Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
blubberball · 30/01/2022 03:13

You'll need a wound, some kind of convincing wound...

*shoots Captain Darling in the foot

Yes, that looks pretty convincing!

swampygirl · 30/01/2022 03:07

It's wrong to allow your child to lie.
You haven't said what the reason is your DD wants to skip PE.
We all have to do things we'd rather not - that's life!
YABU. Shame on you!

LG123 · 30/01/2022 01:55

I'm with you op. PE and sports day are the very reason I can't stand physical exercise.

Intheopinionofourexpert · 29/01/2022 23:50

[quote usinon]**@Intheopinionofourexpert* It really isn't just practise. I played tennis at school for years. I was no better in the 6th form than I was in the first. Some people just aren't able to coordinate their bodies in the way others can. Unless you are one of those people, it simply isn't possible to understand* according to neuroscience it is in fact just practice, creating the neural pathways, assuming NT - and ND often as it is this sort of thinking re creating new neural pathways which is used to help ND people nowadays.

If you had taken a bucket of 50 balls and practised hitting all the balls over the net, then all the balls serving, getting someone to chuck them at you to give practice reurning, a couple of times a week, with determination, and watched youtube videos on technique, I can pretty much guarantee you'd have become a competent player!![/quote]
Grin Ah, if only it was that simple. All of us on this thread who found PE humiliating would have been competent at sport if only we'd hit 50 balls out of a bucket, practised, and watched some YouTube videos.

We had more than a dozen tennis court at my school, we were taught by actual teachers, not by watching a screen, from the first form until the 6th form. Some of us just can't make our hands work in coordination with our eyes, however hard we try. But yeah, we should all be a bit more determined.... because tennis is of course an essential life skill.

Research shows that teenage girls drop out of sport at a huge rate (there's plenty of research on this). The issue won't be resolved by practising more, it's about how sport makes girls feel, how it is taught and the lack of insight displayed by people who just don't understand that changes need to happen.

AnnaSW1 · 29/01/2022 23:20

Osgood-Schlatters would be a good shout.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 29/01/2022 23:15

@WTF475878237NC

am astonished there are people in my professional who have this blinkered view.

^ yes, really shocked to read the teachers who think agree with the OP.

But not all teachers are great teachers, let alone great parents.
NewbieSM · 29/01/2022 23:14

Op I think you are missing the point, your opinion on whether you think P.E is worthwhile is irrelevant. It is a mandatory part of the school curriculum that you agreed to when you registered your daughter. By making up a lie to get her out of participating what message are you sending? If you don't like something you can just make up an excuse to get out of it? That's not how real life works, imagine her in 20 years saying I don't fancy completing this project at work I'll get my mum to to write a note and get me out of it, ridiculous.

QuornSausagesAreTheDevilsPenis · 29/01/2022 23:06

At dc's school even if they're not doing the lesson they still have to get changed and go and sit on the touchline/court/whatever so getting them signed off is kinda pointless. Unless they've got like a broken leg or something.

HelloKittyGirl · 29/01/2022 22:31

Can’t believe the number of responses here. Thanks to those who have suggested reasons to give.

OP posts:
CrankyFrankie · 29/01/2022 22:31

Pathetic attitude to be passing on.

5foot5 · 29/01/2022 22:24

If you had taken a bucket of 50 balls and practised hitting all the balls over the net, then all the balls serving, getting someone to chuck them at you to give practice reurning, a couple of times a week, with determination, and watched youtube videos on technique, I can pretty much guarantee you'd have become a competent player!!

But maybe she just doesn't like tennis much. You would have to really like it and want to do it to go through all that regularly. Maybe she would prefer to do something more interesting and rewarding like learning a musical instrument, say.

And BTW a lot of people have banged on about sport being good for concentration and teamwork and so on, but I bet playing in a band or orchestra beats sport hands down for developing those skills. However as far as I am aware music is very badly treated these days in the NC.

UnicornsReal · 29/01/2022 21:56

@LaDamaDeElche

PE is part of the curriculum, you can't just let her off it because she doesn't like it. We all have to do things in life which we don't love/like. You can't opt out of the parts of your job you don't enjoy, or classes at uni you don't enjoy, or parts of parenting you don't enjoy etc etc. Some kids have massive anxiety around sports and some girls at mixed schools feel very self-conscious in swimming lessons with boys, and got those reasons I'd feel you maybe had a justification. Not liking something isn't s good enough reason and you lying for her is just all out shite parenting.
Yes. I say this as someone who hated PE myself .
ghostmouse · 29/01/2022 21:35

School pe is shit especially for girls. Team sports being a good thing my arse.

My dd2 is 14 and each week she has an anxiety attack at the thought of having to get changed in front of the others, she’s also had sly little pushes and abuse thrown at her and it’s just an ordeal. She does do it but I have on occasion written her a note on the worst days.

The solo sports.. she loves. She is a keen walker with her own hiking boots, she also walks 4 miles to school and back most days and does about 15000 to 25000 steps a day and is starting rock climbing next month.. she also wants a gym membership.

Perhaps if schools encouraged this sort of excercise as much as team sports then so many girls wouldn’t be put of pe for life.

Kittymum7 · 29/01/2022 21:22

OP, how far away is your daughter’s school from your house? If you think she already gets enough exercise, that depends on how long it takes to get to school. How long does it take to walk there?

LaDamaDeElche · 29/01/2022 21:18

@WTF475878237NC

am astonished there are people in my professional who have this blinkered view.

^ yes, really shocked to read the teachers who think agree with the OP.

I was talking about the teacher who seemed to think Spanish, or a language, was something that could be considered unimportant, but in the case of the OP it's not even like her daughter has anxiety about PE, or certain aspects of PE. It's just that she doesn't like it. Imagine if every parent wrote a note to excuse pupils from subjects they didn't like. It would be utter chaos. It's also not teaching a child anything valuable to lie for them to excuse them from a class, unless there's a very valued reason and not liking something isn't a good enough reason. There are many subjects at school children won't like, but having a rich and varied curriculum is something that children in many countries don't have the privilege to experience. First world problems.
usinon · 29/01/2022 21:16

@Intheopinionofourexpert It really isn't just practise. I played tennis at school for years. I was no better in the 6th form than I was in the first. Some people just aren't able to coordinate their bodies in the way others can. Unless you are one of those people, it simply isn't possible to understand according to neuroscience it is in fact just practice, creating the neural pathways, assuming NT - and ND often as it is this sort of thinking re creating new neural pathways which is used to help ND people nowadays.

If you had taken a bucket of 50 balls and practised hitting all the balls over the net, then all the balls serving, getting someone to chuck them at you to give practice reurning, a couple of times a week, with determination, and watched youtube videos on technique, I can pretty much guarantee you'd have become a competent player!!

Kittymum7 · 29/01/2022 21:14

I hated PE from Year 4 onwards. I would hide in the school bathroom to try to miss it, but the teacher eventually found out. I would also not bring in my PE kit and say I forgot it, and most kids who didn’t were told off and made me sit in the classroom and miss playtime/break. I was never a sporty person. I was forced to play football, tennis, hockey and other sports and I hated it. The only thing I actually loved was swimming, and I still love it now. It was worse and less fun by the time I was in secondary school, and I would frequently lie about being on my period to get out of PE. PE is a once a week lesson, and I don’t think it affects a child’s weight or causes them to be obese if it’s only once a week. I know the right thing to do is probably not to teach your daughter to lie to get out of things she doesn’t like, which in this case is PE. You’re supposed to be a role model for her. You only said the reason for her not wanting to attend PE was the weather. I understand that, because many kids are forced to do PE outside in shorts/joggers and short sleeved tops and she must be cold. Maybe find out if there are any other reasons why she doesn’t want to do PE? If she really detests it, then maybe contact the school asking them to excuse her from PE until further notice, but I don’t know if that will still work because some schools expect a medical reason or a doctor’s note. I don’t think it will go down very well getting her to lie, because schools expect some kind of proof and she has to have a good reason. Your daughter could also get into trouble if she is caught lying.

Soul11Soul · 29/01/2022 21:12

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Parenting isn't always a choice. Do you live in a utopian bubble where your job, relationships, children, pet ownership, health is all exactly as you want it. We all need to do things we don't want to do...the alternative is to opt out of relationships and society.

WTF475878237NC · 29/01/2022 21:10

*think like or agree with

Mollymoostoo · 29/01/2022 21:10

@HelloKittyGirl

I don’t have a problem with it to be honest. I never liked PE either and she already gets plenty of exercise walking to and from school everyday. I’m not worried about her fitness levels. If she’d rather spend the time in the library doing homework, I’m happy with that.
What are you going to do when ashe has to do tasks in her job she doesn't like? Life is like this, finding ways to help her avoid things is enabling.
WTF475878237NC · 29/01/2022 21:10

am astonished there are people in my professional who have this blinkered view.

^ yes, really shocked to read the teachers who think agree with the OP.

LaDamaDeElche · 29/01/2022 21:04

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

You can't opt out of the parts of your job you don't enjoy, or classes at uni you don't enjoy, or parts of parenting you don't enjoy etc etc

These are all choices. Compulsory PE isn’t.

Neither are any subjects at school apart from options, or school itself. You point is?
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 29/01/2022 20:53

You can't opt out of the parts of your job you don't enjoy, or classes at uni you don't enjoy, or parts of parenting you don't enjoy etc etc

These are all choices. Compulsory PE isn’t.

LaDamaDeElche · 29/01/2022 20:52

@HiJenny35

100% with you op. I hated pe at school and it put me off all sport for years. Now I do sport several times a week and I'm a qualified instructor in several types. Missing a few weeks isn't an issue. And yes I'd feel the same about art or Spanish or basically any lesson other than English or maths. And yes I'm a teacher and nope it never caused me any extra work to have a few kids sitting out of pe.
And this is the reason the British are mocked the world over, along with the Americans, for not being able to speak other languages and not seeing the importance in doing this. We live in a global world. We live in a multicultural society. Being able to speak other languages is a key life skill. Fucking hell. As a teacher myself I couldn't disagree more and am astonished there are people in my professional who have this blinkered view.
LaDamaDeElche · 29/01/2022 20:47

PE is part of the curriculum, you can't just let her off it because she doesn't like it. We all have to do things in life which we don't love/like. You can't opt out of the parts of your job you don't enjoy, or classes at uni you don't enjoy, or parts of parenting you don't enjoy etc etc. Some kids have massive anxiety around sports and some girls at mixed schools feel very self-conscious in swimming lessons with boys, and got those reasons I'd feel you maybe had a justification. Not liking something isn't s good enough reason and you lying for her is just all out shite parenting.