Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not having a funeral is OK?

561 replies

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:32

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 29/01/2022 13:25

@mum11970

YANBU in my opinion and what I have told my family I would prefer. The thought of my children lined up after my cremation having to make small talk with everyone as they exit the crem is my idea of hell. Why would I want to put them through that? That’s without taking into account how expensive it is. If they wish to get together and have a wake or just a cup of tea would be totally up to them. Being the centre of attention for any reason fills me with horror and don’t feel my death should be the total opposite of my personality.
You could just have a funeral for family only if being the centre of attention is your issue.
Calennig · 29/01/2022 13:24

DH uncle shopped around with funeral costs and saved thousands with his parents each time - they weren't in a rush one case family were away on holiday so there was a delay anyway.

Not so sure I'd have had the presence of mind to do similar.

Where we used to live local paper did some articles claiming funeral costs were the highest in the country to do with restricted access to burrial and cremation sites.

So I do think there can be considerable varration with costs which may not be immediately apparent to greiving family.

Gwenhwyfar · 29/01/2022 13:24

@Pinkyantelope

It sounds like you've been to some awful funerals. I've been to a few like that but also been to modern ones that are all about the person that died and their lives, plus those left behind. No religious music. Humour and touching mementoes on the coffin etc. Having a humanist celebrant rather than a vicar helps massively.
The hymns are the best part. I don't think 'modern music' is necessarily better at helping people through their grief.
RuthTopp · 29/01/2022 13:24

You should have the funeral you want .
You could suggest to people they have a celebration of your life , by having a party of some kind , or a get together to scatter ashes in your favourite place with a picnic after and put money away for it to facilitate the event.

mum11970 · 29/01/2022 13:24

YANBU in my opinion and what I have told my family I would prefer. The thought of my children lined up after my cremation having to make small talk with everyone as they exit the crem is my idea of hell. Why would I want to put them through that? That’s without taking into account how expensive it is. If they wish to get together and have a wake or just a cup of tea would be totally up to them. Being the centre of attention for any reason fills me with horror and don’t feel my death should be the total opposite of my personality.

lljkk · 29/01/2022 13:21

My mother said she wanted a rowdy wake - instead we had a prim & proper church service since that's what comforted my relatives. They would have hated a carousing event.

I feel horrified at idea of people talking about me like folk talk at a funeral about the deceased (I've attended 3 funerals this year). But I won't be there -- sobeit.

...
Pinkyantelope · 29/01/2022 13:21

It sounds like you've been to some awful funerals. I've been to a few like that but also been to modern ones that are all about the person that died and their lives, plus those left behind. No religious music. Humour and touching mementoes on the coffin etc. Having a humanist celebrant rather than a vicar helps massively.

Halfabag · 29/01/2022 13:20

Hmm. Nobody should force you if you really don’t want it, however I’d be thinking of what my kids want. They’re the ones who will have to grieve and I wouldn’t want to do any psychological damage to them! Yes it’s an old fashioned thing, as many traditions are but it does mean it’s in many of us to view the funeral as necessary for us to grieve properly. I had a few funerals in lockdown that I couldn’t go to (restricted to 6) and we found it quite difficult not saying goodbye in any formal way. Please don’t think I’m saying direct cremation is wrong or selfish in itself, I don’t. I do think though that I’d be discussing as a family when they’re old enough, because it’s them who will have to go through it.

astoundedgoat · 29/01/2022 13:20

@ABCeasyasdohrayme I clarified in my subsequent post above that I wasn't referring to funerals for children, but was speaking within the context of most of the posts here which are assuming death in old age.

Nothing can lessen the sorrow of burying a child, and I am truly sorry for your losses.

Gwenhwyfar · 29/01/2022 13:19

"I know of people who attended who he had washed his hands of when he was alive. So they only went out of guilt/hypocrisy."

Or maybe regret?

CrimbleCrumble1 · 29/01/2022 13:17

I had a middle option for my DF. It’s called a Simple Service and is a cremation earlyish in the morning, a shorter than normal service, three songs, a short speech and a poem. No flowers or wake. It was perfect for him and cost 2K. Ideally I would have liked a small wake, coffee and cake type of thing but it was during lockdown so we couldn’t have one.

Frankley · 29/01/2022 13:17

YANBU. My husband died a year ago. We had discussed funerals and decided we wanted direct Cremation. I used Pure Cremation, I'd read about them but not signed up or prepaid. They were excellent. I recently decided l wanted to do something and l am going to plant a tree at the local Natural burial field which will have his name attached. A few family members are coming and we will all go to a nearby restaurant afterwards. I didn't know what l wanted till now.
This has been a perfect way for me and I'm sure this would have pleased him.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 29/01/2022 13:17

Mum definitely didn't have a basics funeral. But nowhere near 7k at a basic cost.

I wonder if there are strong national and regional differences through the UK?

iklboo · 29/01/2022 13:15

Honestly funerals arent about you, your funeral isn't your decision

It absolutely is. That's why they ask for your preference in wills.

Gwenhwyfar · 29/01/2022 13:14

"Not convinced the formal funeral setting allows people to actually grieve - more of a stiff upper lip setup."

Well, no, it's one of the few places open crying is allowed.

Pallisers · 29/01/2022 13:14

I'm Irish and always loved the big funeral. But recently my stepdad died and there was no funeral/no memorial service at all. he didn't want one. Just a cremation. There was no pushback from family because of covid.

I was surprised at how good it felt not to have to turn around immediately after a death and organise a funeral/meet everyone. We were able to just adjust to his death in our own time. Missing all the aspects of a funeral that had given me comfort in the past didn't matter at all.

I've known two people in close family/friends who died tragically young. One had a tiny private funeral - not even aunts or uncles there. One had a big funeral for everyone - beautiful eulogy by the parents, friends involved, music that mattered, lunch for everyone after with photos of the lovely young person everywhere. I would have done the second but I know that both sets of parents grieved in the same way afterwards and in the end the funeral wasn't going to solve or not solve anything much - just personal preference.

I think you do what you want and it is fine.

Crackercrazy · 29/01/2022 13:13

@HappyPumpkin81

I don't want a funeral. I'm happy for everyone who knows/knew me to go to the pub together for a knees up.
This exactly how I feel except the pub - I’d like everyone to go for a cream tea (my favourite) and think of me.

Ultimately though, funerals are for the living aren’t they? When I told my mum about direct cremation, she pointed out that my DC might like the ‘closure’ of a funeral…difficult one really.

AlDanvers · 29/01/2022 13:12

@AngelinaFibres

Funerals are at least £7,000 these days plus the cost of a coffin floral spray and the wake food, drink and location afterwards. If the deceased hasn't planned financially it is a huge burden for the relatives. There is a bit of financial help that you can apply for but it is a drop in the ocean of all the costs. I would rather my children and the small number of other people I truly love, had a fabulous meal , dressed up in something lovely and remembered stuff about me. I live in a village where lots of people have died recently. It seems to have almost become a hobby for other people to attend funerals. We had 3 in a week during July. No need for them to do an evening meal those nights because they can just pop into the wake.
No they aren't. We recently paid 3.5k. Including the wake and Post funeral good and drink.

Of course if you want to spend more you. Usually don't need to know. Mum definitely didn't have a basics funeral. But nowhere near 7k at a basic cost.

ddl1 · 29/01/2022 13:12

I disagree with you about funerals being for the living. Why should I pay for something I don't want or believe in, and find abhorrent?

I would prefer no funeral for myself, but I do disagree on this. The funeral costs will come out of the estate so your family will presumably have their inheritance reduced - so it's them who are paying for it, not you (as the cliche goes , 'you can't take it with you').

Calennig · 29/01/2022 13:12

My IL early 70s very social do now seem to enjoy a good funeral we get to hear all about them Hmm- but it's their friends I don't think that was so true when it was their close family.

I certainly haven't found GP funerals great - vicar didn't know then so it was generic talk - lots of people not seen for years all expecting to be fed and watered by family who frequently been ground down prior to it all with caring reponsiblites. Usually not much about the person being burried with my family - seemed similar with DH family as well.

I don't know if it's just my family but many big visible events don't seem to happen any more - weddings either not done or very small, christening not done -graduations not always a big thing.

I do wonder if this is the way things are moving in our culture.

I don't think it a wrong choice - and when it's time the children/relatives wll have options to do more if they choose if they feel the need for something.

iklboo · 29/01/2022 13:12

We've just had a direct cremation for my dad. Mum's housebound so wouldn't be able to get to a service. We're having a small wake at home instead. We've already said goodbye when he died, we don't need to be in a crematorium or around a grave for that. I understand some people feel differently, of course.

Plus direct cremation is £££ cheaper.

Guacamole001 · 29/01/2022 13:12

I also think funerals attract people going who did not care enough about the person when they were alive. So why go when the are gone? Madness.

A friend died last summer and he had not seen his daughter for years due to a falling out. She was the one organising the funeral and apparently very upset. I did not go due to worries about covid but I know of people who attended who he had washed his hands of when he was alive. So they only went out of guilt/hypocrisy.

Just our culture I guess.

ChrimboGateauxCatto · 29/01/2022 13:11

The funeral is for your surviving relatives. Speak to them x

user1496146479 · 29/01/2022 13:11

@jevoudrais

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

Where I am, funeral takes place with 1-2 days. Much easier to get closure
dottydodah · 29/01/2022 13:11

godmum56 Dad died when I was a child . Didnt go to the Funeral though. You are probably right ,many people can grieve without a Funeral . I just think its a way of saying goodbye properly . Still imagine it would seem strange if someone passed and no arrangements made. The Vicar said as much to my friend who didnt want one for her Dad when he went in his 80s .I must admit I hate going to one and find them traumatic.Very little spoken of Death in our Society I think .