Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
XelaM · 28/01/2022 22:47

My daughter loves PE. She's not an elite athlete or anything, just a normal 11-year-old kid. There's nothing inherently sadistic about PE lessons.

Gwenhwyfar · 28/01/2022 22:47

"If she's cold, she could put extra layers on."

Don't they have a uniform? We had to wear very short skirts for hockey while the teacher was in her tracksuit.

Gwenhwyfar · 28/01/2022 22:46

"Physical exercise is very important."

Yes, but it's games/sports not exercise and not all of them are even very active!

Drinkyourweaklemondrink · 28/01/2022 22:46

Dyssentry with a cough!

Gwenhwyfar · 28/01/2022 22:45

" ive learnt now it doesnt matter how good u r, its about the just taking part and enjoying the feeling of it. "

That's true for exercise, but not really for team sports. I remember a friend telling me to 'stand like a stone' in doubles badminton because if I tried to do something I hindered her. Children can get competitive in team sports and turn against those who are weak.
I suppose they've stopped doing the thing where you get picked for teams now, but that was enough to show it wasn't just about the taking part!

DrRamsesEmerson · 28/01/2022 22:44

@Undecicive

PE is not just about the curriculum and university places. It's about establishing a healthy habit of regular exercise as well. If she's cold, she could put extra layers on.
Except it isn't, is it? It clearly puts some people off for life.
chaosrabbitland · 28/01/2022 22:43

im really failing to understand how all the comments obesity have any relevence to once a week pe lessons
overweight children of which there are a fair few in my dds form and indeed the school in general all do pe and they dont seem to be looking any thinner when i see them coming out the gates when i wait to get her and its been that way for the last years now

strange that is , cant figure it out for the life of me

Undecicive · 28/01/2022 22:43

PE is not just about the curriculum and university places. It's about establishing a healthy habit of regular exercise as well.
If she's cold, she could put extra layers on.

DrRamsesEmerson · 28/01/2022 22:43

@Whydoiwearsomuchleopardprint

Do you think any of our kids want to get up early, study hard , participate in swimming lessons, do sports days when they come last etc?? No, so why on earth would you stop a child being part of school life to sit in a library on their own? What lesson are you teaching them at 11? That mum will get you out of it for no reason. Life is not like this out of school so you are being really quite unkind to suggest to your daughter that you can opt out of stuff you don’t like and that mum will support this!
I think the lesson is that sadistic bullying is not OK even if it comes in the guise of a school lesson (which is not "for no reason"). And sitting in the library on your own can be really valuable time for your later life.
Bluesparkled · 28/01/2022 22:41

I’d have been so grateful if my Mum had done this for me. The damage from forced participation and the attendant humiliation and sense of failure far outweighed any benefit from team participation or whatever. When I got to around year 9 I learned to lie very well and just didn’t go anymore. I was also at a school that sounds like your daughter’s OP and just went to the library- unsupervised- and read.

louderthan · 28/01/2022 22:41

I hated PE. Not because of the exercise but because of the relentless bullying because I wasn't good at throwing or catching or running fast. I took every single opportunity to get out of it, whether that meant bare-faced lying or just simple truanting.

Hopefully schools now have more robust anti-bullying policies than they did in the 90s.

I now go to the gym 3/4 times a week, walk to and from work and go horse riding twice a week, so it was really nothing to do with laziness. Just self-preservation. I really hope your DD isn't being bullied OP.

Whydoiwearsomuchleopardprint · 28/01/2022 22:41

Do you think any of our kids want to get up early, study hard , participate in swimming lessons, do sports days when they come last etc?? No, so why on earth would you stop a child being part of school life to sit in a library on their own? What lesson are you teaching them at 11? That mum will get you out of it for no reason. Life is not like this out of school so you are being really quite unkind to suggest to your daughter that you can opt out of stuff you don’t like and that mum will support this!

DrRamsesEmerson · 28/01/2022 22:40

PE was positively counter-productive for me (and clearly lots of other people on this thread): in my twenties i made it a point of principle never to do any physical activity because I was an adult and didn't have to. Just before I turned 30 I bought a bike and started cycling to work, and now (when I'm very old) I do cycling, yoga, fitness DVDs and Pilates. During the lockdowns I made DD do Jillian Michaels DVDs with me: it's not that I don't think physical activity is important.

But if it were ever a condition of any job I applied for that I had to play lacrosse, I'd decline it. There's "bits of your job you don't like" and there's "stuff you wouldn't do even if the alternative were starving in the gutter" and all team sports are in that second category for me.

Gwenhwyfar · 28/01/2022 22:40

"I'm interested in how much sport/exercise you (and others who are happy for their children to miss PE) have gone on to do as an adult, and how much importance is placed on being active in everyday life."

I hated PE at school, but cycled as a teen. Quite slowly and badly, but I wasn't a couch potato the whole time. As an adult the gym and now jogging. I jog very slowly and have been pretty bad this winter, but again I'm making an effort.
PE put me off being active for so many years. I just can't do sports and forcing me to do it doesn't help anything.

HonoreDeBallsack · 28/01/2022 22:39

@DietrichandDiMaggio I'm actually a bit obsessively fit now, but that's only because I have found ways to keep fit that I love. Even when I was a child/teenager, I walked several miles every day with dogs, because I loved walking. I also loved playing tennis and cricket with my dad and my siblings at home. School sports were the issue, not fun things that also keep you fit.

LondonWolf · 28/01/2022 22:38

I'm interested in how much sport/exercise you (and others who are happy for their children to miss PE) have gone on to do as an adult, and how much importance is placed on being active in everyday life.

I did everything I could to get out of PE, down to forging notes from my parents and getting my ears pierced and pretending to be sick. I simply couldn't bear the communal showers and changing room bitching.

These days I run 3-5 km three times a week. Used to 10 km 4-5 times a week, but I developed adult onset asthma and had to cut way back till it was brought under control. Trying to build back up now.

GreenWhiteViolet · 28/01/2022 22:38

@Iggly what about the people who end up obese in part because they found school PE so awful that they assumed all physical exercise was similar and avoided it from the moment they were no longer forced to do it?

Gwenhwyfar · 28/01/2022 22:38

@Invisimamma

A walk too and from school, unless it's 5 miles each way, really isn't plenty of exercise. What other physical activity does she do? This isn't setting a good example that you can just opt out of things you don't want to do.
PE at school isn't necessarily enough exercise for the less sporty either though. I wasn't sporty so barely moved in most sports.
HonoreDeBallsack · 28/01/2022 22:36

Would it not be better for her to have a talk to the PE teacher and explain her anxiety - they may be able to help

My PE teacher was a vile sadist who liked humiliating girls who were crap at team sports. She also weighed and measured us in public, and got her "favourites" to call out everyone else's weight. This wasn't an issue for me as I was a completely "normal" weight - but it was absolutely mortifying for the one girl who was significantly overweight. I still remember the bitchy girls calling out her weight, and the sneery PE teacher saying "ooh, yes, a bit ... cuddly, aren't we?" She also had a habit of talking to us about "leakage from your ... bits while you are running". No, no, NO.

There is no way I would have "explained my anxiety" about anything to her. I wasn't anxious about PE. I just loathed it with every fibre of my being. Fortunately my mum was sensible she might also have said it was a waste of school fees

JohnMcCainsDeathStare · 28/01/2022 22:36

I'm ambivalent about PE. True, being a late developing ND person team games were a complete loss but I did learn some physical literacy despite it all being geared toward ball games and fast-twitch reflexes.

But I can honestly say I learnt far more about teamwork in an orchestra than in any PE game. And it is lousy at actually teaching children physical literacy.
Also don't remember doing a single PE lesson after term 1 in yr11 - non of the other girls wanted to! Being seen as not being afraid of your body and getting sweaty was seen as super uncool.

I lift, swim and run as an adult and I had a 'round' number of swimming hours at secondary school.
Having said that is it 'just' the cold or is there a deeper underlying unease to it - this needs to be addressed. But PE still lets down so many people - if you have a disability or injury - forget it - you are essentially a set dressing

Plus I used Sports Days as practice for being dead.

GreenWhiteViolet · 28/01/2022 22:35

@Drunkpanda

Child will be getting out of swimming - I assume that's not done in a lake so why does the season make a difference? Nor is it a team sport lie hockey.
Swimming was a 'winter sport' at my school. Going around for the rest of the day with wet hair in the cold wasn't pleasant (and for some reason they used to make us leave the changing rooms attached to the pool in bare feet and put our shoes and socks on outside the building standing in the cold, but that was probably just my school...)
DietrichandDiMaggio · 28/01/2022 22:33

@ThoseFestiveLights

I’ve always let my kids bunk off PE. I utterly hated it. Found it humiliating.

Bad circulation works for winter. In summer they just bunked off to go to the quiet room or library.

I think it’s wrong to force kids to do PE.

I'm interested in how much sport/exercise you (and others who are happy for their children to miss PE) have gone on to do as an adult, and how much importance is placed on being active in everyday life.
Iggly · 28/01/2022 22:33

@happypineapples

So many perfect parents on this thread Hmm I personally don't agree with lying about it but it's PE for goodness sake. You'd think this mum wanted to take her daughter out of education full stop.
“But its PE”

And that’s why we are an obese nation! Physical exercise is very important.

chaosrabbitland · 28/01/2022 22:32

@Flickflak

What awful parenting. Your daughter has no hope with you teaching her to lie and to break the rules. Disgusting.
my mum wrote me loads of excuse notes to get out of having to do pe because i didnt want to and strangely enough i didnt grow up to be a feckless evil drug dealer , i have oddly enough worked since i was 18 years old . and my own dd is complimeted on her good manners and is loved by her teachers , so you might want to rethink your ridiculous statement
Dita73 · 28/01/2022 22:32

@HonoreDeBallsack I didn’t say that people who don’t do PE end up on benefits! I was referring the the OP’s attitude of if you don’t fancy doing something just make up a bullshit excuse to get out of it. You’ve completely misread my post and missed the point

Swipe left for the next trending thread