Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any ideas how to ensure the house valuation is on the low side?

291 replies

Iliveinahovel · 29/01/2022 14:06

I need a valuation to be on the low side for the house I now live in. Not out-of-this-world low, but somewhere realistic, i.e. 10% to 15% lower than an "average" similar house would be valued at. Currently the house is probably "average" with respect to the overall appeal and condition.

Have around 6 months until the valuation will be done. Any ideas? Let the garden overgrow?

OP posts:
boardbored · 30/01/2022 19:39

I would go with the surveyor’s report. They are always bloody low. Find out the recent sales that are priced lower and tell the surveyor about them.

Are there any structural issues you can tell the surveyor about? Any planning permission you didn’t get? Any disputes with neighbours you can generate?

tickingthebox73 · 30/01/2022 19:29

Are you sure you have this right?

So when the order was made you had £300k house, £60k equity and owed him about 20% of equity = £12k

Now, £600k house, £480 equity (??) and he will therefore get £96k?

Why on earth don't you remortgage the house? So you have less equity?

If you are right and it goes on the amount of equity you could technically remortgage to 90% so equity of £60k again? (I realise you may need help to do this but please see a mortgage broker as many things are possible.)

Are you SURE its not fixed on the proportions at the time, so £12k then is £24 k now due to house price increases, this would make much more sense.

Ddot · 30/01/2022 19:19

You were only married two years he should get bog all, and i would think the same if it was a woman. Did he give up his house to move in with you and why didn't he contribute

ShoshanaBlue101 · 30/01/2022 19:14

Smash a window. It puts thousands off and doesn't cost so much to fix...

PigeonLittle · 30/01/2022 19:07

I would bribe a neighbour hard cash and ask them to keep an old dishevelved wet sofa in the garden or down the side of the house etc.

Partyowl · 30/01/2022 19:03

STBExH planning the same with marital home OP.
I moved out 3 years ago and left the place immaculate.
Now the divorce is being finalised, I understand he's totally neglected my former home (of 25 years) and the place now looks like a total and utter pigsty.

Iliveinahovel · 30/01/2022 18:59

I sometimes think that I must be really bad at explaining my position.

I know that the order is final, nowhere had I said that I want to overturn it now, that I received bad legal advice, that I want to avoid paying, take personal revenge for non-payment of maintenance, or intend to be dishonest in any way. I actually said the exact opposite, that I think I was represented fairly and it is my own fault and general cowardice that led to not acting on this earlier.

I just absolutely do not want to fall over myself to ensure that my ex's financial gain from this is maximised at my (and the children's) expense. I do not think that I have any duty of care now towards his financial interests - neither implicit, nor explicit, neither legal nor moral. If rewilding the garden, being more relaxed about cleaning and choosing some cheerful colours for the walls can be to my and the children's benefit, why not? It is nowhere near causing intentional damage.

OP posts:
Coldcoffeeclub · 30/01/2022 18:47

See if you can get a condemned sticker for the boiler and anything the surveyor asks you haven't got eg cavity wall insulation etc and casually tell them there is damp etc

prh47bridge · 30/01/2022 18:33

@mylifestory

Also citizens advice on the point of the valuation 7 years ago. Why shd he be benefitting from an increase in something he had not contributed to at all. even the £13k you mentioned then + increase in % that he wdve gained in the bank on that amount wd be better. I wdnt just give him this large sum of money tbh. hes laughing at you. If it takes a good solicitor to give him less then id rather pay the solicitor.

Ive had legal problems all my life due to other family members, pls contact me!

Because if the financial settlement awarded him a percentage of the equity, that is what he is entitled to. His percentage doesn't reduce just because time has gone by. If the OP is describing the financial order correctly, paying a solicitor will get her nowhere. She must abide by the terms of the order.
Ddot · 30/01/2022 18:29

Paint door a baby shit colour, keep some damp clothes in a plastic bag, place under sink for that authentic stench. Paint some damp patches on ceiling upstairs. Have your neighbours scream obscenities and play heavy metal full blast

Cissyandflora · 30/01/2022 18:25

@Dishwashersaurous

Commit a horrendous crime in the house so it will forever be known ad the crime house and no wants to live there
Absolutely this. No one wants to buy my home now after what I did to the neighbour.
Flatwhitetostayin · 30/01/2022 18:23

I really hope you get to stay in your home. Don't listen to the naysayers, they would do exactly the same in your position. Do whatever you can morally live with. You and your kids deserve to stay where you are.x

Leedsfan247 · 30/01/2022 18:22

If you own it tell the agent you want a quick sale they will value it lower

mylifestory · 30/01/2022 18:11

Paint kitchens bedrooms especially ceilings black, its a known put off with estate agents. Im sure your som wd like camo all over the walls and ceiling for a bit, you can do this with netting easily bought online, lots of it!!

mylifestory · 30/01/2022 18:10

Also citizens advice on the point of the valuation 7 years ago. Why shd he be benefitting from an increase in something he had not contributed to at all. even the £13k you mentioned then + increase in % that he wdve gained in the bank on that amount wd be better. I wdnt just give him this large sum of money tbh. hes laughing at you. If it takes a good solicitor to give him less then id rather pay the solicitor.

Ive had legal problems all my life due to other family members, pls contact me!

Rtruth · 30/01/2022 17:59

Dodgy!!!!

But valuers have 10% swing on their valuation either way, so just tell them why you need it and they will do their job.

Letting garden go or anything not substantial won’t have much effect as process will be 1) 1/2 radius if property sales prices of similar houses in last 6 months. 2) your property conditions. If gardens a mess that’s easily fixed and won’t effect it much.

mylifestory · 30/01/2022 17:53

I feel for you.
I had to do similar for inheritance tax purposes a long time ago.
it was rented out at the time and i told the tenants to make it messy, they did a grand job.
The valuer didnt even go to the top floor where there were 2 more large rooms and a huge loft bt i said there was only 1 more room there and he believed me.
If you have space, collect anything you'd now be chucking out in black bin liners and when needed dot it around the house in the said bin liners. make a wall of them into any big room so they can't get in. Mounds of bags anywhere is good. Kitchen utensils all out. keep tea bags, make an obvious wall then look damp with them, say its the roof leak as you need a new one. Also damp around the bottom of any wall like the kitchen, tea and some black paint thrown against the wall a few weeks before valuer due, so you have damp coming from up and down, its really de-valuing.
Do you know who will be doing the valuation? If you have to pick them, get an estate agent who doesnt sell your type of house, one from a cheaper area, you can say anything you like to them like a likely value and they will just write it and get out of there - you pay then a fee for a divorce valuation and they really dont care.
Also act strange, insane, like they wdnt want the job of selling yr house as you would put off potential buyers so they will value it low.

Pls feel free to PM me as I have done this before - good luck and take the bastard for everything you dont have to give him. 2 years sounds like he was only in it for 1 thing.

prh47bridge · 30/01/2022 13:56

[quote Unknown83]@Iliveinahovel

I understand all you're saying but I'm not helping you because you're trying to breach a court order and act in bad faith. If you get a good solicitor, I think they will say the same. Only a bad one will encourage you to fight a hopeless case so they can get fees out of you (that you can ill afford to pay).

I've also reported this whole thread because I think it is in contempt of court, a criminal offence.[/quote]
Although contempt can lead to imprisonment, it is not a criminal offence.

prh47bridge · 30/01/2022 13:51

@Alondra

OP, you really need to consult an experienced family law lawyer to set aside the agreement you made on the basis of receiving wrong legal advice. Even if setting aside the agreement is out of date, you still need to know what's your best course of action considering you are going to be forced to leave a home you purchased before marriage when the marriage was of short duration on legal advice you received at the time.

This your fault. You received the wrong legal advice and there are legal ways to set a dud agreement aside. Just do it right this time.

You really, really need an family law solicitor with years of experience.

You cannot get a court order set aside on the basis that you received the wrong legal advice (and it is not clear that the advice the OP received was wrong).

Just to repeat the legal position, a financial order on divorce can only be overturned if there is a Barder event (i.e. something unexpected happens shortly after the order that invalidates the basis on which the order was made), one party did not make a full disclosure, the judge got the law wrong, or the order is clearly unfair. As the order appears to have been made 7 years ago, it is too late to claim a Barder event or appeal on the basis that the judge got the law wrong or that the order is unfair. So, unless the OP has evidence that her ex did not make a full disclosure, the order is final.

I don't think it helps the OP to give her the impression she can get the order changed. It is extremely rare for a divorce financial order to be reopened and changed. Nothing the OP has said suggests she has any basis for doing so.

I would also say that it is not clear that the OP received the wrong legal advice. It is not uncommon to advise someone that, although their ex wants more than the court would award, it is going to be cheaper to let them have what they want than to fight it through the courts.

Iliveinahovel · 30/01/2022 11:31

[quote Unknown83]@Iliveinahovel

I understand all you're saying but I'm not helping you because you're trying to breach a court order and act in bad faith. If you get a good solicitor, I think they will say the same. Only a bad one will encourage you to fight a hopeless case so they can get fees out of you (that you can ill afford to pay).

I've also reported this whole thread because I think it is in contempt of court, a criminal offence.[/quote]
How on earth am I trying to breach a court order??? I will do exactly what is tells me to do (i.e. either sell or buy out), and I have no plans at all to get a solicitor now to contest it or weasel out of payment in any other way.
My question is exactly the mirror opposite of the usual ones "how to ensure that the valuation is on the top of the range", asked for the mortgage LTV purposes.

OP posts:
MilduraS · 30/01/2022 11:29

Just explain you need the valuation to buy your ex out and not to actually sell the property. A lot of agents give a higher valuation in the hope you choose them and then accept a lower offer for the actual sale. When I worked in probate the solicitors used to contact 3 agents and say it's for probate so they'd give a realistic valuation. Otherwise they could end up with one beneficiary dragging out a sale "because the agent said it was worth more". Was very frustrating when they were holding out for an extra 5k for several months but racking up legal costs with daily telephone calls and emails because it was taking so long.

Unknown83 · 30/01/2022 11:26

@Iliveinahovel

I understand all you're saying but I'm not helping you because you're trying to breach a court order and act in bad faith. If you get a good solicitor, I think they will say the same. Only a bad one will encourage you to fight a hopeless case so they can get fees out of you (that you can ill afford to pay).

I've also reported this whole thread because I think it is in contempt of court, a criminal offence.

Ukholidaysaregreat · 30/01/2022 11:10

I agree, explain to the estate agents that you need a valuation at the lower end of the range. Then look into maybe extending your mortgage repayment in years to make it more affordable but over pay within the allowed limits when you can. Mortgage interest rates are at a historic low at the moment. I have a great deal with HSBC. Worth booking in some meetings with a variety of lenders to see if they can help you. Good luck with all this. Flowers

Iliveinahovel · 30/01/2022 10:22

@NannyOggsWhiskyStash

How is your ex not legally obliged to pay child maintenance? Would he see his own children made homeless if you can't pay him?
He doesn't have any regular income in his own name, his family apparently pays for everything, with quite a comfortable lifestyle achieved as a result, and no need to work. Our child maintenance dispute ended up in the tribunal, and there still was nothing tangible to attach an order to. The current tune is that he won't fund my lifestyle, but rather would prefer to sponsor the children directly "when they need it later". Any expenses such as nursery fees, childcare, travel, extracurricular activities, days out etc is apparently for my benefit, not theirs. And there's state help when it comes to basics like food and shelter, should I fall on really hard times, so he's not liable for that either.

He knows they won't be homeless, I am competent enough for that. I won't be able to re-house us locally though via buying another property though, so it is either uprooting the children from schools (incl SEN support that was a separate nightmare to secure) and friends and moving somewhere much cheaper where I have zero support, and quitting my job (well - actually, likely my profession too) which is London centric. Or renting for another 10 years or so, which will slowly eat into the equity released (my mortgage now is around 60% of the market rent for a similar property). I mean, it is not a complete disaster, of course, it could have been much worse. But I'd prefer a solution that does not put me back to square zero in a couple of years when the children fly the nest and I am 50+. Even if it looks "immoral" to many people.

OP posts:
NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 30/01/2022 09:54

How is your ex not legally obliged to pay child maintenance? Would he see his own children made homeless if you can't pay him?

Swipe left for the next trending thread