Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
Anonymouseposter · 28/01/2022 23:09

In my experience the vast majority of teachers are not sadistic bullies who enjoy humiliating kids but there's usually one in a school.

louderthan · 28/01/2022 23:09

Just to add, not playing rounders twice a week has had no effect on my physical health or enthusiasm for exercise in later life.

On the other hand, the bullying (from teachers and other kids) has had a significant, long-term, and resoundingly negative effect on my general self-esteem, my assertiveness in relationships, and my confidence in the workplace. I'm still trying to unpick this in therapy.

Not doing PE is not the same as not doing maths. It just isn't. Other lessons don't involve ritual humiliation.

Lastofthecelebrations · 28/01/2022 23:08

So you're ok teaching your daughter that if you don't want to do something in life it's ok to lie your way out of itConfused that's some rod you're making for yourself!

Thirtytimesround · 28/01/2022 23:07

I’m amused by all the people who think that children actually get good exercise in PE lessons and learn teamwork and sportsmanship and so on. That hasn’t been my experience! The tricky bit is teaching her to lie her way out of a tricky situation though. Lying is such a bad habit and a weak thing to do. It’s students mucking about like this that make teachers suspicious when a child genuinely has stomach/period pain / needs the loo urgently. Teachers so often assume children are lying… Because of children like this one.

ItsDisneyBitch · 28/01/2022 23:05

God I fucking hated PE. I was useless at sport. Now I’m later life I have realised that I’m probably dyspraxic. I had the piss ripped out of me by everyone including the teachers.

Two years I stomached it until I would go in every week and tell the male teacher I had my period and couldn’t participate.

PE put me off enjoying exercise or trying any other kind of sport. If you are crap at sports it can absolutely break you.

My daughter has asked me before to get her out of it because much like me she is rubbish at sports. She was being picked on. So yes I’ve written the note for her.

I encourage my children to exercise but am I going to force them to participate in something where they ritually humiliated, knowing how it made me feel. No.

mummykel16 · 28/01/2022 23:05

@Asperula

My children go to an average local Comp and they don't have people on the staff who are sadistic bullies who enjoy humiliating kids. What sort of schools are these where they employ people like that?
How would you know?
Gwenhwyfar · 28/01/2022 23:04

"remember if she's cold she is probably not doing it properly."

Oh FFS, if she's not sporty, she's not sporty. It's not something you choose!

Asperula · 28/01/2022 23:02

My children go to an average local Comp and they don't have people on the staff who are sadistic bullies who enjoy humiliating kids. What sort of schools are these where they employ people like that?

Cherrysoup · 28/01/2022 23:02

But why? What’s your aim here?

Gwenhwyfar · 28/01/2022 23:01

"I don't think standing waiting, knowing you will be the last person to be picked because you are hopeless at PE, and the ensuing shame of a terrible performance teaches you anything about teamwork actually."

Exactly, when there's a big difference in ability, you're not part of the team. Nobody would throw me the ball because they knew I'd run away in horror with a ball coming towards me so I wasn't really part of anything anyway. I used to sit and make daisy chains when I was supposed to be fielding.
Not teamwork and not exercise either!

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/01/2022 22:58

I didn’t like maths. Quite glad now though that my parents didn’t lie to get me out of lessons.

Walking to and from school is not enough exercise, unless you live miles away.

Chloemol · 28/01/2022 22:58

You are not setting her a good example. As she goes through life there will be things she doesn’t want to do, but has to, mummy won’t be able to write her a note

She should be doing PE

Intheopinionofourexpert · 28/01/2022 22:57

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

I’m not sure walking two and from school is enough exercise for a teen - or an adult really. Isn’t it important to get your heart rate up.

Also as pps have said, it’s the team element that’s also necessary, and the fact that you can’t miss a subject you just don’t like.

I don't think standing waiting, knowing you will be the last person to be picked because you are hopeless at PE, and the ensuing shame of a terrible performance teaches you anything about teamwork actually. It's an exercise in public humiliation for some children. I broke my leg badly as a child, and genuinely my first thought was thank god I won't have to do PE for ages, swiftly followed by hoping it wouldnt be better by summer so I could miss sports day too, with all the humiliation that brought.
OhGingleBells · 28/01/2022 22:56

Sorry - meant to add that I actually did have a spell of regular migraines in year 7, assumed to be brought on by the combination of hormones and the stress of transitioning to secondary school!

Then proceeded to continue to suffer from migraines on convenient occasions the whole way through secondary…..

If she’s never had one just scroll through the NHS page and choose a combination of symptoms to describe if anyone asks. Doctors aren’t interested and anyone who has had one will definitely understand why she is trying to avoid ‘triggering’ one!

mummykel16 · 28/01/2022 22:56

@louderthan

I hated PE. Not because of the exercise but because of the relentless bullying because I wasn't good at throwing or catching or running fast. I took every single opportunity to get out of it, whether that meant bare-faced lying or just simple truanting.

Hopefully schools now have more robust anti-bullying policies than they did in the 90s.

I now go to the gym 3/4 times a week, walk to and from work and go horse riding twice a week, so it was really nothing to do with laziness. Just self-preservation. I really hope your DD isn't being bullied OP.

It's worse
OfstedOffred · 28/01/2022 22:56

overweight children of which there are a fair few in my dds form and indeed the school in general all do pe and they dont seem to be looking any thinner when i see them coming out the gates when i wait to get her and its been that way for the last years now

They'd be even fucking bigger if they didnt do pe.

Teenylittlefella · 28/01/2022 22:55

This has pissed me off a bit tbh. My 11 year old has fairly recently diagnosed Crohn's disease. She has already had one section of her intestines removed and is facing lifelong medication and an 80 percent chance of further intestinal surgery. She is anaemic and until recent treatment used to get a stitch walking more than 100 yards. She was stick thin, ghostly white and she still tried her best to join in PE. She sat out twice, when her feeding tube wasn't compatible with the touch rugby. She isn't sporty and it was never her favourite subject, but she so desperately wants to be like her friends.

You are lucky enough to have healthy bloody kids perfectly capable of participation. My daughter has more committment in her little finger than you. Don't take your children's good health for granted and collude with them like this. It's crap of you. Crap.

HopingForMyRainbowBaby · 28/01/2022 22:53

Won't things like tennis elbow, tendonitis, plantar fasciitis etc need a Drs note as proof? I'm pretty sure they'll know you're trying to pull a fast one without medical proof.

Snoopsnoggysnog · 28/01/2022 22:53

@TheBareTree

Gwendoline Mary Lacey, is that you?
😂😂😂

OP are you going to write her a note every January / February?

OfstedOffred · 28/01/2022 22:52

Sport is important. The walk to and from school is unlikely to be getting her heart rate up, or strengthening her core, improving her strength & coordination, or providing opportunities to learn from being one of a team.

Not to mention you are sending her completely the wrong message that you can opt out of things you don't like.

Why should she essentially get extra homework time while others participate?

If she's getting very cold outdoors doing it, get her some decent base layers to wear but also remember if she's cold she is probably not doing it properly.

Physical laziness isnt a good trait. My mum was like you and didnt do anything to promote fitness in my teens and I wish now as an adult that she had.

mummykel16 · 28/01/2022 22:52

@Whydoiwearsomuchleopardprint

Do you think any of our kids want to get up early, study hard , participate in swimming lessons, do sports days when they come last etc?? No, so why on earth would you stop a child being part of school life to sit in a library on their own? What lesson are you teaching them at 11? That mum will get you out of it for no reason. Life is not like this out of school so you are being really quite unkind to suggest to your daughter that you can opt out of stuff you don’t like and that mum will support this!
It isn't for no reason
waterlego · 28/01/2022 22:50

I think a lot of posters are assuming PE is still like it was in the 80s/90s when many of us were at school. I know my teens don’t just do team sports in their school PE lessons. They also do indoor stuff like dance, gymnastics, and gym (circuits, weights machines, treadmills, rowing machine, etc). I think there’s more of an emphasis on fitness, not just team sports. At least that’s the case in my DCs’ school (one of them loves PE, the other one doesn’t, but they both do it).

OhGingleBells · 28/01/2022 22:50

What about migraines? She’s overtired and the additional exertion of PE lessons is bringing on migraines.

Impossible to prove or disprove.

I hated PE and am sorry to say that despite doing it for years never got anything out of it, did less exercise in general because it put me off and ruined it for other people in my class because I didn’t care if we won or lost and put no effort into anything. I’m perfectly fit (and was then too) so it’s not laziness but there was just something about it that didn’t suit me. Unless she wants to do it GCSE I think you are right to help her avoid it. If she’s not getting anything out of it why bother making her go?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/01/2022 22:48

What about when she gets a job, there might be a part of it she doesn't like. She can't just not do it!

Why not? She could always get mummy to call the employer and insist that she simply can't be expected to do such-and-such

Believe me I've had it happen ...

DietrichandDiMaggio · 28/01/2022 22:48

Thanks for the replies. I just wondered if people who had hated PE were put off exercising for good, and therefore when they had children they didn't introduce them to sports/the children didn't grow up seeing exercise as a normal part of life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread