Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not having a funeral is OK?

561 replies

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:32

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

OP posts:
Wreath21 · 29/01/2022 14:10

This is starting to look like the competetively-shit-weddings threads - 'oh we got married in food-stained tracksuits and had our reception in a skip, we don't understand how anyone could want to have a nice new outfit and offer the guests champagne...'

Everyone's family circumstances are different. Everyone's experiences of grief and loss vary: plenty of people do find it enormously comforting to have a traditional-style funeral - and there are all sorts of ways that a funeral service can be arranged so it suits the person and their immediate family.
I don't think people should be pushed into having elaborate funerals by people who were less close to the deceased, but nor do I think people should be persuaded not to have a funeral at all if they feel that not having one would distress them further. Really, the people whose wishes take priority are those closest to the deceased (and yes, this can sometimes be enormously difficult because there are certain legal restrictions on who can and cannot arrange a funeral...)

Klippetyklip · 29/01/2022 14:10

@EmbarrassingHadrosaurus

Mum definitely didn't have a basics funeral. But nowhere near 7k at a basic cost.

I wonder if there are strong national and regional differences through the UK?

My dad’s was a basic funeral due to covid restrictions. We also chose a basic coffin (he didn’t like fuss) and just 2 cars. There was obviously no wake. It still cost just over 5k. We live in Yorkshire.
MagnoliatheMagnificent · 29/01/2022 14:08

Such a personal thing but ultimately up to you.
My sister has a terminal illness and has decided to donate her body to medical science. They take her body and when they no longer need it she will be cremated by them. So no funeral. Her choice. Felt a bit weird to me but it's what she wants.

Gatehouse77 · 29/01/2022 14:07

Any alternative is for those left behind to do as they wish. I feel it’s their choice at that point.

Stuffin · 29/01/2022 14:06

For those that say you must have a funeral for the living I wonder how many would be prepared to fund it themselves.

It is an awful lot of money for some families let alone the emotional toll of organising it.

My DM had a funeral because that was her wish and we had discussed it as she was diagnosed with terminal cancer long before she died. But if she had wanted no funeral I would have been perfectly happy to do that as well. For me it's not about the living but honouring the persons wishes who had died.

SportsMother · 29/01/2022 14:06

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Suzanne999 · 29/01/2022 14:06

I’m having direct cremation, no funeral as I think funerals are miserable and a lot of the time people turn up because they feel they have to.
Friend had direct cremation for her husband about 15 years ago, before it was a thing really. She couldn’t bear the thought of being at the crem so after the ashes were returned to her she chose where to scatter them, lots of friends turned up and we toasted him with champagne and generally looked after her. It wasn’t raucous but it wasn’t miserable or tearful either.

Moonmelodies · 29/01/2022 14:06

Can you simply refuse to collect a dead person from the hospital, and let them deal with the disposal?

SportsMother · 29/01/2022 14:05

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

AlDanvers · 29/01/2022 14:03

@EmbarrassingHadrosaurus

Mum definitely didn't have a basics funeral. But nowhere near 7k at a basic cost.

I wonder if there are strong national and regional differences through the UK?

Possibly, but 50% is a huge variation. Mum's also Included being brought home the night before and someone staying a few hours. Then someone else coming early the next day.
Sportslady44 · 29/01/2022 14:02

yes its fine and its becoming more popular. Lots of older people dont have many people that could attend a funeral anyway, the people they know are old or passed on themselves.

Its a great and cheaper alternative.

ddl1 · 29/01/2022 14:01

ThePlantsitter:

*I think I should probably have been clearer and was a bit glib on a topic that doesn't really suit glibness. No offence was intended but I can totally see why it might be taken and I do apologise for that.

I think people should be able to do whatever they want about relatives' funerals including not having one. I think that planning a direct cremation with no conversation about it beforehand could well feel like telling a child (in particular) that you should grieve in the way the parent wants them to and leaves no room for the huge variety of emotion that happens after someone dies and the huge variety of comfort people can take from different funeral arrangements.*

Thanks - no problem - sorry I was a bit touchy!

I do agree with your second paragraph; but I think it can apply to any situation where the parent doesn't consult the child in advance: e.g. they unexpectedly find that their parent demands a 'big send-off' which causes great discomfort and sometime debt for the children.

MananaTomorrow · 29/01/2022 13:58

@Tara336

I don’t want a funeral either, I have found it so distressing attending them and it just made everything more painful waiting in a weird limbo between losing the person and then attending the funeral. I don’t want to put the people I love through that. A direct cremation and just let my close family have a lovely meal together is much kinder in my mind. I find wakes awful as well
Who says that everyone will have the same experience than you though?

I have been to the funeral of my gran and FIL. I found them helpful for myself. I know my MIL found it helpful and so did DH.

MananaTomorrow · 29/01/2022 13:56

I think there are several issues there.

  • no funeral for someone who was religious is awful tbh. If there is one thing that should be respected it is their religious beliefs and that should come first imo.
  • for someone to say they don’t want a funeral once they are dead is crap. Bar religious reasons, funerals are for the livings not the dead. I think it’s up to the people who are left to decide what’s best for them.
Tara336 · 29/01/2022 13:54

I don’t want a funeral either, I have found it so distressing attending them and it just made everything more painful waiting in a weird limbo between losing the person and then attending the funeral. I don’t want to put the people I love through that. A direct cremation and just let my close family have a lovely meal together is much kinder in my mind. I find wakes awful as well

VioletOcean · 29/01/2022 13:54

It’s definitely the persons choice.
If you want cremation only that fine
If your dh wants funeral that fine
What ever you as an individual decides is fine

Co op cremation only in 2020 cost £1800 all in. Having dealt with the death, coroner, finances etc I was worn down to pieces and couldn’t raise a single thought let alone make funeral plans. Person wanted to be cremated so they got their wish, I stayed at home. 2 relatives moaned there was no funeral, I said they were welcome to plan and pay if in excess of £2k (all I had) and they soon stfu

Huntswomanonthemove · 29/01/2022 13:51

As a family, we don't do funerals. Instead we have a get together with food and we celebrate our loved ones life. I works for us.

Blossomtoes · 29/01/2022 13:50

@userxx

I hate funerals and don't want my own, Id like a direct cremation, then a celebration of life party for people for whoever wants to go, lots of nice food, nice wine and happiness.
I have no idea why you care - you won’t be there whatever they have.
TheWernethWife · 29/01/2022 13:49

I'm having a Pure Cremation, my partner, son and granddaughter have been told to go out and have a bloody good booze up and remember me that way.

My daughter doesn't know about it, nothing to do with her as she shut the door in my face 8 years ago, as I had complained about her second husband being a racist/fascist, which he definitely is.

whenwilliwillibefamous · 29/01/2022 13:49

Doesn't stop them organizing a wake or memorial service, does it?
I chose direct burial for my Mum, just very close relations present and no service, but organized a separate memorial/wake gathering. The prospect of elderly friends of hers slipping on winter mud in the cemetery and falling in the grave did not appeal!
And we were able to go to town on the big gathering. A friend's funeral had the undertakers looking daggers as we were overrunning the crem slot, AND the celebrant got his name wrong. This sort of nonsense definitely pushed me towards a more diy, pick and mix approach!

Wreath21 · 29/01/2022 13:49

@D0lphine

I agree that the wait for funerals is ridiculous.

Other cultures have it right- 48 hours and it's done, no messing. If you can get there fine if you can't you can't.

I've had 6 week waits and it just feels like everything is on pause until it's happened. Piss take.

The average time between death and funeral is about 3 weeks where I am based. It's worth remembering that there is only so much capacity at any crematorium or cemetery - as it is, some people find crematorium ceremonies a bit 'conveyer belt' so the number of crems/graveyards in the area in ratio to the number of people dying there is a factor in the timing. Another factor, particularly these days, is the legal requirements for certain forms to be completed - you cannot proceed without these being done and some doctors are lazy buggers really overwhelmed with work and can't prioritize death paperwork over live patients.
icedancerlenny · 29/01/2022 13:43

We’ve just had this with a member of my family and it was awful. There was no closure. It’s feels like nothing had happened. I haven’t cried or grieved. I wouldn’t wish this on anyone.

BigYellowHat · 29/01/2022 13:43

My dad had a direct cremation and then a wake down at the pub. If you’d have known him it was so ‘him’. Everyone just relaxed and getting merry talking about the good old days. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with it.

Wreath21 · 29/01/2022 13:43

@Brainwave89

We have already organised this. Cheapest possible arrangement for a cremation and then a really good wake with a great free bar and entertainment and loads of opportunities to reminisce and tell good stories. FME with my parents funerals, the industry can be a rip off- very high costs at a time when people are grieving and people relying on funeral directors to tell then what is expected. Also if everything is organised it takes the pressure off your relatives at a time of real stress.
Any industry can be a rip off. When I am dealing with bereaved people I try to be as clear as possible about the breakdown of costs and where you can economise if necessary. And yet we still get people wanting £10000 coffins and horse-drawn hearses with six limousines, plus a marching band and a flight of doves. And there are certainly cultural variations in what is expected and wanted (have at least once supported a bereaved daughter in standing up to the neighbours who thought she should have the full monty when she and her late mum had wanted to keep things simple).
DoraSpenlow · 29/01/2022 13:42

I hate funerals. Having buried/cremated my parents and in-laws I found them horrific. Extra pressure when you are already at your very lowest. Gained no comfort from them at all. Everyone around me also agreeing and just wishing it was all over.

Don't understand how people say they can't grieve or say goodbye if there is no funeral. I am still grieving for my Mum and she died very suddenly from a stroke 20 years ago. I miss Dad terribly too but he had dementia and in the end I also felt relief hat he was no longer suffering. Often have a little tear when dusting their photos even now. Attending a funeral doesn't draw a line under grief.

So, I want a direct cremation and for everyone who wants to, to meet at our local a few months afterwards when a little of the sting has gone. Have a good drink and talk about all the daft things I did during my life.

I understand that everyone is different though.