Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think not having a funeral is OK?

561 replies

jevoudrais · 29/01/2022 10:32

Looking at prepaying funeral or cremation plans for DH and I. I've realised you can do a direct cremation without a funeral service.

Does anyone think this robs anyone of the chance to say goodbye? My brother died last year and the wait for the funeral was horrendous. The funeral was horrendous. I can't say I've found the six funerals I've been to in my life remotely helpful in any way for grieving and such like. I feel they have dragged the grieving out further, if anything.

If we go for direct cremations, are we going to cause our DC issues by taking that experience of planning and attending a funeral away from them?

YANBU - direct cremation sounds easy and simple
YABU - it's not up to you, it's the decision of those left behind (but I fear they would do a funeral because they feel they 'should'?)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
oviraptor21 · 24/02/2022 19:35

Funerals are for the living not the dead.

My funeral is for me. I don't want money wasted on a funeral service.
A party sounds nice, maybe with some speeches.
Then scatter my ashes in a planting hole for a nice tree somewhere and have a little plaque maybe for those that need that physical symbol. I wonder if that can be done.

KimDeals · 24/02/2022 10:22

I think it’s awful how funerals take place so long after the death in the U.K. In Ireland the funeral is three days later: removals the night before. It’s intense and it happens when grief is raw and it feels appropriate. I would hate to have that window drawn out for a month.

I think funerals are really important. I wouldn’t like to skip any. Even the most tragic ones, - I mean I hate funerals, but they are healing and you share a pain with others.

LetsGoCrazyPurpleBanana · 24/02/2022 10:14

I don't know how my dad did it. He was diagnosed with cancer and he paid for and chose his coffin etc so my mum didn't have to worry about it. Selfless til the end.

Sausagedogsarethebest · 24/02/2022 09:59

I believe 'traditional' funerals will become less popular in years to come, mostly for those who are not hugely religious. It's not just the time taken to arrange everything, it's the cost, which is only expected to go up and up in the future (and I say all this as a funeral arranger).

My own mum is leaning towards direct cremation and I'll be honoured to arrange that for her through my own company.

For those of you who do want to have the full works my only suggestion is to invest in a pre-paid plan now (if you can afford to) so that you pay today's prices for your funeral director's costs. Make sure you use a company whose plan is fully regulated by the FCA.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 24/02/2022 09:55

IMO the funeral is for those left behind, so it should be what they would choose - whether a direct, no fuss cremation, or the whole works. Might add that while sitting outside a pub in Tooting (SW London) recently, I witnessed a funeral procession with black plumed horses pulling a glass sided coach, coachman in black top hat, etc.

I hadn’t imagined that such funerals really happened any more. It was like something out of Dickens.

The last funeral I attended was my mother’s, not really a dreadfully sad occasion since she was 97 and had had advanced dementia for some years. So although it’s a horrible cliche, it really was a ‘merciful release’.

Because she was fairly traditional, we did have a ‘proper’ funeral, with favourite hymns, and her much-loved ‘Jesu joy of man’s desiring’ played as we entered.
I’m not at all religious, but I did find it comforting.

A childless aunt had been considerate enough to prepay her own funeral - a traditional but simple enough one - so we didn’t have to wonder what she’d have wanted.

Figmentofmyimagination · 24/02/2022 09:42

Also, all the admin effort those closest to you have to go to to track down relatives and friends, make arrangements etc, just when they are at their saddest. It seems a counter-intuitive thing to expect people to do.

And after organising my mum’s funeral, I feel these funeral companies take advantage of the bereaved. It’s v awkward having conversations with funeral companies about cost cutting in relation to hearse, coffin etc when the money is there in the estate and you just feel like a cheap skate.

Also awkward when just one sibling is wealthier than the others and feels under pressure to foot the bill.

Figmentofmyimagination · 24/02/2022 09:37

This is interesting. I don’t really want a funeral as I’m embarrassed at how few people will come, compared with my sister who is way nicer, kinder and more sociable than me. I’m hoping I die first so I won’t be there for the mortification at the tiny handful of people who will be there. Don’t get me started on how utterly irrational this is!

caringcarer · 24/02/2022 09:36

My Mum was a believer in the afterlife and I read the eulogy at her funeral. She had planned her own funeral in so much as she chose her favourite hymns and readings, She had been very ill with cancer for about 3 months before passing. This was years before Covid. I was really dreading the funeral, but on the day I found it strangely comforting stood at the front seeing all her family, friends and neighbours gathered in the church. She had over 70 people there and I knew she had touched them all. The old man she cooked a Sunday dinner for, ladies from Parish Council she arranged flowers with, a couple of old school friends, people she used to work with, to great grand children, I felt proud of her and proud of myself for not crying whilst delivering the eulogy. Then trip to cemetery for burial for a smaller number. I am glad I had that experience and she had organised a catered buffet for afterwards where a lot of her older friends and colleagues came and told us lovely things about Mum when she was younger. My fil died during Covid and it was awful. DH was not allowed to travel to see him before he died. Only 8 allowed to crematorium including celebrant, 20 minute service with taped music and no singing. Very difficult telling some people they could not go in person but welcome to do the video link. Funerals are for those left behind. My mil is still upset she had to choose between children and in laws and fil's siblings to go to funeral.

Jk987 · 24/02/2022 09:06

It doesn't have to be a funeral in the traditional sense. I do think loved ones need a sense of closure though in order to help the grieving process. You can chose what this looks like. A get together of loved ones in form or another. You decide.

DiscordandRhyme · 24/02/2022 09:04

I'm not fussed on a funeral.

Half the people who go acr sad but never bothered with you in life, which seems so fake.

I'd rather close friends and family spent time together, perhaps a meal or watching a marathon of my favourite films or something in memory.

blobby10 · 24/02/2022 09:01

I've told my 3 (young adult) children that I don't want a funeral or wake - I don't have any friends tbh and would be so embarrassed when no one turned up! So my wish is to be directly cremated then have my ashes scattered (on an off-shore breeze) off the cliffs of my favourite beach then any money that is saved by not having a funeral and wake can be shared between them. Kids are fine with it.

My mother has said if I die before her it would be terribly selfish of me to not allow her and my siblings to say goodbye properly etc etc.

This thread has reminded me that I need to get my will sorted and have my wishes put into writing! Grin

LetsGoCrazyPurpleBanana · 24/02/2022 08:53

My mum has told me she has prepaid with pure cremation. We lost my dad almost 3 years ago and we have a small family. NC with brother. I wasn't sure how I felt to be honest as I was told I wouldn't be able to see her after she passed,which had helped with previous family who had died and my grief process. One thing that does worry me is because I'm NC with brother,I can imagine him getting very difficult re mum's ashes. Would they automatically go to me being the oldest? Or would they half them?No one seems to know anything. It does worry me :'(

Furries · 23/02/2022 23:45

@A580Hojas

I don't think funerals are a "non-sensical ritual". Every faith and every culture in the world has some way or other of sending a dead body off. Bodies can't just be left to rot where they fell.
I don’t think that anyone on this thread is advocating for bodies to be left where they fell - that’s a very odd takeaway re this thread!

I still can’t get my head around those that think it’s acceptable to go against the express wishes of the deceased. That, to me, is definitely a “fuck you”. The fact that, when you’re gone, your thoughts/feelings/wishes are so inconsequential - just feels wrong on so many levels.

Maybe I’ll change my will - if my wishes haven’t been followed, then my assets go elsewhere! I feel I have the right to decide what happens to me when I die.

I am NOT against funerals/cremation services. But I really think that the wishes of that person should be followed.

2bazookas · 23/02/2022 20:38

You can have a direct cremation , and also hold a separate little farewell or memorial service of your own. I've been to a couple of these and they were lovely, one was in the home of the deceased and the other in their garden . But you could do it anywhere, favourite hill or beach.

Quite recently a friend  died who has left their body  for medical   research; so no funeral.  The family held a little memorial service  at home.  No prayers , just friends and family gathered to appreciate his life and say goodbye.
Fordian · 23/02/2022 20:36

I have cut from first post to the end. Sorry. I normally scroll through threads but this is 500 posts long.

My tuppence? Both my parents died (me aged 47/53). Dad died overseas, and was cremated there, ashes flown back; whence we had a memorial service at the local church, followed by a 'do' locally. It was great.

Thus we did the same for mum (which she would have liked- no fuss). Non attended cremation, ashes delivered. Memorial service (both in church, 'remembering the life of...')

No one had the whole coffin thing, the coffin in the cold earth; or curtains closing around the coffin at a crematorium.

It's never great, but no less grim. And for dad, we had to get his ashes delivered to a local funeral director, from who we collected. He, himself, said he favoured what we were doing. A nice floral arrangement in lieu of a coffin was much easier to handle.

Fl0w3ry · 23/02/2022 20:14

I think it’s a good idea. It would be nicer to have a positive event to remember a person - like a meal or a get together or a memory tree or something. Funerals are expensive and painful. I fully understand that some people need them to say goodbye though, in a ritualistic way. Personally, the way covid temporarily restricted numbers etc, it made me think differently about funerals. I’ve unfortunately been to a lot of funerals in my life, and I was also unable to attend funerals of a few people we lost in the pandemic because of number restrictions. I realised I still felt sad, not being at the funeral didn’t make that any worse though, and I was able to say goodbye in my own way.
I think if I were you I would just maybe run the idea by your immediate family and see what they think. They might prefer you spent the money from the pre-paid funeral with them now enjoying experiences together, when you are still alive.

Rory1234 · 23/02/2022 20:10

I lost a parent last year and they wanted this so it is what we did.

My family had our own immediate family only lunch where we played specially chosen music and ate food that reminded us of happier times.

I am so glad that is how things were. I absolutely couldn’t have coped with a funeral and having to see loads of people expressing their grief when I was so completely overwhelmed by my own.

Sazzlepop22 · 23/02/2022 20:08

My parents have just explained their wishes to myself and sister, about having direct cremations. I am happy that they have thought about their passing and made their wishes clear to us both now. We will respect them and I am sure I will find some comfort in it, when the time comes.

As long as you discuss with your kids when it's appropriate, it's your wish and you can discuss alternative ways to celebrate your life.

A580Hojas · 23/02/2022 19:40

I don't think funerals are a "non-sensical ritual". Every faith and every culture in the world has some way or other of sending a dead body off. Bodies can't just be left to rot where they fell.

A580Hojas · 23/02/2022 19:33

My Aunt had specified a direct cremation, which is what she got.

The family all got together and a had a whole day memorial in a pub anyway because we wanted to. There were readings, memories, lots of emotional stuff. The only difference to a "normal" funeral is that none of us were actually present on her cremation day. I look back on her memorial with great fondness as it was the last time the family all got together (early March 2020).

Your loved ones are going to want to mark your passing in some way. Might as well let them choose.

My mother is approaching the end of her life. She recently told me and my brother "please do whatever you want for my funeral, I just have these two pieces of music I'd like played and to be cremated at X crematorium, any donations to X charity". I think she has the right approach.

LightSpeeds · 23/02/2022 19:32

@EishetChayil

The funeral isn't for you; it's part of the grieving process for those left behind.
I agree with this. It's for the people left behind to decide what they need.
LilacPaisley · 23/02/2022 19:26

I mean not having a traditional funeral.

LilacPaisley · 23/02/2022 19:20

Do you think it's a fuck you even if they know it's what you want? I am finding it hard to imagine how it's seen as a fuck you

It's hard to imagine because nobody would see it that way, especially if they know it's what you want and you discuss it beforehand. I've been thinking seriously about this for myself and this thread is tipping me towards it. I've lost both parents and a brother and the funerals were horrible. I was distraught at each one. They made the loss worse. I do hope this new idea takes off so people can stop feeling guilty about having one.

balalake · 23/02/2022 19:08

Whilst I want there to be a funeral when I die, if someone does not want one, that is their choice and I would respect that.

Not having a funeral does not prevent some form of memorial event taking place at a later date, say on what would have been their next birthday.

JudgeJ · 23/02/2022 19:05

@ThePlantsitter

I think your children would feel it as a 'fuck off' from beyond the grave tbh.

Sorry about your brother. Flowers

Many people haven't been able to have full funerals for the last two years. After my OH's cremation locally we had a small ceremony in the local church yard to inter his ashes and I think my daughters found that very comforting, it's something that those looking to a direct cremation could look into if they want a permanent place to go.