Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any ideas how to ensure the house valuation is on the low side?

291 replies

Iliveinahovel · 29/01/2022 14:06

I need a valuation to be on the low side for the house I now live in. Not out-of-this-world low, but somewhere realistic, i.e. 10% to 15% lower than an "average" similar house would be valued at. Currently the house is probably "average" with respect to the overall appeal and condition.

Have around 6 months until the valuation will be done. Any ideas? Let the garden overgrow?

OP posts:
Callipygion · 29/01/2022 18:34

Put some mouse or rat traps round the place. Dig up some weeds and place in gutter. Before valuer come round splash some water under a windowsill so it looks like it leaks or is damp.

prh47bridge · 29/01/2022 18:34

[quote Cockwomblingfree]@prh47bridge thank you. can the OP argue the order or the wording? do they have an expiry timescale, then have to be redone? or are they set in stone?

The kids could lose their home, the OP's home just so the exH can walk away with a lump sum despite not contributing to their lives financially and only being married for a couple of years. It sucks. [/quote]
As the order was made years ago, it is far too late to challenge it now unless she can show that her ex failed to make a full disclosure. The OP appears to have agreed to give her ex a percentage of the house. That being the case, a challenge was unlikely to succeed even if she had done so at the time unless there was a Barder event, or he failed to make a full disclosure.

Iliveinahovel · 29/01/2022 18:28

@Tulipomania

Paint the kitchen purple.

Add lots of clutter.

Install low power light bulbs so it looks dark.

My kitchen is purple Grin so at least that is ticked off!
OP posts:
inheritancetrack · 29/01/2022 18:27

seal off one of the rooms and paper over it and say it only has 2 nor 3 bedrooms like the surrounding houses? joking!

Just let it look extremely uncared for with curtains falling down and the rooms so cluttered they look small than they are. tbh estate agents are good at looking past these things when valuing properties.

Darbs76 · 29/01/2022 18:25

Anyone suggesting this is not morally right what about the lack of money this man has paid for his children? I have zero sympathy for him at all

Iliveinahovel · 29/01/2022 18:25

@Rosscameasdoody

So its your house - I assume this because you’re saying things like ‘when I bought it’ rather than ‘when we bought it’ ? If he’s never contributed and his name isn’t on the deeds, why is he entitled to a share ? A friend had this a few years ago - short marriage and ex husband tried to claim a share in the house she owned outright well before they got together. She rejected the settlement proposals and went to court. She could prove he had never contributed anything towards the property and she paid the majority of the bills. He lost. Sorry - slightly derailing but to answer your question I don’t think there’s much you can do to lower the valuation other than talk to the estate agent and see what they are prepared to do.
I already answered earlier on the thread, it was a consent order (i.e. by agreement) as the amount at that time has been not extraordinarily high, and the legal fees to go all the way to the final hearing were significantly in excess of it. There was a risk that the court would have made some award in his favour anyway, as there were two children of the marriage, so wasn't worth it.
OP posts:
Horst · 29/01/2022 18:21

Don’t tidy up at all or take rubbish out before a viewing. Borrow a wet smelly dog.

Horst · 29/01/2022 18:19

If you know a gas man friend genuinely get him to mark it off as condemned even though it’s not.

Get any appliances out that could cook a dinner because cookers condemned/broken too sad face. Turn off the water to the taps yeah broken too.

Just cannot afford to fix it sad face.

Iliveinahovel · 29/01/2022 18:18

Thank you for all the suggestions. For the avoidance of doubt, I am not trying to do anything illegal or defraud anyone. Any valuation will be an expert opinion, and it is obviously a range rather than a precise scientific estimate. My question was how to get towards the lower end of that range.

From the moral perspective, obviously you hear only one side of the story, so can only trust my word that it is a complete windfall to my ex, effectively infinite return as he has invested zero into it - and there have been no other assets I took share of during the divorce.

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 29/01/2022 18:14

So its your house - I assume this because you’re saying things like ‘when I bought it’ rather than ‘when we bought it’ ? If he’s never contributed and his name isn’t on the deeds, why is he entitled to a share ? A friend had this a few years ago - short marriage and ex husband tried to claim a share in the house she owned outright well before they got together. She rejected the settlement proposals and went to court. She could prove he had never contributed anything towards the property and she paid the majority of the bills. He lost. Sorry - slightly derailing but to answer your question I don’t think there’s much you can do to lower the valuation other than talk to the estate agent and see what they are prepared to do.

Soontobe60 · 29/01/2022 18:14

@nicelyneurotic

Have you spoke to your solicitor?

I've been in your position.
The estate agent - a lovely woman of a similar age to me - was very happy to value it low to help me out.

And the courts will only expect you to offer what you can afford.

In my case I said I can afford to give you £x now (not quite the full amount but all I had), or you can wait until the kids have grown up/left home for x%.

He took the money now.

No, the courts will expect her to pay whet she agreed to pay 7 years ago. They could force the sale of the house in order to or pay him off. The fact that the house has so much equity in it now would go against her, as she would have enough equity left to buy another property.
Blossomtoes · 29/01/2022 18:08

[quote prh47bridge]**@Blossomtoes* - Please explain why @Viviennemary* should be behind the OP? In what way is anyone trying to diddle her out of her rights?[/quote]
My comment was from a moral rather than a legal point of view. I should have clarified that.

prh47bridge · 29/01/2022 18:06

@Blossomtoes - Please explain why @Viviennemary should be behind the OP? In what way is anyone trying to diddle her out of her rights?

Cockwomblingfree · 29/01/2022 18:04

@prh47bridge thank you. can the OP argue the order or the wording? do they have an expiry timescale, then have to be redone? or are they set in stone?

The kids could lose their home, the OP's home just so the exH can walk away with a lump sum despite not contributing to their lives financially and only being married for a couple of years. It sucks.

Iliveinahovel · 29/01/2022 18:03

@Toanewstart22

Deprivation of assists is rightfully looked up VERY unfavourable by the courts
I don't intend to deprive anyone of assets. No need to make a villain out of me.
OP posts:
Londoncallingme · 29/01/2022 18:02

Can you cut the garden back so that it’s overlooked? People hate that.
Pull all the furtniture away from the walls slightly so it looks smaller. Please things in the hall that have to walked around.
Don’t make the beds. Keep the windows dirty and curtains semi drawn. Very low wattage bulbs everywhere.

Iliveinahovel · 29/01/2022 18:01

@TillyTopper

As many PPs have said you could left the property run down, but I don't think it'll have as much of an impact you want. I'd say to devalue a property you need to do something more serious such as (1) Get the boiler condemned so there is no working heating or (2) render the bathroom unusable or (3) take out the kitchen.
Eh, no, won't go as far. We live in this house, after all, and I would it to be habitable. But yes, the consensus on the thread seems to be that messiness / overgrown gardens / shabby carpets won't affect the valuation much.
OP posts:
nicelyneurotic · 29/01/2022 17:58

Have you spoke to your solicitor?

I've been in your position.
The estate agent - a lovely woman of a similar age to me - was very happy to value it low to help me out.

And the courts will only expect you to offer what you can afford.

In my case I said I can afford to give you £x now (not quite the full amount but all I had), or you can wait until the kids have grown up/left home for x%.

He took the money now.

Toanewstart22 · 29/01/2022 17:57

Deprivation of assists is rightfully looked up VERY unfavourable by the courts

Koshnique · 29/01/2022 17:57

I would get three estate agents round now as well as in a few months, just in case prices rise again.

Toanewstart22 · 29/01/2022 17:57

And the second is also correct

Iliveinahovel · 29/01/2022 17:54

@Toanewstart22

1. Good solicitor condition includes condition that proceed if x% higher than valuation when sold is reduced
  1. If he thinks you are making he property less desirable - deprivation of assets
On the first point, that is correct - on sale the actual sale price minus the equity will be divided, not the valuation.
OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 29/01/2022 17:54

My ex tried to do precisely this to me. It backfired because I was then in a position to buy HIM out, and either he paid me off or I could pay him off.
All the things that have been suggested won’t necessarily alter the value of the house, but will limit the possibility of someone wanting to buy it - which the OP doesn’t want.
OP, I think your only chance is to be there when the valuers come round, mention your situation, hope they value it low. Meanwhile, put in a claim for maintenance from him asap.

jacks11 · 29/01/2022 17:52

I think you need to be very careful before damaging or neglecting essential upkeep.

I strongly advise you to get clarification on what type of valuation you are required to get (and can he also instruct his own?). I really think that you need to be clear what sort of valuation you need- as others have said RICS surveys are a very different beast from an EA valuation for probate. Damaging/neglecting the house could leave you with a big repair bill but make no/only a little difference to the end valuation- effectively shooting yourself in the foot.

And if you rip out the kitchen/bathroom or make the house appear to have a structural issue then you could make it harder to get a mortgage- or perhaps harder to get one at the rate you want- I’d think very carefully.

I’m not without sympathy, but as this agreement has been made and is legally binding, you need to make sure of where you stand, just to make you don’t do anything that worsens your position.

Iliveinahovel · 29/01/2022 17:46

@cakeambush

This is so fucking immoral. If a man came here and asked this he'd be ripped to shreds and rightly so, not indulged with suggestions. You shouldn't have married him if you didn't want to share assets.
I shouldn't have, you're absolutely right. Can't turn the time back, unfortunately. I am trying to make the best of a not very good situation, and not to disrupt my children's life more than it already has been.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread