Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
MargosKaftan · 29/01/2022 15:58

Also realised the OP said her DD is at a selective grammar. So assuming she's at least in the top 25% academically (or some the selectives take only the top 10%), is this the only thing she's not naturally good at, and is being allowed to just give up? Terrible lesson to learn.

Its good for naturally academically gifted children to have something that they find tough and have to make an effort in. Something that they don't just find easy and learn that it takes effort and time to improve. Or even learn to cope with other people being significantly better than them at something. (And no, walking to school and back isn't going to be enough exercise for a teen if you live less than 2 miles away from the school.)

Theluggage15 · 29/01/2022 15:41

So when these children have a job and get a task they don’t want to do, they’ll just say they’re not doing it? Mum said I don’t have to do things if I don’t want to?

blyn72 · 29/01/2022 15:36

Morgan, your posts are refreshing. Your mum was great!

Puts me in mind of Nigella Lawson's mother who wrote to Nigella's school, saying, "Nigella is far too sensitive to do geography", :-).

PE made me miserable. I was super anxious about it. And got very embarrassed.
Me too!

I didn't realise pupils could actually opt out, am glad they can.

Morgan12 · 29/01/2022 15:31

Also why do we need to make children do things that they don't want to do?

My children aren't ever learning this particular lesson.

It's bullshit.

Morgan12 · 29/01/2022 15:30

My mum just told the school I wouldn't be doing PE and that was that.

I didn't 'opt out' because I never chose it to begin with!

PE made me miserable. I was super anxious about it. And got very embarrassed.

If this was my kids I'd let them stop too.

Is just telling the school not an option?

Klippetyklip · 29/01/2022 15:27

@SenselessUbiquity

I am really curious as to why there is such a strong view that it's a terrible lesson that kids learn that they have some choice in what they do, and they don't have to do things they don't enjoy that have no value to them.

One of the worst lessons I ever learnt, and I learnt it far too well, is that you have to do everything other people want you to do. I have stuck at shit jobs and shit relationships far too long in my life. I am 50 now, and gosh life is short. I wish to god I'd wasted less of it on
this defeatist attitude that you just have to get on with things.

Well said. I realised this about myself at around the same age as you. My life is far happier as a result.
hellcatspangle · 29/01/2022 15:20

[quote SE13Mummy]@catchingzzzeds "Our school have a good system where they must still get changed into kit and be wherever the lesson is taking place"

My DC2 with their broken limb has just said a new PE teacher is bringing in this rule and the consequence for not getting changed is a detention. Getting dressed is really hard for DC2 at the moment as it is. Walking to school carrying a PE kit, and then carrying it around all day (no lockers or anywhere to leave the kit) is going to make a difficult, painful time all the more difficult and painful. DC2 wants to be able to join in with PE but can't because of the broken limb. To be made to get changed into their kit doesn't feel helpful or kind. They've attended PE lessons without being able to join in and it's pretty obvious the injury hasn't been made up! Whilst I understand that requiring students to get changed if it's believed that they are trying to be elsewhere is one strategy, I can't see its benefits to children with broken limbs![/quote]
I'd be complaining to the head about that nonsense.

GreenWhiteViolet · 29/01/2022 15:10

@Hercisback

The humiliation argument doesn't really wash either. Being crap at maths isn't easy and there is plenty of stigma attached to that. Not being good at something is not a reason to not do it.
It's more like not being good at maths in the days when children had to call out their test scores in front of others, or move up or down desks based on how well they'd done lately so that it was publicly and constantly apparent who was crap at maths, and they would be told that the competition was good for them.

Schools stopped doing these things for good reason.

doorornottodoor · 29/01/2022 15:08

What about the non academic kids? They have to struggle through lessons every day but don’t have a choice! Just get on with it. The weather is a pathetic excuse. Put more clothes on. You’re raising a real snowflake there. In a decent school non sporty kids should have options that aren’t humiliating for them.

VitalsStable · 29/01/2022 14:52

No I wouldn't do it, we just don't lie in our house. Just feel it's important we are honest and teach our children to be so. When she's lying to teachers you'll not have a leg to stand on telling her it's not acceptable.

Buy her some skins and tell her to get on with it. Exercise is good for her and learning resilience is also good for children.

Hercisback · 29/01/2022 14:50

The humiliation argument doesn't really wash either. Being crap at maths isn't easy and there is plenty of stigma attached to that. Not being good at something is not a reason to not do it.

bedheadedzombie · 29/01/2022 14:36

@Itsalmostanaccessory

What schools did you all go to? I loved PE at my high school. Set me up with a life long love of trampolining and handball. Wasnt great at racquet sports but badminton was always fun.

We didnt have bullying or jeering or anything during PE. There were the popular kids who were good at all the sports and the kids who were totally rubbish, but the bullying being discussed on here didnt happen. Not in my uesr group anyway; I cant speak for the rest of it. But I'm getting a shocking idea of PE from this and that doesnt go along with my experience at all.

Have you asked the rubbish kids though? bullying can be invisible for the majority.
DrCoconut · 29/01/2022 14:36

@Thesearmsofmine same here. I learned and gained zero from it. It was just miserable and soul destroying. I really don't care if my kids never do PE again. They do activities out of school. Unless you want to work in sports PE (as in compulsory team sports) is a waste of time for academic kids who'd rather be building skills in important subjects. So I'd say if OP's child really hates PE and is being made miserable by it then it's fine to skip it. Desirable in fact. PE kits sometimes go missing and they are very costly to replace......(I got about 4 months out of that one in year 8 Grin)

heartonthetyne · 29/01/2022 13:55

@DamnUserName21

No judgement here either, OP. As someone who was humiliated by other kids during team sports, I'd say use your discretion but find a balance where DC doesn't feel they can get their own way all the time.
The thing is, the only reason the OP has given for getting her dd out of PE is "the weather". Nothing about SEN, being humiliated etc. And she's also included swimming which is a bit confusing as I'm assuming that the pool is not outdoors and unheated.
DamnUserName21 · 29/01/2022 13:50

No judgement here either, OP.
As someone who was humiliated by other kids during team sports, I'd say use your discretion but find a balance where DC doesn't feel they can get their own way all the time.

MargosKaftan · 29/01/2022 13:35

She won't be left alone in the library. There will be a member of staff there. If they don't have a library lesson going on, normally they would be getting on with other tasks, that often would take them out of the library. They will have to stay in the library to supervise. Screws up their day.

Your dd needs to learn that sometimes in life you have to get on with stuff you don't enjoy. She will never get better if you dont let her take part. The weather won't be significantly better end of February than the start of Feb, so unless you are going to make up excuses until a summer heat wave, you need to give up this idea and let her get in trouble for refusing to take part. Let her have the argument. Let her face the detention for refusing to join in. Let her see the consequences. Dont lie.

user1496146479 · 29/01/2022 13:22

[quote FTEngineerM]I would write a note for my kids if I could see it was torturous for them to do it. I hated it, it ruined my whole day when I had PE. So I got out of it as often as possible.

@user1496146479 lying isn’t always disgraceful that’s really dramatic; humans lie ALL THE TIME, including you. It’s inbuilt within us to lie to maintain social politeness.

crimereads.com/lying-is-fundamental-to-who-we-are-as-humans/[/quote]
But this isn't to maintain social politeness!!!Hmm
And is it any wonder if parents teach their children that lying like this okay?

FTEngineerM · 29/01/2022 13:19

I would write a note for my kids if I could see it was torturous for them to do it. I hated it, it ruined my whole day when I had PE. So I got out of it as often as possible.

@user1496146479 lying isn’t always disgraceful that’s really dramatic; humans lie ALL THE TIME, including you. It’s inbuilt within us to lie to maintain social politeness.

crimereads.com/lying-is-fundamental-to-who-we-are-as-humans/

lanthanum · 29/01/2022 13:15

DD didn't like PE when she was 11. Now (15) she loves it, and PE is one of her favourite lessons. Tell your daughter to get on with it.

skybluee · 29/01/2022 13:11

The thing I find a bit sad is say if it's maths or a language or any other subject, if someone is behind they offer help for them to catch up. With PE, it isn't a level playing field. Some people will have been doing sport from 2-3 years old with multiple sports and sports clubs, so they have a massive advantage when it comes to PE. PE was my favourite lesson - I loved it (apart from I hated swimming) but part of that was because I'd been doing sport outside of lessons anyway. People should be offered a chance to catch up and get better. My best friend in high school decided to train for the 800m and after only about six weeks or so finished 3rd in the school sports day at that event. Improvement can be huge in children/high school age.

People say PE isn't important for jobs but life isn't solely about jobs. I'd say it's arguably more important than some other subjects as a lifelong thing. Children need to be active and so many aren't now.

If this is literally just about the weather you need to look at what she's wearing as she shouldn't be that cold. It's 10C here which is warm for January.

user1496146479 · 29/01/2022 13:10

@MilduraS

Surprised by the number of people who seem hell bent on making kids doing PE. It took me years to get over my self consciousness and realise sports could be enjoyable after I left school.
It's not so much PE! It's teaching your child that lying is okay! Disgraceful!
ufucoffee · 29/01/2022 13:06

@Mamamia7962

Surely this can't be real. No parent would pander to their child this much would they? She doesn't want to do PE for a few weeks because it's too cold! You can buy thermal base layers to wear under PE tops, most sports people wear them. Doesn't the school have a PE tracksuit they can wear for colder weather. Most secondary schools have them.
They definitely do. God forbid their little darlings should have to do anything they don't want to do.
pastypirate · 29/01/2022 13:03

@MilduraS

Surprised by the number of people who seem hell bent on making kids doing PE. It took me years to get over my self consciousness and realise sports could be enjoyable after I left school.
Completely relate to this
user1496146479 · 29/01/2022 13:01

@HelloKittyGirl

I don’t have a problem with it to be honest. I never liked PE either and she already gets plenty of exercise walking to and from school everyday. I’m not worried about her fitness levels. If she’d rather spend the time in the library doing homework, I’m happy with that.
Yes teach your child that she doesn't need to follow any rules that are there for her benefit. She of course is a special snowflake, and lying is okay! Ffs!! Biscuit
MilduraS · 29/01/2022 12:49

Surprised by the number of people who seem hell bent on making kids doing PE. It took me years to get over my self consciousness and realise sports could be enjoyable after I left school.

Swipe left for the next trending thread