Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
ElftonWednesday · 31/01/2022 05:34

I work in a secondary school and the biggest fear I have for the children is the lack of resilience taught by parents

Maybe if schools didn't put so much pressure on kids to do well they would be more resilient. We need a total rethink of the secondary school education system in this country as Finland had a number of years ago as there are so, so many children that it is utterly, utterly failing. I think generation Z is incredibly resilient in spite of all the shit society throws at them.

Ericaequites · 31/01/2022 01:12

The whining from school librarians is risible. Students using the library are major problems. How often do you have reason to call parents or place orders? Some one has to be there to check out books and other materials. Secondary students don’t need constant supervision. It’s certainly not how public libraries work.

pastypirate · 30/01/2022 23:26

This thread is hilarious. As of bunking pe is a terrible life lesson. Get a grip. As if an 11 year old can't tell the difference between a fib to get out of pe and telling a lie in court.

The most self righteous thread I've ever read in my 12 years on mn!

pastypirate · 30/01/2022 23:24

@Jedsnewstar

Think about the bigger lesson you are giving your child. Your dislike of PE has probably rubbed off.
Pe isn't compulsory as an adult. Thank god
GrolliffetheDragon · 30/01/2022 23:00

[quote doorornottodoor]@Ericaequites Grin the boys don’t physically play against the girls. They play separate sports. They might do some sport together like cross country or fitness. Boys “more violent” what a lot of tosh. You should educate yourself before you comment. I work in a school. What a lot of rubbish you’re talking.[/quote]
In secondary school we sometimes had games lessons with the boys, we must have been about 14. The boys were vile to us, physically aggressive and I ended up needing an x-ray on my hand after volleyball practice.

mummykel16 · 30/01/2022 22:54

[quote LightBulbous]@HelloKittyGirl honestly. Have a think about what you’re teaching your child long term. I work in a secondary school and the biggest fear I have for the children is the lack of resilience taught by parents. Any time a child doesn’t want to do something it’s pandered to. Teach her strength. Teach her sometimes there are tougher times in life where you have to graft and hate it. Teach her lying isn’t great. Teach her not everything worth doing will be fun at the time.

Resilience to overcome and tackle challenges is what children need and you getting her out of PE for a term due to weather is not teaching her that.[/quote]
It's teaching her to overcome

blyn72 · 30/01/2022 20:05

Op, just tell the school that your daughter will not be partaking in PE from now on. Leave it there. Apparently she cannot be forced to do the classes.

UnicornsReal · 30/01/2022 19:27

@Ericaequites

I went to a private girls’ school, so have never been to a coed secondary gym class. One need not experience something to know it’s wrong. It’s not right for boys and girls in puberty to exercise together. It’s too suggestive for them to interact in revealing clothing. Coed classes rule out most sports because boys are so much stronger and more violent.
Rubbish.
FrippEnos · 30/01/2022 18:49

HelloKittyGirl

The only reference that I can find to age in your posts is a comment about yr 7 and universities.

If your DD is in year 7 you will be doing this for the next five years

As for the comment about not being forced to do a subject that she doesn't like, I can already see what will happen for her GCSEs.

I have seen this over many years of teaching an options subject.

doorornottodoor · 30/01/2022 18:46

@Ericaequites Grin the boys don’t physically play against the girls. They play separate sports. They might do some sport together like cross country or fitness. Boys “more violent” what a lot of tosh. You should educate yourself before you comment. I work in a school. What a lot of rubbish you’re talking.

Ericaequites · 30/01/2022 18:42

I went to a private girls’ school, so have never been to a coed secondary gym class. One need not experience something to know it’s wrong. It’s not right for boys and girls in puberty to exercise together. It’s too suggestive for them to interact in revealing clothing. Coed classes rule out most sports because boys are so much stronger and more violent.

Gwenhwyfar · 30/01/2022 18:35

@Ericaequites

Secondary coed PE lessons are unseemly, inappropriate, and downright dangerous. Big boys are too rough to play well with others. Many girls from conservative religious traditions would not be allowed to participate.
In general yes, but one term in my school they put the crap boys and the crap girls together for hockey. We were all jointly crap and it was one of my least hated terms for PE lessons. Obviously boys and girls playing rugby in a competitive way together would be very dangerous.
TopsieGreenwood · 30/01/2022 17:28

OP's kid goes to a girls' school

doorornottodoor · 30/01/2022 17:28

@Ericaequites what a load of rubbish! Have you ever been to a recent one? You don’t know what you’re talking about. Angry

Ericaequites · 30/01/2022 17:25

Secondary coed PE lessons are unseemly, inappropriate, and downright dangerous. Big boys are too rough to play well with others. Many girls from conservative religious traditions would not be allowed to participate.

yzed · 30/01/2022 17:22

JohnMcCainsDeathStare
No, you are absolutely not "a joke" to me. But I do not understand your point. Mine was that hardly anyone had had suggested the onus might be on teachers/schools to make their lessons more enjoyable for pupils.
In your post you suggested one of many options that might bring this about.
You also suggested the OP should discuss the issue with the PE department. Excellent plan if there was a high chance of a happy resolution. Poor strategy if the school simply said "No" (as so many posters on this thread have said); there would then be no chance of saying, "Oh well, you won't compromise, so my daughter has an illness that will take about three months before she's fit to do PE."
I do not know what your own individual position is, so if I've said something that offends maybe you could be clearer so that I can avoid this in the future.

Bellexx · 30/01/2022 16:45

I hate PE at school and then ended up in 2 sports societies at uni. A lot was to do with the poor attitude of staff. I actually told my high school pe teacher this when she made a comment about me now being a ‘gym bunny’.

This also never affected me for sixth form or university. I had verrucas frozen off and needed a number of weeks off as the bottom of my feet were sore and I could bleed. I had to have them frozen for a number of weeks. Didn’t affect my walking though

MargosKaftan · 30/01/2022 13:50

@Becky11 - we do all parent differently,but some people do make bad parenting choices and it's ok to point it out on a parenting forum.

If the OP really thinks its OK for her DD to not do PE because she doesn't like getting cold and won't run about /join in to warm up, then she should stand by that and tell the school the truth. A really good option would be asking to have a call with head of PE and see if anything can be done to help DD be comfortable enough join in. If your dc didn't like another subject on the curriculum enough to want to dodge it, would you say yes or work with the school to find a way to make it better for your dc?

StCharlotte · 30/01/2022 12:27

@Oblomov22

Sorry, I've skim read thread, but all of OP posts and I still can't work out what the actual reason is?
I think It's because she doesn't like being cold.
TopsieGreenwood · 30/01/2022 11:20

I wonder what illness the op has decided to lie to the school that her daughter has.

Lampshading · 30/01/2022 11:19

I used to wiggle out of PE as I was crap at it and embarrassed, but it actually made things worse and I felt even more of an outcast. If the issue really is weather than they're all in it together and whatever the account they won't be out there shivering. Id ask and try and make sure it wasn't an escape from something else, as she has several years left there and it isn't going away.

CrankyFrankie · 30/01/2022 11:00

It’s the ‘entitled’ subtext that gets me. ‘Don’t worry darling, we’re too good for PE anyway. Let’s think of a convincing lie to get you out of it. We’re besties aren’t we darling!’

Becky11 · 30/01/2022 10:56

It is absolutely impossible to post anything on MN without being judged.
Why can't people just reply to the question being asked. You don't have to agree. You have the control, as we all do, to keep scrolling.

We all parent differently. And just because someone has different ideas on what is best for their own children does not make them wrong or an available target for vitriol just to make you feel better about your own parenting.

I wish people would stop saying, posting and wearing Be Kind slogans and actually just do it.

VickyEadieofThigh · 30/01/2022 10:48

@Gwenhwyfar

"the only reason the OP gave for her daughter missing the classes was "the weather""

The weather being too cold. I do think there's a double standard there. Apart from certain jobs, adults aren't forced outside in all weathers so why should children be. If you told me I had to go out to exercise in uniform sportswear that I can't choose in the rain and cold you'd get short shrift.

I still want to know what her strategy is going to be in the winter of DD's Y8, 9, 10 and 11.
Gwenhwyfar · 30/01/2022 10:46

"the only reason the OP gave for her daughter missing the classes was "the weather""

The weather being too cold. I do think there's a double standard there. Apart from certain jobs, adults aren't forced outside in all weathers so why should children be. If you told me I had to go out to exercise in uniform sportswear that I can't choose in the rain and cold you'd get short shrift.