Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School "lost" my vulnerable ADHD/ODD son today!

367 replies

3Daddy31982 · 28/01/2022 20:13

Head was nice to me. That in itself isn't normal. She said XXXX played a game with us today. I was a bit lost. Turns out they'd lost him for quite some time. He'd hidden in cupboard. Other child told us they'd been out shouting his name. Class children were also searching for him!

He has ehcp and meant to have a one to one. I've previously not been happy with TAs not watching him.

He also came out in huge sobbing tears.

When he'd calmed down he told us noone found him. He didn't want to go to assembly and they'd said he had to. He said he was on his own! Which he must have been if they didn't know where he was.

Gut feeling is he isn't safe at this school. Felt that way since Sept when my Dad went to pick third child up and saw him solo and unwatched.

OP posts:
dorkfink · 29/01/2022 12:09

@LetHimHaveIt sorry if I confused you.

You responded to my post saying curious question. I was simply responding to that & saying why I asked the question & imo didn't think it was curious. I'm not sure how you extrapolated from that that I think employment is utopia & everyone should be happy all of the time.

Personally, I'd be nothing but grateful to teachers and TAs to using their best endeavours to help my additional needs child in their learning.

I certainly don't believe in being blindly grateful without critical thinking when the circumstances are so vague so we all have to disagree there.

However I'm also not sure where I've made a particular judgement on the TA in this thread. My criticism is how the school responded to the incident & the lack of detail seemingly provided.

Spikeyball · 29/01/2022 12:09

Special schools don't generally provide 1:1 so they are not the solution for a runner unless being in the special school means the running and hiding doesn't happen ( these often happening because a child isn't coping with the mainstream environment ).

Scabetty · 29/01/2022 12:07

I would raise a complaint as schools are underfunded and understaffed at the moment and your child’s 1:1 may be being used as a class TA and 1:1. In my school class TAs are covering different 1:1 roles due to absence and lack of supply staff (covid) and not knowing the child you are responsible for is causing ‘issues’ that SLT ignore. Hope your dc is ok.

StationaryMagpie · 29/01/2022 12:07

@Burnshersmurfs

Specialist provision is not allocated on the basis that it prevents children running away and hiding in cupboards. Obviously, the child’s mother may feel that the school are not meeting the child’s needs for a range of other reasons, but we do not know what these are. If the EHCP provision is for 17hours 1-1 support then the level of support is not automatically adjusted because of the change to setting. I would seem a stronger argument to request additional hours of support within the current setting. This would be the next step after seeing whether a reasonable adjustment for this child might be that they do not have to go to assembly.
Well, it can be.. it was part of the consideration where my son is concerned as the local secondary schools are too easy for students to get into/out of during the day, and it was felt that his habit of bolting during a meltdown meant that they were a safety concern.
mynamesnotMa · 29/01/2022 12:07

Why did he Hide?
Have you discussed why this is wrong.
Kids are fast. Not the fault of the TA they aren't body guards. If there are repeated incidents then maybe look for another setting

Spikeyball · 29/01/2022 12:04

Just seen it is not full time. If the child cannot be kept safe on the hours allocated then the ehcp needs reviewing for extra hours or staffing. It depends on if this situation was unsafe. My child went from 1:1 to 2:1 because of safety needs.

Mumofsend · 29/01/2022 12:02

You generally won't get specialist school if you only need 17 hours of support.

Teenylittlefella · 29/01/2022 11:59

"It is LITERALLY the job of the 1 to 1 to 'watch a child constantly' for goodness sake."

No it really, really is NOT. Are you an education or SEN expert?

www.teachwire.net/news/send-teaching-assistants-should-you-use-the-velcro-or-helicopter-models-of-teaching

Burnshersmurfs · 29/01/2022 11:59

Specialist provision is not allocated on the basis that it prevents children running away and hiding in cupboards. Obviously, the child’s mother may feel that the school are not meeting the child’s needs for a range of other reasons, but we do not know what these are. If the EHCP provision is for 17hours 1-1 support then the level of support is not automatically adjusted because of the change to setting. I would seem a stronger argument to request additional hours of support within the current setting. This would be the next step after seeing whether a reasonable adjustment for this child might be that they do not have to go to assembly.

Spikeyball · 29/01/2022 11:59

"No one can watch a child constantly"

Some children do need watching constantly. That's what full time 1:1 or 2:1 is for.

MrsVeryTired · 29/01/2022 11:57

I think if he has a 1-1 for all his hours then you need to get clarification on what happened. Although if he was hiding in a cupboard then he needs to be told to not do that (unless he has a learning disability that means he can't understand).

All those saying schools are locked etc, they are locked to outsiders, they are not locked on the inside, and things vary depending on where you live.

WonderfulYou · 29/01/2022 11:53

At the end of the day if you feel your child is unsafe at school then you need to pull them out and homeschool them until you can find somewhere else.

PupInAPram · 29/01/2022 11:53

@toppkatz

Maybe the TA was sitting quietly waiting for him to come out?

Er... the OP's dd says she heard them calling his name for some time, and the head admitted that they couldn't find him.

The 1-1 is there for a reason, and that is so they don't take their eyes off him for a second. They neglected in that duty of care.

The school didn't neglect the duty of care. The 1 to 1 TA is for 17 hours a week. With covid rampant in schools at the moment, it's entirely possible this happened when one teacher was with a class of 30 six and seven year olds. If the teacher spent their whole time never taking their eyes off of op's child, even accompanying them to the toilet, they would be neglecting their duty of care to the other 29. Many of the posters suggesting op takes an adversarial or aggressive attitude with the school would be the first to whinge if schools were shut due to safety and safeguarding reasons!
heartonthetyne · 29/01/2022 11:52

@LindaEllen the OPs child has 17hrs a week 1:1, so that nowhere near covers a whole school week.
They've said in another post that they don't think mainstream is working out donator this is the point where that has become clear and her DS needs to be moved. I don't think it's the fault of the school.

RavenclawDiadem · 29/01/2022 11:51

did nobody read the message from @Periwinkletoes where she explained a real life scenario where despite everything being in place, a child still managed to evade their 1-1, who is never meant to act as a guard?

I completely understand the panic when a child disappears, even for a second (still recovering from losing a toddler for 30 seconds in Woolies in Abingdon around 2004). But rather than going in to school all guns blazing, or removing the child entirely causing more upheaval and upset for a child who is already struggling at school, I would advise working with them to put more strategies in place.

GlittercheeksOakleaf · 29/01/2022 11:51

It is NOT the job of a 1:1 to constantly have eyes on a child. That would require 2:1 or 3:1 supervision because TA's are not superhuman.

LetHimHaveIt · 29/01/2022 11:51

'It is LITERALLY the job of the 1 to 1 to 'watch a child constantly' for goodness sake.'

No. Nope. That's literally not what 1:1 means.

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 29/01/2022 11:50

We don’t know the age of the child, although I imagine he is the younger end of primary or infant.

We don’t know what the EHCP specifies in terms of hours. If it specifies all the hours the child is in school, then that is what the provision should be. That will mean more than oneTA, since an adult is entitled to a toilet break or a drink or something to eat during the course of the day, so those times must be covered. If it gives a number of hours that are less than the time the child is in school, then the school has to mitigate a risk by choosing the times when the child will have 1-1 support.

There may have been a reason why the school felt he had to be in assembly. If there isn’t, it would be a reasonable adjustment for a TA to do something with him in the classroom, rather than taking him into assembly. It’s important to find out if possible, what it is about assembly that upsets him.

I think OP needs to ask the school for a meeting to find out exactly what happened, what led up to it, what happened as a consequence and for a plan to be devised that will reduce the possibility of a similar circumstance. If she isn’t satisfied by that, it may be time to look for another school and probably an emergency review of the EHCP, to reflect that. Perhaps mainstream school isn’t the most appropriate setting, but that’s a decision for everyone involved, not for people here to decide.

I think that removing him from school might be in danger of allowing the local authority to abdicate responsibility for the boy’s education. If he’s withdrawn from school, without another one to go to, the OP will be regarded as withdrawing him to home educate.

LetHimHaveIt · 29/01/2022 11:50

@2reefsin30knots

The 1-1 is there for a reason, and that is so they don't take their eyes off him for a second. They neglected in that duty of care.

He doesn't have full time 1:1, in fact only about 50% of school hours. We don't know he had cover scheduled at the time he hid.

And that's not what 1:1 means at any rate! 1:1 can be understood as distinct from 2:1; 3:1; 15:1. It doesn't mean 24/7 (or the school time equivalent).'

'They neglected in that duty of care' is meaningless. Do you mean 'they were negligent in their duty of care'?

LindaEllen · 29/01/2022 11:46

@RedHelenB

No one can watch a child constantly. He ran away and hid, talking about paedophiles in the neighbourhood is a red herring, he was in school.all the time. I hope you told him in no uncertain terms that he shouldn't ever hide in a cupboard at school again.
It is LITERALLY the job of the 1 to 1 to 'watch a child constantly' for goodness sake.
danni0509 · 29/01/2022 11:45

[quote Porcupineintherough]@danni0509 and you never take your eyes off him for a second? That's your life is it, staring at him?[/quote]
I never said that. So don’t put words that never came out of my mouth.

I was responding to her post where she said do you follow your ODD kid to the toilet? Do they not play in their room unsupervised? And that the school have them more waking weekday hours. Yes I follow him to the toilet, no he doesn’t play upstairs unsupervised and no school don’t have him more hours than I do.

My ds needs hefty supervision. Always in sight or sound. (He quite often has 2-1 support in his specialist school)

LetHimHaveIt · 29/01/2022 11:45

'I have an ODD (adhd & autism) 8 year old child.

Yes I follow him to the toilet, he also has to follow me when I go. No he doesn’t play in his room without an adult to supervise him.

My sons special school doesn’t have him more waking weekday hours than I do either.'

Then I'd suggest you're unusual, and I'm further astonished that you ever get anything done in the evenings, at the weekends, during the holidays - a meal cooked; washing on. Ultimately, I suppose, you are his mother. But it's largely academic. The expectation that a TA has 'eyes on' every second is unrealistic. That is emphatically not* what 1:1 means.

2reefsin30knots · 29/01/2022 11:44

The 1-1 is there for a reason, and that is so they don't take their eyes off him for a second. They neglected in that duty of care.

He doesn't have full time 1:1, in fact only about 50% of school hours. We don't know he had cover scheduled at the time he hid.

Stellaroses · 29/01/2022 11:42

I'm just going to add to the posters saying they did not lose your son, he hid.
Am an SEN teacher, this could easily happen. No 1-1 Is superhuman and I bet even these SEN parents commenting "omfg sue the school" sometimes take their eyes off their child at home.
He was safe and was in an enclosed space- that he had chosen to get into. You and the school need to either work on his understanding of hiding not being acceptable in school, or he needs to not be in mainstream. Very sorry to be blunt but that is it.

applesandpearz · 29/01/2022 11:40

Since your gut feeling is he is unsafe at this school, move him rather than complain. Everyone's a winner then.
Does your DS have an understanding that hiding in a cupboard is wrong and not okay when his name is being called by a search party? He need to learn these things or go to a specialist school.