Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not having a funeral is OK?

561 replies

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:32

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

OP posts:
godmum56 · 29/01/2022 12:15

@AlternativePerspective

But again, and no-one has yet answered this, if you think that funerals are for the living and you have no right to decide whether or not you will have one, then surely you equally have no right to decide that you want your body donated to science? After all, your body isn’t yours to do with as you see fit because it’s the property of your family who have the ultimate say.
true!
godmum56 · 29/01/2022 12:15

@dottydodah

I think most people feel like this .I remember when a friend died it was terrible .her DS said they didnt want a Funeral .However without one you cant really grieve properly .Death is such a taboo subject these days.My DGM remembers people "laying out their dead " people coming to pay their respects .I would hate to see a dead body in common with most people I expect! This is a modern way of saying goodbye and remembering all the good times spent together .
you may not feel able to grieve properly....plenty of other peopld can!
AlternativePerspective · 29/01/2022 12:14

But again, and no-one has yet answered this, if you think that funerals are for the living and you have no right to decide whether or not you will have one, then surely you equally have no right to decide that you want your body donated to science? After all, your body isn’t yours to do with as you see fit because it’s the property of your family who have the ultimate say.

godmum56 · 29/01/2022 12:13

@NewYearNewMinty

one of the points of the buy ahead plan is that usually it fixes the price for what you want. We know that things can go up massively in price and what you can afford to leave may not cover even a simple funeral at the time its needed....also if its left as money its part of the estate and has to be treated as such.....may be taken to pay a credit card bill for instance....if you have prepaid, all of that is avoided.

HelloFrostyMorning · 29/01/2022 12:12

@AngryApple

I’m with you OP. YANBU.

I’ve buried 3 members of my immediate family now. I’m only 41. I find funerals harrowing and unnecessary. People who attend are usually only their for their own reasons and don’t actually care about what you’re going through. You’re expected to make conversation with people when you’re at your lowest.

I won’t be having one!

All of this. ^ The vast majority of people at funerals are just there to show their face, to pretend they give a shit, and to see if there's anything up for grabs in the will.

Like fuck is it a 'fuck you' to the children/other close family members. They would all know beforehand that this was happening in the vast majority of cases.

The people saying it's wrong to have a direct cremation are either

a) funeral directors who are butt-hurt because they're unable to cream off 4 or 5 thousand pounds off grieving families.

or

b) they are the type who just HAS to go to every funeral just to show their face, pretend they care, and see what's up for grabs!!!

As for the 'religious families want them' type comments... Whether the family is strongly religious or not (and many are NOT in this day and age in the UK,) the person's wishes MUST be respected.

You are right @AngryApple that many of the people who go to funerals, have no idea what you are going through, if it is someone incredibly close to you who has died. The funerals of my parents - one year apart - were 2 of the darkest and most devastating days of my life.

I would have given anything for them to have not had funerals, and to have had direct cremations instead.. Then me and my extended family could have celebrated their lives in our own way when we were ready.

dottydodah · 29/01/2022 12:12

I think most people feel like this .I remember when a friend died it was terrible .her DS said they didnt want a Funeral .However without one you cant really grieve properly .Death is such a taboo subject these days.My DGM remembers people "laying out their dead " people coming to pay their respects .I would hate to see a dead body in common with most people I expect! This is a modern way of saying goodbye and remembering all the good times spent together .

Chickychickydodah · 29/01/2022 12:11

I’m not having a funeral , my family and people that are will remember me for who I was. None else gives a shit!
It’s an unnecessary expense.

ddl1 · 29/01/2022 12:10

Well, a bit of both - ultimately it's the decision of those left behind, as I won't be there. But I would prefer no funeral. My father and later my mother explicitly requested no funeral and that was a relief to me, as grief is even worse for me if it's turned into a big social occasion (when I'm grieving, 'hell is other people'). It's different if someone is religious, of course.

TheOriginalNutty · 29/01/2022 12:09

My advice is don't do it.

My dad died suddenly in June and his wish was for a direct cremation. We wrestled with it but ultimately decided to honour his wishes.

It's left me feeling in limbo and not really able to come to terms with his death. I absolutely hate the fact that no one (except funeral home staff) were there when he was cremated.

MovingSwiftlyOn · 29/01/2022 12:09

We did this for FIL, just me DH and MIL at the crematorium. DH made a box for his ashes which he hand painted, and we buried them in a plot in a natural burial ground with family and friends. Afterwards we all went for lunch in the local pub. We felt it was perfect for him because he was a pragmatic soul who always hated making a fuss. I think it was easier for MIL too as she didn't have to worry about holding herself together in front of everyone at the cremation.
I would just say do what feels right. Xxxx

astoundedgoat · 29/01/2022 12:09

Gosh. I absolutely LOVE a good funeral. But I'm from a culture that traditionally goes all in for them. Big events, family and friends invited. A celebration of life, so it would be unthinkable not to have a nice big funeral.

I'm really surprised at the people saying they're traumatic. If anything, the LOSS might be traumatic, certainly. The funeral's "job" is to soothe that loss, and centre the joyousness of the life of the deceased, EVEN if they were a miserable git. :)

But we also do them very quickly after the death. Someone I know here in the UK only yesterday buried a loved one who died back in mid December, which is just astonishing to me.

downtonupton · 29/01/2022 12:08

*My grandparents and Dad didn't

Wreath21 · 29/01/2022 12:08

@AlternativePerspective

No coincidence that people who work in the industry are advising people to have funerals. Hmm for whose benefit did you say? The family? Or the industry?

Funerals are prohibitively expensive, I mean we’re potentially talking hundreds for a coffin which is going to be burned or buried (personally I think they’re probably recycled) but either way funerals ar the gift which keep on taking.

One thing about working in the funeral industry is that we meet and hear from lots of people who find having a funeral for their spouse/.friend/relative enormously comforting. I certainly don't think funerals are obligatory, it's very much a matter of personal choice but, as has been said, the processes of dealing with the remains of a dead person is going to cost a fair bit because it involves the time and labour of several people, plus operating costs (fuel, materials etc).
downtonupton · 29/01/2022 12:08

My family don't do funerals - My grandparents and Dad did and my Mum has stated that she doesn't want one.

From my point of view I kind of missed it - but not as much as I thought I would have before.

But equally I'm not sure that I would have liked there to be a funeral either. I'm not sure it would give me what I think it would.

With regards to my Dad and Grandparents - other people came first - My Mum would have been heart broken if we had pushed for one that she didnt want.

We (the kids) have spoken to Mum and she doesn't want one but as she says we can do what we like because she'll be dead and wont have to go.

Talk to your family. Explain what you are thinking etc. Funerals are expensive and bad for the environment - if you don't want one, don't have one.

Not having a funeral doesn't mean you cant go to a home/pub/restaurant etc and remember the person.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 29/01/2022 12:06

Both my mum and grandad have paid for this. Don't know how we will feel about it but we will likely find out soon enough as grandad has terminal cancer

We will just get together as a family probably as soon as thet die and also to do somethingvwith the ashes. None of us feel we need to go through the whole funeral thing

Roselilly36 · 29/01/2022 12:06

@2YearsOfWastedTime

Im donating my body to science So my funeral will be more of a remembrance thing as there will be no body there Grin
That is to be commended, but not everybody is accepted, it depends on when you die, also your remains will be given back to your family at some point. I watched a very interesting programme on this subject years ago.
Iamnotamermaid · 29/01/2022 12:06

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple.

People can still gather away from the crematorium and remember you in a more informal setting. Not convinced the formal funeral setting allows people to actually grieve - more of a stiff upper lip setup.

I think you can still attend the cremation itself - it is just there is no service.

TheWordWomanIsTaken · 29/01/2022 12:06

@AlternativePerspective

No coincidence that people who work in the industry are advising people to have funerals. Hmm for whose benefit did you say? The family? Or the industry?

Funerals are prohibitively expensive, I mean we’re potentially talking hundreds for a coffin which is going to be burned or buried (personally I think they’re probably recycled) but either way funerals ar the gift which keep on taking.

Recycled coffins? Aye right.
lljkk · 29/01/2022 12:04

i wish Aquamation didn't cost twice as much as cremation.

yanbu to OP

fourandtwo · 29/01/2022 12:04

When my son died we didn’t have a funeral. He was cremated and we picked up his ashes and scattered them in a place that meant something to us. Just DH and I, we didn’t want anyone else there. We later had a meal with the wider family but it definitely didn't have a “wake” feel. I’d be very happy if my family wanted to do the exact same for me when it’s my turn.

NewYearNewMinty · 29/01/2022 12:02

Rather than a funeral plan bought ahead, how about just setting aside enough money in a separate account for simple funeral, but leaving a letter or note in your will stating that you are happy to have a direct cremation if that what your children feel comfortable with.

I think a lot depends on circumstances and there's just no way of knowing how those closest will react.

My dad was declared 'end of life' with frailty early in the first lockdown. Mum had previously mentioned a direct cremation and I'd been horrified, but within the context of restrictions I could get on board with that and having a low key scattering of ashes with friends and family at a later date.

In the end he hung on for a year and by the time he passed away restrictions were being rolled back and we were able ro have a funeral and wake for 30 people which was fine for us.

The period in between his death and funeral was nearly 4 weeks, which seemed like a long time, but it meant we didn't have to rush anything, and those weeks gave me the chance to look back over his life, my memories and photos of him.

The input I had into his service (mixed as he wasn't religious but we did include his favourite hymn and a prayer for mum's benefit) was really meaningful for me and I'm proud of the send off we gave him and still comforted by it months later.

People's reactions are so difficult to judge...mum, who is normally squeamish, visited Dad at the undertakers with an open coffin 4 times. I'm normally quite stoic but I couldn't make it fully into the room and had a closed coffin visit the day before the funeral.

Even now, mum keeps talking about what we're going to do with his ashes and I'm just ready to make that decisions yet...again I'd have expected that to be the opposite way round.

What I'm trying to say amid all this ramble is I think giving your kids options when the time comes is the kindest way to go about it.

godmum56 · 29/01/2022 12:02

@JudgeRindersMinder

Having had to have a covid compliant funeral for my dad, so with minimal people there, and no wake, I’ve found it’s made the grieving process a lot more difficult. Part of funeral traditions are about the people left behind and these traditions have evolved over the years as they are what make grieving easier to cope with, so don’t necessarily discount them
that could be though because what happened wasn't your choice?
Thirtytimesround · 29/01/2022 12:02

My grandad left instructions that he wanted a cremation with zero fuss and no service. So we did that, but there was this weird lack of closure and it didn’t feel right. Eventually a couple of weeks later we asked a local vicar’s opinion. We aren’t even religious! He kindly did a private service just for our family, and after that we felt we’d closed the chapter in a way that the ten minute cremation (which felt surreal, even farcical) hadn’t.

My aunt had very specific ideas about her funeral, and paid for it all in advance and the funeral company promised to do exactly what she had said. But she went ‘a bit funny’ and made her weird neighbour executor. Weird neighbour completely rewrote the funeral plan to include all the neighbour’s favourite tunes (and none of the songs my gran had specified on the paperwork). Family asked the funeral company to stick to my aunt’s plan but they refused.

Bottom line is you have very little control as to what happens after, no matter who you pay and what they promise. It’s all about who you pick as executor, they have 100% control.

Flowersandhearts · 29/01/2022 12:01

@AlternativePerspective

There is also a lot of evidence to suggest that humans cannot really process that a death has really occurred to a close loved one until they see a body. They need that visual closure. I disagree. Plenty of people don’t view the body at or before a funeral. There have been threads on here from people who have not got over seeing their loved one in the chapel of rest because it was so harrowing, because in truth, it wasn’t them.

My dp’s brother died two years ago and his partner fell apart after seeing him in the chapel of rest.

I don’t want anyone to see my body. I don’t actually want anyone to feel they have to go through watching me die if it comes to that. Obviously if they want I’ll probably be unconscious by then and won’t know, but I don’t think anyone should feel obligated to be there. Even my parents or my partner.

Yeah I'm not sure I would opt to see anyone in the chapel of rest after having seen my Gran's body- she didn't look anything like herself and it was a slightly disturbing situation.
PhilCornwall1 · 29/01/2022 12:01

@Ozanj

The decision whether to have a funeral or not isn’t not and should not be the dead person’s. Funerals are ceremonies for the living and so it’s the living who get to decide either way - the best thing you can do for them is organise a little pot of money to help.
If they are going against the persons wishes, why should they help fund them to do it.
Swipe left for the next trending thread