Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not having a funeral is OK?

561 replies

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:32

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

OP posts:
AlternativePerspective · 29/01/2022 11:51

There is also a lot of evidence to suggest that humans cannot really process that a death has really occurred to a close loved one until they see a body. They need that visual closure. I disagree. Plenty of people don’t view the body at or before a funeral. There have been threads on here from people who have not got over seeing their loved one in the chapel of rest because it was so harrowing, because in truth, it wasn’t them.

My dp’s brother died two years ago and his partner fell apart after seeing him in the chapel of rest.

I don’t want anyone to see my body. I don’t actually want anyone to feel they have to go through watching me die if it comes to that. Obviously if they want I’ll probably be unconscious by then and won’t know, but I don’t think anyone should feel obligated to be there. Even my parents or my partner.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 29/01/2022 11:51

Direct to cremation near us is still about £1000. It cost money to store the body and the cremation charges a fixed fee and none of that is taken away by it being direct. Obviously, cheaper than say the £3000 we spent but it's still a lot to find if saving money is the objective. Unless you have no relatives and then the council will pay.

EishetChayil · 29/01/2022 11:51

"I hate funerals" is like "i hate hospitals". Who doesn't??

AtLeastPretendToCare · 29/01/2022 11:50

I would like direct cremation and then some form of funeral/memorial service without my body there. When I die my body is just the vessel I was in and I don’t like the idea of it being preserved for weeks and carted around to sit by an altar.

When we did our wills DH insisted he wanted to be buried. I personally hate this idea and I don’t know why he feels this way because nobody in his family has been buried. I would respect his wishes but would much rather cremation than his body rotting away in the ground is some large scale site.

PhilCornwall1 · 29/01/2022 11:49

Not that I'll be there to enjoy it, but I don't want a funeral.

I'm going to have the conversation and say that, my wishes are for no funeral and just get done with my body what needs to get done. Saves all the pissing about.

Blossomtoes · 29/01/2022 11:48

@AlternativePerspective

No coincidence that people who work in the industry are advising people to have funerals. Hmm for whose benefit did you say? The family? Or the industry?

Funerals are prohibitively expensive, I mean we’re potentially talking hundreds for a coffin which is going to be burned or buried (personally I think they’re probably recycled) but either way funerals ar the gift which keep on taking.

The words of someone who knows the price of everything and the value of nothing.
Shufflebumnessie · 29/01/2022 11:48

I'm an only child and live a few hours away from my parents. When my parents pass away I would quite happily not have a funeral for them. For completely selfish reasons I feel organising, waiting for and actually having attend the funerals would be horrendous for me. I'm a very private person and have no desire to grieve in public surrounded by several people I don't know (their friends).
I'm pretty sure my dad would be more than happy with that, but not my mum. Also, I suspect it wouldn't go down well with other family members.
I would much rather they chose a direct cremation and then I could choose a time/place with DH & DC to scatter their ashes and say goodbye privately.
Obviously I'm hoping it's quite a while until I have to think about it but I'll admit that the thought of having to get through a traditional funeral fills me with dread and panic.
Talk to your family about your preference and hopefully they'll accept, and be supportive of, your decision.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 29/01/2022 11:48

I don't work in the funeral industry, but I was lucky enough to hit on an amazing funeral director who was a friend of a friend, she was fantastic and so compassionate and I really valued having someone help me create the perfect funeral- I wouldn't have wanted to put on a memorial by myself that that point, it would have been too stressful.

I note that often once memorials come round a few months later, I don't want to attend. Might just be me though!

ScribblingPixie · 29/01/2022 11:47

I'm doing this. It's what David Bowie did, isn't it?

Thingsdogetbetter · 29/01/2022 11:47

FiL died before Xmas and had no funeral. Both sons and his elderly wife (who also has a plan) really appreciated it and it had been discussed as a family first. They got to grieve in their own way. None are religious, and are very practical, private people. Dh and I are planning to do the same. I've never found a funeral service to be comforting: full of hypocrisy, platitudes, one-upmanship and grieve vultures.

loislovesstewie · 29/01/2022 11:46

We have viewed the body BTW. We said our goodbyes then.

Porcupineintherough · 29/01/2022 11:46

@AlternativePerspective the truth is the dead have no rights. No funeral home is going to fight your kids to have things the way you've specified if they demand different. You can state burial, or cremation or stuffed and put on display but unless you next of kin agree I wouldnt bet on it happening.

AlternativePerspective · 29/01/2022 11:45

No coincidence that people who work in the industry are advising people to have funerals. Hmm for whose benefit did you say? The family? Or the industry?

Funerals are prohibitively expensive, I mean we’re potentially talking hundreds for a coffin which is going to be burned or buried (personally I think they’re probably recycled) but either way funerals ar the gift which keep on taking.

supercatlady · 29/01/2022 11:45

My Mum felt the same way and donated her body to science to save us the cost of a funeral. In the event, it didn’t feel right to not do anything so we had a small non-religious memorial service and some food at a pub after. Lots more people came than she would have imagined and personally I was glad of the opportunity to celebrate her life. I think it did help.
It was a little odd not having the focal point of the coffin, but we had a photo of her and a bouquet of her favourite flowers.
A year or so later the University cremated her remains and my sister collected them.

Torunette · 29/01/2022 11:44

What I would say is think carefully about dispensing with rituals.

Rituals create boundaries, and recognise a transition into a different stage of the life course. As humans, we created them for a purpose.

I would argue funerals are not really about "saying goodbye". On a deeper level, they are more about recognising formally that something significant has changed, that life going forward will be different than how it was before, and that change being formally registered by a wider circle of people.

Not doing the funeral ritual does not dispense with the pain. It is a way for the living to face it, rather than tuck it away -- to face the "goneness" of death.

There is also a lot of evidence to suggest that humans cannot really process that a death has really occurred to a close loved one until they see a body. They need that visual closure.

I worry sometimes that we react to rituals that feel old-fashioned by chucking them out, rather than reforming them. There are lots of funeral directors who will work with a family to deliver a ritual that is not old-fashioned. My mother, for example, had a white wool coffin and a service at a local memorial chapel with poems and a eulogy written as though it was a fairy tale.

And her funeral was extremely painful, though there were moments of smiling. But it was necessary. It was a event that marked the transition between being a married man and a widower for my DF, and having a living mother and no longer having a living mother for me.

I would suggest that if you dispense with a funeral, you need to put something else of equal weight in place. The problem there is that a very alternative ritual with no real antecedents for that purpose may not be sufficiently resonant enough to hit the right psychological notes for attendees, and there are dangers of going somewhere that, at the moment you turn up, ends up feeling very inappropriate.

IncompleteSenten · 29/01/2022 11:44

That's what my dad had and it's what my mum wants when her time comes.
It's what I'd like but I know my husband will need a service and since I'll be dead and won't know or care I'd prefer him to do what he needs to do.

People should do what feels right for them.

AngryApple · 29/01/2022 11:43

*there

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 29/01/2022 11:43

Funerals don't have to be 'bizarre rituals' if you don't want though, you can do them yourself, you can have a humanist celebrant, you can say what you like (within reason), you can have any music, you can wear what you like, you can have one on a hillside as my lovely friend did overlooking a river.

No wearing black, no rolling the box off, no hymns, no random reading out a eulogy, it doesn't have to be like that any more and I don't think many people have realised that.

Stookeen · 29/01/2022 11:43

Mainstream British culture does death, death rituals etc incredibly badly, in my opinion — the funeral appears to have to happen weeks after the death at best, people hardly go to funerals outside of close family so they find them frightening and burdensome etc. I wouldn’t blame anyone for opting out.

Interesting, though, that some of this thread strongly resembles the ‘Will my family be heartbroken if I elope with two witnesses, rather than having a wedding and inviting them?’ ones.

Blossomtoes · 29/01/2022 11:43

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@Blossomtoes

See I think the exact opposite. I think it would be very cruel of me to want to put my kids through something so traumatic. The last thing I can do for them is to protect them by not having a traditional funeral.[/quote]
Neither of my parents’ funerals were traumatic, they were very sad and very loving. I found organising them to ensure they reflected the people they were very cathartic and the kindness shown us on the day was very healing.

They were both in their late 90s and the crematorium was full for both of them, it was so comforting to see how loved and respected they were by so many people. My son agrees with me, we’ve already discussed readings and music for mine. And I want an entire flower shop too!

WellThatsMeScrewed · 29/01/2022 11:42

I agree.

I will leave money for a gathering with very strict instructions that there is to be no mention of religion/God and all good must be vegetarian.

Also I don’t mind a bit of black at funeral. I am not keen on the ‘not formal’ I think if you can’t make an effort when saying goodbye to someone that says a lot.

So at my gathering best frocks on please

AngryApple · 29/01/2022 11:42

I’m with you OP. YANBU.

I’ve buried 3 members of my immediate family now. I’m only 41. I find funerals harrowing and unnecessary. People who attend are usually only their for their own reasons and don’t actually care about what you’re going through. You’re expected to make conversation with people when you’re at your lowest.

I won’t be having one!

loislovesstewie · 29/01/2022 11:42

I've just arranged a direct cremation for my husband who died earlier this month. It was what he wanted; it's being done in a respectful way and people are going to remember him in their own time and manner that suits them. We, our children and I, are going to remember him when the actual cremation takes place and there will be a gathering later in the year to scatter the ashes.
I think it really is about what suits the deceased and their loved ones. We aren't religious, and I don't feel having a humanist celebrant would actually make it better for us.

FourChimneys · 29/01/2022 11:41

Agreed no funerals here. Money in a kitty for a meal for all the family and close friends.

Proudboomer · 29/01/2022 11:41

My mum will probably have a direct funeral. She has outlived all her family apart from her 2 children and 3 grandchildren. She has been housebound for years so her friends have either died or fallen by the wayside so if she had a funeral there would be a total of 7 people to come. Better a direct funeral and then a small private scattering of the ashes for us 7 to pay our last respects.