Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu or is dh ?

411 replies

P4nicSt4tions · 29/01/2022 08:35

We live in a seaside town and I commute into London 4-5 days a week. My commute - door to door - is approx 4-4.5hrs round trip due to me recently working the other side of London (not sure how long this is sustainable but that's besides the point I'm trying to make). My work day is long and I work hard for our family. DH works 3.5days during week days 30mins drive away.

I have two dc aged 15&9 (not dh's) who I share custody of with their dad. On days I'm in London I walk to station at 6:30am from our house. It is a 15-20min walk. DH will keep the car and kindly helps with school runs on days I have my dc. The studio I work in is open on a Saturday so i work on the Saturdays I don't have my children EOW and take a day off during the week to do school runs and collect my children at normal pick up times. So DH will help with school run two days max per week.

The Saturday I work (which is today - I'm on the train now) I ask DH for a lift. I get a later train at 8:07am so not super early and DH thinks this is unfair. I have said to him that I am happy to drive myself to station and take the key to London and drive it back tonight. He feels this means I am strong arming him into making him give me a lift when it is his day off and he could be sleeping. He said it is ridiculous I will keep him from using the car all day on an Saturday to avoid doing a 15-20min walk to station.

Aibu at feeling so upset at his lack of consideration towards me when I am working my arse off to support our family which includes doing a hellish commute ? When he has 3.5days off a week, works much shorter hours and I am the breadwinner.

OP posts:
Ginandvomits · 30/01/2022 19:39

I wouldn't think twice at dropping my DH at the train station or him me. Since she's the main bread winner, she probably bought and paid for the car too.

P4nicSt4tions · 30/01/2022 19:12

We don't need more money. This isn't about that. It is about the division of responsibilities and what is fair in other ways than finances

OP posts:
CaptainCabinets · 30/01/2022 18:51

[quote silkience]@CaptainCabinets what? Confused

This thread is nothing to do with providing for someone else's children. The children sound perfectly well provided for! I have no idea why some people think he should work more hours. It is irrelevant to the op's point

The point is when one person's life is more exhausting, when they have less downtime, more stress etc, if you are in a loving relationship you do nice things for each other....but perhaps more so for the person who has it harder ?..... just natural fairness to me ..
[/quote]
There are many comments asking why he doesn’t work more to contribute to family expenses.

silkience · 30/01/2022 18:42

@CaptainCabinets what? Confused

This thread is nothing to do with providing for someone else's children. The children sound perfectly well provided for! I have no idea why some people think he should work more hours. It is irrelevant to the op's point

The point is when one person's life is more exhausting, when they have less downtime, more stress etc, if you are in a loving relationship you do nice things for each other....but perhaps more so for the person who has it harder ?..... just natural fairness to me ..

P4nicSt4tions · 30/01/2022 18:33

@CaptainCabinets

Can you imagine the responses if OP was a man? Grin

Would anyone be telling him to tell his wife to work more and stop being so lazy because she has to provide for someone else’s children? Would they fuck.

Also YABU, fresh air and exercise is good for you before sitting on a train for two hours.

I sit on the train for 1hr 12mins. I then cycle from st pancras to Chelsea. That takes the same time as walking down to the tube, getting the tube, then walking from tube station to my place of work. I get more than enough physical exercise as I cycle back too (10 miles per day)
OP posts:
CaptainCabinets · 30/01/2022 18:06

Can you imagine the responses if OP was a man? Grin

Would anyone be telling him to tell his wife to work more and stop being so lazy because she has to provide for someone else’s children? Would they fuck.

Also YABU, fresh air and exercise is good for you before sitting on a train for two hours.

Cherrysherbet · 30/01/2022 17:50

I’m torn here. On the one hand, if it was me I wouldn’t think it was fair to get my dh up just to save me a walk. On the other hand, I know he would offer to, just to make my life easier .

I don’t think either of you are being really unreasonable. It seems to be a minor problem, unless there is a bigger resentment bubbling under the surface here?

It does sound a little like you want to drag him out of bed, because he gets more days off that you do?! If that’s the case, then you may need to talk about the bigger picture. Your commute does sound like hell.

Getting another key cut is probably the best solution in the short term, but won’t solve the actual problem.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 30/01/2022 17:29

[quote BABAHOTEL]@fairylightsandwaxmelts because successful relationships thrive on being kind and acting as a team. Helping your partner, making life easy for each other.

Something you don't value obviously LOL!!! [/quote]
Hmm, on the contrary - I would argue that it's not necessarily "being kind" to expect someone to get up early just to save you a 10-15 minute walk, especially when there are plenty of other ways to avoid that walk anyway.

P4nicSt4tions · 30/01/2022 17:20

@PinkSyCo

It hasn't been 50/50 tbh (read the responses ) and yes if a woman had so much time to herself (he actually has 3.5days off so one week in a fortnight he has off work child free ) then she would be flamed for not doing a small favour to her much harder working bread winning partner

But it’s not his fault that you have kids and that you have a long commute to work. You sound jealous of him, hence you would rather he needlessly got up early rather than doing the obvious thing of getting another bloody key. To be honest it seems like you need him more than he needs you so I would not be so petty about this if I were you.

You appear to have skim read and not taken in my responses which address your argument
OP posts:
Concestor · 30/01/2022 17:11

I used to commute 4 hours a day and I know how tiring it is but I still think YABU to expect him to get up early to take you to the station, and for not just getting a new key cut so he can collect the car from the station later if he needs it.
I think he should then collect you at the end of the day though, as for me it was always that last bit of walking that killed me at the end of the day. Although I lived alone and had to do it anyway.
He is also BU for not suggesting these things.

nanbread · 30/01/2022 17:07

Get him to pick you up on the way back but walk to the station in the morning. It will add on what, 10 mins to your commute once a fortnight?

PinkSyCo · 30/01/2022 16:55

Also you say you are the breadwinner but are you saying your partner doesn’t pay his way?

PinkSyCo · 30/01/2022 16:51

It hasn't been 50/50 tbh (read the responses ) and yes if a woman had so much time to herself (he actually has 3.5days off so one week in a fortnight he has off work child free ) then she would be flamed for not doing a small favour to her much harder working bread winning partner

But it’s not his fault that you have kids and that you have a long commute to work. You sound jealous of him, hence you would rather he needlessly got up early rather than doing the obvious thing of getting another bloody key. To be honest it seems like you need him more than he needs you so I would not be so petty about this if I were you.

BABAHOTEL · 30/01/2022 16:02

@fairylightsandwaxmelts because successful relationships thrive on being kind and acting as a team. Helping your partner, making life easy for each other.

Something you don't value obviously LOL!!!

HTH1 · 30/01/2022 15:33

There is no way in hell I would do that commute, maybe worth a re-think especially if you’re the breadwinner and DH is working so few hours (why is that?).

But putting that aside, getting another car key cut or DH just driving you in his PJs would be the best solution.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 30/01/2022 15:32

[quote BABAHOTEL]@fairylightsandwaxmelts so it's no beg deal 10 drive twice a month, so why doesn't he do it? [/quote]
Because he doesn't want to?

Why does he need a valid reason anyway? lol.

BABAHOTEL · 30/01/2022 15:28

*big

BABAHOTEL · 30/01/2022 15:25

@fairylightsandwaxmelts so it's no beg deal 10 drive twice a month, so why doesn't he do it?

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 30/01/2022 13:59

@silkience

Can I please point out that there have been numerous threads where women who work part time and need to do very little in the way of childcare have their arses handed to them for expecting their DH who works long hours to do things for them.

@fairylightsandwaxmelts you have literally had it spelt out chapter and verse to you that he does a total of one hour of after school care a week, and two mornings, how much can there even be to do with kids that age, most will sort themselves out! Yet you continue to repeat "he already does a lot to help you out" etc.

Yes it's nice that he drops the younger one into school, but he doesn't have to do anything to help out in the holidays so that three or four hours works out as about two hours a week over the course of the year! Christ I've done more for my neighbour just because she was struggling, this is op's husband, why are you making out that this is some kind of huge contribution that absolves him of anything else?

I'm not making out like it's a huge contribution at all Confused I'm just saying it's not like he doesn't already do things to help OP out as a result of her working hours, so it seems a bit silly to fall out over a 10 minute lift twice a month.
silkience · 30/01/2022 13:36

Can I please point out that there have been numerous threads where women who work part time and need to do very little in the way of childcare have their arses handed to them for expecting their DH who works long hours to do things for them.

@fairylightsandwaxmelts you have literally had it spelt out chapter and verse to you that he does a total of one hour of after school care a week, and two mornings, how much can there even be to do with kids that age, most will sort themselves out! Yet you continue to repeat "he already does a lot to help you out" etc.

Yes it's nice that he drops the younger one into school, but he doesn't have to do anything to help out in the holidays so that three or four hours works out as about two hours a week over the course of the year! Christ I've done more for my neighbour just because she was struggling, this is op's husband, why are you making out that this is some kind of huge contribution that absolves him of anything else?

P4nicSt4tions · 30/01/2022 13:14

@NuffSaidSam

We are working on a plan to make things fair so we are both happy.

Is the plan to get a second car key? 😂

Yes and other stuff. Such as division of housework.
OP posts:
P4nicSt4tions · 30/01/2022 13:13

@jevoudrais

I'm leaning towards YABU.

My commute is 5 hours round trip into London too. If we only had one car I think it would be selfish of me to take it just to leave it parked at the station all day. Shaving half an hour off that commute wouldn't make much difference to me. If it was half an hour off a two hour commute that's different, but I think for the time it saves it's pointless, and you should just walk.

This is partly why we have always had two cars. Yes it costs more, but the freedom not to rely on each other is everything.

Also I'm sorry to hear about your even more killer commute. Let's hope we look back and it is worth it.

I'm hoping soon that I can work closer to train station and cut commute down to 3hrs round trip. Which some would be horrified by but loads of people here commute to London every day. It's just part of life if you want well paid work

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 30/01/2022 13:12

We are working on a plan to make things fair so we are both happy.

Is the plan to get a second car key? 😂

P4nicSt4tions · 30/01/2022 13:09

@jevoudrais

I'm leaning towards YABU.

My commute is 5 hours round trip into London too. If we only had one car I think it would be selfish of me to take it just to leave it parked at the station all day. Shaving half an hour off that commute wouldn't make much difference to me. If it was half an hour off a two hour commute that's different, but I think for the time it saves it's pointless, and you should just walk.

This is partly why we have always had two cars. Yes it costs more, but the freedom not to rely on each other is everything.

Of course it makes more sense for me to spend thousands of pounds and further contribute towards fucking up the environment by buying a second car to avoid this every other Saturday.

We don't need another car. I need a second key. A more empathic DH. And a lobotomy at this point

OP posts:
jevoudrais · 30/01/2022 13:03

I'm leaning towards YABU.

My commute is 5 hours round trip into London too. If we only had one car I think it would be selfish of me to take it just to leave it parked at the station all day. Shaving half an hour off that commute wouldn't make much difference to me. If it was half an hour off a two hour commute that's different, but I think for the time it saves it's pointless, and you should just walk.

This is partly why we have always had two cars. Yes it costs more, but the freedom not to rely on each other is everything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread