Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wendy house has blown into nightmare neighbours car and cracked rear light.

116 replies

user1488481370 · 29/01/2022 12:59

We’ve actually very recently had to move because of these neighbours (my in laws/OH’s brother and his partner) and their harassment/threats however OH still owns the house.

Kids had a Wendy house, the house we’re renting doesn’t currently have a garden or anywhere to store it. Wendy house was in a corner between a wall which is at least 5 feet and OH’s house. We’ve had storms before and it’s never blown over the wall before, we did have a 10kg bag of play sand on the roof too.

We had BIL banging on our door this morning going absolutely mad because the Wendy house had blown over the wall and cracked his partner’s car’s rear light. Demanded payment there and then. Really quite scary when I was on my own with 4 children. Threatened to ring the police if he didn’t calm down and told him to go away and ring me about it later.

We’re wondering if it would be covered under OH’s house insurance or is it an act of god? They’ve reacted completely out of proportion to the issue. Despite everything they’ve done it doesn’t sit right with either myself or OH to not pay for the damage caused and I really don’t want any more aggro as I’m finding it quite triggering.

Posted here for traffic really but WWYD? Or what should we be doing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CornishTiger · 06/02/2022 08:23

Sorry just seen this. It’s not for the police to decide on a non mol. It’s for the judge based on what you present. BIL then gets to present his version. I can imagine he won’t behave in front of judge and present a good picture of himself.

Currently doing nothing isn’t helping you stay safe.

CorsicaDreaming · 05/02/2022 22:12

@user1488481370 - it's a matter for the Court Judge to decide if you should get one. The police are probably not keen to have to enforce it as they can see what a nutter your BIL is, and that it will probably run and run. But they would have a duty to do so if the court make it. And it may be needed. If he breaches it it amounts to contempt of court and he could be imprisoned for that (but generally for a fairly short time, depending on what he did).

Agree with PP re getting advice from other sources. You could also try a solicitor or the CAB - or some University Law Dept run Law Clinics (run by law students but overseen by lawyers).

The only tricky thing is if your BIL would respect the order and it would make him back off, or just aggravate the situation more.

But it doesn't feel very safe to carry on as you currently are. I would at least get some more advice on it.

RandomMess · 04/02/2022 19:14

Have you spoken to the national domestic violence helpline?

They are the experts on Non-mol orders.

user1488481370 · 04/02/2022 13:15

I’ve spoken to the police about a non-mol and they don’t think we’d get one. They’ve basically said that they don’t want to blow smoke up our arses and that it’ll be a waste of time.

We’ve had to have the firearm’s officer out because OH has a firearms license. He owns a gun which he occasionally uses for clay pigeon shooting maybe once a year, if that. He’s inspected the gun cabinet etc and said that he’s satisfied that all is in good order etc. He pissed me off when he told me not to report ‘every little thing.’ So I was quite blunt with him and told him if I were to report everything that I’d never be off the phone. I don’t think threats of violence, following people to their homes, imitating head butts and punching hands into fists are little things.

OP posts:
RandomMess · 31/01/2022 12:15

I hope the non-mol makes it impossible for them to contribute live on the farm.

Please ring the national domestic violence helpline this morning and get their help to guide you through applying for it.

RandomMess · 31/01/2022 12:14

You need to tell the police that this isn't ok that you will be getting a non-mol because he has hurt your partner before and he continues to try and harm you all including children.

user1488481370 · 31/01/2022 12:12

Front and rear and records sound. I’ve reported it on the non emergency line and they’ve asked me to send over the footage which I’ve done. He’s just on an absolute rampage. I can’t believe they’re so reluctant to act!

OP posts:
CornishTiger · 31/01/2022 11:04

Log the head butting gesture to the police. It was dash cam that got my conviction. Is it front and rear or just front. Is it set up to record sound.

user1488481370 · 31/01/2022 10:03

It’s a really scary position to be in. I was sat in the car yesterday at the farm as OH had some cows to check. BIL walked past the car and imitated like he wanted to head butt me. Just about caught it on dash cam.

OH has seen him and his partner this morning, he was still mad. Said the whole of the country knows what a lazy bastard he is and that he only ‘punched his lights out’ years ago because OH had given their mum a black eye (which OH managed to get on recorded on his phone) so I guess he’s got a case for slander now too! His partner said our children should be taken off us as were ‘not fit’ to parent and that we shouldn’t be buying our children ‘cheap and nasty’ plastic garden toys!

OP posts:
LakieLady · 30/01/2022 11:32

I remember your previous thread, OP, and your BIL sounds like a complete nightmare. And I think it's shocking that the police wouldn't do anything, given that he already has a GBH conviction for the assault on your DH and that this could be a sign that his behaviour is escalating.

If the non-mol is feasible, I'd go for it, tbh.

And yes, for the sake of shutting him up, I'd buy the part for the light and maybe even fit it to save the labour charge. I can't see that you're liable though, wind damage is usually an act of God.

FreedomFaith · 30/01/2022 11:24

Based on things they've done which weren't acts of god (unless you can count the devil controlling them if you believe in this sort of thing), then I'd have laughed in his face and told him to send the bill to god.

LakieLady · 30/01/2022 11:15

@BoredZelda

We’ve had no warning about the weather

Then you weren't paying attention.

The weather warnings weren't for the whole country. We didn't have them in the SE.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 30/01/2022 11:01

@Workinghardeveryday

You are covered under the Liability section of your home insurance, however the cost to repair the car would lightly fall with your excess amount on the policy or be just over. If you do claim it will increase your renewal premium.
You are covered under the Liability section of your home insurance, This is true, but only for things for which you are legally liable - OP doesn't appear to have liability here.
StripedMousse · 30/01/2022 11:01

So your nightmare neighbours are your partner's brother? Wow that is quite shocking. His brother is threatening his own family?

CornishTiger · 30/01/2022 10:59

Thank you @CorsicaDreaming. When I was looking at them because of my neighbour I knew I couldn’t get one. However as he’s a family member you can.

I believe they are free to apply for. I’d suggest you consider how you will allow contact regarding the legal matters of the properties. PO Box maybe.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 30/01/2022 10:57

@ThePlantsitter

People on mumsnet aren't going to be able to tell you what your insurance covers. Ring the insurance company and make a claim.

Yes, you should pay for it. Must be horrible falling out with neighbours who are family, but your wendy house damaged their car so you need to take responsibility. If you do it through insurance hopefully you can do that without actually having to talk to them.

Insurance never covers stuff like this unless you would be legally liable.

Form everything stated there would be no legal liability.

A lot of people seem to think there is strict liability for these things - i.e. it was your wendy house means you are automatically liable - but that's not the case.

Whatsonmymindgrapes · 30/01/2022 10:52

This sounds awful! Is there a sensible family member that can tell BiL to back off?

NewtoHolland · 30/01/2022 10:23

Yes Non-Mol all the way and repeatedly mentioning to the police your concerns for the risks he poses towards your children, as proved by the rat poison and the glass.

What other criminal history does he have?
I reckon if you out Non-Mol in place he will escalate and breach it, then repeatedly breach and end up with consequences.

Does he have other features of anti-social personality disorder? Is this behavior just towards you guys or towards others too?

CorsicaDreaming · 30/01/2022 09:57

@CornishTiger

A non molesation order is only for those who have been intimate partners. You are looking at a civil injunction order or a restraining order as part of a criminal conviction.

I’d complain about the lack of action of Police- you have neighbours and a nephew as witnesses.

This is not correct – you can apply for a molestation order @user1488481370

See the attached information on the government website and look at the non molestation form there. Section 4.4 on page 10 sets out other relationships and you can tick the other box and put brother in law there.

This is exactly the kind of case that you should be using a non-mol order and why they replaced the old system (where only people in sexual relationships could do so)

If granted by the Court, it gives the police immediate powers if he breaches it. Which not only makes their life much easier, but also give them an absolute duty to act.

It does sound like you have got to a point where you really should consider applying for this.

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachmentdata/file/998334/FL401Non-molandocc_order.pdf

CorsicaDreaming · 30/01/2022 09:43

I would be careful about claiming it on insurance when it is probably going to be such a relatively small amount as it may well be it would still affect your claims record and may be your premium will then go up and that would be as much (if not more over time) as cost for replacement of a rear light cover (esp if you can source the part from a breakers yard or off eBay).

It's your DH family, I'd get him to sort it out.

They sound really over reactive and unpleasant tbh 🤨

SockFluffInTheBath · 30/01/2022 09:20

I hope you get it sorted and find a way to get rid of him OP it sounds like a nightmare. It’s a shame you don’t have a slurry tank he could fall into.

CornishTiger · 30/01/2022 09:14

I’ve been here unfortunately personally and still living in fear of the perpetrator. I also work in this arena. It’s crap - I know.

Unfortunately people like this will only stop unless they are made to ( the law) or you move. I know the legal side is a nightmare and going to take money and erode your asset but you need to bring it to an end.

user1488481370 · 30/01/2022 09:05

@CornishTiger your advice has been brilliant, thanks so much. I’ll push and push on this. We’ve looked at the Price of the shields online and they’re around £45. Honestly the way they’ve carried on you’d think it’d been written off.

OP posts:
maddening · 30/01/2022 09:00

If you know what car it is and which lamp it is (it will likely just be the lens cover broken) Google it in Google shopping, on amazon they range from £40 - 100 so replacing it should be easy

CornishTiger · 30/01/2022 08:59

Also look at this website. It is very simple language to understand and shows you how to escalate the authorities response. Look at your local threshold for a community trigger and don’t be afraid to use it. asbhelp.co.uk/anti-social-behaviour/

Swipe left for the next trending thread