Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not having a funeral is OK?

561 replies

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:32

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

OP posts:
JoBrodie · 30/01/2022 11:08

My lovely dad (died 2016) stipulated no funeral and he wanted cremation. I didn't know about Direct Disposal until a friend mentioned it and my dad would have loved the efficiency of it. The funeral receptionist person I spoke to about it, with my online print-out from some 'Funeral Options Today' website, hadn't heard of it herself but agreed to get back to me and everyone said 'yes, that's fine'.

They wrote me a letter to say his body would be picked up from the hospital morgue on Day X and taken to Crematorium Y for cremation at Time Z. I wasn't forbidden from attending but it wasn't expected (there's nothing in place for visitors or guests really so it would be a bit odd) and for his ashes to be scattered in the garden there. £1,200 or thereabouts.

Dad and I were not remotely 'romantic' about death and I really wasn't in the right frame of mind to organise anything like that, and would have hated an event myself so I was quite glad he'd said that there shouldn't be one.

Jo

WeatherwaxOn · 30/01/2022 08:46

Can't see voting but the no funeral thing is what one of my parents wanted. So that's what we did.
Some months later we organised a celebration of their life, inviting friends and family to get together. We had a nice time (although tineged with sadness that parent wasn't there, obviously). I think I would prefer that, too.

A friend of mine who doesn't have a long life expectancy had just made arrangements for andirect cremation for themselves too.

SleepQuest33 · 30/01/2022 08:22

I’m loving the sound of a direct burial, hadn’t heard of it.
I’m pretty sure I’ve read that cremations are terrible for the environment.
Also scattering ashes is really bad for wildlife.
So I’m hoping for a simple biodegradable coffin with a tree planted near me.

Hesma · 30/01/2022 07:29

Personally I think this is something that should be talking to your DC about. Explain your experience and thinking to them otherwise yes, you may be making their grieving process harder.

NewbieDivergent · 30/01/2022 03:45

Have started discussing this with my mum,shes 66,has copd and heavy smoker with a well hearty drinking life so who knows how long shes got.She is adamant about being cremated so the plan at the moment is direct cremation and a piss up celebration of her life(should be fun I'm teatotal) all siblings happy to go along with her wishes.

SquirrelG · 30/01/2022 03:34

@Furries - I agree. While funerals may be for the living rather than the dead, if someone has made known their funeral wishes it is disrespectful to ignore them just because they don't suit what the family want.

Furries · 30/01/2022 03:03

What I’m finding difficult from this thread is some people asserting that the “dead” have no rights over their personal wishes.

I totally get that some people may find a full-on service comforting/cathartic etc. but to go against what the deceased wishes just feels wrong to me.

Personalky, I would find it hugely disrespectful, to the person that has died, to ignore their final wish. It might not be what I want, but that person mattered in life and, if they expressed their wish beforehand, then that is what I’d honour. My grief would be my grief - it would never override what the person I loved had expressed as their preference.

DerAlteMann · 30/01/2022 03:02

MIL had direct cremation. We said goodbye when we scattered her ashes. DW loved it so much, she wants the same and I agree with her.

SquirrelG · 30/01/2022 02:51

There is also a lot of evidence to suggest that humans cannot really process that a death has really occurred to a close loved one until they see a body. They need that visual closure.

For some people, but we are all different. I didn't see my DM's body after death, and I had a direct cremation for her. I processed the fact that she was dead as soon as I heard the news (she died suddenly in a rest home) - and my mother and I were very close. I wanted to remember her as she was the last time I saw her. I didn't have her ashes interred until recently - she died almost two years ago - and felt no differently afterwards than I did before. Some of us really don't require "closure".

SquirrelG · 30/01/2022 02:46

Part of the reason you may have to wait is legal: if the person's death was unexpected ie they did not have a terminal illness/were not at the stage of 'end of life care' and particularly if their own doctor hadn't seen them as a patient for a few weeks, then a coroner will be involved and there will be a postmortem. And you can't have the funeral until the coroner's office sign the relevant form.

I understand that - but we have unexpected deaths in NZ as well, and there is no great wait time for post mortems. The only time a funeral will be held more than a week after death is usually if there is a time delay in family members being able to get to the funeral.

WeighaFreya · 30/01/2022 02:43

@Torunette

What I would say is think carefully about dispensing with rituals.

Rituals create boundaries, and recognise a transition into a different stage of the life course. As humans, we created them for a purpose.

I would argue funerals are not really about "saying goodbye". On a deeper level, they are more about recognising formally that something significant has changed, that life going forward will be different than how it was before, and that change being formally registered by a wider circle of people.

Not doing the funeral ritual does not dispense with the pain. It is a way for the living to face it, rather than tuck it away -- to face the "goneness" of death.

There is also a lot of evidence to suggest that humans cannot really process that a death has really occurred to a close loved one until they see a body. They need that visual closure.

I worry sometimes that we react to rituals that feel old-fashioned by chucking them out, rather than reforming them. There are lots of funeral directors who will work with a family to deliver a ritual that is not old-fashioned. My mother, for example, had a white wool coffin and a service at a local memorial chapel with poems and a eulogy written as though it was a fairy tale.

And her funeral was extremely painful, though there were moments of smiling. But it was necessary. It was a event that marked the transition between being a married man and a widower for my DF, and having a living mother and no longer having a living mother for me.

I would suggest that if you dispense with a funeral, you need to put something else of equal weight in place. The problem there is that a very alternative ritual with no real antecedents for that purpose may not be sufficiently resonant enough to hit the right psychological notes for attendees, and there are dangers of going somewhere that, at the moment you turn up, ends up feeling very inappropriate.

I agree totally with the above,

Having only got half way through the thread so far I don't know if anyone has mentioned having a Humanist celebrant. My son's funeral was the first I had done anything other than bog standard C of E. Bog standard for my family of origen that is - I don't consider it the norm for everyone of course.

She made it an incredibly personal ceremony. Not religious, but giving a respectful acknowledgement and space for those of religious convictions .

Bolstered by this, my daughter and I went for a Humanist celebrant for my husband a year later. He was great and with his support and help from the hospital mortury staff my daughter and I did not use a funeral director. Made the service totally ours and how my husband would have appreciated it.

So, when planning whatever comes next when someone you love dies, it's OK to do it a bit differently.

We're thinking about mine now and I'm owning it in advance. It should be an interesting experience and I've found myself inviting people in advance.

The mark of a sucessful funeral, IMO, is to think 'I wish the deceased could have been here, it was just right for them and they'd have appreciated it'

Not like my father's. A dire off the peg service. Absolutely awful.

Link to the Humanist website -> humanists.uk/ceremonies/non-religious-funerals/

Poppins2016 · 30/01/2022 02:40

My father in law was adamant that he didn't want a funeral. We respected his wishes and we scattered his ashes (in the place he requested) as a small group of close family and then went for a meal afterwards, so I suppose there was a sort of informal memorial. I don't feel that I or any of the others 'missed out' on any sense of closure through doing it in this unconventional manner.

Having said the above, I do feel that funerals are for the living and with that in mind I would allow the people left behind to make the choice (perhaps stating how you feel in case it sways the decision).

Wreath21 · 30/01/2022 02:22

Part of the reason you may have to wait is legal: if the person's death was unexpected ie they did not have a terminal illness/were not at the stage of 'end of life care' and particularly if their own doctor hadn't seen them as a patient for a few weeks, then a coroner will be involved and there will be a postmortem. And you can't have the funeral until the coroner's office sign the relevant form.
Most funeral firms will book a date for you while you're waiting for the coroner's paperwork on the understanding that it might have to change. But, again, as I posted upthread, where you live is another factor in terms of the availability of crematoria/cemeteries.

tomorrowisanother · 30/01/2022 02:18

I have also told certain members of my family that I want a direct funeral/ cremation.
If it is good enough of David Bowie, it is good enough for me!!

Wreath21 · 30/01/2022 02:09

@Porcupineintherough

All those of you stating that the living can make a decision - does that mean they can go against clear wishes/religious faith.

Yep. I mean I'm sure it would be difficult to give an Orthodox Jew a Christian burial (hopefully the vicar would refuse) but no one can make your relatives either give you a religious burial or insist they do. It may be morally wrong but it's not illegal.

I'm sure you would find it insulting if the dead person had arranged for a fancy funeral and their relatives went 'sod that' we'll keep the money and have them directly cremated instead.

Yes and no. If its prepaid its one thing but when you die your accounts are frozen (unless they are joint accounts). So there may not be cash immediately available to pay for a fancy funeral, even if the sum might eventually be reclaimed from your estate. Alternatively if it is a joint account then the surviving member is not legally obliged to shell out for an expensive funeral, even if you wished it.

The dead have very limited control over what happens after their death, except via their wills which are not dealt with quickly enough to deal with funerals.

If you prepay a funeral before you die, that money goes to the funeral company you nominated. (Some funeral prepay plans are done via specific funeral homes, some are not - and they can be transferred if, for instance, the plan was taken out decades ago and the nominated-at-the-time funeral home no longer exists). If you die without a prepaid plan, the one payment your bank will happily make on request is to the funeral directrs (unless you died with less than the cost of a funeral in the bank). Paying for your funeral doesn't have to wait for probate.
ABitOfAShitShow · 30/01/2022 01:45

I don’t want a funeral. There is a piece of music and a poem that I would like people to read/listen to in their own time if they want to remember me. Neither are anything to do with me but I come from a musical background and the poem captures what I think is important in life. I’d also prefer not to be in a jar on anyone’s sideboard (but have no special place I care to be scattered).

It’s not just that I don’t see the point - I actively don’t want people formally gathered while someone witters on about me.

CreamFirstThenJamOnTop · 30/01/2022 00:39

My dad has said he wants a direct cremation with no funeral, no memorial, no wake etc.

I do find it sad, as I would prefer to have a funeral for him when the time comes but I have promised him that I’ll respect his wishes. His life, his death and up to him what happens is my view.

mjf981 · 30/01/2022 00:35

I recently lost my Grandmother, who had been ill for a few years now. Her passing was a relief as she was suffering towards the end. As I live in a different country and travel was next to impossible, I watched her funeral online. I took the day off work and expected to be distraught ( we were very close growing up.) However, I wasn't. I just felt a bit sad but not much else. On reflection, I think I had already grieved her passing as her disease progressed. The funeral imho was a formality but did nothing to aid my grieving process.

SquirrelG · 30/01/2022 00:13

Can someone explain why there is such a long wait between the passing and burial/cremation of someone in England? Is it a logistics thing?

That's something I have often wondered. I'm in NZ and funerals are usually held within a few days of the death.

SquirrelG · 30/01/2022 00:10

I've been to enough funerals to not wish that upon the few that love me. It is hideous and I'm forever surprised we put ourselves through such misery.

That is exactly the way I feel. I would rather remember the person as I last saw them, and don't feel any sort of need to "say goodbye" (I don't understand what the point of that is) with a funeral service. I had a direct cremation for my DM and have never felt any sort of "delayed grief" from not having a service. My DF now wants one for himself.

HailAdrian · 29/01/2022 23:49

My mum didn't have a funeral and I don't really care, nothing would have made anyone feel better.

Drunkpanda · 29/01/2022 23:48

I would not be happy about this with a member of my family. Organising the funeral gives you something "to do" at a very difficult time - something practical. It provides a focal point for your initial grief.
Where I'm from funerals happen quickly so there isn't the wait the OP refers to.

Kite22 · 29/01/2022 23:43

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye?

Yes.
Like so many others, I find a funeral cathartic and an immensely important part of the grieving process. I understand what @astoundedgoat means (and she did clarify she was NOT talking about children's funerals, but was specifically talking about after an older person has died after a full and happy life). What I find to be much more common in recent years is a 'Celebration of Life' or a 'Thanksgiving Service' after the cremation - and I think this is a really positive thing.
OP I don't think your limited experience of funerals has given you perhaps enough of a look at how funerals can be. I don't recognise the 6 week wait and I don't recognise 'being in processions' as part of my experience of going to loads of funerals.
I can see that a Church service isn't for everyone - obviously particularly people who aren't Church goers - but I do think a "coming together" of people who are grieving is a really important part of the grieving process for most people.
Indeed, I knew someone who had donated her body for medical research so there was no body to cremate, and who had no religious belief so she had said no funeral. After a couple of months, her dh made the difficult decision to then arrange something as it just felt so wrong to have just 'carried on' without a chance to come together and say goodbye.

3scape · 29/01/2022 23:33

I don't hold any religious beliefs i hate the idea of some meaningless nonsense that my family would have to pay for! Funerals are bigg fuss money making scheme of expectation and exploiting the bereaved.

I've made it very clear to my family i really want just the legal bare bones (pun slightly intended) and whatever then works for them.

Ophanim · 29/01/2022 23:22

Where I am most people who go for cremation get cremated very soon after death and memorial services are held afterwards, sometimes a week later, sometimes several months later, but the cremation always seems to happen first.

I said I didn’t want a funeral and I didn’t want my ashes buried or placed in any one particular place; I want to be everywhere and nowhere at the same time. I don’t want my family feeling obliged to visit or maintain a gravesite. MIL was horrified and said I MUST have a final resting place for the sake of the kids etc. 🤷‍♀️