Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School "lost" my vulnerable ADHD/ODD son today!

367 replies

3Daddy31982 · 28/01/2022 20:13

Head was nice to me. That in itself isn't normal. She said XXXX played a game with us today. I was a bit lost. Turns out they'd lost him for quite some time. He'd hidden in cupboard. Other child told us they'd been out shouting his name. Class children were also searching for him!

He has ehcp and meant to have a one to one. I've previously not been happy with TAs not watching him.

He also came out in huge sobbing tears.

When he'd calmed down he told us noone found him. He didn't want to go to assembly and they'd said he had to. He said he was on his own! Which he must have been if they didn't know where he was.

Gut feeling is he isn't safe at this school. Felt that way since Sept when my Dad went to pick third child up and saw him solo and unwatched.

OP posts:
nocoolnamesleft · 29/01/2022 00:41

Does he have a 1 to 1 for as many hours as he is actually in school? Or have they done the usual thing in the EHCP and only funded part of the time?

Staffy1 · 29/01/2022 00:34

I don’t get the voting either. Obviously a lot of people who don’t understand why some children need 1 : 1. What really annoys me is the schools get funding especially for this, so they should bloody well provide it, not just palm off to several different arbs who just happen to be free or someone who is literally just going to watch the child and do nothing constructive with them, which happened in my experience. And as a PP said, there needs to be someone to cover for the times the assigned 1 : 1 is on any sort of break.

Nat6999 · 29/01/2022 00:23

An sen child at ds primary school managed to escape from the school grounds & it took several teams of police over 2 hours to find him & he was supposed to have constant 1:1 support.

Thirtytimesround · 29/01/2022 00:14

He was hiding, not lost surely? But follow your instincts re the school. Just looked up ODD: that must be so hard 😔

The 1:1 funding thing is weird in practice. I’ve volunteered in two schools where a child had 1:1 funding, yet “their” person was treated as an extra pair of hands and definitely not doing real 1:1. I suspect it never really happens in mainstream schools. The staff were a bit guilty about it but felt it was one of the many many things they can’t do properly because of underfunding.

Burnshersmurfs · 29/01/2022 00:12

The safety and security of the schools environment is one of the main parts of an Ofsted inspections. So no, I haven’t personally visited every school but I am aware that schools follow codes of practice and are carefully regulated.
I am not sure what posters think a specialist provision (without a clear idea that this child has additional SEMH, communication or learning needs) could have done for this child that mainstream hasn’t. The EHCP would still be for 1-1 support, and the child could still run off in exactly the same conditions.

Hospedia · 29/01/2022 00:05

Children in primary schools (again, assuming this is the setting, as middle schools are rare as hens’ teeth nowadays) do not have access to kitchens, heating cupboards, or maintenance offices. Schools risk assess carefully, as all young people are vulnerable.

Have you visited every school to check?

Burnshersmurfs · 29/01/2022 00:03

Children in primary schools (again, assuming this is the setting, as middle schools are rare as hens’ teeth nowadays) do not have access to kitchens, heating cupboards, or maintenance offices. Schools risk assess carefully, as all young people are vulnerable.

Motheranddaughtertotwo · 29/01/2022 00:00

I was a 1:1 for autistic children for over ten years. I would have never, ever have left them for a split second until someone was covering me. People seem ignorant as to the severity of leaving a child with particular needs unattended. I would kick off about this. Ignore the parenting advice, I hope your son is ok now.

amnm · 28/01/2022 23:59

If your child, of his own will, will deliberately hide in a cupboard, and deliberately not come out when he hears people calling his name, then you need to seriously consider if a mainstream school is the right place for him.

Mainstream schools can only do so much.

Keep in mind as well that If despite him having a 1:1, this still happens, then the school might look to use this as evidence that they are doing all they can and it isn't the right place for your child. Ultimately, if they feel your child's needs means they can't provide the best environment for him, they might push to have him moved elsewhere. And frankly, I think you need to consider as well if it's the best place for him.

Howshouldibehave · 28/01/2022 23:59

A 1:1 cannot watch a child continuously-they can try their very best, but things will happen even if they are right by them. They might blink, turn their head, tie their shoe laces and if a child wants to run away and hide in a cupboard and ignore adults calling for them, they can. That is a child hiding and not wanting to go to assembly, not an adult ‘losing’ them.

Burnshersmurfs · 28/01/2022 23:57

This child has a diagnosis of ADHD/ODD. I’m a bit hesitant about recommendations which suggest that all neurodivergent or SEN needs are the same. Examples here are posters who are referring to their specific experiences with autistic children.

Hospedia · 28/01/2022 23:56

I know with DS that his TA is clued into his triggers and signs that he's starting to have difficulty coping, she intervenes before the situation escalates and sorts out whatever he needs at the time to bring him back into a state of regulation. That's because his school follows his EHCP.

Hospedia · 28/01/2022 23:54

how do you think they can stop him from running off? Do you think he should be tied to the 1-1 TA so he physically can’t run anywhere?

Without sight if his assessment records I couldn't possibly presume what support measures he needs that would fit his particular profile however school will have a copy of his EHCP and his supervision needs will be set out in that, they should be meeting those needs and providing the appropriate level of support/supervision.

WonderfulYou · 28/01/2022 23:52

@Hospedia
how do you think they can stop him from running off?
Do you think he should be tied to the 1-1 TA so he physically can’t run anywhere?

Hospedia · 28/01/2022 23:52

@3Daddy31982 I would ask MNHQ to move your thread to the SN boards, you will get more knowledgeable advice and support there than you will on AIBU

Hospedia · 28/01/2022 23:49

People without a child with SEN should sit this one out as you really have no clue and your comments are often silly as a result.

Very much this.

  1. If he is a known flight risk then school should be taking this into account when supervising him
  1. If he has an EHCP stating he needs constant supervision then, by law, he needs to be constantly supervised
  1. Being a mainstream school is no excuse, he has a right to attend a mainstream setting and even if a special school was more appropriate there are too few places available to simply move into one
  1. Depending in his specific needs, he may nit act in age appropriate ways or have the cognitive ability needed to understand not to hide in a cupboard. The same applies to "why didn't he come out when called?" Applying neuro-typical expectations to a neuro-atypical child leads to safeguarding issues (much like this one) as those who should be supporting the child instead overestimate their abilities and the child ends up in difficulty
  1. "He was still on school premises so was reasonably safe" doesn't wash either. He could have hidden in the kitchen, in a heating cupboard, a utility or a maintenance cupboard, and a dozen other hazardous places. School got lucky that it was "just" a cupboard
  1. OP is not unreasonable to want to know the circumstances around how and why it happened, it absolutely is a safeguarding issue, and she is not unreasonable to raise a complaint
WorstXmasEver · 28/01/2022 23:48

If my kid were in the class I'd be mad that his learning time was being wasted & have a word with the school.

Imitatingdory · 28/01/2022 23:45

1-1 means different things in different settings. If it is mainstream they are probably used as a general ta too

If the 1:1 is specified and quantified in the EHCP it must be provided. Regardless of what setting it is. To not provide 1:1 or use them as a general TA would be unlawful, and leaves both the LA and school open to legal proceedings.

I'm a 1:1 TA, due to covid absences meaning we have about 50% of staff I was doing the job of around 5 people today. I don't it's any different in any school i the UK at the moment

With the right planning the majority of schools should still be able to provide 1:1 for pupils with 1:1 specified and quantified in EHCPs. Not saying it’s easy, but for the majority it is possible.

LetHimHaveIt · 28/01/2022 23:44

'People without a child with SEN should sit this one out as you really have no clue and your comments are often silly as a result.'

'My adult son has had a 1:1 once out of his SN nursery and yeah I'd be raising hell and contacting my attorney for this bullshit! There's no excuse for a 1:1 to 'lose' him.'

Yeah; doesn't look like the non-SEN parents have the monopoly on silly comments. Fucking L.A. Law up there 🙄

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 28/01/2022 23:40

Some posters have very little understanding of how a child with SEN feels when overwhelmed. I know quite a few Autistic children, some of whom absolutely must be watched every moment of the day, including to the toilet and in the playground. I know children who abscond from school when overwhelmed and can't safely attend a school that isn't completely fenced, with tall fences and locked gates. Do posters really think having a stern conversation never occurred to their parents? Or that telling your child to answer when hidden and overwhelmed was a solution? If these things worked they wouldn't be in this situation.

An overwhelmed child whose hidden in a cupboard to escape and having a meltdown (not a tantrum) can absolutely be unable to leave the cupboard even though they want to be found. He might not have even been in a state to register the calling.

I hope you're DS is doing ok now @3Daddy31982 and you get some answers from the school on how this happened.

RobertaFirmino · 28/01/2022 23:40

They didn't lose him though, did they? Your son hid from them. Any wilful child can easily slip away in a split second.

This incident occurred because of your son's complexities rather than any failing on the school's part. You say 'He said he was on his own!'. Well yes, of course he was - he was hiding in a cupboard for crying out loud!

Perhaps this isn't what you want to hear but have you tried working WITH the school and doing as The DinnerWitch suggests rather than blaming them? I imagine he came out in 'huge sobbing tears' as the teacher had already spoken to him firmly about never running off (just as a teacher is well within their rights to do). I expect you would agree about never running off so maybe now is the time to reinforce this.

Lalliella · 28/01/2022 23:40

He wasn’t lost though. He chose to hide, to get out of doing something, and he didn’t come out when they called his name. He needs to learn that he shouldn’t do that

HandWash · 28/01/2022 23:39

People who don't work in schools (especially large, mainstream) really have no idea.

It takes a split second for an incident to happen,
1-1's are not super human. Also children can move very quickly! Do you really think you could keep up with a 10yo (for e.g.), in a busy school with lots of long corridors/ rooms who was determined to get away from you? Who do you think would run out of steam first Confused

We used to have a girl, with a 1-1 who used to run and hide in cupboards constantly. We had to lock them all to stop her.

He wasn't lost, he was hiding.

Hospedia · 28/01/2022 23:39

He was unlikely to get out as post Dunblaine (RIP) schools are locked when children are attending

No, they're not. Infant schools maybe but middle school and upwards, in my experience, isn't locked during the school day. The community library shares premises with DC school, the upper floor of it is also their school library, and it shares an entrance with the school gym. I could walk right into a PE lesson if I had a mind to.

I don't think a 1-1 can watch all the time & don't think that's exactly their job but not an expert

If a child has a 1:1 for the entirety of the school day and it is also recorded in their EHCP that they need constant supervision/support then it is exactly the 1:1s job to watch them all the time.

Also, why did he stay hidden? Especially when they called him?

Depending on his specific condition(s) and needs he might not behave in age or situation appropriate ways. It also depends on what was going in when he was being called, I know my DS has shutdowns and during one you could call for him until you were blue in the face and he wouldn't respond.

Soontobe60 · 28/01/2022 23:35

@SparkleSpangle

1-1 means different things in different settings. If it is mainstream they are probably used as a general ta too
In my school, if an EHCP stated 1:1 for X hours, then the child has 1:1 support for those hours as a minimum. We have 3 children with this on their EHCPs. None of them have full time support though.