Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not having a funeral is OK?

561 replies

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:32

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

OP posts:
Chely · 29/01/2022 10:57

YANBU people should respect your wishes.

Funerals are very much for the living. I am not a fan and would like minimal fuss when I pop my clogs.

SportsMother · 29/01/2022 10:54

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 29/01/2022 10:54

This is what I've planned.

My kids know, and understand and there's no feeling of "fuck you" Confused

Funerals are just the absolute worst, having arranged 2 for my children I don't want anyone having that pressure for me when I die.

AuntieMarys · 29/01/2022 10:54

@user1491404899

Working in this industry I see alot of families hurt by direct cremation. We get them sobbing at our door asking why their loved one isn't allowing them to grieve. Often direct cremations aren't done locally, you are shipped off to a central crem often miles away. So family can't even come to 'wave you off'.

Please discuss what you want with your family but please listen to what they want too.

Funerals are for the living not the dead.

That is why families need to discuss plans beforehand so it doesn't come as a surprise. I disagree with you about funerals being for the living. Why should I pay for something I don't want or believe in, and find abhorrent?
Gardengates · 29/01/2022 10:54

I think that with the wait times for death certificates and cremation slots, the process can already be very disjointed.

DF died suddenly so had to have a PM and we didn't even get a death certificate for 4 weeks. Then it was another 3 weeks before we could get a slot at the crematorium, and that was if we were willing to go in at 8:30am.

I think a directed cremation with instructions and money for a wake would have been much better.

The family are in control of the timeline and can make it a celebration. I was living abroad when he died and was in limbo for weeks, not knowing whether to go back home or wait for the funeral. With small kids, it was horrendous.

As long as you make people aware what and why you are planning, I think it would be fine.

Honeyroar · 29/01/2022 10:53

My best friend died a couple of years ago. She didn’t want a funeral but a party with her fave music etc. So she was cremated with just five of us there. No music, no words, nothing. I don’t know why we went really. We went out for a meal afterwards. Then we had the wake later. It really didn’t work. People wanted to grieve. We played her music, put up photos, had her urn in the middle, like she wanted, but it was awkward and painful. I think of people had gone to the cream and cried there, they’d possibly have been able to cope with the party not afterwards.

AlDanvers · 29/01/2022 10:53

@jevoudrais

Also if I leave money for a knees up that wouldn't be til a year or so down the line anyway, I don't think you can get probate sorted much sooner than that?!
That's not always the case.

Dad didn't have to wait for probate. They had individual and joint accounts at HSBC. He advised then of her death then took the paperwork and all the cash was transferred straight to him. The house is in joint names etc

If you die before dh, he may not need to wait for probate to have a get together, paid for by you .

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:53

@ShavingTheBadger thanks for sharing your experience. I'm sorry to hear you lost your brother too.

I would be happy for there to be some kind of gathering. I think it's the archaic structure of a funeral and the procession etc that goes with it that I dislike and find upsetting. Something like
other posters have suggested around gatherings to scatter ashes and all coming together is a better option for me. Informal, outdoors, and a lot of the admin junk that needs sorting out before you can say goodbye has all been dealt with.

OP posts:
HomeHomeInTheRange · 29/01/2022 10:53

There are other options.

A get together, with a celebrant or not, at a time and place of the family’s choosing.

Ash scattering at a place and time if the family’s choosing.

A ceremony in a municipal crematorium that means nothing as a venue does not have to be the default.

Formal funerals in crematoria or churches are not part of our family culture or priorities. Remembering, mourning and celebrating those we love is.

Talk to your family.

In the end, they will do what they most want at the time.

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2022 10:52

Yanbu

Depends on the circumstances but imo funerals make things far worse if you're immediate family/tragic death/young person.

I've buried both parents, only sibling and a best friend. They were torture. I had to put on a performance and it exacerbated my grief. I just wanted to hide. They were traumatic ordeals in themselves.

And the platitudes from the hangers on...

I wouldn't put my kids through that.

PermanentTemporary · 29/01/2022 10:52

I get that you have been in such pain. What about a death where there was no funeral though? Have you experienced that?

When my dh died the funeral was - oh it was so important. Puttibg the coffin in the ground was intensely painful but we shared the pain.

Later at the memorial we found a better place. Ds smiled for the first time in a month - he was surrounded by his friendswho just wanted to help - he'sso bonded to them, ever since. His parents saw that over a hundred people wanted to say goodbye to him. People talked about all the best times in his life and the man he really was. I had cousins come from overseas, my dad came from 60 miles away in his late 80s. Ill never forget it.

Cocogreen · 29/01/2022 10:52

I think it's ok.
It's whatever suits your family.

An older man I knew ( in his 80s) donated his body to science so there was no funeral because there was no body and he didn't want a memorial service.

Instead the family invited everyone who had known him in any capacity and wanted to pay respect to his local pub.
About 80 - 100 people dropped in over the course of an afternoon to have a drink and raise a glass to him.
There was no formality to it and if people felt moved to they would stand up and tell a story about a period in his life. It was a recognition of his life and a really wonderful way to send him off but it wasn't a funeral.

Bagelsandbrie · 29/01/2022 10:52

We had a direct cremation for my Mum. She hadn’t actually told us what she wanted except that I knew she wanted to be cremated and given that there were only 4 of us who would attend to have a funeral seemed a bit overkill. (Me, dh and two dc). Oddly enough people she hadn’t seen or spoken to for years (including my Dad who she divorced from when I was 12 and my ex mil and fil!) were really angry with me and funny with me about it as they assumed there’d be a funeral and they’d get to go. I just thought if you couldn’t be bothered to make contact during the last years of her life why would you think you should just turn up at a funeral? So no, fuck them. We got the ashes and scattered them privately on one of her favourite walks. My dad etc were even angry with me about that and kept asking to come!

VickyEadieofThigh · 29/01/2022 10:52

@jevoudrais

Do you think it's a fuck you even if they know it's what you want? I am finding it hard to imagine how it's seen as a fuck you.

I'm perfectly happy to leave £x aside for a party or a dinner. But I don't get the whole service with flowers and songs with a body in a coffin. It hasn't helped me with anything when I've attended before. I've been to the funerals of 4 x grandparents between DH and I, a friend and my brother.

I think YANBU.

But I don't have children, which is my primary reason for not wanting a funeral. My partner and I have written in our wills that we are to simply be cremated.

I loathe funerals and don't accept that they provide 'closure' or whatever. I know people left traumatised by the whole process of organising one, let alone attending.

I think, however, it's important to discuss this with children if they exist. Knowing a parent's wishes is key and explaining why ought to help!

ikeepseeingit · 29/01/2022 10:52

I would ask everyone closest to you how they would feel about a memorial service instead of a funeral. If your children/ anyone else really close says they would struggle more then you can rethink I guess. But I would think a memorial instead gives people space to come together without the need for a body in a coffin.

AuntieMarys · 29/01/2022 10:52

@MrsSkylerWhite

We’re both specifying direct cremation. Family are all good with it. They have a lunch at our favourite place and scatter our ashes in the sea in a lovely, summers day.
Exactly my wishes. I've told mine to be nice to me when I'm alive and make the most of me! I think the key thing is discuss it with family and don't shy away from it, calling it morbid.
Ohmygodyesthatsit · 29/01/2022 10:52

My brother died very suddenly i did a eulogy at his funeral as did many of his friends i found it very comforting to hear all the stories about him. It was definitely part of the process.
However when my mum died very different she was old had been very very ill for 8 years the funeral was small for obvious reasons and i had already mourned her years before.

user1491404899 · 29/01/2022 10:51

Working in this industry I see alot of families hurt by direct cremation.

We get them sobbing at our door asking why their loved one isn't allowing them to grieve. Often direct cremations aren't done locally, you are shipped off to a central crem often miles away. So family can't even come to 'wave you off'.

Please discuss what you want with your family but please listen to what they want too.

Funerals are for the living not the dead.

Theunamedcat · 29/01/2022 10:51

[quote jevoudrais]@Theunamedcat that gave me a horrible sinking feeling in my stomach if he truly expressed he wanted that and family chose to go against that Sad[/quote]
It was a church funeral too im pretty sure he never crossed a church threshold apart from duty calls he was not a religious man my father isn't either he stands in church and holds the song book as a book stand for the rest of us! I swear if my sister tries to make my dad have a religious ceremony after death I'm putting an open book on his coffin

grapewine · 29/01/2022 10:51

I agree with you, but I have no children. I never found closure in funerals. I just find them awful.

My2favboys · 29/01/2022 10:50

irish here and they wat funerals work here is done and dusted in 3 days. it's a lot for the family having to organise it all very quickly but I couldn't imagine my loved one waiting 8 weeks to be buried. we normally have them home asap and probably weirdly all sit about in the room with an open casket. then a mass, burial and a soup/sandwich in a hall after. of course normally ends in the pub.

Puddycatfan · 29/01/2022 10:50

My will states that my family should use the "most cost effective" method to dispose of me. There's only really my brother and nephews and my brother is on the same page as me. I want my money to go to my family, not a funeral director.

Rupertpenrysmistress · 29/01/2022 10:49

I agree I don't want a funeral it's depressing and all consuming. Others have different opinions, I will discuss this with my family but I would rather direct cremation, and then those close to me can mark it how they wish.

ParkheadParadise · 29/01/2022 10:49

No one likes having to go to a funeral 🤨
Personally, I want a full Requiem Funeral Mass like my dd, mum & dad had.
Funerals are for those felt behind. It's the last thing I did for them was organize their funerals.
Everyone's views are different and that's ok.

MichaelGovesBeard · 29/01/2022 10:49

I would be extremely relieved if I knew a loved one wanted no funeral. I have an elderly dm and her funeral wishes are quite specific - although she has made financial arrangements to cover it - the organisation and attendance of it all will be the last thing we’ll want to do when she goes. We will do, of course, as those are her wishes but personally I would much prefer your plan. And will be discussing with my own dc at some point.