Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
Sweettruelies · 28/01/2022 20:30

It’s not cool to lie about being sick - bad karma. Sorry if that’s a bit woo

BurntO · 28/01/2022 20:29

Get your shit together OP and be a parent

Asperula · 28/01/2022 20:29

[quote SE13Mummy]@catchingzzzeds "Our school have a good system where they must still get changed into kit and be wherever the lesson is taking place"

My DC2 with their broken limb has just said a new PE teacher is bringing in this rule and the consequence for not getting changed is a detention. Getting dressed is really hard for DC2 at the moment as it is. Walking to school carrying a PE kit, and then carrying it around all day (no lockers or anywhere to leave the kit) is going to make a difficult, painful time all the more difficult and painful. DC2 wants to be able to join in with PE but can't because of the broken limb. To be made to get changed into their kit doesn't feel helpful or kind. They've attended PE lessons without being able to join in and it's pretty obvious the injury hasn't been made up! Whilst I understand that requiring students to get changed if it's believed that they are trying to be elsewhere is one strategy, I can't see its benefits to children with broken limbs![/quote]
The school policy in my kids' school says they have to get changed into PE kit unless it's not possible eg. A broken leg. Probably the same in your school

Tillymintpolo · 28/01/2022 20:28

So what happens when she starts PE again ?

Hercisback · 28/01/2022 20:28

@Thesearmsofmine
Who is supervising them doing something else? PE isn't optional.

RedskyThisNight · 28/01/2022 20:28

@HelloKittyGirl

I was thinking this too *@Lavender24*!

Yes, she’ll be sent to the library to work. Other than for swimming where she gets to sit in the viewing area (but can still read or get on with other work there on her lap if she chooses).

She’ll still get plenty of opportunities to learn sportsmanship, etc. We’re only talking about a few weeks.

As for whether I’d let her skip maths, I don’t see that as comparable. Most further education courses, degrees, jobs etc. will want to see a good GCSE maths pass. Not so PE.

What will change to make PE more palatable in a few weeks' time?

What are your feelings about subjects such as Art, Music, DT or even Spanish? She can cope perfectly well as an adult without studying any of those.

speakout · 28/01/2022 20:27

It iant just for exercise. It's team sportsmanship.

The thing that put me off exercise for decades.

SE13Mummy · 28/01/2022 20:26

@catchingzzzeds "Our school have a good system where they must still get changed into kit and be wherever the lesson is taking place"

My DC2 with their broken limb has just said a new PE teacher is bringing in this rule and the consequence for not getting changed is a detention. Getting dressed is really hard for DC2 at the moment as it is. Walking to school carrying a PE kit, and then carrying it around all day (no lockers or anywhere to leave the kit) is going to make a difficult, painful time all the more difficult and painful. DC2 wants to be able to join in with PE but can't because of the broken limb. To be made to get changed into their kit doesn't feel helpful or kind. They've attended PE lessons without being able to join in and it's pretty obvious the injury hasn't been made up! Whilst I understand that requiring students to get changed if it's believed that they are trying to be elsewhere is one strategy, I can't see its benefits to children with broken limbs!

NerrSnerr · 28/01/2022 20:26

Why now OP? To the end of this term? What will happen when she doesn't want to do PE next term, and every term after that?

Thesearmsofmine · 28/01/2022 20:25

@Monkeytapper

They make our kids get changed into PE kit anyway if they are excused and watch from the sidelines.
I would love to know why schools do this? It seems utterly pointless making them change and watch when they could be doing something else.
Hercisback · 28/01/2022 20:25

What happens after a few weeks?

It is exactly the same. Its a school subject (whether examined or not) that is part of the curriculum. Subjects aren't optional.

Fetchthevet · 28/01/2022 20:24

Break her legs?

Sorry, poor attempt at a joke. Honestly OP, it's not a good idea to teach her that it's ok to lie to get out of things.

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 20:23

I was thinking this too @Lavender24!

Yes, she’ll be sent to the library to work. Other than for swimming where she gets to sit in the viewing area (but can still read or get on with other work there on her lap if she chooses).

She’ll still get plenty of opportunities to learn sportsmanship, etc. We’re only talking about a few weeks.

As for whether I’d let her skip maths, I don’t see that as comparable. Most further education courses, degrees, jobs etc. will want to see a good GCSE maths pass. Not so PE.

OP posts:
Monkeytapper · 28/01/2022 20:22

They make our kids get changed into PE kit anyway if they are excused and watch from the sidelines.

nocoolnamesleft · 28/01/2022 20:22

If I'd been let skip PE, maybe I wouldn't have been left with a lifelong visceral hatred for exercise. Every single sport, I was either the worst or the second worst in the year. You can imagine what the bullying was like. From the other kids, but especially from those sadistic bitches of teachers.

Smartiepants79 · 28/01/2022 20:22

I never really liked games either.
But she’s only 11!! She’s got years of school P.E ahead of her.
What’s the long term plan?? She can’t never do PE again.
I think she’s a bit young to start in on lying to get her out of stuff.
And I agree with Pp that it’s unlikely that skiving is going to result in a nice, warm hour in the library.
My Dd is rubbish at team sports. But her getting as much physical exercise as possible is important.
I do sympathise but I’m not sure this a sensible solution.

Mo1911 · 28/01/2022 20:22

@HelloKittyGirl

I don’t have a problem with it to be honest. I never liked PE either and she already gets plenty of exercise walking to and from school everyday. I’m not worried about her fitness levels. If she’d rather spend the time in the library doing homework, I’m happy with that.
Good for you it's nice to see a mum supporting her child.

PE at school can put kids off exercise for life. My son was like this, he wasn't into football or rugby which covered most of the PE sessions and suited the football lot but did r cater at all for anyone else. My son did loads of exercise out of school from black belt tae kwon do to street dance and was fitter than all of the football lot combined!! He did have a problem with Achilles tendonitis though which was a real nuisance and very painful but as a long term reason for getting out of PE was fab.

Brainwave89 · 28/01/2022 20:21

No don’t do this.Its morally wrong and it tempts fate if you make up an illness.

iklboo · 28/01/2022 20:20

God these responses 😂 Did none of you ever skive PE?

Not for more than half a term, no. But I did have a nice hustle in writing notes for classmates 😂

Asperula · 28/01/2022 20:20

In our school you don't get to sit in the library if you aren't participating. You are a ref, or score keeper, or line judge. Funnily enough not many kids don't do it, because they know they'll be doing part of the lesson anyway
Same in my kids' school

randomchap · 28/01/2022 20:19

Why doesn't she want to do it? I understand preferring to do something else, but getting your mum to lie to the teachers is a bit much.

It'd be far better for her for you to get to the bottom of her issues than giving her an excuse to avoid it.

Too many girls drop out of PE, this can have negative effects for them in the long term. A good article here

www.theguardian.com/sport/2017/nov/08/girls-engaging-school-sports-solution

Thesearmsofmine · 28/01/2022 20:19

I hated PE at school and would have loved not to do it, I can’t say doing PE taught me anything that I couldn’t learn in other ways, the only thing it did do was to turn me off any kind of physical activity for many many years.

beaverdiego · 28/01/2022 20:19

@Lavender24

God these responses 😂 Did none of you ever skive PE? My Mum always wrote me notes. I got plenty of exercise, I just hated competitive sports. Didn't mind if we did gym or running.
Haha, thought the same. 😅 Then when the child is able to I'd recommend learning to forge your parents writing and signature!
Fearnyleaves · 28/01/2022 20:19

'Can'tbearseditis' would probably do it.

Sux2Buthen · 28/01/2022 20:18

PE at my school was awful and I did end up being permanently signed off from doing it.
I'm no worse off for having missed it either.
People underestimate how badly some things at school can affect kids
Sorry OP my reason wouldn't work