Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu or is dh ?

411 replies

P4nicSt4tions · 29/01/2022 08:35

We live in a seaside town and I commute into London 4-5 days a week. My commute - door to door - is approx 4-4.5hrs round trip due to me recently working the other side of London (not sure how long this is sustainable but that's besides the point I'm trying to make). My work day is long and I work hard for our family. DH works 3.5days during week days 30mins drive away.

I have two dc aged 15&9 (not dh's) who I share custody of with their dad. On days I'm in London I walk to station at 6:30am from our house. It is a 15-20min walk. DH will keep the car and kindly helps with school runs on days I have my dc. The studio I work in is open on a Saturday so i work on the Saturdays I don't have my children EOW and take a day off during the week to do school runs and collect my children at normal pick up times. So DH will help with school run two days max per week.

The Saturday I work (which is today - I'm on the train now) I ask DH for a lift. I get a later train at 8:07am so not super early and DH thinks this is unfair. I have said to him that I am happy to drive myself to station and take the key to London and drive it back tonight. He feels this means I am strong arming him into making him give me a lift when it is his day off and he could be sleeping. He said it is ridiculous I will keep him from using the car all day on an Saturday to avoid doing a 15-20min walk to station.

Aibu at feeling so upset at his lack of consideration towards me when I am working my arse off to support our family which includes doing a hellish commute ? When he has 3.5days off a week, works much shorter hours and I am the breadwinner.

OP posts:
Pinkfluffyunicornsandrainbows · 29/01/2022 10:46

@P4nicSt4tions Yes sorry you did say you would take the car, my mistake. I think it's a tough one, you are probably exhausted and just want a little help from him once every other week but he maybe doesn't want his day disturbed by getting woken up early on a day he's not in work or being without the car all day. I don't see a clear cut right or wrong, i can see both sides of the argument. I think you feel very let down and unsupported that you work so hard and he won't sacrifice his lie in every other Saturday or do without the car for the day, I understand that. The spare key is the obvious solution but if you feel like there's more to this than just this one issue then you both need to talk about it and deal with things. I hope you can both work it out op.

Scianel · 29/01/2022 10:46

If you can't afford or don't want to buy a car

OP already owns a car.

inheritancetrack · 29/01/2022 10:45

He is being an arse not giving you a lift. He has a pretty easy life and the least he can do is show he cares about you and gives you this lift. He still gets plenty of lie ins

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 29/01/2022 10:45

DH collects them at 6pm after his work. My train gets in at 6:30

Ah, gotcha.

I would just get a second key cut or pay for a taxi if you don't want to walk, though.

DH and I do give each other lifts if absolutely necessary but it would becoming tiring if it was expected all the time when there's a simple solution.

P4nicSt4tions · 29/01/2022 10:44

@Iwonder08

There are many solutions to your problem without creating unnecessary drama.. Taxi, new key, another car, bike etc. You just feel you are entitled to it because you work more hours and earn more money. I would concentrate on addressing the bigger problem you have: why is your DH work fewer hours and doesn't earn more? I bet it annoys you and you feel the car is just that little thing he could have done for you
I think it is about caring for your OH. I would do it for him if I had 5 other days off in a fortnight to lie in bed.

I am happy for him to work PT. I think we need to work together on if he is working PT then what is fair in terms of addressing each other's needs.

OP posts:
Hb12 · 29/01/2022 10:43

I don't think you're unreasonable at all, he sounds like a petulant teenager. I'd take the car.

SirChenjins · 29/01/2022 10:43

YANBU - I can’t imagine a scenario where DH or I wouldn’t give each other a lift in this situation.

litlealligator · 29/01/2022 10:42

If you can't afford or don't want to buy a car, why not buy yourself a little moped? Then you can ride the moped to the station and the problem is resolved.

Iwonder08 · 29/01/2022 10:41

There are many solutions to your problem without creating unnecessary drama.. Taxi, new key, another car, bike etc. You just feel you are entitled to it because you work more hours and earn more money. I would concentrate on addressing the bigger problem you have: why is your DH work fewer hours and doesn't earn more? I bet it annoys you and you feel the car is just that little thing he could have done for you

P4nicSt4tions · 29/01/2022 10:41

@FawnFrenchieMum

I’m totally on the fence here, on paper I think DH is being unreasonable but I know deep down I would hate getting up on my day off to do it, even though I know I should do it. If DH has had to leave his van at work for any reason (if we’ve had holiday, they needed it for a weekend job and he wasn’t working etc), I have to get up on a Monday am and drop him off at 6am. I do it but I hate it.
I wouldn't ask for a lift at 6am. Or 7am. I think 8am is reasonable on a Saturday when you have 5 other days off in a fortnight to lie in bed until when you want to get up
OP posts:
Toffeevodkaplease · 29/01/2022 10:40

Sorry but if I was your dh I'd feel the same.

P4nicSt4tions · 29/01/2022 10:38

@fairylightsandwaxmelts

But why would he have to do unnecessary school clubs if your DH is around to do the school run? *@P4nicSt4tions*
DH collects them at 6pm after his work. My train gets in at 6:30
OP posts:
Youngstreet · 29/01/2022 10:38

I would tell dh to work more hours and buy himself a car.

P4nicSt4tions · 29/01/2022 10:38

@ExtraOnion

I really don’t understand the point of posts like this. OP has already decided that OH is being unreasonable, and she isn’t. She’s clearly not going to changed her mind … pointless.

For the record … get a cab, it’s a fiver and you are both sorted.

The point of the post is that I don't think I'm being unreasonable and Dh thinks he isn't being unreasonable. Lots of posters are saying I'm not, lots of posters are saying DH isn't. Based on conflicting responses, why would I conclude that iabu?

Also some posters have made some interesting suggestions and pov and I thank them for that

OP posts:
NeverAgainSam · 29/01/2022 10:36

So @P4nicSt4tions you agree with getting a key.

But are you still pissed off with your DH? Not being goady...just interested to see if it has calmed your emotions around it?

I think I would intially be really WTAFuckety fuck with my DH in a similar situation. Just fucking get up.

But actually the two sides have been suggested (plus there is a solution).

Not always easy to let go of the WTAFuckety fuck feelings though...

Mrstamborineman · 29/01/2022 10:36

Get a second key cut. You drive and he walks to pick up the car when he is ready. No brainer. He is NBU to want a lie in and be without the car all day. YAnbu to want to save time and get earlier trains. If you can walk so can he. Get a second key cut.

WidgetyWoo · 29/01/2022 10:36

And it’s not his “day off” - he has a day and a half during the week, plus weekends. Your DC are not young children who wake at 6am, so no-one is disrupting his “lie in” then!

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 29/01/2022 10:35

But why would he have to do unnecessary school clubs if your DH is around to do the school run? @P4nicSt4tions

WidgetyWoo · 29/01/2022 10:34

I think he should get up and give you a lift. My DH would do this without a second thought, and I am not the breadwinner.

Presumably the job you have and the money you make is enabling him to work only 3.5 days a week? And even if you were both full time I think he should be taking you, marriage is supposed to be about being a team which involves doing things you don’t HAVE to do for your spouse, but you do them because you love them.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 29/01/2022 10:34

So as it's a choice I would stop doing it @P4nicSt4tions.

I know you want to do the school run but realistically this kind of commute combined with working weekends isn't realistic long-term. You will exhaust yourself if you never have a proper day off with no early start and long commute.

Ask DH to do the school run on the weekdays your kids are there and have your weekends off to rest.

P4nicSt4tions · 29/01/2022 10:33

@fairylightsandwaxmelts

Do you have to work every other Saturday or are you choosing to do it so you get a day off in the week to do the school runs?

Personally I would just work during the week and get him to do the school runs (which he does most days anyway) and then you get a proper break at the weekends.

And I would rather be around for my kids than have a whole day off to myself without them. Doing lots of unnecessary after school clubs is not what I want for my 9yo so I'm doing my best to work around this
OP posts:
ExtraOnion · 29/01/2022 10:33

I really don’t understand the point of posts like this. OP has already decided that OH is being unreasonable, and she isn’t.
She’s clearly not going to changed her mind … pointless.

For the record … get a cab, it’s a fiver and you are both sorted.

P4nicSt4tions · 29/01/2022 10:32

@fairylightsandwaxmelts

Do you have to work every other Saturday or are you choosing to do it so you get a day off in the week to do the school runs?

Personally I would just work during the week and get him to do the school runs (which he does most days anyway) and then you get a proper break at the weekends.

I choose to do it to be there for my children at normal school day times on the week day I have off.
OP posts:
Chloemol · 29/01/2022 10:31

He gets t8me off in the week, it’s every other weekend

So yes take the car, he doesn’t like it he gets up and drops you off and picks you up and has the car

Or pays for another key picks the car up later then come and picks you up. It’s two days a month, not everyday

P4nicSt4tions · 29/01/2022 10:30

@Pinkfluffyunicornsandrainbows

On reading the comments i agree with what many other posters have said, get a second car key and that solves the problem. You can drive to the station, he collects the car if he wants to use it in the day and he either drops it back at the station for you to drive home or he picks you up.
Yes I agree and have said so above
OP posts: