Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not having a funeral is OK?

561 replies

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:32

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

OP posts:
HelloFrostyMorning · 29/01/2022 12:34

@astoundedgoat

Gosh. I absolutely LOVE a good funeral.

Fuck me sideways! Confused I don't even know where to start with THAT comment. That is God-Tier level hideous. Have a word with yourself FFS. Hmm

TonTonMacoute · 29/01/2022 12:34

Why are you asking a bunch of strangers on the internet? Ask your children!

Sloth66 · 29/01/2022 12:34

I’ve found humanist funerals better, more personal. Otherwise I’d like a direct cremation then put money aside for family and friends to go out for a pub lunch

BreakingUpWithMyPhone · 29/01/2022 12:33

I arranged a direct cremation for a family member, and (on a different day), a sandwiches / coffee / drinks do with a celebrant at a local restaurant. I think it worked really well, and the family member wouldn't have wanted lots of extra £ spent on a funeral for the sake of it.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 29/01/2022 12:32

You have to talk to them about it first!
If they don't care whether or not there is a funeral, then do it your way - but if they feel that they would need to have one, then sort it out so that they can.

Saracen · 29/01/2022 12:32

I think it's fine as long as your relatives understand that you aren't saying " no funeral please", and that they can arrange whatever they wish, whether that is nothing, or a traditional funeral, or a little DIY service.

When my dad died, my mother preferred to have no service of any sort. He'd donated his body to science, so there wasn't even a cremation. I was fine with it, but my sister later told me she'd felt deprived of a chance to say goodbye, but felt unable to ask for it at the time.

A few years later when my mum died, my sister arranged a lovely DIY ceremony in a local quilt shop.

KatherineJaneway · 29/01/2022 12:31

I vote YABU as my Mum didn't want a funeral. I think it would have helped me enormously as the person left behind to have one.

Honeyroar · 29/01/2022 12:25

@FortunesFave

But again, and no-one has yet answered this, if you think that funerals are for the living and you have no right to decide whether or not you will have one, then surely you equally have no right to decide that you want your body donated to science? After all, your body isn’t yours to do with as you see fit because it’s the property of your family who have the ultimate say.

This is irrelevant because the lack of an assembly with some traditional words is nothing to do with what happens to the body. Hmm The body is either cremated or buried but the funeral is the service and the words spoken/songs sung.

Yes I agree. What happens to the body still happens to the body whether there’s a funeral or not. My mum has organised that she goes to medical science, so her body won’t be there, but we’ll still have a memorial for her when she dies.
godmum56 · 29/01/2022 12:24

@TheWordWomanIsTaken
"A funeral takes priority over everything else from the estate. Even HMRC."

that assumes that the funeral happens and is paid for before probate.

FortunesFave · 29/01/2022 12:24

I'm really surprised at the people saying they're traumatic. If anything, the LOSS might be traumatic, certainly. The funeral's "job" is to soothe that loss, and centre the joyousness of the life of the deceased, EVEN if they were a miserable git

Have you ever been to a Catholic funeral? Or I should ask, are you religous? If you're not of a faith, funerals are in my opinion, even worse because the words of the priest or whoever don't really offer any comfort. It's all a strange world of unfamiliar things and routines...church when you don't usually, go, somber words being spoken, strange smells....people you don't see....awful.

Porcupineintherough · 29/01/2022 12:23

@AlternativePerspective

But again, and no-one has yet answered this, if you think that funerals are for the living and you have no right to decide whether or not you will have one, then surely you equally have no right to decide that you want your body donated to science? After all, your body isn’t yours to do with as you see fit because it’s the property of your family who have the ultimate say.
What's your question exactly? If you leave your body to science, science wont come get it til your next of kin notify them its available. If they don't, science wont turn up 10 years later wondering what happened to it. Science also wont fight for it if your nok say know, weve decided that what Alternative Perspective really wanted was to be interred in an expensive mausoleum.

It's the same principle by which an organ donation card is an expression of intent but your nok get the final decision.

Whoopsies · 29/01/2022 12:23

Both my parents are opting for this, they have said they will leave money for a small wake to be held for them both but no funeral. Me and my sisters are totally fine with this, actually I like it!!

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 29/01/2022 12:23

Two family members of ours who had left their body to medical science had their bodies refused in covid times! Leave a Plan B...

You can also have an in-between thing which is just the cremation but attend it. Direct to cremation can take place a long way away and no-one is there. But you can attend cremations and still not have a funeral which is the service that usually happens beforehand.

ancientgran · 29/01/2022 12:22

I know someone who did this and a couple of people who are planning to do it. The plan was/is that there is a direct cremation and then plan for everyone who wants to be involved to meet up to scatter the ashes. Nothing formal, no issues of when the crem/church/cemetery can fit you in. Everyone then going for a meal.

No religious issue for these people and they all want something more informal. I think it sounds fine.

For myself I am Catholic and want to be received into the church the night before and have a Mass said. If you aren't a believer I don't think you should have to do something like that.

AlternativePerspective · 29/01/2022 12:22

The body is either cremated or buried but the funeral is the service and the words spoken/songs sung. but you don’t need a body to have a funeral/memorial whatever.

So, direct cremation and then the family can have whatever else they can afford.

FortunesFave · 29/01/2022 12:22

Sorry I didn't meant to attach that to TheWordWomanIsTaken post!

godmum56 · 29/01/2022 12:21

@astoundedgoat

Gosh. I absolutely LOVE a good funeral. But I'm from a culture that traditionally goes all in for them. Big events, family and friends invited. A celebration of life, so it would be unthinkable not to have a nice big funeral.

I'm really surprised at the people saying they're traumatic. If anything, the LOSS might be traumatic, certainly. The funeral's "job" is to soothe that loss, and centre the joyousness of the life of the deceased, EVEN if they were a miserable git. :)

But we also do them very quickly after the death. Someone I know here in the UK only yesterday buried a loved one who died back in mid December, which is just astonishing to me.

well that works for you and that's great...it sounds cultural to me....like a cultural expectation...... When I arranged a very low key affair for DH (there was no such thing as direct cremation then) I got a LOT of feedback from friends and work colleagues about how wrong I was being because the culture was for them all to turn up and have a piss up afterwards. I told them it wasn't happening and told the funeral home that the short service was to be strictly private and no details given out to anybody who asked. Even where is part of the culture, its not always right or what those closest want.
FortunesFave · 29/01/2022 12:21

@TheWordWomanIsTaken

Those that want to leave their bodies to medical science - you should still plan for an alternative or make your wishes known. Many many bodies are not accepted after death. And if they are accepted before death, they may not be after death depending on the circumstances - if there's been a post mortem for eg.
My last response was for @AlternativePerspective.
warmeduppizza · 29/01/2022 12:21

@Torunette I found your post very helpful and wise.

And yes, people in the funeral industry believe in funerals, not because we personally make a fortune (we don’t), but because we’ve seen families through the process and experienced first hand how it has helped them.

user1497207191 · 29/01/2022 12:21

OH and I have both said we don't want a funeral. I really don't "get" it at all. We'd rather see/talk to relatives/friends whilst we're alive as we won't benefit from them coming when we're dead!

billysboy · 29/01/2022 12:20

we had a direct cremation for my late father

No one really knew much about them , however all went smoothly and we then had a memorial day about a month later in the village hall

The lady remarked what a brilliant " service " it was and" God was not mentioned once "

I organised the whole thing with my sister and we asked a celebrant to be present to keep it all together

A lot of people remarked what a fantastic afternoon it was and that they didnt know it was possible

After the cremation etc you could do as much or as little as suits you

FortunesFave · 29/01/2022 12:19

But again, and no-one has yet answered this, if you think that funerals are for the living and you have no right to decide whether or not you will have one, then surely you equally have no right to decide that you want your body donated to science? After all, your body isn’t yours to do with as you see fit because it’s the property of your family who have the ultimate say.

This is irrelevant because the lack of an assembly with some traditional words is nothing to do with what happens to the body. Hmm The body is either cremated or buried but the funeral is the service and the words spoken/songs sung.

TheWordWomanIsTaken · 29/01/2022 12:17

Those that want to leave their bodies to medical science - you should still plan for an alternative or make your wishes known.
Many many bodies are not accepted after death.
And if they are accepted before death, they may not be after death depending on the circumstances - if there's been a post mortem for eg.

FortunesFave · 29/01/2022 12:16

It's absolutely fine! You can just have a moment alone or as a family.

TheWordWomanIsTaken · 29/01/2022 12:15

[quote godmum56]@NewYearNewMinty

one of the points of the buy ahead plan is that usually it fixes the price for what you want. We know that things can go up massively in price and what you can afford to leave may not cover even a simple funeral at the time its needed....also if its left as money its part of the estate and has to be treated as such.....may be taken to pay a credit card bill for instance....if you have prepaid, all of that is avoided.[/quote]
A funeral takes priority over everything else from the estate. Even HMRC.