Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
usinon · 01/02/2022 10:13

I don't think people should be encouraged or permitted to lie to get out of things, but that's to develop the value of truthfulness, not resilience. I hate the idea that forcing people to do things they dislike develops resilience. It's not a million miles from the Victorian idea that beating children would build character Life involves both good and difficult experiences for everyone, and the easier you can deal with more difficult things, which are normal things most people are expected to do, the easier and happier your life is. I think it is better to join in with things you are expected to do at school or at work, unless they are unreasonable. This is where the victorian beating comes in - it isn't reasonable to beat a child, it is reasonable to get children to exercise outside

I agree the lying is a different point.

TopsieGreenwood · 01/02/2022 10:05

@RockingMyFiftiesNot

I'm shocked that the school allows people excused from PE to go to the library and do homework. I think there are days I'd have preferred to do that. But we had to be out in the same weather, watching the lesson or litter picking around the field. No one got to sit inside. So actually it was worse to be let off PE as you were just as wet/cold and not moving around to get warm, By masking a nice, warm alternative, the school is enabling the lying excuses really.
Yes, I'm sure once word catches on you can go and sit in the library with a note from mum there will be many joining her. It's why most schools are sensible enough not to allow that
Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 01/02/2022 08:42

Our local secondary school put the children in sets for PE so none of that being last to be picked nonsense. Makes it much more fair in my opinion.
I wouldn't lie for my dd but l would reward her for doing it until she gets used to it

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 01/02/2022 08:41

I'm shocked that the school allows people excused from PE to go to the library and do homework. I think there are days I'd have preferred to do that. But we had to be out in the same weather, watching the lesson or litter picking around the field. No one got to sit inside. So actually it was worse to be let off PE as you were just as wet/cold and not moving around to get warm, By masking a nice, warm alternative, the school is enabling the lying excuses really.

Ericaequites · 01/02/2022 07:53

@AnneofRedGables. Aren’t English teachers responsible for reading ages? I’ll agree to disagree, as I don’t and probably can’t understand how English state schools work.

7eleven · 01/02/2022 07:10

I think it’s wonderful that you are teaching your daughter the essential life skill of lying. I’m sure she’ll go far in life. You never know - she might even make it to Downing Street.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 01/02/2022 06:58

@CrankyFrankie

It's called

R E S I L I E N C E

Without resilience, your mental health is shot.

Generally, you become resilient because you've been through shit and upsetting times.

The resilience comes because you've suffered, it doesn't prevent it.

AnneofRedGables · 01/02/2022 06:28

@Ericaequites that’s fab for US schools. Meanwhile, back in Blighty, I am solely responsible for the reading ages of 500ish pupils across KS3. If those reading ages don’t improve year-on-year, it’s on my head and my head only. So yes, phoning parents is a daily occurrence for me, amongst the 101 other tasks I have to fit in around my classes. A student who genuinely can’t do PE because of an injury etc. is more than welcome to come and use the library - I’ll just stay late that day or skip lunch. A student who has come in because they don’t like the cold and mummy has enabled that? Nah, no time for that.

Please don’t insinuate I’m ‘whining’ when you have no idea about the job of a school librarian in the UK. It’s insulting and I feel embarrassed for you.

Ericaequites · 01/02/2022 02:58

School libraries work differently in the United States generally, but we have double or triple the funding per pupil.

ddl1 · 31/01/2022 22:48

@Ericaequites

I went to a private girls’ school, so have never been to a coed secondary gym class. One need not experience something to know it’s wrong. It’s not right for boys and girls in puberty to exercise together. It’s too suggestive for them to interact in revealing clothing. Coed classes rule out most sports because boys are so much stronger and more violent.
Boys are not necessarily stronger, and in year 7 the girls will mostly be more physically mature than the boys. And boys and girls do many activities separately, even in a co-ed school.

'Revealing clothing': ever seen the average school gym or sport outfit? If anything seeing the opposite sex doing school sports is more likely to put kids off them than be madly suggestive!

ddl1 · 31/01/2022 22:42

@CrankyFrankie

It's called

R E S I L I E N C E

Without resilience, your mental health is shot.

It's the other way round mostly. Resilience is a consequence, not a cause, of good mental health.

I don't think people should be encouraged or permitted to lie to get out of things, but that's to develop the value of truthfulness, not resilience. I hate the idea that forcing people to do things they dislike develops resilience. It's not a million miles from the Victorian idea that beating children would build character.

Oh, and I don't deny that sometimes people have to do things they don't like! Quite often, in fact. But I think they're more likely to accept the necessity if they haven't been forced to do such things just because they dislike them.

ddl1 · 31/01/2022 22:37

Why does she want to avoid PE? If it's just that she finds it boring, I don't think this is a good reason to avoid it, and certainly not to lie about it. If she is being bullied or body-shamed, then I think that it's a good reason to avoid it for a while, but best to be honest if possible.

If she does avoid school PE, then you should IMO make sure that she does some sort of alternative physical activity.

CrankyFrankie · 31/01/2022 22:20

It's called

R E S I L I E N C E

Without resilience, your mental health is shot.

AnneofRedGables · 31/01/2022 21:35

@Ericaequites I’m so glad you know my job better than I do - what time can I expect you in the morning? School libraries are vastly different places to public libraries my dear. I’ve worked in both.

XelaM · 31/01/2022 21:05

@mbosnz "
As a person who went to a co-ed secondary school and did co-ed PE, I think I know a little more about it than someone who went to a same sex school and did not.

We did not play contact sports together - hockey, or rugby. Everything else we did together. No one got raped or sexually assaulted during a PE lesson, no one had involuntary masturbation sessions or orgasms during PE. PE kit is possibly less revealing than the way many girls wear their school uniform and sure as hell isn't designed for its sex appeal. We females gave at least as good as we got, and there was never more than the usual collection of ouchy boo boos that didn't often require so much as a kiss better, let alone surgery and criminal charges.

We. Played. Sports."

ALL OF THIS!! I have gone to (several) co-ed schools as a kid and my daughter is currently going through a co-ed secondary school (after a co-ed primary). My daughter just rolled her eyes and laughed at the crazy Mumsnetters' fantasies about some awful horrors that happen during PE.

In reality, all they do is play sports! And PE uniforms are the OPPOSITE of attractive. They are absolutely hideous for the most part and in no way revealing. My daughter's uniform is a baggy tracksuit with a baggy polo and a frumpy netball skirt, which they have to wear shorts under. It's really not some sexy Physical-video-style leotard Grin

usinon · 31/01/2022 19:09

@Becky11 I am usually an enthusiastic "BeKind" supporter, so i thought long and hard about your post saying that people are judging here. I don't want the OP to feel got at, and I do think most of the posts here reflect the fact there are some polarised views about sport at school. However, I really don't think "bekind" is relevant to the issue of lying to the school, lying about her breaking school rules, because so many people (not everyone, granted, but most people I know) would judge this in reality, it is more BeingKind to tell the OP this? Or pearl clutching?

CoconutQueen · 31/01/2022 14:00

Why on earth would you, as your child's role model, tell a blatant lie to the school? What is that teaching her? Have some morals!

And PE is actually good for them...

saygeronimo · 31/01/2022 13:54

@Ericaequites

I went to a private girls’ school, so have never been to a coed secondary gym class. One need not experience something to know it’s wrong. It’s not right for boys and girls in puberty to exercise together. It’s too suggestive for them to interact in revealing clothing. Coed classes rule out most sports because boys are so much stronger and more violent.
What gave I just read? ConfusedIs this really how some people think? We're doomed.
mbosnz · 31/01/2022 13:39

Oh, and discussed it with my two girls in a current co-ed, and they (once they'd finished laughing at ericaquite's outraged posts) said much the same thing. . .

mbosnz · 31/01/2022 13:38

As a person who went to a co-ed secondary school and did co-ed PE, I think I know a little more about it than someone who went to a same sex school and did not.

We did not play contact sports together - hockey, or rugby. Everything else we did together. No one got raped or sexually assaulted during a PE lesson, no one had involuntary masturbation sessions or orgasms during PE. PE kit is possibly less revealing than the way many girls wear their school uniform and sure as hell isn't designed for its sex appeal. We females gave at least as good as we got, and there was never more than the usual collection of ouchy boo boos that didn't often require so much as a kiss better, let alone surgery and criminal charges.

We. Played. Sports.

ufucoffee · 31/01/2022 13:27

@Ericaequites

The whining from school librarians is risible. Students using the library are major problems. How often do you have reason to call parents or place orders? Some one has to be there to check out books and other materials. Secondary students don’t need constant supervision. It’s certainly not how public libraries work.
Says the person who doesn't appear to have ever worked in a secondary school GrinGrin
UnicornsReal · 31/01/2022 07:34

I absolutely hated PE and used the excuse of guitar lessons to get off it for quite a while. It’s given me a lifelong horror of team games and competitiveness. However I love walking and swimming now.
If my mother had encouraged me to skive and lied to teachers, I think that would have had a very negative impact on me . Given me the message that lying and skiving were fine.

GrammarTeacher · 31/01/2022 06:13

@Ericaequites

The whining from school librarians is risible. Students using the library are major problems. How often do you have reason to call parents or place orders? Some one has to be there to check out books and other materials. Secondary students don’t need constant supervision. It’s certainly not how public libraries work.
While they're in school they do require supervision. It's a safeguarding
ChampagneLassie · 31/01/2022 06:08

I think good on you @HelloKittyGirl I did this as a teen for similar reasons. As an adult I've got really into exercise but the PE on offer at my school was grim. If you're at a fee paying school I'd be asking for better PE variety. Or try to get your daughter doing some active hobbies. I do think sport/activity is really good toget into early

RantyAunty · 31/01/2022 06:04

I can't believe you'd lie like that.

Not a good message to send to your DD.