Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not having a funeral is OK?

561 replies

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:32

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

OP posts:
Kitkat151 · 29/01/2022 11:29

@ThePlantsitter

I think your children would feel it as a 'fuck off' from beyond the grave tbh.

Sorry about your brother. Flowers

Why would they?🙄
RandomLondoner · 29/01/2022 11:29

@ThePlantsitter

I think your children would feel it as a 'fuck off' from beyond the grave tbh.

Sorry about your brother. Flowers

I've had a funeral for both a parent and a child. In both cases the funeral was a huge and unpleasant burden I could have done without.

I find your point of view extremely odd. It's as if you regard your funeral as some sort of treat for your survivors, rather than a horrific obligation imposed upon them that makes a bad time even worse.

Maybe different people have different feelings about funerals?

I don't care what anyone does with my body after I die. People can suit themselves, but I will let them know direct cremation is fine by me.

Queenoftheflumps02 · 29/01/2022 11:29

I used to think a direct cremation was a good idea. Once you are dead you are dead and how your remains are disposed of is unimportant. It's how you are remembered that is.

Then at the beginning of the year my dad died. The thought of him going to the crematorium alone, with no one with him broke my heart. We had a very small, very personal service for him. No singing, no hymns etc, but an appropriate service for him. I never thought I would feel like that, I always thought I was very pragmatic about funerals and didn't really see the purpose, but when it came to someone so close, I just couldn't do the direct route. I should also say, my dad didn't mind what we did!

LouLou789 · 29/01/2022 11:29

YANBU. I feel the same about my own non-funeral. I’ve talked to my two (adult) DS, however, and while the younger is Ok with whatever I decide, the elder seems uncomfortable with the idea, as does my DH.

AlternativePerspective · 29/01/2022 11:29

So for the people who say that these things should be the decision of the living, surely that also means that only your family should be allowed to decide if your body is donated to science/if you become an organ donor?

If you decide to donate your body isn’t that as much of a fuck off to your children as having a direct cremation? After all, they don’t have a say in that either do they?

PossiblyDreaming · 29/01/2022 11:28

I’ve already written in my will that I do not want a funeral. It’s always traumatic for everyone closely involved and awkward and strained for people who were close enough friends/ colleagues to be expected to attend but not get emotional.

I’ve attended lots of ash scattering ceremonies, often months after the person died and they’ve always been really beautiful, emotional goodbyes when the rawness and shock has faded somewhat. I’d much prefer that for myself.

Plasmodesmata · 29/01/2022 11:28

YANBU. Up to you.
My parents both want this option, I'm happy.
I've signed up to be dissected by medical students.

Jossbow · 29/01/2022 11:28

My friend mother died, not unexpectedly although she wasnt with her when she passed.

3 years on, she suffers deadfully- she feels she never has never had point at which to say ''goodbye'' as there was no funeral. No chance for her to hear all the nice things people would have said about her mum.

Someone passes, and the next point is the funeral, the formal goodbye- some will find it very hard not to do that. I would

interferingma · 29/01/2022 11:27

My mum died earlier this month. We had the funeral 10 days ago. She wanted a small funeral (30 or so people). I found the act of organising it - eulogy, readings, music, photos - very therapeutic. I actually wouldn't want to deprive my children the experience

godmum56 · 29/01/2022 11:27

@pantjog

I think funerals can potentially be very cathartic and an important part of the grieving process.
depends entirely on the people involved....and there are other options than a funeral for those who need a ceremony.
EmmaH2022 · 29/01/2022 11:26

I know how you feel

I think it's fine to do this

But when my dad died, mum felt too many people would be upset if we didn't have a funeral. It was horrendous. I have been to funerals before and I felt differently when I was young and the deceased were young - though I'd respect their wishes regardless.

I don't feel able to ask mum what she wants but I really don't want to go through a parent funeral again. It's not comforting, it's not helpful.

She has some really awful friends too. The sort I wouldn't want to have my phone number.

If she doesn't leave instructions and siblings are okay with it, then it will be a direct cremation.

Socialcarenope · 29/01/2022 11:25

Yanbu.

I didn't realise their was a no funeral option. That's what I want. I don't see the point in funerals. I've been to a few and would prefer not to do anymore.

2022success · 29/01/2022 11:25

YANBU

I hate funerals and would much prefer this route.

hackneyzoo · 29/01/2022 11:25

My sister died a few years ago and she lived a European country where direct cremations are quite normal. We had a memorial for her in her favorite lakeside restaurant with all her friends and family and it was a very fitting way to rennet her and say good bye. Have lost both my parents who had traditional funerals I felt my sisters memorial was a much more fitting and personal way to say goodbye and mark her life.
It’s very personal though…

godmum56 · 29/01/2022 11:25

@Gatehouse77

I have come to the conclusion that it’s for the living to decide how they want to grieve and not for me, the dead person, to dictate.

I’ve organised for my body to be used either for science as a whole or as a donor. Obviously, depends on the nature of the death which I can’t predict (at this point).

So my family may or may not have a body to deal with. I feel it’s up to them how they wish to remember me and not how I wish to be remembered - that should be reflected by how I’ve lived my life.

On the other hand, my mother had details wrote down - what music, why and when it should be played. Certain people were asked if they wanted to speak and it followed the pattern of funerals in her family.

For me, I see it differently. I’m dead, there’s no after life and, at that point, my ‘feelings’ are irrelevant.

Are you sure that your body won't be returned at some point and have you got a alternative arranged in case your body is refused?....not all research or donor options agree to dispose of the body after they have used it.
warmeduppizza · 29/01/2022 11:25

Just for info - if you leave your body to be used for science, there will still be a funeral, whenever they’re done with you. But your family can choose whether to attend or not.

0palescent · 29/01/2022 11:24

Lots of my family have indicated they would be fine with a direct cremation for themselves. I have never found funerals particularly helpful, more something to get through. I'd choose direct cremation for myself, and would be fine if anyone else preferred this too. As already said by others, family are free to gather in a way they like, and remember their loved one then.

Hbh17 · 29/01/2022 11:24

Absolutely right. I want direct cremation, also no wake/party/gathering/ashes scattering or whatever. I'll be dead, that's normal, & anyone around who knew me will have better things to do, I'm sure.

phoenixrosehere · 29/01/2022 11:24

Three of my grandparents had funerals (one a military funeral) and my maternal grandmother chose not to (cremated and placed in a beautiful urn at my parents home). After she passed, the subject came up and my parents, my mother’s uncle and I all agreed we rather be cremated. Having been to several funerals, the thing I hated the most was seeing the shell of what the person used to be. I hated that was my last memory of them. Not their smiles and laughter but their deceased bodies, dressed up in something they would have never worn, in a frilly, glossy wooden box. My first memory was of a funeral, maybe that has coloured my judgement however I recall what my great uncle (hates funerals and will be cremated) said that has always stuck with me: “Don’t pay tribute to me when I’m dead, do so when I’m alive. I’ve been to many funerals (he in his late 70s) and it’s always full of people who show up to pay their respects yet few of them actually showed up in life for the person who died. I rather be cremated than have people who couldn’t bother to pick up a phone make a public spectacle of my death. My death is not going to be a morbid family reunion.”

I have been open to my DH that I rather be cremated and have my ashes either scattered in a beautiful place as part of a holiday (I love traveling and we as a family went on many trips), turned into jewellery (something they could carry along with them), or a tree (I love gardening and nature) as a tribute to my life whichever he and our children prefer. For the wake, a party near or on the beach where people dance and have a good time.

pantjog · 29/01/2022 11:24

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Vbree · 29/01/2022 11:24

*Phrased!

Vbree · 29/01/2022 11:24

Godmum sorry I probably leased that incorrectly. I'd hope to leave enough for a modest funeral if I can.

vixeyann · 29/01/2022 11:24

I've hated every funeral service I've been to but can tolerate the after meet ups to share memories. YANBU. I don't want a funeral and ideally would like a natural burial at a local site that when full becomes a nature reserve. I've told my husband and he is thinking along the same lines for when he goes.

MojoJojo71 · 29/01/2022 11:23

Every family is different and I feel it’s something you need to discuss together.

I detest funerals and if I could I would never attend another. For me they are not helpful at all and feel like some kind of ritualised torture. I have recently decided to donate my body to the local medical school, I have the forms to complete and return but it says on there that sometimes they can’t/won’t accept a donation and my son is aware that if this happens a direct cremation would be my preferred option.

godmum56 · 29/01/2022 11:23

@Vbree

My mum wants to do the same. Tbh she's always been quite a miserable joyless person. I think I would want to leave a small amount if I can and leave it up to relatives.
Being brutally honest, if you are only leaving a small amount, they won't have much choice....ordinary funerals are expensive.