Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
AreWeThereYetMummy · 30/01/2022 10:45

Op - I think you've had some very judgemental responses. It's amazing how many people on MN are so perfect.

If it really is 'the weather' then I'm a bit  too but assuming that isn't the real reason, then I totally agree, no one ever ruined their child or their prospects because of a note for PE.

I've done pretty ok in life (work extremely hard, 1st. Class degree, earn enough to keep my family on my salary alone in a nice house). I skipped PE, canoe lessons, swimming, ... more times than anyone could count and all thanks to my lovely mum's notes. I hated PE, I was useless at it. Always picked last, always the slowest. It did nothing but erode my confidence and humiliate me.

Why condone doing that to kids. It doesn't make them stronger people. Find hobbies they can excel in outside of school. I learnt teamwork and leadership through drama classes.

As an adult I go hiking and mountain biking!

heartonthetyne · 30/01/2022 10:28

@yzed

What I find most interesting about this thread, is that 661 posts so far, many of which berate OP for daring to think her child might be allowed to avoid something unpleasant, almost no one suggests that schools/pe teachers might up their game and make their lessons enjoyable. Not, I might add, that children should be encouraged to favour enjoyable lessons (heavens no!) but perhaps that physical exercise might be a potentially enjoyable activity, if only approached in a less unpleasant manner.
I think a lot of people on here have made the point that PE is nothing like it was 30yrs ago. And as far as I'm aware, the only reason the OP gave for her daughter missing the classes was "the weather"Confused
Jedsnewstar · 30/01/2022 10:25

Think about the bigger lesson you are giving your child. Your dislike of PE has probably rubbed off.

ElftonWednesday · 30/01/2022 10:20

@yzed

What I find most interesting about this thread, is that 661 posts so far, many of which berate OP for daring to think her child might be allowed to avoid something unpleasant, almost no one suggests that schools/pe teachers might up their game and make their lessons enjoyable. Not, I might add, that children should be encouraged to favour enjoyable lessons (heavens no!) but perhaps that physical exercise might be a potentially enjoyable activity, if only approached in a less unpleasant manner.
They have. PE at my DDs' schools was nothing like it was 30 years ago.
WhenTheyComeForYou · 30/01/2022 10:16

YANBU

When I first read your post, I thought to myself - she shouldn't be making up lies for her daughter at school. It's sets a bad tone for respecting the teacher and school and may make her have an entitled view.

THEN I remembered my mum telling me that her mum basically did the same for her 50 years ago. She hated PE so her mum allowed her to come home and chill for the afternoon with her. She was an avid cyclist as a child (lived rurally so had to really), just hated PE.

Despite missing PE, my mum by far has the best work ethic I've known. She has worked 60 hour weeks back to back and she has very rarely had a sick day in her whole career. She's also far more active than your average 66 year old. She walks everywhere and can still touch her toes no problem. Her lack of PE has made zero difference to her life.

But how lovely that her mum respected her and allowed her to have some say over what she does (within reason). PE isn't really important to kids who are otherwise active.

My only caution would be to make sure your daughter doesn't 'confide' in any school friends about your lie.

ArchibaldsDaddy · 30/01/2022 10:07

Are rules and timetabling just for other people?

We all need to do stuff we don’t particularly like doing so setting an example where things like this can be dodged through deception is pretty poor parenting.

3Daddy31982 · 30/01/2022 09:53

Walking to and from school is nowhere near enough exercise. Yabvvu.

Oblomov22 · 30/01/2022 09:51

Thank you Grasping.

We all need to do things we don't like. I think thats a poor thing to teach secondary school children. How about teaching them that this is part of life.

Deciding what to eat for the next week, the monotony of supermarket shopping, then cooking dinners every night: is something I don't wanna do a lot of the time thanks very much! Hmm

whiteroseredrose · 30/01/2022 09:30

@yzed

What I find most interesting about this thread, is that 661 posts so far, many of which berate OP for daring to think her child might be allowed to avoid something unpleasant, almost no one suggests that schools/pe teachers might up their game and make their lessons enjoyable. Not, I might add, that children should be encouraged to favour enjoyable lessons (heavens no!) but perhaps that physical exercise might be a potentially enjoyable activity, if only approached in a less unpleasant manner.
Great post!
Primadonna1 · 30/01/2022 09:16

I loathed PE it was a genuine nightmare - and would my mother ever write notes , no she wouldn’t . Once and similarly unsporty friend and I were forced to play in the house basketball team due to lack of players . We happened to be sheltering from the rain in then sports hall & were forced to play , by chance our team won the competition but only because the other three players were fab . Did I find this a positive experience no !

Charlotteskye · 30/01/2022 09:13

That depends on the school and their PE teachers. Your school didn't teach you anything sports related. What a shame.

ThinWomansBrain · 30/01/2022 09:01

why not opt for home schooling if your precious princess only wants to do what she likes?

Grasping · 30/01/2022 09:00

@Oblomov22

Sorry, I've skim read thread, but all of OP posts and I still can't work out what the actual reason is?
She just doesn’t like it 🤷‍♀️
Oblomov22 · 30/01/2022 08:59

Sorry, I've skim read thread, but all of OP posts and I still can't work out what the actual reason is?

TopsieGreenwood · 30/01/2022 08:57

Surely if this school allows kids to do homework in the library instead of PE they'll all end up getting notes. That way they get more free time

LightBulbous · 30/01/2022 08:53

@HelloKittyGirl honestly. Have a think about what you’re teaching your child long term. I work in a secondary school and the biggest fear I have for the children is the lack of resilience taught by parents. Any time a child doesn’t want to do something it’s pandered to. Teach her strength. Teach her sometimes there are tougher times in life where you have to graft and hate it. Teach her lying isn’t great. Teach her not everything worth doing will be fun at the time.

Resilience to overcome and tackle challenges is what children need and you getting her out of PE for a term due to weather is not teaching her that.

TracyMosby · 30/01/2022 08:50

teachers might up their game and make their lessons enjoyable
Hmm
You understand the purpose of education, right?

PUGMEISTER21 · 30/01/2022 08:44

If there is no genuine reason then well done for sending the message to you child that it is OK to fake illness and lie about stuff. That should set her up nicely for phoning in sick when she starts working. :-(

doorornottodoor · 30/01/2022 07:14

I was really crap at PE, didn’t enjoy competitive sport (still don’t ). Our teachers were pretty nice luckily and never humiliated us. As we got older we also did stuff like aerobics (this was the 90s!) I was at an all girls’ school.

I feel for people who have had such awful experiences. Sad All I can say as a teacher is that the new generation of PE teachers are very different. At the school I teach at they do HIIT classes as well as all the usual competitive stuff. There is a lot of emphasis on being kind etc… throughout the school too. Inclusive.
I say this to reassure people that it’s not the same as it was.

damnthisvirusandmarriage · 30/01/2022 06:56

I am sporty. And was one of top in school.

BUT. I hated PE initially. This was because I was embarrassed by my changing body. And didn’t want anyone to see it and mock me.

You should know at this time I was also a very good swimmer. And had no issues getting changed there twice every day.

The girls were just horrid in school. Nasty. Didn’t have the boobs coming, pubes. Periods. Plus periods were hard to manage at that age anyway. Never mind having to to PE with a manky ST.

You should also know the teacher got done and sacked and trialled for being very inappropriate a number of years after I left high school. She was obsessed with us girls getting changed. It was weird.

Those were the days eh 🙄

I’d be getting to the root cause of why your child doesn’t want to do this lesson.

JohnMcCainsDeathStare · 30/01/2022 06:42

yzed Am I a joke to you?!?

Grasping · 30/01/2022 05:17

I would rather mine do PE than Maths tbh Grin

sashh · 30/01/2022 03:58

@doorornottodoor

What about the non academic kids? They have to struggle through lessons every day but don’t have a choice! Just get on with it. The weather is a pathetic excuse. Put more clothes on. You’re raising a real snowflake there. In a decent school non sporty kids should have options that aren’t humiliating for them.
But the kids that are struggling in maths and English are put in classes with other children of the same level, we don't put them in the top set and criticise them for not keeping up.

I don't know a school without a school uniform so 'put more clothes on' isn't an option.

NewbieDivergent · 30/01/2022 03:29

Also she'll have at least one lesson a fortnight up until the end of year 11,she cant miss them all.I was the short,overweight,shy,glass wearing two left feet child who never got picked for teams etc,but my mother would still never let me miss p.e.

yzed · 30/01/2022 03:24

What I find most interesting about this thread, is that 661 posts so far, many of which berate OP for daring to think her child might be allowed to avoid something unpleasant, almost no one suggests that schools/pe teachers might up their game and make their lessons enjoyable.

Not, I might add, that children should be encouraged to favour enjoyable lessons (heavens no!) but perhaps that physical exercise might be a potentially enjoyable activity, if only approached in a less unpleasant manner.