Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not having a funeral is OK?

561 replies

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:32

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

OP posts:
jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 18:47

@EmmaH2022

I know how you feel

I think it's fine to do this

But when my dad died, mum felt too many people would be upset if we didn't have a funeral. It was horrendous. I have been to funerals before and I felt differently when I was young and the deceased were young - though I'd respect their wishes regardless.

I don't feel able to ask mum what she wants but I really don't want to go through a parent funeral again. It's not comforting, it's not helpful.

She has some really awful friends too. The sort I wouldn't want to have my phone number.

If she doesn't leave instructions and siblings are okay with it, then it will be a direct cremation.

I'm so sorry to hear this. How your mother felt, about having to have a funeral, is how I fear my DC would feel. I want it to truly be up to them, and for them not to feel pressured to do as society or certain people expect.
OP posts:
freshcarnation · 29/01/2022 18:46

The last family funeral we had was for MiL several years ago. It cost well over 10k and was a truly traumatic and awful day for the family. We all agreed that from then on it would be direct cremation for this family. When FIL died in lockdown we had a direct cremation for him and brought his ashes home to be scattered. We had a lovely dinner a few months later in his honour. It's the way to go for us all now. Removed the trauma from the funeral process for us.

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 18:45

@pantjog

I think funerals can potentially be very cathartic and an important part of the grieving process.
This is what I have always thought. But it's only today I have counted how many I have been to, and as yet it hasn't been that way for me. I don't know if that will change or if I'm just one of those people that doesn't get anything from them.
OP posts:
Volterra · 29/01/2022 18:44

I had the conversation about releasing payment to funeral director recently.Apparently I need to take the funeral invoice to any branch of Lloyd’s and they will settle it directly in 2 hours.

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 18:43

@godmum56

I think two things.....people are posting on here about how they would feel....which is not how your family would feel. Have you got family other than your small children? Because TBH if they are too young to discuss it, then whatever happens, if it happens while they are young, it will be "normal" for them. Similarly when they are old enough to discuss it, then your decision will be "normal" for them. As others have said, some companies offer various kinds of package....I think the only ones who only offer a true no options direct cremation are the ones who only offer that service and what may suit you better is an existing company who have added in direct cremation to their existing options. Last time I checked, some of the prepay services also offered options for the bereaved to add in other options at the point of burial if they wished to do so.....its not one or the other, there are middle way options to think about. In every case in my family, good byes were said before the funeral and, to me at least, the funeral was only a source of stress and distress.
This is such a helpful post. Thank you.

In a way I think I would like no funeral to be the norm for my DC. My all means a memorial or something if they choose. But I really haven't found funerals healing or helpful in processing.

I do hate the thought of them having to organise a funeral from scratch so a company who offer packages could be a good idea too, without limiting their options. Having lost my brother at a young age I think I fear my own mortality, and hate the thought of my DC having to plan a funeral at a young age etc.

OP posts:
Porcupineintherough · 29/01/2022 18:43

@Blossomtoes a "fancy" funeral, which is what we are talking about here, is likely to cost upwards of 10k, given that a basic one is often not that much less than 5k. Not everyone has 10k in their current or bank savings account and if the money is sat in stocks, shares, long term isas or house value, its not going to be available 3 weeks after death. Maybe some funeral homes will extend credit but I've never dealt with one that said "after probate will be fine".

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 18:39

@AlDanvers re:

And yet, you still think its fine to use such a negative word when other people are telling you it important to them.

Fair dos. Can't umagine your friends like it when you tell them their wedding and christening is archaic. But each to their own.

_

That is their choice, and I have no problem with it. This is about me, and when I die. My friends all agree church weddings are old fashioned but some of them like that which is why they have them. The world would be boring if we all liked the same thing.

I am coming at this with my own personal experience, realising how terrible I find funerals to experience. The responses on this thread show that I am not alone in that. I don't want my DC to feel they must organise a funeral. If it will help them so be it, but equally I don't want two children disagreeing over how they think it should be, so I feel it best I take some form of control and either plan something I don't want or go for a direct cremation. I want to make sure I don't rob them of something that might be important to them which is why I started this thread, to open up my perspective some more.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 29/01/2022 18:37

So there may not be cash immediately available to pay for a fancy funeral, even if the sum might eventually be reclaimed from your estate.

Most, if not all, banks release the payment for the funeral on presentation of the funeral directors’ invoice.

Porcupineintherough · 29/01/2022 18:34

All those of you stating that the living can make a decision - does that mean they can go against clear wishes/religious faith.

Yep. I mean I'm sure it would be difficult to give an Orthodox Jew a Christian burial (hopefully the vicar would refuse) but no one can make your relatives either give you a religious burial or insist they do. It may be morally wrong but it's not illegal.

I'm sure you would find it insulting if the dead person had arranged for a fancy funeral and their relatives went 'sod that' we'll keep the money and have them directly cremated instead.

Yes and no. If its prepaid its one thing but when you die your accounts are frozen (unless they are joint accounts). So there may not be cash immediately available to pay for a fancy funeral, even if the sum might eventually be reclaimed from your estate. Alternatively if it is a joint account then the surviving member is not legally obliged to shell out for an expensive funeral, even if you wished it.

The dead have very limited control over what happens after their death, except via their wills which are not dealt with quickly enough to deal with funerals.

gonnabeok · 29/01/2022 18:31

My friend did this. She died of cancer. She was cremated but did not want friends or family there.She explained it to everyone and they respected her wishes. Its perfectly fine if that's what the person's wishes are. Their wishes should be respected. Friends and family can remember the person in whatever ways they choose to.

Pinkyantelope · 29/01/2022 18:30

The hymns are the best part. I don't think 'modern music' is necessarily better at helping people through their grief.*

Yes but that's you doing you. The OP said she's not religious and doesn't enjoy those kind of funerals, hence my post.

Wreath21 · 29/01/2022 18:23

@YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp

My DH and adult DCs are fully aware of my wishes to leave my body to medical science or the simplest, least fuss way, probably direct cremation and my ashes scattered on the beach at Shell Bay. Then they can go for a lovely meal somewhere overlooking the sea afterwards. My father’s cremation service was hijacked by one of my siblings; he was vehemently anti religion but they insisted on hymns and prayers.
Yes: that happens sometimes and it is very distressing (and not much fun for the funeral company who have to do their best to mediate between fighting family members - there is only so much we can do with regard to the legal aspects of who gets to have their own way...)
YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 29/01/2022 18:12

My DH and adult DCs are fully aware of my wishes to leave my body to medical science or the simplest, least fuss way, probably direct cremation and my ashes scattered on the beach at Shell Bay. Then they can go for a lovely meal somewhere overlooking the sea afterwards.
My father’s cremation service was hijacked by one of my siblings; he was vehemently anti religion but they insisted on hymns and prayers.

Blossomtoes · 29/01/2022 18:06

I get the impression that some people's horror of funerals is down to thinking it has to be some local minister when the deceased wasn't religious, and that you have to have hymns/prayers/flowers. You really don't.

This. My dad wasn’t remotely religious so we had a humanist service with his favourite music and the poem he read for my mum at their Diamond wedding. I spent days writing the eulogy to ensure it was just right for him. Organising it was a labour of love. The packed crematorium for a man approaching his 100th birthday was immensely moving and comforting.

6ixty9ine · 29/01/2022 17:14

@SportsMother

How is it crap if they choose it? Nobody here is talking about overriding the wishes of the dead, except those insisting of a funeral.

It’s crap if they don’t discuss it, and just land it on adult children without considering their feelings. That’s why some people might feel it’s a fuck you, because there is a standard-ish way of acknowledging death. And when you if effect say “Screw that” without warning, it would be hurtful. That’s why you have to talk about it.

Doesn't mean you have to blacklist their name or something, they just don't want a traditional all black funeral. You can still presumably have a memorial and meet with friends and family. They don't want their money spent on an unnecessary (as they see) ceremony - rather to go to their family.

sirfredfredgeorge · 29/01/2022 16:32

I'm dead, so I can't give a shit what the people who are alive want to do, I would much rather there was a direct cremation, but I am in no way going to dictate or even pre-pay for such a thing, just leave it to the living. You can let them know your ideas and desires, but you're dead, so utterly pointless dictating anything.

Furrydog7 · 29/01/2022 16:30

I don't want a funeral. My granddad died during the third lock down and i got absolutely nothing from the service. I was ccounting down the minutes until i could remove my face covering. It helped me fa r more when i went on holiday last September.

Kickers567 · 29/01/2022 16:18

@jevoudrais

That's interesting to know *@Kickers567* I wasn't aware of that, food for thought. Thank you for sharing.
It may be possible to still have this care before being cremated without a ceremony, and it's important to note that not all funeral packages include it either.

I paid £3500 (South East, very close to london) which was a very basic level (cheapest coffin, just the herse and no family cars, made our own order of service, ashes in a cardboard box) but felt it had the dignity and respect my dad deserved.

It stuck with me when I was speaking about what I'd chosen for him to wear and an older family friend who had lost her 90 year old mum said the funeral home hadn't asked what she should wear so she must have been cremated in the old nighty she was taken away in... :(

Wreath21 · 29/01/2022 16:16

As with a lot of things: if you dislike funerals, you don't have to participate (though, as with a lot of things that involve other people, sometimes there has to be compromise). However, why is it so hard to understand that plenty of people do find funerals comforting and would be distressed if they couldn't hold/attend one. Let's not forget how many people's grief over a bereavement during the worst of the Covid lockdowns was increased by the fact that they couldn't give their loved ones what they considered an appropriate send-off. Their feelings are just as valid as those of the ones who dislike ceremonies.

And I honestly think it's very very important to talk about funerals and make people aware that they can have whatever kind of ceremony they want (within reason - sky burial is neither legal nor appropriate in the UK, for instance). I get the impression that some people's horror of funerals is down to thinking it has to be some local minister when the deceased wasn't religious, and that you have to have hymns/prayers/flowers. You really don't.

Furries · 29/01/2022 15:46

@Gwenhwyfar

"I find it a bit rude that you think it’s ok to question what we’ve decided amongst us!"

Um, it's a thread about whether funerals are useful or not so we should be able to discuss that.

Equally, it’s fine for me to think you’re rude by questioning what my family has decided.
feelsobadfeltsogood · 29/01/2022 15:42

When my mum died the funeral was over £5000 service at church, crem and wake, flowers etc...
My dad hardly has any friends and to be honest I'd say ideally just the crem and a small family get together would suffice however I think some family members will have other ideas

Batoutofhell70 · 29/01/2022 15:40

My friends dad did this. It was within the last year so funeral would have been limited anyway but she didn't like it

Oblomov22 · 29/01/2022 15:35

I too don't understand why people don't meet instead and raise a glass to the person at say the pub.
I've been to 2 funerals recently and still feel this.

willingtolearn · 29/01/2022 15:11

Massive waste of money from my point of view.

Had the experience recently of being told a direct cremation was 'not proper' so that various relations who had not bothered with my father in years could turn up to 'pay their respects' - fat lot of use that was to him as he spent his last days lonely and in pain.

I'm for Direct cremation for myself - as is my husband and as it will be my money paying for it it should be my decision. I'm not sure I like the assumption that the financial gifts I might choose to give in my will can be relied upon. There might only just be enough money to pay the bills etc - it would be against everything I am for someone to piss money away on pointless flowers and family cars so that they and random relatives (of which I have many) personally 'felt better'. My children are aware of my thoughts.

All those of you stating that the living can make a decision - does that mean they can go against clear wishes/religious faith.

I'm sure you would find it insulting if the dead person had arranged for a fancy funeral and their relatives went 'sod that' we'll keep the money and have them directly cremated instead.

Darbs76 · 29/01/2022 14:57

A colleagues dad did that recently, my colleague was ok with his wishes. I personally found it healing to plan a lovely funeral and get to say goodbye