Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any ideas how to ensure the house valuation is on the low side?

291 replies

Iliveinahovel · 29/01/2022 14:06

I need a valuation to be on the low side for the house I now live in. Not out-of-this-world low, but somewhere realistic, i.e. 10% to 15% lower than an "average" similar house would be valued at. Currently the house is probably "average" with respect to the overall appeal and condition.

Have around 6 months until the valuation will be done. Any ideas? Let the garden overgrow?

OP posts:
zeg3885 · 30/01/2022 21:55

Despite not paying towards the mortgage? I find this so difficult to swallow.
Sell it to a friend for dirt cheap and buy it back at a later date Wink

prh47bridge · 30/01/2022 21:49

@zeg3885

Surely it’s 20% of the price at the time of the agreement - not afterwards? You made an agreement to give that amount based on the value then. I’d get legal advice.
Just to repeat, this is a divorce settlement. If it was based on the price at the time of agreement, the OP's ex would almost certainly have been awarded a fixed amount. He has instead got a percentage of the equity and is as entitled as the OP to benefit from any increase in the value of the property.
zeg3885 · 30/01/2022 21:37

Surely it’s 20% of the price at the time of the agreement - not afterwards? You made an agreement to give that amount based on the value then. I’d get legal advice.

Iliveinahovel · 30/01/2022 21:26

@Pat123dev

How do you get on with your neighbor? Would they mind if you started a dispute
Neighbours would be one of the biggest losses if I move anywhere. They are all quite eccentric in their own ways, but we get on exceptionally well.
OP posts:
Iliveinahovel · 30/01/2022 21:25

Get another valuation and be clear what the valuation is for. You may have to pay for it since you aren't intending to sell, but you should get a more realistic figure that way.
Yes, this seems to be the most rational way forward.

OP posts:
Pat123dev · 30/01/2022 21:23

How do you get on with your neighbor? Would they mind if you started a dispute

Iliveinahovel · 30/01/2022 21:21

[quote Soontobe60]@prh47bridge has a point. If you e been overpaying the mortgage, should that not be taken into account? Please seek legal advice.[/quote]
No, no, not overpaying - just reducing the principal in the usual way through scheduled payments.

OP posts:
Iliveinahovel · 30/01/2022 21:21

I note that one of the OP's posts says she has reduced the mortgage. If that is the case, he may not be entitled to 20% of that, he may only be entitled to 20% of what the equity would be if the mortgage had remained the same. She should check with a lawyer.
Unfortunately, it is linked to the actual mortgage balance. Formally it works in a way that he charges me notional "occupation rent" on his share and I forfeit in return any claim against him to contribute to my mortgage or other costs. So from the legal perspective he does contribute towards the mortgage reduction, I guess, it is just remitted by me directly to the bank instead of me paying him rent and him paying me back the mortgage share.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 30/01/2022 21:17

@prh47bridge has a point. If you e been overpaying the mortgage, should that not be taken into account? Please seek legal advice.

Isthisprivate · 30/01/2022 21:16

Well, there is a natural variation of around £100K to £150K when it comes to sold prices for the houses on my very street - and they are all similar, it is quite a standard two up - two down terrace. Apart from the condition they're in - last renovated in the 80s, with artex on the ceiling and avocado-coloured bathrooms, vs an immaculate house with all the usual pre-sale improvements.

Swap door numbers with someone owning an avocado bathroom!
I would have random buckets of water in places, maybe take a couple of doors off cupboards in the kitchen so it looks like it needs replacing. Maybe put black paint in a spray bottle and spray a bathroom wall to look like black mould. And a good old sofa in the overgrown garden

RubyKitty · 30/01/2022 21:11

Can you not just get the valuation based on the date he left, or the date of the legal order? If he hasn’t paid any money since, either for the house or the children, he can’t expect a current days valuation

prh47bridge · 30/01/2022 21:06

@Iliveinahovel

I'd also contact a couple of estate agents NOT on the list and quietly get a 'starting' valuation' if you haven't done so already. At least it'll give you a jumping off point. Then you can ask those agents (since they won't be asked to do the actual valuations) how to 'reduce' the value. Well, time for a drip feed! I already did that (got a valuation from an agent, however, it was one from the list). It is way way way way higher than I expected, but I think now, when I cooled down a bit, that it was intended to be aspirational (say, the highest recent sale is 600K - for a massively extended immaculate house, and they suggested to market for offers over 650K). They kept on mentioning that "this needs work to fetch you the best offer" and "that needs some TLC before the viewings", so I thought to ask for some collective wisdom on here. All recent local sold prices seem to be just insane (at least to me), as they all are just from the recent stamp duty holiday. I honestly don't know how someone in my exact position ~10 years ago is supposed to step on the property ladder now.
Get another valuation and be clear what the valuation is for. You may have to pay for it since you aren't intending to sell, but you should get a more realistic figure that way.
prh47bridge · 30/01/2022 21:04

@tickingthebox73

Are you sure you have this right?

So when the order was made you had £300k house, £60k equity and owed him about 20% of equity = £12k

Now, £600k house, £480 equity (??) and he will therefore get £96k?

Why on earth don't you remortgage the house? So you have less equity?

If you are right and it goes on the amount of equity you could technically remortgage to 90% so equity of £60k again? (I realise you may need help to do this but please see a mortgage broker as many things are possible.)

Are you SURE its not fixed on the proportions at the time, so £12k then is £24 k now due to house price increases, this would make much more sense.

If it was fixed on proportions at the time, the order would have given him a fixed amount, not a percentage of the equity. When the sale of the marital home is delayed, it is normal for the party being forced to wait to be given a proportion of the equity. He is as entitled as the OP to benefit from the increase in value. Your final sentence would only work if he had been given a fixed proportion of the house. As he has 20%, that means he would have got £60k (i.e. all the equity) 7 years ago and would now be entitled to £120k.

If the OP increased the mortgage in an attempt to reduce the amount she had to pay her ex, he should find it easy to get the courts to order her to pay the full £96k.

I note that one of the OP's posts says she has reduced the mortgage. If that is the case, he may not be entitled to 20% of that, he may only be entitled to 20% of what the equity would be if the mortgage had remained the same. She should check with a lawyer.

Iliveinahovel · 30/01/2022 21:03

I'd also contact a couple of estate agents NOT on the list and quietly get a 'starting' valuation' if you haven't done so already. At least it'll give you a jumping off point. Then you can ask those agents (since they won't be asked to do the actual valuations) how to 'reduce' the value.
Well, time for a drip feed! I already did that (got a valuation from an agent, however, it was one from the list). It is way way way way higher than I expected, but I think now, when I cooled down a bit, that it was intended to be aspirational (say, the highest recent sale is 600K - for a massively extended immaculate house, and they suggested to market for offers over 650K). They kept on mentioning that "this needs work to fetch you the best offer" and "that needs some TLC before the viewings", so I thought to ask for some collective wisdom on here.
All recent local sold prices seem to be just insane (at least to me), as they all are just from the recent stamp duty holiday. I honestly don't know how someone in my exact position ~10 years ago is supposed to step on the property ladder now.

OP posts:
Iliveinahovel · 30/01/2022 20:43

Are there any structural issues you can tell the surveyor about? Any planning permission you didn’t get? Any disputes with neighbours you can generate?
There's a flat felt roof on the (pre-existing) extension that genuinely leaks. Not sure whether is worth much.

OP posts:
HairyAl · 30/01/2022 20:41

I have a friend who’s a surveyor, and depending on people’s circumstances, and whether he likes them or not (offer drinks and biscuits), he’ll adjust a bit up or down to help them out. 15% would be a lot tho. I’d try and do some low grade surface damage…

Iliveinahovel · 30/01/2022 20:35

@MondayYogurt

Check if anyone nearby has japanese knotweed growing.
I actually did have it, that's how I was able to afford the house in the first place Grin. Took around 5 years to get rid of it completely. Crap, should have just let it grow.
OP posts:
Iliveinahovel · 30/01/2022 20:33

@tickingthebox73

Are you sure you have this right?

So when the order was made you had £300k house, £60k equity and owed him about 20% of equity = £12k

Now, £600k house, £480 equity (??) and he will therefore get £96k?

Why on earth don't you remortgage the house? So you have less equity?

If you are right and it goes on the amount of equity you could technically remortgage to 90% so equity of £60k again? (I realise you may need help to do this but please see a mortgage broker as many things are possible.)

Are you SURE its not fixed on the proportions at the time, so £12k then is £24 k now due to house price increases, this would make much more sense.

Yes, all correct, only ~£420k equity not £480k (I posted upthread with a correction). I did round-up / distort the actual numbers a bit as wasn't too comfortable quoting the actual amounts (thus the confusion), but the overall picture when it comes to proportions is accurate. My lived reality hasn't changed though, it is exactly the same pebble-dashed terrace I bought as my starter home, it did not become any more luxurious over time, and I seem to be even in a worse position now when it comes to the affordability. My income has increased since, unfortunately not in line with the real estate growth - but taking into account dependants the overall net, as calculated by the bank, is now worse. It is bizarre what happened to the property market, but it is another sad topic.

I cannot remortgage the house unilaterally as (a) he has a beneficial interest charge on the property (b) in any case only the original mortgage counts, no additional post-separation borrowing.

OP posts:
MommaDuck · 30/01/2022 20:12

@Iliveinahovel

I sometimes think that I must be really bad at explaining my position.

I know that the order is final, nowhere had I said that I want to overturn it now, that I received bad legal advice, that I want to avoid paying, take personal revenge for non-payment of maintenance, or intend to be dishonest in any way. I actually said the exact opposite, that I think I was represented fairly and it is my own fault and general cowardice that led to not acting on this earlier.

I just absolutely do not want to fall over myself to ensure that my ex's financial gain from this is maximised at my (and the children's) expense. I do not think that I have any duty of care now towards his financial interests - neither implicit, nor explicit, neither legal nor moral. If rewilding the garden, being more relaxed about cleaning and choosing some cheerful colours for the walls can be to my and the children's benefit, why not? It is nowhere near causing intentional damage.

You’re not bad at explaining anything OP. People are being pedantic and twisting your words purposefully. I have been in a similar situation recently; why must we work so hard, raise our children alone and be absolutely shafted by men, who contribute fuck all to their children up-bringing!!? It’s abhorrent. I’m sorry you’re in this position and I wish you the best of luck. Fingers crossed property prices crash again for a while before zooming back up 🤞
GrandmasCat · 30/01/2022 20:09

A house is only worth what people are prepared to pay for it so it is relatively easy: re arrange all rooms and decoration putting everything in the worst position, remove everything that makes the house feel warm. Feature every downside of the house, if you have a steamy kitchen or bathroom, let the mould grow free for a couple of months.

And also, don’t use estate agents for the valuation, demand a paid valuation professional who will value for bricks and walls rather than your lovely furniture.

CrankyFrankie · 30/01/2022 20:08

What an absolute scumbag bloodsucker he must be. Sorry you’re in this position OP.

Off the top of my head, maybe just like you say, the opposite of what boosts a house’s perceived value, ie:
smells - get some old towels festering from now and maybe hide them around a few rooms so it stinks if damp.
Old prawns in the bathroom?! 🤣
Noise - any sympathetic neighbours either side who can make a racket (voices/music/vehicles)?
Bad lighting
Clutter
Zero kerb appeal
Litter
(Dog) poo on the pavement right outside?!
Insect ‘infestation’...?
Borrow 10 stinky cats and backcomb your hair
I’m here all week ;)

boardbored · 30/01/2022 20:00

@MondayYogurt

Check if anyone nearby has japanese knotweed growing.
Yeah or just tell the surveyor you think you’ve seen it
MondayYogurt · 30/01/2022 19:58

Check if anyone nearby has japanese knotweed growing.

AcrossthePond55 · 30/01/2022 19:56

I think it might be worth a visit to a solicitor to see if there are any legal 'angles' that have not been explored.

I'd also contact a couple of estate agents NOT on the list and quietly get a 'starting' valuation' if you haven't done so already. At least it'll give you a jumping off point. Then you can ask those agents (since they won't be asked to do the actual valuations) how to 'reduce' the value.

Where I live in the US 'cosmetic' stuff doesn't knock much off so an overgrown yard, tacky carpets and paint, outdated furniture or a just dirty house wouldn't bring the price down much. Structural issues, poorly or non-working heat and AC, and REALLY outdated kitchens & baths in bad condition, ie badly chipped or cracked tiles & fixtures, cabinets hanging off hinges, poorly working equipment that will need expensive replacements do. And a bad location will 'kill' a house value, just as a 'good' location will raise it sky high.

Catslave67 · 30/01/2022 19:39

My advice would be to get an estate agent who doesn’t specialise in your type of house. My friend had hers valued for divorce and it is a fantastic house with a pool and annexe & she needed three valuations so she asked an estate agent who specialised in park homes, one who was a new agent who was just out of area and one who deals with big houses. The first two valued it significantly lower than the third (which was still low in my opinion) and when they took the average she was happy as that meant she could afford the mortgage on her own after the divorce. Hope that helps.

Swipe left for the next trending thread