthread how the attractiveness of the 2 actors helped sell the film and I said that whilst this was true for Di Caprio who was at the time a pin up boy, Winslet was always more of a serious actress on the Meryl Streep league and was never really a 'beauty'.

I see.

Well, let's just say I've never met a single man who refused to watch the scene because she wasn't worth his sight, and nor have you.

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 14:44

What's this got to do with the film apparently having no reason at all to have any appreciative audience

because it was said upthread how the attractiveness of the 2 actors helped sell the film and I said that whilst this was true for Di Caprio who was at the time a pin up boy, Winslet was always more of a serious actress on the Meryl Streep league and was never really a 'beauty'.

OP posts:
Pootlepoodle · 30/01/2022 14:41

Also beauty is about spirit as well as body parts and Kate absolutely shines in Titanic!

DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 14:40

@makkapacca

You just think it because she was playing the lead female in 1 of the biggest romances ever, if she worked at your local Tesco back then or was in your college class you'd not think anything of her. Nice body I suppose in her nude shot but 'beautiful' is stretching it.
Like I said, OK, she's not beautiful. I'd still love to be that level of not beautiful.

What's this got to do with the film apparently having no reason at all to have any appreciative audience?

Pootlepoodle · 30/01/2022 14:38

Winslet looked pretty in the film but she was always an average looking girl, nothing amazing.

WTAF??? Shock

All right. Kate Winslet isn't beautiful. God, I'd kill to be as non-beautiful as she is.

Yeah, me too!

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 14:37

You just think it because she was playing the lead female in 1 of the biggest romances ever, if she worked at your local Tesco back then or was in your college class you'd not think anything of her. Nice body I suppose in her nude shot but 'beautiful' is stretching it.

OP posts:
powershowerforanhour · 30/01/2022 14:36

"remember reading Cameron was so obsessed with attention to detail that he had the exact tableware recommissioned only to destroy it when the boat starts to sink."

Pity he didn't spend some of the €200M budget on a voice coach for Victor Garber. His acting was good but the accent was wrong.

DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 14:35

All right. Kate Winslet isn't beautiful. God, I'd kill to be as non-beautiful as she is.

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 14:33

She was perhaps a bit more "girl next door" than most Hollywood starlets but she's always been beautiful

not really no, 'beautiful' is a term given to above average. Winslet looked like just another girl/woman you'd see in the supermarket or you'd work with. She always was and is an average looking woman.

'Beautiful' are the type who'd stand out like young Michelle Pfeiffer or Mila Kunis etc. Winslet was never 'beautiful', not that there's anything wrong with that, most of us aren't.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 14:28

Oh, and the boob shot was a few seconds, in context. To think we had yet to get Game Of Thrones on our screens!

DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 14:27

@makkapacca

What, Kate Winslet wasn't appealing to the men? I remember the boys being dazzled by her. The casting required good looking young people, so what

yea cos she got her boobs out, a move pretty unheard of for a mainstream film that was on the mainstream and like a pg/12 cert. Winslet looked pretty in the film but she was always an average looking girl, nothing amazing. Di Caprio was more pin up looking boy back then and was certainly above average.

She was perhaps a bit more "girl next door" than most Hollywood starlets but she's always been beautiful. The role wouldn't have gone to me no matter how well I acted, put it that way. I'm sure Leo's looks appealed to the younger women, so what? That's why lead roles usually go to good looking people, and there are more women being selected for their looks than men.

It quite clearly had a wider appeal than just teenage girls and a handsome male lead. You don't get that kind of success, especially when it cost so much to make and required more cinema attendance than usual because its length meant it had fewer showings and ate into showtimes for other films, if it's got only a very niche audience.

There's nothing wrong with not liking it, or thinking it's overrated or whatever. But it's obtuse to pretend that it has nothing going for it at all and that it's had such enduring success, despite its disadvantages, because everyone in 1998 was stupid.

makkapacca · 30/01/2022 14:21

What, Kate Winslet wasn't appealing to the men? I remember the boys being dazzled by her. The casting required good looking young people, so what

yea cos she got her boobs out, a move pretty unheard of for a mainstream film that was on the mainstream and like a pg/12 cert. Winslet looked pretty in the film but she was always an average looking girl, nothing amazing. Di Caprio was more pin up looking boy back then and was certainly above average.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 30/01/2022 14:20

Mama Mia is exactly what it's supposed to be. It's not everyone's cup of tea but it hits its mark perfectly.