Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not having a funeral is OK?

561 replies

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:32

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

OP posts:
jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 11:06

@AlDanvers yes, I think they are. I was religious and I did get married. But my faith is no more. None of the DC have been christened. I have been invited to a christening soon and am really torn whether to go or not. I feel I should for my friends, but I don't want to go.

OP posts:
jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 11:04

That's interesting to know @Kickers567 I wasn't aware of that, food for thought. Thank you for sharing.

OP posts:
AlDanvers · 29/01/2022 11:04

[quote jevoudrais]@AlDanvers I said archaic, but I didn't say abhorrent.

To me funerals are very old fashioned. Even chapels at crematoriums feel like religious buildings. The template services are the same layout as religious services have been for decades. It's the very definition of old fashioned. Only two of the six funerals I have attended were for people who were religious, yet all felt very religious and old fashioned.[/quote]
I didn't say you said both. Both have been said on this thread.

In which case christenings, weddings etc are all old fashioned?

Blossomtoes · 29/01/2022 11:04

@ThePlantsitter

I think your children would feel it as a 'fuck off' from beyond the grave tbh.

Sorry about your brother. Flowers

This. My son would be devastated if I did this. It’s the very last mark of love and respect for the person you’ve lost. It’s a very cruel thing to do to your kids.
dopple · 29/01/2022 11:03

It's an option possibly if they know they don't have family and friends to attend or maybe they are out of country or died off.

Marmarind · 29/01/2022 11:03

There is a lot of family that don't get along in my family and a lot of trauma and resentments. My grandmother doesn't want a funeral as she doesn't want the grief to lead to funeral arguments or fights. She wants to donate her body to science and just be "disposed of".

I don't care either way. I've never been to a funeral anyway.

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 11:03

DC are not yet old enough to consult, no.

I feel somewhat traumatised by the decisions made for my brother's funeral. He would have hated so much of it. I found that very difficult to deal with, it felt very selfish on the part of those organising. I had no choice but to attend, in terms of yes I could have physically or gone, but the fallout would have been so insane I felt I had no choice.

I don't want that for my DC or remaining family/friends.

OP posts:
CreativeCharlie · 29/01/2022 11:02

No funeral has ever helped me, quite the opposite in fact.

I want a direct cremation too.

Happenchance · 29/01/2022 11:01

I actually think a direct cremation could be better for your DC. Lots of people who they don't know would turn up to a funeral, so they may not feel that they can be themselves and say goodbye in the way that they want, and then feel guilty afterwards.

A direct cremation means that the ash scattering is the main event (for want of a better phrase) and your DC may be more comfortable saying goodbye in the way that they want because only a select number of people will be there.

SmallPrawnEnergy · 29/01/2022 11:01

SportsMother

ThePlantsitter
I think your children would feel it as a 'fuck off' from beyond the grave tbh.

Sorry about your brother. flowers
I would agree.

No-one will ‘understand’ in the way that you want to be able to make them. Hurtful to your children, and will be perceived as being done deliberately.

The other thing about funerals is that they are a way of showing respect. What you are proposing shows no respect to you as people or as one another’s spouses.
If (God forbid) one of your children pre-deceased you and their spouse said “what funeral are you talking about” how would you feel?

If my parents did this I would never think of it as a big “fuck you”. We have an excellent relationship and if they wanted a direct cremation then I would completely understand and wouldn’t think about me, only them. In fact, being selfish and thinking of me, it would take a lot of stress and upset away from me doing that as I’m an only child, don’t live close and have a life of my own. Far from a “fuck you” it would be a “thank you”.

If you perceive it as being “done deliberately” perhaps you have an already strained relationship with your parents as I would never read that as how you have described, a last petty act of upset or hurt.

You can certainly show respect without standing around a lifeless body, and nothing says respect more than following the wishes of the deceased. If they want an all singing all dancing funeral then that should be respected and understood (money obviously outstanding) same as it should be understood for a direct service.

Kickers567 · 29/01/2022 11:01

The thing that upsets me about direct cremation is that there is no care of the body. I didn't want to see my dad again in the Chapel of rest (had already said goodbye to him where he had collapsed on his floor), But it felt good to choose clothes that he would have liked, and to know that he was cleaned up and taken care of.

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 11:01

@AlDanvers I said archaic, but I didn't say abhorrent.

To me funerals are very old fashioned. Even chapels at crematoriums feel like religious buildings. The template services are the same layout as religious services have been for decades. It's the very definition of old fashioned. Only two of the six funerals I have attended were for people who were religious, yet all felt very religious and old fashioned.

OP posts:
Curlygirl06 · 29/01/2022 11:00

Although saying that, I did go to a humanist funeral, no hymns, no bible reading etc and it was the best one I've been to, so that might be an option?

rookiemere · 29/01/2022 11:00

I didn't realise this was an option. I will talk to DH about it as - and this may be contentious- I find funerals to be a massive waste of money. I'd rather the bare minimum was spent on mine and then the money saved used for people to have a meal out to remember me by.

AlternativePerspective · 29/01/2022 11:00

No-one needs a body to have a memorial.

i won’t be having a funeral and it’s not up for discussion. If my family want a memorial they’re welcome to do so, but the presence or absence of a body doesn’t matter, it’s not as if I’m going to be there.

As it happens my parents feel the same way anyway.

Curlygirl06 · 29/01/2022 10:59

We're planning that and have told the children, who are all grown up. My 3 are fine about it, my dh's son seems a bit iffy about it but when we've definitely sorted it will have another chat. They can celebrate our lives with a drink/ dinner/ meeting to scatter the ashes etc and to remember us, but we have been to too many funerals lately to want that for us and them. I think it's very practical.

Blackmagicqueen · 29/01/2022 10:58

the*

wearyanddreary · 29/01/2022 10:58

A relative of mine opted for this, quite unexpectedly. At first we found it quite difficult as Covid delayed us being able to organise something ourselves and so there was no 'goodbye' for some time, which felt quite wrong.

However, once restrictions eased we were able to bury the ashes. About a dozen of us, just close family gathered together, it was very personal, some people said a few words, the ashes were buried by us and flowers planted before we went to grab a bite to eat together.

Honestly, it was the best way I can think of to say goodbye to someone. I find funerals, with their artificial formality, music and set way of doing things quite difficult. This just felt more honest, and being hands on and not having lots of unfamiliar faces around really helped.

I would be tempted to opt for this myself now. However, only after a chat to all of my family that they would be ok with it and the practicalities (obviously it is a lot to ask for people to organise something themselves, plus, I think there are certain restrictions like not being able to visit the deceased after, or give clothes for them to be dressed in - though maybe that depends on what you opt for. But it's important to be aware of those things).

We did find it hard to begin with, but came to see the wisdom of our relatives choice in the end. One thing that I found unexpectedly difficult was that there was a fair bit of judgement from others, as though we were bad people for respecting their wishes and not having a funeral. Which is something to consider. I found that quite hurtful.

SomewhereOnlyIKnow · 29/01/2022 10:58

@SomewhereOnlyIKnow

When my DD was cremated we had a service at the crem. Then his ashes were put in a grave, with a funeral director digging the hole and placing them in. Looking back, it would have been better to go for straight cremation and then a ‘service’ at the graveside for the ashes being placed in the grave.
Sorry, that should be DF.
ShadowPuppets · 29/01/2022 10:57

Are your DC old enough to consult?

Personally I do find that funerals give closure and I would be heartbroken if my parents decided they didn’t want one, the idea of just disappearing and never having a chance to gather and reflect on their lives sounds awful. But if we’d spoken about it and they were really clear about it I’d respect that. I’d hate it though.

MrsSkylerWhite · 29/01/2022 10:57

user1491404899

Working in this industry I see alot of families hurt by direct cremation.
We get them sobbing at our door asking why their loved one isn't allowing them to grieve. Often direct cremations aren't done locally, you are shipped off to a central crem often miles away. So family can't even come to 'wave you off'.

Please discuss what you want with your family but please listen to what they want too.

Funerals are for the living not the dead“

Completely disagree. It’s the deceased last wish and should be respected.

As an aside, the cost of traditional funerals are outrageous and completely unjustifiable, leaving countless families in debt at one of the worst times of their lives.

Your “industry” should perhaps focus on that rather than the emotive nonsense (which frankly I don’t believe).

Blackmagicqueen · 29/01/2022 10:57

It is down to the people left behind to respect the wishes of of dead. If the deceased wises was for there to be no funeral service than so be it. I personally hate funerals and find they can be false with relatives there that haven't been seen for ages! I would be relieved if there wasn't one and feel it takes away nothing. I believe can pay your respects anywhere in your own special way, light a candle or say a few words it, it doesn't have to be with sometimes a load of strangers in a set time and place.

AlDanvers · 29/01/2022 10:57

I really think it's quite awful to call a tradition that gives some people alot of comfort and happiness "archaic" and "abhorrent" tbh.

SomewhereOnlyIKnow · 29/01/2022 10:57

When my DD was cremated we had a service at the crem.
Then his ashes were put in a grave, with a funeral director digging the hole and placing them in.
Looking back, it would have been better to go for straight cremation and then a ‘service’ at the graveside for the ashes being placed in the grave.

ThePlantsitter · 29/01/2022 10:57

I think if your children are of an age where you can discuss it with them, fair enough. If there's a way to express your wishes without arranging it so they get no say as to whether or not it happens like that, also fair enough. I personally find funerals a useful way of saying goodbye and have found with other things that traditional rituals follow an easy, predictable path for reasons of comfort and practicality. I'm aware not everyone feels like that and there's no 'right' way of saying goodbye to a loved one though.

The thing I would worry about with an all arranged no funeral procedure is that those left behind would feel that you hadn't factored in their grief into the arrangements and that they were obliged to grieve in exactly the way you thought best. I guess all that is very much dependent on the relationship that existed when the dead person was alive, too.